Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A review on what people spend DLA/PIP for children on

173 replies

DoaBetterReview · Today 12:40

After seeing all the controversy over the Milburn review and knowing first hand through family and work exactly where the majority of people claiming for dc spend their DLA/PIP I think there actually needs to be a better review conducted where they gather info on what it’s spent on to then identify the weak areas where they need to concentrate funding and efforts.

What is being proposed now is just support in the wrong place at the wrong time ! By 18-24 anyone with ND or MH issues are really struggling so significantly that it could be useless.

Everyone I know getting DLA or PIP for a child / young person is spending it on timely access to diagnosis and/or therapies. This is where the focus needs to be.

Also I’m still shocked at the language around PIP - IT IS NOT AN OUT OF WORK BENEFIT!!! Why is being referred to as if it is a lot of the time.

OP posts:
plasticplate · Today 18:16

We spent it on
Incontinence pads because the NHS don't provide enough.
Specialist equipment such as a specialist bed, changing table, sn buggy and harnesses for every car he went in
A larger car than we would otherwise have bought so we had sufficient space for all his equipment and needs.
Extra clothing including school uniform because he frequently got through 3 sets a day
Fuel for taking him the 40 miles to school when school transport didn't turn up and to his overnight respite 60 miles away
Legal fees when education etc failed to provide what they said they were going to provide
One parent being available at all times.

Kirbert2 · Today 18:17

strictlybusinessuntildecember · Today 18:12

I’m in the process of completing DLA forms for my child - they still require specialist nappies compared to other children their age and also incontinence pants (doubly incontinent) which I had been buying at £12 each but the constant soiling means I just can’t get them clean so get replaced a lot and they can need changing several times a day. I’ve never had to do a DLA form before (child has been unwell for several years now as long term condition became apparent) but cost of living all round is biting and as a family we don’t receive any benefits whatsoever including CB (yes I’m over the threshold but I’m also a lone parent of 3 with a disappeared ex husband who doesn’t pay CMS) so if they are awarded it (and I would assume it will be the lowest award) it will all get spent on the sanitary and personal hygiene products they need.

It will depend on if they have any care needs during the night which is what can make a child eligible for medium or high rate care as opposed to low rate care.

TheodoreisntBeth · Today 18:17

Happyindevon · Today 18:05

Nobody luxuriates in it; I’ve been very severely mentally ill and have been through fairly extreme abuse as a child. I haven’t had a luxury life; I know what it is to suffer. But I DO think parents are so emotional about their child’s distress, and terrified they’ll kill themselves, they get trapped in a pattern of seeing their demands as ‘needs’ and fighting for them.

If we withdrew all financial support bar the bare minimum from everyone with these ‘needs’ (SEMH/MH, the type who can go on holiday and have fun but NOT work or attend school), I think less than 1% would actually kill themselves. Necessity would push the others through a painful transition to the point where they take responsibility for themselves.

The alternative is to keep running the country as a very expensive life support system where taxpayers dwindle and become increasingly resentful, but the SEMH people get what they want… until we can’t afford it.

I would choose option 1.

Ah so you're fine that some will kill themselves, but not that many, so you don't mind? Good to know.

ilbehonest · Today 18:21

DoaBetterReview · Today 13:06

If that was truly the case and written on the claim form then they would not get awarded? So there must be more to it. If you don’t send evidence with DLA forms they will contact school id say 99.9% of the time for more information

sorry to butt in but not every parent if a ND child likes to divulge what is happening. My eldest still poos himself daily and he is coming towards the end of primary. I would never ever tell my friends this to respect his dignity. If they new I get DLA for him and thought of well he goes to softplay and he can talk etc I don't need it they may be ignorant and have the same view as you. He also doesn't sleep adequately and is down for about 5 hours a night. I used the money to buy things like echo dot and projector lights which he can do so he doesn't disturb us all. These get broken almost every month because he just loves to try and figure out how to take them apart and put them back together and have to be replaced after he's completely destroyed them out of curiosity. My friends wouldn't really see this because it's in an evening they aren't at my house in an evening. He also goes to mainstream because specialist places are so bloody hard to get into. He also loves noise and busy spaces but when he doesn't my god lord I can't even leave the house to go to a petrol station. Children who are ND can present different at different times. Try not to be so judgy

BluebellBeth · Today 18:21

Happyindevon · Today 17:59

I know.

The problem is we are suddenly inundated with people insisting they ‘need’ very specific, arbitrary items which are far from actually necessary. And that they’ll actually self harm or something if they don’t get them.

Where do you draw the line.

Yes mine does need specific items otherwise they would starve to death. Sorry their eating disorder annoys you.

hibernatinghedgehog · Today 18:22

Kirbert2 · Today 18:17

It will depend on if they have any care needs during the night which is what can make a child eligible for medium or high rate care as opposed to low rate care.

You can get MRC without any night needs. MRC is for frequent help &/or constant supervision during the day, prolonged &/or repeated help during the night, prolonged or frequent supervision at night, or need someone to help when on dialysis. HRC is for help or supervision both day and night - you have to satisfy one of the day criteria and one of the night criteria I mentioned in my previous sentence or have a claim under the special rules.

DoaBetterReview · Today 18:22

Happyindevon · Today 18:05

Nobody luxuriates in it; I’ve been very severely mentally ill and have been through fairly extreme abuse as a child. I haven’t had a luxury life; I know what it is to suffer. But I DO think parents are so emotional about their child’s distress, and terrified they’ll kill themselves, they get trapped in a pattern of seeing their demands as ‘needs’ and fighting for them.

If we withdrew all financial support bar the bare minimum from everyone with these ‘needs’ (SEMH/MH, the type who can go on holiday and have fun but NOT work or attend school), I think less than 1% would actually kill themselves. Necessity would push the others through a painful transition to the point where they take responsibility for themselves.

The alternative is to keep running the country as a very expensive life support system where taxpayers dwindle and become increasingly resentful, but the SEMH people get what they want… until we can’t afford it.

I would choose option 1.

Even less than 1% killing themselves would be unacceptable. I think as well there would be a huge rise in MH inpatients / those being sectioned which would cost the government a lot.

OP posts:
ilbehonest · Today 18:23

BluebellBeth · Today 18:21

Yes mine does need specific items otherwise they would starve to death. Sorry their eating disorder annoys you.

people who comment ignorant shit definitely have never experienced a neurodiverse child

SleeplessInWherever · Today 18:25

Velumental · Today 18:03

Are you sure you're happy in Devon? You're more like irate at people wanting to eat and wash their clothes in Devon

I can confirm I’ve never been sleepless in Devon.

Good job, really, think it’d wind people up.

BluebellBeth · Today 18:25

DoaBetterReview · Today 18:01

CA wasn’t mentioned at all in the Milburn review and as there were no details of any new disability benefit schemes for 18-24 it’s worrying as what will happen re carers allowance ?

My aim when starting this thread wasn’t to ignite arguments about fabric conditioner it was to see if there are multiple people having to use DLA for therapies that the government should be looking at funding as an alternative to putting billions into a youth employment scheme that may or may not work yet we know for definite that early interventions with SALT, physio and OT is proven to improve long term outcomes for ND children.

I think they need to do both. There's a distinct lack of early intervention, fixing that would help immensely for those who are young now and in turn will help reduce the welfare (and education, and nhs, and social care) bill once they're adults . Those who are currently NEET have missed out on much needed early intervention so need the support to get them into work, we can't just write them off.

Kirbert2 · Today 18:26

hibernatinghedgehog · Today 18:22

You can get MRC without any night needs. MRC is for frequent help &/or constant supervision during the day, prolonged &/or repeated help during the night, prolonged or frequent supervision at night, or need someone to help when on dialysis. HRC is for help or supervision both day and night - you have to satisfy one of the day criteria and one of the night criteria I mentioned in my previous sentence or have a claim under the special rules.

I thought it was and for MRC too, just not as frequent at night than HRC. My mistake! My son gets HRC.

DoaBetterReview · Today 18:28

BluebellBeth · Today 18:25

I think they need to do both. There's a distinct lack of early intervention, fixing that would help immensely for those who are young now and in turn will help reduce the welfare (and education, and nhs, and social care) bill once they're adults . Those who are currently NEET have missed out on much needed early intervention so need the support to get them into work, we can't just write them off.

Edited

I do think that for the 18-24 group surely it’s better to just leave Pip out of it (as in don’t take away pip) and use the money allocated to the scheme instead of paying these companies £3-5 k per person for just 6 months maybe instead fund therapies / qualifications/ support groups etc and have employment options that are longer term and more secure

OP posts:
Stuckintheswing · Today 18:29

Budgiedrama · Today 17:02

@hibernatinghedgehogif an employer didnt let you have time off for school meetings, they could quickly be found guilty of discrimination. My boss has children with multiple disabilities herself.

You're lucky your boss can give you lots of paid time off to support your child. Most would not tolerate that for years on end.

Working part time allows me to keep a lid on things at home, do a decent job when I'm at work and not have a total mental breakdown due to the stress.

strictlybusinessuntildecember · Today 18:30

@Kirbert2
ah thanks - my child doesn’t have care needs at night other than being incontinent and still in nappies to sleep in. I wasn’t sure whether to claim TBH and put it off in the hope they would get better. I know now they won’t and the cost for the bigger and bigger sizes just keeps going up

hibernatinghedgehog · Today 18:33

strictlybusinessuntildecember · Today 18:30

@Kirbert2
ah thanks - my child doesn’t have care needs at night other than being incontinent and still in nappies to sleep in. I wasn’t sure whether to claim TBH and put it off in the hope they would get better. I know now they won’t and the cost for the bigger and bigger sizes just keeps going up

If DC needs support with their incontinence overnight that typical peers the same age wouldn’t need, it definitely counts.

Have you had a referral to the continence service. Many still have to top up what they receive on the NHS, but it does help.

TheLivelyCat · Today 18:38

I Clame for DD. To look at her from an outside perspective she doesn't need it, however what people don't see is travelling to appotments, she 11 but can't attend school full-time, on full days I have to bring her home for lunch and take her back. She starts the night in our bed then I have to move her around 11.30pm. She needs me to help her shower, do her hair ect, she will only eat certain foods, not family meals. I do 3 school runs a day. Shes damage my property, had meltdowns at 3am, has a huge fight or flight response. I have daily check in at school with her 1to1. I have meetings, forms to fill that take hours. The money gives us breathing space as a family to afford us to meet her needs. Follow specialist recommendations.

Berniestavern · Today 18:39

Chinscratches · Today 18:05

everyone has costs for their children. No child skips through life without challenges.
For my two, neither of whom qualify for any benefits (at least they don't if I am honest on the form)

  • huge additional costs due to their multiple food allergies
  • the cost of therapy as a result of abuse from their dad
  • the legal costs to keep them safe from their dad
  • costs of hospital parking for clinics and emergency appointments (probably at least once every few weeks)
  • cost of missed time off work to care for them
  • cost of tutors to top up the education they miss when their asthma flares.

There's this weird assumption that anyone not claiming doesn't have any additional costs or challenges and that's just so ridiculously far from the truth

This is my point, thank you. Why should the state support some things and not others? What about getting cancer and not being able to work? Your examples here are pertinent. It’s a mentality of oh my life is so terrible, my kid has ND but you are luxuriating in ‘normalcy’. Absolute nonsense. I’m sick of funding a lot of it.

DoaBetterReview · Today 18:40

As well as therapies I’ve heard of some parents just being able to work PT rather than FT due to the dla award/UC disability element which surely is a good thing as they can then meet the needs of their dc with appointments/days off school etc

OP posts:
SleeplessInWherever · Today 18:41

I’m not giving an itemised list of what I spend my son’s DLA on, because frankly I see no need to justify his receipt of it to some of the people on this thread.

He receives the highest rate of DLA for both care and mobility (£778 for those who’d like to be pissed off about it) and spend every penny of it plus more on his needs. And obviously have the same costs as everyone else in the country on top.

We both work FT and still claim it, I’d welcome people to froth about that too.

We manage to work full time because I’m in a management role that offers flexi time for the school holidays and have a very flexible employer, and my partner has worked for the same business since before my son was born, who also are a great support to him.

That set of circumstances lining up with a child like ours is very fucking rare.

We have a very specific set of circumstances that is genuinely impossible for most parents in our position.

I appreciate there are an increasing number of people who don’t want to support the disabled, or their parents and carers, and that’s unfortunate - but for them, that they’re so morally bankrupt.

ThatFunnyCoralScroller · Today 18:42

My son gets high rate dla for both care and mobility.
Its very month depending.
Taxi's a trip to the hospital for example will cost roughly 80 pound there and back.
driving lessons for me ( this will save money overall and give my son a better quality of life and make things safer outside and he can get to hospital quicker)
When j learn to drive the mobility part will be used for a car. so the above won't count anymore.
Care
Nappies he needs the adult ones and they cost £££
I try and save 150 of it to pay for bigger items such as new poles for his bed ( he has a safe space bed) sometimes it's used to cover a gap due to unpaid leave at work.
A couple of months ago we had to pay for a window to be fixed

Kirbert2 · Today 18:46

SleeplessInWherever · Today 18:41

I’m not giving an itemised list of what I spend my son’s DLA on, because frankly I see no need to justify his receipt of it to some of the people on this thread.

He receives the highest rate of DLA for both care and mobility (£778 for those who’d like to be pissed off about it) and spend every penny of it plus more on his needs. And obviously have the same costs as everyone else in the country on top.

We both work FT and still claim it, I’d welcome people to froth about that too.

We manage to work full time because I’m in a management role that offers flexi time for the school holidays and have a very flexible employer, and my partner has worked for the same business since before my son was born, who also are a great support to him.

That set of circumstances lining up with a child like ours is very fucking rare.

We have a very specific set of circumstances that is genuinely impossible for most parents in our position.

I appreciate there are an increasing number of people who don’t want to support the disabled, or their parents and carers, and that’s unfortunate - but for them, that they’re so morally bankrupt.

Yep. Me either. High rate for both here too and frankly, it is no one's business what it is spent on.

strictlybusinessuntildecember · Today 18:50

@hibernatinghedgehog
thanks - I’ll re read the forms again as I didn’t see anything on it about nappies at night part but it’s very wordy!
child is under urodynamics neurology and neurosurgery - no referral to continence …. Yet. Possibly as we have bounced between these 3 consultants for 3 years - we are trialling a new medicine regime at the moment but if anything bowel incontinence is actually worse! I’m just so worn down and exhausted by it all plus being a lone mum working full time drowning under bills no village nearest family 4 hours away and an ex husband who left because HE couldn’t cope! Plus I calculated compared to my parents - no increase in personal allowance in line with inflation and losing CB compared to my parents generation I am £500 plus per month worse off so thought why should people like me have to keep suffering through financially

SleeplessInWherever · Today 18:50

Kirbert2 · Today 18:46

Yep. Me either. High rate for both here too and frankly, it is no one's business what it is spent on.

Yeah, call me harsh but if you’d like to find out what the cost of his disability is, come and spend 24hrs in my house and you’ll find out.

Otherwise, bugger all the way off.

OrganisedOnTheSurface · Today 18:51

I am currently in process of applying for DLA but worried my child won't get it.
We have funded extras related to my child's issues for the last 5 years but now can't meet the extra costs
If he did receive it.we.would.use it towards

Attending a hobby he likes and it's.forat time.he has managed to socialise with other children his age in 4 years.
Mental health support ( we.previously funded a psychologist when needed but now.cant do this.)
Help towards the costs of my driving him to everything ( on a very part time.time.table 1.lesson a day in school and then a couple of alternative provisions).

Buying items that support sensory needs

I also can't work as I need to.bw available to.support him.

There are other costs (food related) but hopefully those are.managable from.family budget if we.can get the DLA to help with the more specific outlays.

ClaudettedeBeauvoir · Today 18:51

Budgiedrama · Today 13:01

I don’t claim DLA for my diagnosed child as her neurodivergence doesn’t cost me any more than her NT brother. I wish people thought more pragmatically about it. Don’t claim it if you don’t need it. I know someone who claims for her child when said child is self diagnosed and has no problem in mainstream school, going to soft play on busy days, eating a full and balanced diet, going to childcare.

We claim for one of our children, but not the other - both autistic, one also has a physical condition.
I had to reduce my working hours to 0.9 so that I could flexi around her needs. It doesn't cover that, but it makes a difference.