Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask my daughter’s teacher to check she’s dressed properly after PE?

259 replies

Gertrudethechicken · Yesterday 19:50

My daughter is five and came home from school today after PE wearing her trousers back to front, her shoes on the wrong feet and, bizarrely, with no T-shirt on at all (just her jumper).
It’s November!

I appreciate that children need to learn independence and I’m certainly not expecting someone to get her dressed from head to toe. However, she’s five, and she still needs a bit of help getting dressed. She needs help at home too, and we’re working on developing those skills.

I’ve politely messaged her teacher asking if someone could give her a little hand after PE and just check she’s properly dressed before sending her home.

I’m not asking for anything unreasonable, or am I? I have quite a lot of anxiety about her at school as we’ve had afew issues already and I don’t feel the school have been great at communication.

AIBU to expect a member of staff to make sure a five-year-old has actually got all her clothes on properly before leaving school? Or am I being silly?

OP posts:
SquirrelGG · Today 00:05

augustuss · Yesterday 20:34

Am I the only one tired of the ‘there’s 20/30 children in a class’ argument… Let’s change that then! Are we saying it’s ok for our young children to not be adequately supervised…
I might be overreacting because I’m angry at my dc school today BUT when did it become ok to expect the bare minimum actual childcare from schools!

Since when did dressing children become part of a teacher's job? I doubt the teacher even noticed the child hadn't dressed herself properly and what does it actually matter anyway, she didn't come to any harm.

OP, it's your job to teach your child how to get dressed.

FatCatSociety · Today 00:14

Pobblewob · Yesterday 22:45

Nope, most kids can have a decent go at dressing themselves at 3 (SEN aside). Most kids SHOULD be toilet trained by 3 (SEN aside).

This is the issue, low expectations of what children are capable of doing.

For all anybody on here knows this could be an indication of sen. I would discuss it with the teacher if I thought the issue was her ability to pay attention while getting dressed.

ifonlytheydlisten · Today 00:21

this is normal in reception: countless kids go home with shoes on wrong feet. Or stuff on the wrong way, or in some one else’s clothes .. all part of the learning when they are rushing.

seahorsessky · Today 00:22

BillieWiper · Yesterday 19:54

Do you teach her at home how to dress herself? It's more of a home based learning thing than a school based skill.

Dressing and undressing is primarily meant to be taught by parents. For obvious reasons involving privacy, body autonomy etc.

So do a practice with her regularly with PE kit at home so she'll know how at school. Teacher doesn't have time to dress or supervise/ instruct dressing each child.

She might have additional needs though? I know the making sure your kid is ready for school thing says they should be able to dress themselves, but some children have physical reasons why they struggle. I know some parents say it's worth looking for alternatives on certain clothing to make it easier, and have some adult friends who buy specific clothing with certain fasteners due to their disabilities, so might be helpful to look into that, OP?
Or for anyone else reading this, M&S has some, and it is worth looking into brands that make life massively easier for some people, even if you have a temporary problem with dressing after an operation.

Salmonoftheseas · Today 00:36

Itwasthe90s · Yesterday 19:51

Your DD is still getting changed for PE?

I thought most schools abandoned the getting changed in school for PE thing since COVID, and that kids just wear their PE kit all day on PE days.

But to answer your question - Yes, YABU. The teacher has 30 kids to oversee, not just yours.

Edited

I went to strict Catholic school in the early 2000s. I was in a class of 35 and our teacher would check we were dressed properly up until the age of 10. She’d make us line up. We had ties and all sorts to put on properly (at 4!). I remember her helping me get dressed after PE, as I was probably 7 and couldn’t do my top button up or my tie.

NeverDropYourMooncup · Today 00:38

seahorsessky · Today 00:22

She might have additional needs though? I know the making sure your kid is ready for school thing says they should be able to dress themselves, but some children have physical reasons why they struggle. I know some parents say it's worth looking for alternatives on certain clothing to make it easier, and have some adult friends who buy specific clothing with certain fasteners due to their disabilities, so might be helpful to look into that, OP?
Or for anyone else reading this, M&S has some, and it is worth looking into brands that make life massively easier for some people, even if you have a temporary problem with dressing after an operation.

Most - not all, but most - infant uniforms now are pull on trousers, a polo or t-shirt and a sweatshirt, plus velcro fastening shoes. They are already far easier than the previous shirts with buttons, tie to learn to do, trousers with zips and hooks, lace up shoes or buckles.

This is all part of the School Ready things so a teacher isn't having to stop and spend time with multiple 5 year olds to tell them how to put their clothes on.

Illsingyouasongthatwonttakelong · Today 02:09

augustuss · Yesterday 20:34

Am I the only one tired of the ‘there’s 20/30 children in a class’ argument… Let’s change that then! Are we saying it’s ok for our young children to not be adequately supervised…
I might be overreacting because I’m angry at my dc school today BUT when did it become ok to expect the bare minimum actual childcare from schools!

Childcare 🙄

JigsawPuzzler2 · Today 02:40

Anon501178 · Yesterday 22:43

I disagree.5 is still very young...I think schools push little hildren too hard too soon with this kind of stuff, same as toileting.Some of those kids are barely 4! Doing buttons, laces, tights etc is something staff need to expect to help with.A child should not be going around half dressed due to being expected to do something they can't manage....not their fault the class sizes are too big!

No you are right it is not the child's fault, it is the parent's fault.
As a teacher, if a child really could not get themselves dressed i would tell them get their more capable classmates to help them.This tends to encourage the kids to become self-sufficient as they are not being rewarded with adult attention every time

WitchesBritches · Today 03:00

W0tnow · Yesterday 20:24

I think it’s unreasonable, yes. I get she is little, but a quick lesson from you on ensuring she knows the tag goes at the back with her trousers, and which foot goes in which shoe should do the trick.

on a side note, getting changed for PE is such a faff and I don’t know why schools insist little ones do it!

I'M old. We did it in our vest, knickers & plimsolls.🤣🤣 in the olden days when school uniforms weren't made from stretch fabric!

@Gertrudethechicken you are being unreasonable. It won't hurt her home without a T-shirt on underneath her jumper.. how did she get home & why did the person picking her up not notice she had her shoes on the wrong feet? I'm sure if they have been uncomfortable enough she would have swapped them over..

Clydebuilt · Today 04:34

Newname26 · Yesterday 20:08

What?
I'm guessing its an autocorrect, but autocorrect from what?

Kit presumably…

TheMessyMermaid · Today 06:54

Ligesani · Yesterday 19:56

Yanbu, she's still very little and this is part of a teacher's job.

Actually it's not. It's not part of the curriculum to teach a child how to dress themselves. Would you also expect teachers to toilet trains kids, teach them how to use a knife and fork, teach them to tie their shoe laces, teach them how to wash dishes? School doesn't teach everything a child needs to learn, parents are expected to educate their children as well

Differentforgirls · Today 06:57

Ligesani · Yesterday 19:56

Yanbu, she's still very little and this is part of a teacher's job.

No it isn’t!

Differentforgirls · Today 06:58

Shalalaa · Yesterday 20:20

I agree

4 years at uni to teach children how to dress?

DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 06:59

Ligesani · Yesterday 19:56

Yanbu, she's still very little and this is part of a teacher's job.

This. I remember plenty of kids being slow getting dressed at school when I was little and we had a massive class. They would never have let a child sit there all day with no t shirt. I don't know what business teachers have teaching young children to not notice or bother about this.

Pobblewob · Today 07:01

DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 06:59

This. I remember plenty of kids being slow getting dressed at school when I was little and we had a massive class. They would never have let a child sit there all day with no t shirt. I don't know what business teachers have teaching young children to not notice or bother about this.

Because it's the parents job....

If they notice, great. No major harm done if they don't.

DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 07:02

Illsingyouasongthatwonttakelong · Today 02:09

Childcare 🙄

Of course they should be caring for the children, that's basic. They are in loco parentis.

Differentforgirls · Today 07:02

augustuss · Yesterday 20:34

Am I the only one tired of the ‘there’s 20/30 children in a class’ argument… Let’s change that then! Are we saying it’s ok for our young children to not be adequately supervised…
I might be overreacting because I’m angry at my dc school today BUT when did it become ok to expect the bare minimum actual childcare from schools!

Schools are for education. Not child care.

Sartre · Today 07:05

As others have said, you should ask the school if they can do what most other primary schools do and let them wear the kit to school all day. At 5, this sort of thing is normal and not a massive issue. Get kickers shoes, the red and green tabs help.

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · Today 07:06

Motheranddaughter · Yesterday 23:04

And?
Presumably not all of them need help

Bo. Bit what of 27 do, because parents think they're only tiny and couldn't possibly do basic tasks like put a jumper on ...

DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 07:06

Pobblewob · Today 07:01

Because it's the parents job....

If they notice, great. No major harm done if they don't.

But it's not the parents job while they are at school. Don't you see?

This thread just shows why schools that start formal schooling later have it right. These days we expect kids to be good little learning drones at four and start testing them by five. It's all wrong. Then you wonder why so many children don't get on with school. Because they have been brought up with love and kindness at home and none whatsoever is shown to them at school.

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · Today 07:08

augustuss · Yesterday 22:43

No one is actually demanding teachers teach children how to dress. They are saying the five year old’s MISTAKE should have been noticed (shoes on wrong feet especially as it’s a tripping hazard) and someone at some point should have prompted the child to correct their mistake.

Honestly, I can’t believe actual parents are looking for excuses here as to why this is such an impossible ask. Do we need more staff in schools - Yes! Let’s shift collective focus on demanding that from decision makers. Don’t settle for what is inadequate.

The occasional shoes on wrong feet is expected.

Bit this OP hasn't bothered teaching her kid to dress and is now expecting a teacher to do it?

What has tb KP been doing every single day for 5 years of she hasn't fucking bothered to teach her child that labels go at the back etc.

DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 07:08

Differentforgirls · Today 07:02

Schools are for education. Not child care.

It's also child care. They are caring for the children in place of the parents while they are there, particularly when they are so little. This seems to be entirely forgotten these days.

augustuss · Today 07:11

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · Today 07:08

The occasional shoes on wrong feet is expected.

Bit this OP hasn't bothered teaching her kid to dress and is now expecting a teacher to do it?

What has tb KP been doing every single day for 5 years of she hasn't fucking bothered to teach her child that labels go at the back etc.

This is the meanest post on the thread.

BendingSpoons · Today 07:11

Some children just take longer than others to learn. By 2.5 my DD was choosing her own outfits and pretty much dressing herself independently, to the point she would refuse help and spend ages trying to figure out e.g. putting on a pair of tights. My DS found it much harder and needed much more help. I didn't parent him any differently. I remember the day he removed his coat to a back-to-front polo shirt, which looked uncomfortable!

If your DD is still in Reception, getting dressed independently is part of the skills they are looking at. It's one reason why many schools do still make them change for PE. Other reasons include some parents never likely to remember PE day, so at least they only have to get the kit in once per half term, and the flexibility for schools to switch PE days around e.g. if one year have a trip. I therefore don't think it's unreasonable to say she is still having some difficulties and could they keep an eye.

DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 07:11

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · Today 07:08

The occasional shoes on wrong feet is expected.

Bit this OP hasn't bothered teaching her kid to dress and is now expecting a teacher to do it?

What has tb KP been doing every single day for 5 years of she hasn't fucking bothered to teach her child that labels go at the back etc.

She can dress herself, she just get bits wrong sometimes. BECAUSE SHE'S FIVE.

Jesus wept.

Swipe left for the next trending thread