Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A review on what people spend DLA/PIP for children on

173 replies

DoaBetterReview · Today 12:40

After seeing all the controversy over the Milburn review and knowing first hand through family and work exactly where the majority of people claiming for dc spend their DLA/PIP I think there actually needs to be a better review conducted where they gather info on what it’s spent on to then identify the weak areas where they need to concentrate funding and efforts.

What is being proposed now is just support in the wrong place at the wrong time ! By 18-24 anyone with ND or MH issues are really struggling so significantly that it could be useless.

Everyone I know getting DLA or PIP for a child / young person is spending it on timely access to diagnosis and/or therapies. This is where the focus needs to be.

Also I’m still shocked at the language around PIP - IT IS NOT AN OUT OF WORK BENEFIT!!! Why is being referred to as if it is a lot of the time.

OP posts:
Kirbert2 · Today 18:51

SleeplessInWherever · Today 18:50

Yeah, call me harsh but if you’d like to find out what the cost of his disability is, come and spend 24hrs in my house and you’ll find out.

Otherwise, bugger all the way off.

Exactly how I feel. People have no idea unless they actually live it.

hibernatinghedgehog · Today 18:54

Berniestavern · Today 18:39

This is my point, thank you. Why should the state support some things and not others? What about getting cancer and not being able to work? Your examples here are pertinent. It’s a mentality of oh my life is so terrible, my kid has ND but you are luxuriating in ‘normalcy’. Absolute nonsense. I’m sick of funding a lot of it.

If a working-age adult with cancer cannot work, they can look at NS ESA &/or UC (including the LCWRA element). Some will also be eligible for PIP.

DoaBetterReview · Today 18:55

Kirbert2 · Today 18:51

Exactly how I feel. People have no idea unless they actually live it.

I totally understand this I was just thinking that the current proposals for PIP cuts are so wrong considering that a huge number of parents have to use DLA for therapies and interventions that the nhs should be providing and the government should be acting on that for long term outcomes to help not taking away PIP from 18-24 year olds

OP posts:
SantanaHC · Today 18:55

DoaBetterReview · Today 13:06

If that was truly the case and written on the claim form then they would not get awarded? So there must be more to it. If you don’t send evidence with DLA forms they will contact school id say 99.9% of the time for more information

Yeah. They do ask school so thats misleading. You do not need a diagnosis but you need proof of extra needs

hibernatinghedgehog · Today 18:58

strictlybusinessuntildecember · Today 18:50

@hibernatinghedgehog
thanks - I’ll re read the forms again as I didn’t see anything on it about nappies at night part but it’s very wordy!
child is under urodynamics neurology and neurosurgery - no referral to continence …. Yet. Possibly as we have bounced between these 3 consultants for 3 years - we are trialling a new medicine regime at the moment but if anything bowel incontinence is actually worse! I’m just so worn down and exhausted by it all plus being a lone mum working full time drowning under bills no village nearest family 4 hours away and an ex husband who left because HE couldn’t cope! Plus I calculated compared to my parents - no increase in personal allowance in line with inflation and losing CB compared to my parents generation I am £500 plus per month worse off so thought why should people like me have to keep suffering through financially

The form asks about encouragement, assistance and prompting to use the toilet and manage nappies or pads in the help DC need at night section.

In some areas, you can self refer to the continence service. If you can, do that. If you can’t, ask the GP or school nurse/0-19 nursing service to refer.

Kirbert2 · Today 18:59

DoaBetterReview · Today 18:55

I totally understand this I was just thinking that the current proposals for PIP cuts are so wrong considering that a huge number of parents have to use DLA for therapies and interventions that the nhs should be providing and the government should be acting on that for long term outcomes to help not taking away PIP from 18-24 year olds

In theory, I agree. I don't agree with the decision to take away PIP from 18-24 year olds, especially without something in place first.

But I also don't have any trust in the government so I'd also be sceptical of them reducing DLA, as an example, in replace of providing therapy/interventions because frankly, I wouldn't trust it to be anything other than a shit show.

Budgiedrama · Today 19:00

The thing is, all benefits are being scrutinised. Those of you who are on UC or know someone who does knows that everyone has been asked to provide bank statements, sometimes six months to a year, proof of pensions or savings. It’s been utterly soul destroying and anxiety provoking. Why should people on UC be the only people who have to be judge?

SleeplessInWherever · Today 19:01

DoaBetterReview · Today 18:55

I totally understand this I was just thinking that the current proposals for PIP cuts are so wrong considering that a huge number of parents have to use DLA for therapies and interventions that the nhs should be providing and the government should be acting on that for long term outcomes to help not taking away PIP from 18-24 year olds

I get this argument - we paid thousands for a private ADHD diagnosis because the wait list was approximately 85 years, and pay for rebound therapy and sensory sessions ourselves.

I would point out before anyone complains about ADHD private diagnosis - he’s been NHS diagnosed with Autism and global developmental delay since he was 2.5. The ADHD diagnosis was additional, because we needed quicker access to meds, and not pivotal to his overall needs profile.

Personally, I’m okay with receiving the benefit and allocating as and where required, including for interventions if needed, because it means I get some ownership over the process, time length and quality of service he receives.

I don’t actually trust the government to spend that money on his needs, with providers who actually can meet them, as effectively as we do. Which is a shame, but enough dealings with certain NHS employees and the LA will give you that opinion.

SleeplessInWherever · Today 19:05

Budgiedrama · Today 19:00

The thing is, all benefits are being scrutinised. Those of you who are on UC or know someone who does knows that everyone has been asked to provide bank statements, sometimes six months to a year, proof of pensions or savings. It’s been utterly soul destroying and anxiety provoking. Why should people on UC be the only people who have to be judge?

We’re actually already scrutinised at the point of filling the mountain of paperwork in, in order to get that DLA.

I don’t believe UC has anywhere near as much oversight or evidence provided at point of application.

TigerRag · Today 19:06

Budgiedrama · Today 19:00

The thing is, all benefits are being scrutinised. Those of you who are on UC or know someone who does knows that everyone has been asked to provide bank statements, sometimes six months to a year, proof of pensions or savings. It’s been utterly soul destroying and anxiety provoking. Why should people on UC be the only people who have to be judge?

Because UC is an income based benefit. They don't care what you spend it on. They're looking for other income that you have that hasn't been declared

Kirbert2 · Today 19:06

SleeplessInWherever · Today 19:05

We’re actually already scrutinised at the point of filling the mountain of paperwork in, in order to get that DLA.

I don’t believe UC has anywhere near as much oversight or evidence provided at point of application.

It doesn't.

UC is a walk in the park compared to DLA.

mydaughterisademon · Today 19:06

And what do they do about children who are eotas at 16/17 who are catching up due to school failing! The money is used on access to safe food and courses, to get her into work later down the line…

HatchetJob · Today 19:07

I’m one of those people who only applied when I had to give up my £36k job, I couldn’t even access carers allowance unless DD got DLA. we aren’t entitled to any other benefits. I suspect there are a lot of people like me.
Theres an awful lot of talk about targeted support now but it’s too little too late. What they need to do is spend a lot more money on schools early on and through secondary- penalising young people for lack of support and jobs isn’t helping anyone.
The threshold for special schools is very high now, DD was offered a medical school environment miles away, which didn’t suit her at all.
School did as much as they could but they are strapped for cash. DD would sometimes be in and out of school depending what support/staff was available.
Shes in sixth form now where there’s really no support, she’s on a 7 month waiting list from a new mental health service as CAHMS have been no help at all.
As well as ASD and anxiety, she has a long list of physical problems. There are weeks where I have to take her to 6 appointments as well as hospital stays - where they are unable to feed her food allergies so I have to go back and forth with food!
Im trying to get back to work but I’m not sure there are any employers who will tolerate this.
On top of this DH who has worked full time his
whole life is getting medically retired as his degenerative disease has hit a tipping point, so it’s not just that I have to support him, it’s that he can’t help with DD.

SleeplessInWherever · Today 19:09

Kirbert2 · Today 19:06

It doesn't.

UC is a walk in the park compared to DLA.

I assumed not.

I’m alright with being judged. He’s been judged.

When judged, and assessed, it was decided he qualifies for DLA.

That’s where that judgement ends, if we’re being sensible!

hibernatinghedgehog · Today 19:10

mydaughterisademon · Today 19:06

And what do they do about children who are eotas at 16/17 who are catching up due to school failing! The money is used on access to safe food and courses, to get her into work later down the line…

If your DD has EOTAS/EOTIS/C, the LA should be funding the educational provision, including courses. EOTAS/EOTIS/C is not EHE.

Not saying you can’t use PIP for safe foods, but in case you aren’t aware, if DD would receive free meals if she were in a setting, you can request reasonable adjustments in the form of a voucher or money. See Contact’s website and model letters.

BillieWiper · Today 19:17

Budgiedrama · Today 16:35

Would people be in favour of a receipt system where they submit the receipts once a year when renewing their claim? Because this is the only way I can see of working out if the extra money goes on what it’s supposed to.

What it's supposed to? I thought it was for the person to spend on whatever they need?
Why should someone submit receipts to prove how they spent their benefits?
Either it's for whatever you like or it's not? And how can someone be given money but need to justify where it went just because there disabled. That's discrimination.

plasticplate · Today 19:28

Budgiedrama · Today 16:35

Would people be in favour of a receipt system where they submit the receipts once a year when renewing their claim? Because this is the only way I can see of working out if the extra money goes on what it’s supposed to.

Think about the the practicalities of doing that.
Also those in receipt of other benefits don't have to it so why single out one group.

Stuckintheswing · Today 19:38

mydaughterisademon · Today 19:06

And what do they do about children who are eotas at 16/17 who are catching up due to school failing! The money is used on access to safe food and courses, to get her into work later down the line…

I am looking at private A-levels or a part time course for my 18yo teen next year to try and keep her ticking over. She may cope with additional education after college, which should then prevent her becoming a NEET. She's not capable of Uni or work just yet, but I think she'll be OK in time.

Happyindevon · Today 20:02

BillieWiper · Today 19:17

What it's supposed to? I thought it was for the person to spend on whatever they need?
Why should someone submit receipts to prove how they spent their benefits?
Either it's for whatever you like or it's not? And how can someone be given money but need to justify where it went just because there disabled. That's discrimination.

😂

BillieWiper · Today 20:31

Happyindevon · Today 20:02

😂

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Glad you find it funny.

XenoBitch · Today 20:40

I can't see it happening. The only people who want it to happen are those that think because they pay taxes (and many critical of benefits are not even net contributors.. and everyone pays taxes in some form anyway), they get to see what DLA/PIP is spent on, and have a say on it.

DLA/PIP is given in cash because the people claiming are assumed to be the best places to know how to spend it. Every single disabled person has different needs and costs. There is no one size fits all that would satisfy everyone claiming.

I have seen people break down their costs on here, and get obliterated for it (prime example of the PP on about fabric softener). I remember someone saying her autistic DD has equine therapy, and it is paid for with her PIP. Posters then blasting her mum for using tax payers money for "riding lessons" (when equine therapy is not that at all).

Moonlightfrog · Today 20:50

My dd is on the severe end of the spectrum, she’s 20 years old and gets high rate PIP (both care and mobility). My DD’s PIP doesn’t always cover her costs. We pay £68 a week for one day at day service, she gets through a lot of clothing and the washing machine is on a lot, she has allergies/intolerances so our food shop is pretty high. To encourage independence she takes money to her placement each day (day service and her educational placement) so she can purchase her lunch. She breaks a lot of things at home (her things and ours). She is home for 3 days a week and on these days she needs to be kept busy. Around £40 a week goes on fuel to get her to days service, her educational placement (an hour away) and to take her out on the days she’s home. She walks with a gait and needs insoles and wear through shoes every few months. We have paid for some health care, physio because it’s not easily available on the NHS.

I am currently petrified that her PIP will be taken from her as well as her mobility car and my carers allowance. I care for dd alone and we are already struggling to pay the bills. I often have to use my carers allowance to go towards dd.

caringcarer · Today 21:05

I used foster sons pip for counselling once a fortnight to keep him coping with life. I pay for a travel companion once a week who accompanied him to college and I drive to collect him. This in hope if he travels on train and tram enough with a companion eventually he'll be able to do it on his own but he is so far off that ATM. He has moderate learning disabilities so his IQ is 64. He can't cope without someone with him virtually all of the time. He is also autistic with sensory issues and can't cope with busy stations and ours has 14 platforms. He can't cope with platform announcements and general noise so wears headphones. He hates the information board as lights and moving all the time. If I go out for more than 1 hour I have to pay someone to be here with him. Up to an hour I can leave him with a snack, drink and TV football match. I record these and he doesn't care if he's seen it before or not because he will have forgotten the result as memory isdues. Sometimes I organise someone to come and sit with him and just go out for a coffee for a couple of hours just to de-stress. He also has 1-1 sports coaching every week because he needs to go very slowly and gets left behind in larger groups. All of his money gets spent on him. Anything left I save for him and he spends on activities to keep him amused in college holidays.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page