Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A review on what people spend DLA/PIP for children on

173 replies

DoaBetterReview · Today 12:40

After seeing all the controversy over the Milburn review and knowing first hand through family and work exactly where the majority of people claiming for dc spend their DLA/PIP I think there actually needs to be a better review conducted where they gather info on what it’s spent on to then identify the weak areas where they need to concentrate funding and efforts.

What is being proposed now is just support in the wrong place at the wrong time ! By 18-24 anyone with ND or MH issues are really struggling so significantly that it could be useless.

Everyone I know getting DLA or PIP for a child / young person is spending it on timely access to diagnosis and/or therapies. This is where the focus needs to be.

Also I’m still shocked at the language around PIP - IT IS NOT AN OUT OF WORK BENEFIT!!! Why is being referred to as if it is a lot of the time.

OP posts:
hibernatinghedgehog · Today 17:07

Budgiedrama · Today 17:05

@hibernatinghedgehogall that hasn’t happened since 2016, come on!

Actually, there is much more awareness and support to apply now compared to 2016, the cost of living is much more than 2016, NHS services have been cut since 2016, educational support for SEN is harder to access, there has been medical advancements within the last decade.

x2boys · Today 17:08

Budgiedrama · Today 17:02

@hibernatinghedgehogif an employer didnt let you have time off for school meetings, they could quickly be found guilty of discrimination. My boss has children with multiple disabilities herself.

Does she have to attend multiple meetings a week?
Be home for school tranport?
Regularly drop everthing because school have phoned?

PocketSand · Today 17:09

@Boomer55the thing is that an 18-24 year old is not a parent dependent child. You don’t receive CB or parental allowance of UC so the cost should be zero.

So why should parents of disabled adult children meet cost of care? Sod providing receipts - how would I receipt my 35+ hours of caring?

I’m done. Get in a PA (they’ll receipt 35 hours of caring) and the OT and SALT and psychological support and mental health outreach that ended with Covid lockdown. Then maybe I can have a life that is not about caring.

TigerRag · Today 17:11

Budgiedrama · Today 16:49

@CatchALeaf they might, but they might not even if their child didn't have a disability. If your child regularly goes to school 9-3 there is no reason you shouldn’t work.

And sleep when?

ickky · Today 17:12

Budgiedrama · Today 16:57

In England and Wales the child DLA caseload rose from 333,000 in 2013 to 682,000 in 2023, a rise of 104%. By 2023 that was around one in sixteen of all children aged nought to fifteen, double the proportion ten years earlier. In England specifically, the Institute for Fiscal Studies puts the share of under-sixteens on DLA at 7.2% in 2025, up from 3.4% in 2016.

Can anyone explain the increase in these figures? We haven’t suddenly evolved to all be disabled, and DLA is based on need not diagnosis so the old ‘people are more aware’ argument doesn’t work here as it’s based on need. So how do roughly twice the amount of children have needs high enough to qualify for this now? Compared to in 2016?

Could be a result of facilities closing due to austerity. Whereas before you could engage with a service which has since closed due to no funding.

Budgiedrama · Today 17:14

What I feel is that DLA is unfair. It’s unfair because life is so hard, for many parents, particularly single parents, and DLA is not a true reflection of whose needs are greater.
I see some families where the mum has three kids, who are traumatised from domestic abuse, and she doesn’t drive, and yet she has to get a bus too and from a supermarket job. Which she will get sacked from after all her kids have caught every bug going, as they’re living off crap food with no nutritional value. And then when shes sacked she’ll be back having to spend 30 hours a week job seeking.
Yet there are middle class families who don’t even need the money who apply, after getting a private diagnosis for their one highly academic child who goes to school every day and will probably go to guides and off on camp. And the mum was never going to work anyway but now she gets carers and no work commitments. Because the form is just an exercise in writing in a persuasive way, which luckily the mum is great at as she went to Cambridge…
They don’t even need the money and it goes on nice things. But unlike PIP you can write the answers in a way that emphasises certain things and hides others. And no one is ever declined, not that I’ve heard of.
And the money really should go to families who are barely existing, who are going to food banks and scraping by on Tesco wages and UC top ups.

NeverDropYourMooncup · Today 17:15

The last thing parents need is having to account for every single penny in the knowledge that it'll be pored over and criticised to justify why it shouldn't be spent.

Some parents use it for something like getting a cab home rather than put their kid (or themselves) through standing in the freezing cold for 45min in the hope of getting a bus. Some use it to cover the increased heating bill for a child who is in pain if they get too cold like when waiting 45mins for a bus. Some spend on a particular brand of food because it's the kid's safe one. Some bung it all in the pot because it doesn't actually matter whether the additional costs of the child's disability are paid from their wages or the DLA and the council tax bill is paid immediately after the DLA goes in rather than the salary, the child is still benefiting from the payment.

It might sound reasonable to say 'oh yes, well if it's spent on the child for therapy, it'll be easy to evidence', but that excludes those who spend on their child having their own bedroom, having Kellogg's instead of ASDA's cornflakes or being able to stay in a more flexible job/one that's close to the school and still cover the bills.

GetOffTheBedCalicoCat · Today 17:16

Honestly @Budgiedrama if you really think o-one is ever declined from DLA or PIP then you know NOTHING about it. Nothing at all.

BluebellBeth · Today 17:17

Budgiedrama · Today 16:57

In England and Wales the child DLA caseload rose from 333,000 in 2013 to 682,000 in 2023, a rise of 104%. By 2023 that was around one in sixteen of all children aged nought to fifteen, double the proportion ten years earlier. In England specifically, the Institute for Fiscal Studies puts the share of under-sixteens on DLA at 7.2% in 2025, up from 3.4% in 2016.

Can anyone explain the increase in these figures? We haven’t suddenly evolved to all be disabled, and DLA is based on need not diagnosis so the old ‘people are more aware’ argument doesn’t work here as it’s based on need. So how do roughly twice the amount of children have needs high enough to qualify for this now? Compared to in 2016?

Why doesn't that argument work here? If more people are aware then there will naturally be an increase in claims, plus people may have become more aware they're eligible.

x2boys · Today 17:18

Budgiedrama · Today 17:14

What I feel is that DLA is unfair. It’s unfair because life is so hard, for many parents, particularly single parents, and DLA is not a true reflection of whose needs are greater.
I see some families where the mum has three kids, who are traumatised from domestic abuse, and she doesn’t drive, and yet she has to get a bus too and from a supermarket job. Which she will get sacked from after all her kids have caught every bug going, as they’re living off crap food with no nutritional value. And then when shes sacked she’ll be back having to spend 30 hours a week job seeking.
Yet there are middle class families who don’t even need the money who apply, after getting a private diagnosis for their one highly academic child who goes to school every day and will probably go to guides and off on camp. And the mum was never going to work anyway but now she gets carers and no work commitments. Because the form is just an exercise in writing in a persuasive way, which luckily the mum is great at as she went to Cambridge…
They don’t even need the money and it goes on nice things. But unlike PIP you can write the answers in a way that emphasises certain things and hides others. And no one is ever declined, not that I’ve heard of.
And the money really should go to families who are barely existing, who are going to food banks and scraping by on Tesco wages and UC top ups.

Its called Disabillty living allowance not impoverished single mum allowance
And whilst somone may get a private diagnosis they would still need evidence.

Budgiedrama · Today 17:19

@GetOffTheBedCalicoCatPIP is different, it’s hard to get. DLA is awarded 84% of the time, thats pretty high

LoisPrice · Today 17:20

Replaces my income as couldn’t work full time any longer due to high medical needs. Nursery hasn’t been an option yet

it nowhere near covers what I’d earn if working full time and paying fir nursery

TigerRag · Today 17:21

Budgiedrama · Today 17:14

What I feel is that DLA is unfair. It’s unfair because life is so hard, for many parents, particularly single parents, and DLA is not a true reflection of whose needs are greater.
I see some families where the mum has three kids, who are traumatised from domestic abuse, and she doesn’t drive, and yet she has to get a bus too and from a supermarket job. Which she will get sacked from after all her kids have caught every bug going, as they’re living off crap food with no nutritional value. And then when shes sacked she’ll be back having to spend 30 hours a week job seeking.
Yet there are middle class families who don’t even need the money who apply, after getting a private diagnosis for their one highly academic child who goes to school every day and will probably go to guides and off on camp. And the mum was never going to work anyway but now she gets carers and no work commitments. Because the form is just an exercise in writing in a persuasive way, which luckily the mum is great at as she went to Cambridge…
They don’t even need the money and it goes on nice things. But unlike PIP you can write the answers in a way that emphasises certain things and hides others. And no one is ever declined, not that I’ve heard of.
And the money really should go to families who are barely existing, who are going to food banks and scraping by on Tesco wages and UC top ups.

The two aren't comparable

x2boys · Today 17:21

Budgiedrama · Today 17:19

@GetOffTheBedCalicoCatPIP is different, it’s hard to get. DLA is awarded 84% of the time, thats pretty high

Do you have a link for that?

SleeplessInWherever · Today 17:22

@Budgiedrama

DLA is unfair in much the same way having a child with disability is unfair.

UC is for the situation you’re describing. That mum would be being topped up, supported with rent payments, and to be clear I’m very glad she would be.

Single parents of disabled children exist. Parents who are unable to work in a supermarket job, or any job.

My son is 10, and has a cognitive ability of a 2.5 - 3 year old. Until his reassessment he was in receipt of lower rate DLA. He now gets higher for both elements. This idea that disability benefit is easy to get, and nobody ever tries to give you the least possible, is an absolute myth.

BluebellBeth · Today 17:23

Budgiedrama · Today 17:02

@hibernatinghedgehogif an employer didnt let you have time off for school meetings, they could quickly be found guilty of discrimination. My boss has children with multiple disabilities herself.

Oh goody, more admin, stress and expense to add to the list.

hibernatinghedgehog · Today 17:26

Some are declined DLA. You can’t compare the success rate of DLA claims to PIP. Different benefits, different criteria and DLA has a lower care rate which PIP doesn’t have.

DLA is based on needs, not diagnosis, so it isn’t based on a private diagnosis.

Some DC who are traumatised are eligible for DLA.

That single mother working in Tesco who has 3 DC will be getting UC. It isn’t like she won’t be getting any benefits.

Families with disabled DC are not immune to other life stressors on top.

Monty36 · Today 17:27

It is an excellent question OP. The payments are based on need.
But are not based on what additional cost, if any, is associated with that need.

narcASD · Today 17:28

FriggadyDiggady · Today 15:42

Fags and McDonalds.
Put your pitchforks down! The fags are for the kids.

Yep and also people who are earning £5k a month living in houses worth over one million getting get PIP.

it goes on care & mobility needs, no means tested and you can work full time on it.

BluebellBeth · Today 17:31

Budgiedrama · Today 17:14

What I feel is that DLA is unfair. It’s unfair because life is so hard, for many parents, particularly single parents, and DLA is not a true reflection of whose needs are greater.
I see some families where the mum has three kids, who are traumatised from domestic abuse, and she doesn’t drive, and yet she has to get a bus too and from a supermarket job. Which she will get sacked from after all her kids have caught every bug going, as they’re living off crap food with no nutritional value. And then when shes sacked she’ll be back having to spend 30 hours a week job seeking.
Yet there are middle class families who don’t even need the money who apply, after getting a private diagnosis for their one highly academic child who goes to school every day and will probably go to guides and off on camp. And the mum was never going to work anyway but now she gets carers and no work commitments. Because the form is just an exercise in writing in a persuasive way, which luckily the mum is great at as she went to Cambridge…
They don’t even need the money and it goes on nice things. But unlike PIP you can write the answers in a way that emphasises certain things and hides others. And no one is ever declined, not that I’ve heard of.
And the money really should go to families who are barely existing, who are going to food banks and scraping by on Tesco wages and UC top ups.

Yes single parents who are struggling should get help. That's not actually related to dla though is it. Shit tonnes of parents claim CB when they could live without it, why don't you go after them instead on picking on vulnerable disabled families?

and you only get carers allowance if you get middle or high rate dla which would indicate significant needs.

BeLemonMoose · Today 17:31

You haven't read the milburn review have you? It does talk about early years provision

TheDrsDocMartens · Today 17:31

Dd- not in school so covering all her education costs, parent 1:1 with her while she works with tutors, transport to the only exercise she will do which is an hour each way. Like many people have said, extra showers, different foods, clothing is complicated.
Cannot go anywhere on her own or with friends like her peers do because she’s masking so much she can’t speak.

DS- damages/loses everything. He’s not as sensory as dd but there are definitely specific things he has over the basic ones I’d normally buy. Taken places way beyond when he should have been ready too. Probably by the time he reaches 16, he won’t be eligible for PIP as he will have caught up in independence. Won’t help with the losing and trashing things but hopefully that’ll improve too.

narcASD · Today 17:31

DLA, PIP and AA are all non means tested.

Its a strange system, can be very unfair, I work in the DWP have over 20 years experience so see it from all sides.

Dicedpumpkin · Today 17:32

Lots of people think if benefits purely in terms of relief of poverty and most are so its not unusual to therefore think they should be means tested.

I lean a bit more to "universal" so if its for disability its for disability not poverty. Just like old age pension is fir olfd age not just poor and old age.

There are other relief of poverty benefits.

I can see the trying to qualify costs but I agree this gets very complicated and runs the risk of very high bills if peoples costs are very high.