Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A review on what people spend DLA/PIP for children on

173 replies

DoaBetterReview · Today 12:40

After seeing all the controversy over the Milburn review and knowing first hand through family and work exactly where the majority of people claiming for dc spend their DLA/PIP I think there actually needs to be a better review conducted where they gather info on what it’s spent on to then identify the weak areas where they need to concentrate funding and efforts.

What is being proposed now is just support in the wrong place at the wrong time ! By 18-24 anyone with ND or MH issues are really struggling so significantly that it could be useless.

Everyone I know getting DLA or PIP for a child / young person is spending it on timely access to diagnosis and/or therapies. This is where the focus needs to be.

Also I’m still shocked at the language around PIP - IT IS NOT AN OUT OF WORK BENEFIT!!! Why is being referred to as if it is a lot of the time.

OP posts:
Chinscratches · Today 18:00

Maybe they can also look at the cost of chronic /disabling conditions that don't quite qualify for PIP. I know so many people who don't meet the criteria and are too honest to play some of the games advised to get their application approved but have vast additional costs due to their conditions.

GetOffTheBedCalicoCat · Today 18:01

Berniestavern · Today 17:56

This is the reason why some people are desperate to see a review…shampoo and fabric conditioner. Ye gods.

It was a fucking example as to why there are extra additional costs when someone has a disability.

Wowsers. I have been so raw and real about something that is so utterly distressing and disabling for us and how it affects our family. I have said that this is nothing in the scheme of things, compared to many.

Do you know, I cry most days with despair about DS and worry about his ability to cope with life.

And yes- £200 odd quid a month extra because of his OCD (separate from counseling, separate from the fact I gave up work, separate from the fact we have to pay more for heating an water and electricity and everything because of things- well- you walk a day in my shoes. I am not cruel enough to hope you ever experience it what we have experienced for 17 fucking years. I'm not that cruel. But posters on this thread luxuriate in their normalcy and think that it is down to whatever- superior parenting?. Fuck knows. I genuinely hope you never know what this is like.

Happyindevon · Today 18:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

DoaBetterReview · Today 18:01

HeBeaverandSheBeaver · Today 17:46

Just to point out have you got any idea how much money people on carers allowance actually save the government long-term because believe me it’s a lot

CA wasn’t mentioned at all in the Milburn review and as there were no details of any new disability benefit schemes for 18-24 it’s worrying as what will happen re carers allowance ?

My aim when starting this thread wasn’t to ignite arguments about fabric conditioner it was to see if there are multiple people having to use DLA for therapies that the government should be looking at funding as an alternative to putting billions into a youth employment scheme that may or may not work yet we know for definite that early interventions with SALT, physio and OT is proven to improve long term outcomes for ND children.

OP posts:
Velumental · Today 18:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Are you sure you're happy in Devon? You're more like irate at people wanting to eat and wash their clothes in Devon

DoaBetterReview · Today 18:04

GetOffTheBedCalicoCat · Today 18:01

It was a fucking example as to why there are extra additional costs when someone has a disability.

Wowsers. I have been so raw and real about something that is so utterly distressing and disabling for us and how it affects our family. I have said that this is nothing in the scheme of things, compared to many.

Do you know, I cry most days with despair about DS and worry about his ability to cope with life.

And yes- £200 odd quid a month extra because of his OCD (separate from counseling, separate from the fact I gave up work, separate from the fact we have to pay more for heating an water and electricity and everything because of things- well- you walk a day in my shoes. I am not cruel enough to hope you ever experience it what we have experienced for 17 fucking years. I'm not that cruel. But posters on this thread luxuriate in their normalcy and think that it is down to whatever- superior parenting?. Fuck knows. I genuinely hope you never know what this is like.

I’m so sorry you have been given such a hard time on here it is totally unacceptable.

OP posts:
GetOffTheBedCalicoCat · Today 18:05

Thank you.

LetMeGoogleThat · Today 18:05

cupfinalchaos · Today 17:38

You don’t even think one should have to prove there’s a disability?

You are aware that there is an application process? I don't believe that outside of that, additional scrutiny of how the the money is used is necessary. The whole process is based on needs, there is already a process for changing needs.

Chinscratches · Today 18:05

GetOffTheBedCalicoCat · Today 18:01

It was a fucking example as to why there are extra additional costs when someone has a disability.

Wowsers. I have been so raw and real about something that is so utterly distressing and disabling for us and how it affects our family. I have said that this is nothing in the scheme of things, compared to many.

Do you know, I cry most days with despair about DS and worry about his ability to cope with life.

And yes- £200 odd quid a month extra because of his OCD (separate from counseling, separate from the fact I gave up work, separate from the fact we have to pay more for heating an water and electricity and everything because of things- well- you walk a day in my shoes. I am not cruel enough to hope you ever experience it what we have experienced for 17 fucking years. I'm not that cruel. But posters on this thread luxuriate in their normalcy and think that it is down to whatever- superior parenting?. Fuck knows. I genuinely hope you never know what this is like.

everyone has costs for their children. No child skips through life without challenges.
For my two, neither of whom qualify for any benefits (at least they don't if I am honest on the form)

  • huge additional costs due to their multiple food allergies
  • the cost of therapy as a result of abuse from their dad
  • the legal costs to keep them safe from their dad
  • costs of hospital parking for clinics and emergency appointments (probably at least once every few weeks)
  • cost of missed time off work to care for them
  • cost of tutors to top up the education they miss when their asthma flares.

There's this weird assumption that anyone not claiming doesn't have any additional costs or challenges and that's just so ridiculously far from the truth

Happyindevon · Today 18:05

GetOffTheBedCalicoCat · Today 18:01

It was a fucking example as to why there are extra additional costs when someone has a disability.

Wowsers. I have been so raw and real about something that is so utterly distressing and disabling for us and how it affects our family. I have said that this is nothing in the scheme of things, compared to many.

Do you know, I cry most days with despair about DS and worry about his ability to cope with life.

And yes- £200 odd quid a month extra because of his OCD (separate from counseling, separate from the fact I gave up work, separate from the fact we have to pay more for heating an water and electricity and everything because of things- well- you walk a day in my shoes. I am not cruel enough to hope you ever experience it what we have experienced for 17 fucking years. I'm not that cruel. But posters on this thread luxuriate in their normalcy and think that it is down to whatever- superior parenting?. Fuck knows. I genuinely hope you never know what this is like.

Nobody luxuriates in it; I’ve been very severely mentally ill and have been through fairly extreme abuse as a child. I haven’t had a luxury life; I know what it is to suffer. But I DO think parents are so emotional about their child’s distress, and terrified they’ll kill themselves, they get trapped in a pattern of seeing their demands as ‘needs’ and fighting for them.

If we withdrew all financial support bar the bare minimum from everyone with these ‘needs’ (SEMH/MH, the type who can go on holiday and have fun but NOT work or attend school), I think less than 1% would actually kill themselves. Necessity would push the others through a painful transition to the point where they take responsibility for themselves.

The alternative is to keep running the country as a very expensive life support system where taxpayers dwindle and become increasingly resentful, but the SEMH people get what they want… until we can’t afford it.

I would choose option 1.

PDAblues · Today 18:06

hibernatinghedgehog · Today 17:03

There are lots of reasons. For example, there is more awareness of DLA now and support to apply. So parents whose DC are eligible apply more often than they did in the past. Some who didn’t apply previously because they didn’t need it financially do now because of the cost of living. Some who didn’t apply previously because their DC were getting the support they need anyway now claim DLA to use it for therapies/educational support/equipment they now don’t get because services have been cut. Some DC who would have previously died now don’t die because of medical advancements.

Yes, we didn't apply for years until it came more on our radar for whatever reason. I've had 16 years of being unable to work due to caregiving responsibilities, but my DC have only received DLA for 2-3 years.

Velumental · Today 18:06

Velumental · Today 17:41

We started claiming DLA for my son for 2 reasons, firstly I had to reduce my hours and change jobs due to frequent hospitalisations and difficulty a cessing childcare and education settings because he struggled to attend even nursery age 1 let alone school age 8. He grows faster than the average child now being 4foot 9 and 6 stone at 8 yrs old so it's constant buying of shoes and clothes. He struggles to sleep and has sensory needs so we access a play club and a trampoline park with an sessions. he was a runner so we had to run a. Second car (he doesn't get the mobility component despite this but sometimes he just can't be safely walked places so the car is necessary)

Parenting him DOES cost more than parenting his younger sister, I've always thought of her as neurotypicl but she's been referred for ASD assessment since starting school, she however manages so much better and the impact on our practical and financial aspects of our lives just hasn't been there. But then she accesses a lot of things because her brother does as she has been a tagalong.

We've not used it to access diagnosis etc because we've been fortunate to have enough neurology input to justify the services we access.

Meant toa DD the second reason, a child claiming DLA is proof of disability in a roundabout way, I have had to take parental leave and having a child with a disability entitled you to take in 1 day increments rather than having to take entire weeks. It's also a justification if you end up in an attendance review for the amount of parental leave you've taken. We had to claim to protect ourselves. I'm over feeling guilty though because I can assure you parenting my son is significantly harder than average. We've had to juggle our careers so someone is hope for drop offs to school as breakfast club wasn't an option for various health related reasons and someone had to be within dashing distance of school P1 and P2 for medication and recurrent emergency related reasons.

Happyindevon · Today 18:08

Chinscratches · Today 18:05

everyone has costs for their children. No child skips through life without challenges.
For my two, neither of whom qualify for any benefits (at least they don't if I am honest on the form)

  • huge additional costs due to their multiple food allergies
  • the cost of therapy as a result of abuse from their dad
  • the legal costs to keep them safe from their dad
  • costs of hospital parking for clinics and emergency appointments (probably at least once every few weeks)
  • cost of missed time off work to care for them
  • cost of tutors to top up the education they miss when their asthma flares.

There's this weird assumption that anyone not claiming doesn't have any additional costs or challenges and that's just so ridiculously far from the truth

Yes, this!!!! We have:

  1. Special toothpaste for my daughters teeth
  2. Eczema cream for my son - he can’t use normal stuff, or he breaks out, so costs a fortune
  3. I’m type 1 diabetes so extra food, specific types of food, and purchasing items for my comorbidities and symptoms - this is really expensive
  4. DH’s physio for his knee after a sports injury
  5. For a long time DD had gland dysfunction in her eye and needed over the counter treatments and compresses
  6. DS was CMPA as a baby and I was breastfeeding so had to buy alternatives for both of us while still giving DD dairy

That’s off the top of my head. Like any other kids they need to learn to swim, partake in clubs for their socialisation and happiness.

We don’t get a penny in benefits.

Happyindevon · Today 18:10

Velumental · Today 18:03

Are you sure you're happy in Devon? You're more like irate at people wanting to eat and wash their clothes in Devon

If it’s costing the taxpayer £30 a week, yeah. Otherwise wash with liquid gold for all I care, if you’re self funding.

TheodoreisntBeth · Today 18:10

Budgiedrama · Today 17:49

@TheodoreisntBetherr yeah actually. I’ve worked with many nurses with children with disabilities. I’ve also pulled over on the side of the road on the way to a community visit to join an EHCP review or to speak to the SENCO. If you don’t try, you don’t know. And if you don’t hold these employers accountable nothing will change. If you’re clear that you will need these adaptations and you might need to drop everything to go to your child, they can either accept it or not, but I think many know they’re on very dodgy ground to say ‘no’ straight away. Either you or your partner or even a grandparent need to be the point of contact, there is no reason the default has to be the woman. Too many women leave rather than be inconvenient and boundaried. If you know your worth, and work hard, employers will just have to deal with it. Harder when you have no support I understand that. But why in a two parent household does the woman always become the carer? There are higher divorce rates for parents of disabled children, so women should prioritise their financial independence at all costs. Get the husband to take on some of the admin!

Sure, you know loads of nurses whose employers are completely fine about them leaving part way through a shift several times a month. So many employers want to employ people whose focus is always at least half somewhere else, who are unreliable and who've probably not had an unbroken night's sleep in years. Were very in demand.

Again, why is it that you think employers are in dodgy ground to say that's not ok? That's nonsense. The odd emergency most employers will suck up, but we're not talking about the odd emergency. And not all of us have a husband or grandparents to step in. Check your privilege.

Berniestavern · Today 18:11

TheDrsDocMartens · Today 17:31

Dd- not in school so covering all her education costs, parent 1:1 with her while she works with tutors, transport to the only exercise she will do which is an hour each way. Like many people have said, extra showers, different foods, clothing is complicated.
Cannot go anywhere on her own or with friends like her peers do because she’s masking so much she can’t speak.

DS- damages/loses everything. He’s not as sensory as dd but there are definitely specific things he has over the basic ones I’d normally buy. Taken places way beyond when he should have been ready too. Probably by the time he reaches 16, he won’t be eligible for PIP as he will have caught up in independence. Won’t help with the losing and trashing things but hopefully that’ll improve too.

But why should the taxpayer pay?

I’m not just being facetious here, it’s a serious question.

hibernatinghedgehog · Today 18:11

Chinscratches · Today 18:05

everyone has costs for their children. No child skips through life without challenges.
For my two, neither of whom qualify for any benefits (at least they don't if I am honest on the form)

  • huge additional costs due to their multiple food allergies
  • the cost of therapy as a result of abuse from their dad
  • the legal costs to keep them safe from their dad
  • costs of hospital parking for clinics and emergency appointments (probably at least once every few weeks)
  • cost of missed time off work to care for them
  • cost of tutors to top up the education they miss when their asthma flares.

There's this weird assumption that anyone not claiming doesn't have any additional costs or challenges and that's just so ridiculously far from the truth

Many DC who have multiple allergies, need therapy and whose asthma is sever enough that they repeatedly miss enough school to need tutors would be eligible for DLA at one rate or another.

BTW, if a CSA child is unable to attend school full-time due to their medical needs, the LA is responsible for ensuring they still receive a suitable full-time education. That can be tutoring.

Those with disabled DC receiving DLA are not immune from having other costs such as legal costs.

cupfinalchaos · Today 18:12

LetMeGoogleThat · Today 18:05

You are aware that there is an application process? I don't believe that outside of that, additional scrutiny of how the the money is used is necessary. The whole process is based on needs, there is already a process for changing needs.

I think that with the underfunded state of public services as they are, it’s extremely necessary.

strictlybusinessuntildecember · Today 18:12

I’m in the process of completing DLA forms for my child - they still require specialist nappies compared to other children their age and also incontinence pants (doubly incontinent) which I had been buying at £12 each but the constant soiling means I just can’t get them clean so get replaced a lot and they can need changing several times a day. I’ve never had to do a DLA form before (child has been unwell for several years now as long term condition became apparent) but cost of living all round is biting and as a family we don’t receive any benefits whatsoever including CB (yes I’m over the threshold but I’m also a lone parent of 3 with a disappeared ex husband who doesn’t pay CMS) so if they are awarded it (and I would assume it will be the lowest award) it will all get spent on the sanitary and personal hygiene products they need.

Chinscratches · Today 18:14

Happyindevon · Today 18:08

Yes, this!!!! We have:

  1. Special toothpaste for my daughters teeth
  2. Eczema cream for my son - he can’t use normal stuff, or he breaks out, so costs a fortune
  3. I’m type 1 diabetes so extra food, specific types of food, and purchasing items for my comorbidities and symptoms - this is really expensive
  4. DH’s physio for his knee after a sports injury
  5. For a long time DD had gland dysfunction in her eye and needed over the counter treatments and compresses
  6. DS was CMPA as a baby and I was breastfeeding so had to buy alternatives for both of us while still giving DD dairy

That’s off the top of my head. Like any other kids they need to learn to swim, partake in clubs for their socialisation and happiness.

We don’t get a penny in benefits.

Exactly. Those were just the costs for my children. For me (and again, if I am honest I don't meet the PIP criteria although I guess if I lied I would):

  • electric wheelchair for bad days (cost over £2000 to meet my needs)
  • cleaner
  • running costs for a car because I am dependent on it
  • high parking costs because I can't do things like park and ride
  • hospital parking regularly

Thankfully at least my condition means free prescriptions. But that's it. Thats all I get

Chinscratches · Today 18:15

hibernatinghedgehog · Today 18:11

Many DC who have multiple allergies, need therapy and whose asthma is sever enough that they repeatedly miss enough school to need tutors would be eligible for DLA at one rate or another.

BTW, if a CSA child is unable to attend school full-time due to their medical needs, the LA is responsible for ensuring they still receive a suitable full-time education. That can be tutoring.

Those with disabled DC receiving DLA are not immune from having other costs such as legal costs.

The point is all kinds of aspects of life come with extra costs. There has to be a grown up conversation about where the line is drawn

BluebellBeth · Today 18:15

Berniestavern · Today 17:56

This is the reason why some people are desperate to see a review…shampoo and fabric conditioner. Ye gods.

Dla is to cover the additional expenses of being disabled. If that disability means a family uses more water/gas/shampoo/handwash/wash powder, that's exactly what's it's there for.

This is also why they're not means tested. So that people aren't disadvantaged from the disability related expenses.

x2boys · Today 18:16

Happyindevon · Today 18:08

Yes, this!!!! We have:

  1. Special toothpaste for my daughters teeth
  2. Eczema cream for my son - he can’t use normal stuff, or he breaks out, so costs a fortune
  3. I’m type 1 diabetes so extra food, specific types of food, and purchasing items for my comorbidities and symptoms - this is really expensive
  4. DH’s physio for his knee after a sports injury
  5. For a long time DD had gland dysfunction in her eye and needed over the counter treatments and compresses
  6. DS was CMPA as a baby and I was breastfeeding so had to buy alternatives for both of us while still giving DD dairy

That’s off the top of my head. Like any other kids they need to learn to swim, partake in clubs for their socialisation and happiness.

We don’t get a penny in benefits.

What special foods do you need for being diabetic
My oldest son is type3c treated as type1
The only things he specifically needs are jelly babies in case of hypos.

emuloc · Today 18:16

Boomer55 · Today 16:08

The government say they are looking as to why a ND child needs more money than any other parent dependent child.

I don't know the answers, but best leave it to the professionals. 🤷‍♀️

Edited

They should be told to head over to MN then, they would learn a lot that way, and maybe not be so quick to want to cut benefits for people who are ND, who seem to be the main target, from what I can see.

hibernatinghedgehog · Today 18:16

Chinscratches · Today 18:15

The point is all kinds of aspects of life come with extra costs. There has to be a grown up conversation about where the line is drawn

Yes, and those with disabled DC on DLA have those additional costs on top of the costs associated with being disabled. Other aspects of life that come with extra costs don’t just disappear.