Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask my daughter’s teacher to check she’s dressed properly after PE?

257 replies

Gertrudethechicken · Yesterday 19:50

My daughter is five and came home from school today after PE wearing her trousers back to front, her shoes on the wrong feet and, bizarrely, with no T-shirt on at all (just her jumper).
It’s November!

I appreciate that children need to learn independence and I’m certainly not expecting someone to get her dressed from head to toe. However, she’s five, and she still needs a bit of help getting dressed. She needs help at home too, and we’re working on developing those skills.

I’ve politely messaged her teacher asking if someone could give her a little hand after PE and just check she’s properly dressed before sending her home.

I’m not asking for anything unreasonable, or am I? I have quite a lot of anxiety about her at school as we’ve had afew issues already and I don’t feel the school have been great at communication.

AIBU to expect a member of staff to make sure a five-year-old has actually got all her clothes on properly before leaving school? Or am I being silly?

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · Today 07:13

As a teacher who has taught all ages, I would say that it’s important for the adults to ensure all the children are dressed correctly when getting changed after PE. I would also qualify that, however, with the fact that getting 30 4.5 year olds changed, lined up, in the hall, do a PE lesson and then changed again is an absolute nightmare!!!
Yes, parents need to teach their Dc how to get changed, but why would a teacher leave a 5 year old incorrectly dressed for what could be all day if PE is first lesson, clothes back to front and shoes on the wrong feet? It takes seconds to remind a child about putting their pants on correctly or shoes on the correct feet.

Missey85 · Today 07:14

Ligesani · Yesterday 19:56

Yanbu, she's still very little and this is part of a teacher's job.

Or the parent could parent? Why in hell is EVERYTHING the teachers fault? And you wonder why nobody wants to teach anymore 😂

Hadenough32 · Today 07:14

Not the teachers job but I wouldn't like them not having their tops all on in November..Just send her in in her pe kit on pe days

Differentforgirls · Today 07:15

augustuss · Yesterday 22:17

So for six hours a day, every week day, we leave our five year olds without childcare?

Yes.

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · Today 07:15

augustuss · Yesterday 22:43

No one is actually demanding teachers teach children how to dress. They are saying the five year old’s MISTAKE should have been noticed (shoes on wrong feet especially as it’s a tripping hazard) and someone at some point should have prompted the child to correct their mistake.

Honestly, I can’t believe actual parents are looking for excuses here as to why this is such an impossible ask. Do we need more staff in schools - Yes! Let’s shift collective focus on demanding that from decision makers. Don’t settle for what is inadequate.

It is impossible really 30 little chaos monkeys.

If teachers had to help the vet dressed.... They'd have to help multiple times a day.

Putting in 30 coats at break, lunch, second break and after school.... Helping 30 kids in and out of jumpers/cardigans

Helping 30 kids pull up trousers/tights/underwear etc 1-3 times adaybagyer toileting

30+ kids getting into PE kit, and then again I to uniform.

And then any other random reason's that occur because if the chaos.

I always think that people who say things like this have absolutely ZERO experience of what it is like in a classroom.

The parents have had at least 3 years to teach this skill to their children. Parents are so fucking lazy these days, can't be bothered to teach kids how to dress, toilet train them, how to lose, take turns, climb etc. everything is now the schools job apparently.

BendingSpoons · Today 07:15

TheMessyMermaid · Today 06:54

Actually it's not. It's not part of the curriculum to teach a child how to dress themselves. Would you also expect teachers to toilet trains kids, teach them how to use a knife and fork, teach them to tie their shoe laces, teach them how to wash dishes? School doesn't teach everything a child needs to learn, parents are expected to educate their children as well

Actually if this child is in Reception, then getting dressed is part of the EYFS. Under Personal, Social and Emotional Development, there is a section on Managing Self, which includes things like getting dressed.

Missey85 · Today 07:16

DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 07:08

It's also child care. They are caring for the children in place of the parents while they are there, particularly when they are so little. This seems to be entirely forgotten these days.

No it's education not childcare you want a nanny pay for one it's not the teachers job!

EatMoreChocolate44 · Today 07:18

Thegirlwhowent · Yesterday 23:09

@EatMoreChocolate44 I used to teach 11-14 year olds. One woman said to me that she'd hate to be a teacher because 'it must be so boring just sitting and watching them do the work you've set them.' Boredom was not the reason I gave up teaching!

😂 Yes, it's never boring. That's one of the reasons I enjoy it (despite the stresses). The day goes so fast and there isn't a day where we don't laugh (as well as cry 😂🙈).

Caiti19 · Today 07:22

I am shocked any school has 5 year olds changing into and out of a PE uniform. Crikey, I can only imagine the time wastage and chaos with lost/accidentally exchanged items. School life can be challenging/exhausting enough in those first years without introducing totally avoidable hurdles in their day. They should be going to school in their PE gear.

Moonnstarz · Today 07:24

Could I also remind people at this point to ensure they put a name label in the PE kit.
The number of items that end up not claimed grows as the term goes on, and children all deny the items are theirs!

So far this term off the top of my head head we have various socks (some white, some black), 3 pairs of black PE shorts, 3 t shirts and 1 black hoodie.

Also just remembered the week I spent about 5 minutes helping a child look through her PE bag for her school socks only to discover the reason we couldn't spot any was because she had worn tights that day (which were hiding under her jumper on the table).

Differentforgirls · Today 07:28

DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 07:08

It's also child care. They are caring for the children in place of the parents while they are there, particularly when they are so little. This seems to be entirely forgotten these days.

It’s not been forgotten as it has never been a thing.

Lexibletheflexible · Today 07:35

Differentforgirls · Today 07:28

It’s not been forgotten as it has never been a thing.

Its always been a thing. Just some parents are fine with their children not receiving care at school and other parents (like me) would never send their child to school knowing they won't be cared for. That's why I'd only pick up my kid in that state once before their class teacher understood that they can't show that lack of care for my 5 year old.

When you choose to teach the youngest kids, you know the care level is going to be high. That's why some people choose secondary or year 4 up.

Rainbowcat77 · Today 07:37

Itwasthe90s · Yesterday 19:51

Your DD is still getting changed for PE?

I thought most schools abandoned the getting changed in school for PE thing since COVID, and that kids just wear their PE kit all day on PE days.

But to answer your question - Yes, YABU. The teacher has 30 kids to oversee, not just yours.

Edited

I realise this doesn’t actually help you Op but this post nails it.
for the love of God, why are some schools still insisting on a weekly ritual of children taking their clothes off in front of their whole peer group?

It wastes a huge amount of time, is irritating and stressful for teachers, often humiliating for the kids, gives a wonderful opportunity for bullying and body shaming and leaves little ones with their clothes all muddled up and missing afterwards.

instead of focussing your attention on your child’s class teacher (who almost certainly hates it as much as you do!) why not approach the HT and ask if they can consider the kids wearing PE kit all day?

Differentforgirls · Today 07:38

Lexibletheflexible · Today 07:35

Its always been a thing. Just some parents are fine with their children not receiving care at school and other parents (like me) would never send their child to school knowing they won't be cared for. That's why I'd only pick up my kid in that state once before their class teacher understood that they can't show that lack of care for my 5 year old.

When you choose to teach the youngest kids, you know the care level is going to be high. That's why some people choose secondary or year 4 up.

Different qualifications for secondary. You’re right, some children don’t have the tools as their parents haven’t taught them. Awful.

Lexibletheflexible · Today 07:43

Differentforgirls · Today 07:38

Different qualifications for secondary. You’re right, some children don’t have the tools as their parents haven’t taught them. Awful.

No children just develop skills at different times. Spatial awareness and dexterity is needed for dressing. Some kids will have less refined skills than others at 5. It's on the adults to provide a space to practice the skill and then when it comes to something like dressing properly, the adult then ensures it is done appropriately.

As you say, most 5 year olds can do this quite well. So you're only really supporting the few who arent as capable at this skill. You don't have to dreas 30 5 year olds but in truth, you might have to mostly dress at least 1 child in reception.

Sirzy · Today 07:44

I wish some people on here could experience just for one day what staff in a reception class (and any school staff!) are doing for their children day in day out.

It’s no wonder so many are at breaking point when no matter what they do it’s not good enough for some.

Moonnstarz · Today 07:47

Also remembered another funny story....I had a child come to me after going to the toilet to tell me they had forgotten to put their pants on that morning and could I find them some! So even parents might not send their child dressed correctly to school and any items that go under other clothing are less easy to notice. (This was one of our most sensible children too 😂).

Boomer55 · Today 07:51

YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 20:31

Sorry OP, teachers are the sacred caste here you will not get any sympathy.

Not really. I’m not a teacher, never was, and don’t see them as sacred, but I’d expect a 5 year old to be fully toilet trained and able to get changed, without needing the teacher to help. It’s the parents’ job to sort this out.

Differentforgirls · Today 07:58

Lexibletheflexible · Today 07:43

No children just develop skills at different times. Spatial awareness and dexterity is needed for dressing. Some kids will have less refined skills than others at 5. It's on the adults to provide a space to practice the skill and then when it comes to something like dressing properly, the adult then ensures it is done appropriately.

As you say, most 5 year olds can do this quite well. So you're only really supporting the few who arent as capable at this skill. You don't have to dreas 30 5 year olds but in truth, you might have to mostly dress at least 1 child in reception.

Then the one who can’t should have the parent spoken to.

Pobblewob · Today 07:59

Lexibletheflexible · Today 07:43

No children just develop skills at different times. Spatial awareness and dexterity is needed for dressing. Some kids will have less refined skills than others at 5. It's on the adults to provide a space to practice the skill and then when it comes to something like dressing properly, the adult then ensures it is done appropriately.

As you say, most 5 year olds can do this quite well. So you're only really supporting the few who arent as capable at this skill. You don't have to dreas 30 5 year olds but in truth, you might have to mostly dress at least 1 child in reception.

Nope, you speak to the parents who sort it.

Lexibletheflexible · Today 08:03

Differentforgirls · Today 07:58

Then the one who can’t should have the parent spoken to.

About what? The fact they need more guided practice? Okay great, lets do that at home and at school. The 2 places they get dressed and undressed most often. Whatever way you look at it, it's something that teachers and parents will have to support until they learn how. They will get there. Guided support is how.

Differentforgirls · Today 08:05

Lexibletheflexible · Today 08:03

About what? The fact they need more guided practice? Okay great, lets do that at home and at school. The 2 places they get dressed and undressed most often. Whatever way you look at it, it's something that teachers and parents will have to support until they learn how. They will get there. Guided support is how.

It’s the job of the parent.

Lexibletheflexible · Today 08:07

Pobblewob · Today 07:59

Nope, you speak to the parents who sort it.

I'm sorry you are prepared to accept such poor standards for your children. I let my 5 year olds be 5 year olds. Great at some things. Shit at others. One day, hopefully, they'll be alright at most things. Until then, adults will give them support and guidance in how to do things appropriately so they get used to how "correct" looks and feels and they can mirror actions on how to achieve it.

Gertrudethechicken · Today 08:31

Missey85 · Today 07:16

No it's education not childcare you want a nanny pay for one it's not the teachers job!

Rubbish. Schools should provide an element of care. They are children at the end of the day. If schools were expected to just teach then we would be taking our small children to school and remaining with them throughout the day, or employing a nanny or a childminder to do this. It’s inevitable that in a class of small children, afew might still need a hand with getting changed… are you seriously suggesting we don’t allow our kids to start school until they can get dressed entirely independently? I think not.

OP posts:
Differentforgirls · Today 08:32

Gertrudethechicken · Today 08:31

Rubbish. Schools should provide an element of care. They are children at the end of the day. If schools were expected to just teach then we would be taking our small children to school and remaining with them throughout the day, or employing a nanny or a childminder to do this. It’s inevitable that in a class of small children, afew might still need a hand with getting changed… are you seriously suggesting we don’t allow our kids to start school until they can get dressed entirely independently? I think not.

Yes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread