Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask my daughter’s teacher to check she’s dressed properly after PE?

259 replies

Gertrudethechicken · Yesterday 19:50

My daughter is five and came home from school today after PE wearing her trousers back to front, her shoes on the wrong feet and, bizarrely, with no T-shirt on at all (just her jumper).
It’s November!

I appreciate that children need to learn independence and I’m certainly not expecting someone to get her dressed from head to toe. However, she’s five, and she still needs a bit of help getting dressed. She needs help at home too, and we’re working on developing those skills.

I’ve politely messaged her teacher asking if someone could give her a little hand after PE and just check she’s properly dressed before sending her home.

I’m not asking for anything unreasonable, or am I? I have quite a lot of anxiety about her at school as we’ve had afew issues already and I don’t feel the school have been great at communication.

AIBU to expect a member of staff to make sure a five-year-old has actually got all her clothes on properly before leaving school? Or am I being silly?

OP posts:
mrsm43s · Today 09:55

Lexibletheflexible · Today 09:45

No thats the point. Good grief indeed. That you think a child who has a developmental "weakness" in one area must have "additional needs" is indicative of your ignorance and demonstrates the cultural tendency to overdiagnose neurodiversity to epidemic levels instead of addressing your unrealistic expectations of parenthood and child development.

You're the type of parent who would be inappropriately pushing professionals for a diagnosis.

Nope, I'm the kind of parent that parented my children, and put more time and effort into practising the things they found harder. I didn't just pass the responsibility on to the teacher. Yes, some children pick some things up quicker than others. That's part of parenting to recognise this and help them with the skills that need developing.

Expecting a child without additional needs to be able to dress themselves independently by 5 is just basic parenting.

Differentforgirls · Today 09:59

Lexibletheflexible · Today 09:47

Sure. There were likely other things they couldn't do as well as they could get dressed. And that wouldn't have been indicative of much on its own. Not at 5.

Four. Like what e.g?Getting dressed is pretty basic.

augustuss · Today 10:12

Gertrudethechicken · Today 08:31

Rubbish. Schools should provide an element of care. They are children at the end of the day. If schools were expected to just teach then we would be taking our small children to school and remaining with them throughout the day, or employing a nanny or a childminder to do this. It’s inevitable that in a class of small children, afew might still need a hand with getting changed… are you seriously suggesting we don’t allow our kids to start school until they can get dressed entirely independently? I think not.

Honestly, the responses on here are ridiculous and I’m sure those people would be feeling differently if it was their child. It’s very odd and I do hope the particularly mean ones are not working with young children.

And reducing a teacher’s job to teaching the curriculum only makes them very easily replaceable by some Kapow/Whiterose lessons slides.

Differentforgirls · Today 10:15

augustuss · Today 10:12

Honestly, the responses on here are ridiculous and I’m sure those people would be feeling differently if it was their child. It’s very odd and I do hope the particularly mean ones are not working with young children.

And reducing a teacher’s job to teaching the curriculum only makes them very easily replaceable by some Kapow/Whiterose lessons slides.

Teaching is literally their job. Hence the title.

TurtleCavalryIsSeriousShit · Today 10:19

See, this is so weird to me. 5 is tiny. In my country kids start school at 6, going on 7.

A 5-year old will be in nursery here and still receive lots of help.

I don't think you're being unreasonable.

DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 10:29

FatCatSociety · Today 08:50

When my son was 5 we had an issue with him losing all his things, lunchboxes, water bottles coats... I couldn't parent him from home while he was at school. I worried that he wouldn't have his drink if he lost his drink or have to walk home without a coat, so it was something I approached the teachers about. He had undiagnosed inattentive adhd. He loses a lot less now but it took him longer than the average 5 year old to be able to manage his stuff.
Putting shoes on the wrong feet and forgetting a top completely also sounds like it could be an attention span issue to me. Or this little girl might need a bit more practice and a bit more time. Either way it's harsh to accuse op of not teaching her child to get dressed properly when all children are different and we don't know why this 5 year old might need a bit of extra help.
As I said before I would bring it up with the teacher in a respectful way, not putting blame on the teacher for not noticing but make them aware your child still needs help with this.

Indeed.

DD1 was very different to DD2. She would get bras out of my drawer and put them on as a baby (several at once, unfastened but the right way round). She wanted to dress herself before she was even able and I often went with her odd clothing choices if it wasn't going to make her uncomfortable! She is 21 now and doing a design subject at university, has sooo many clothes, shoes, coats, a lot from charity shops, always looks fantastic.

DD2 would have rather gone naked, or just had me dress her, as quickly as possible so she could go off and do something more interesting. She is more interested in clothes now aged 17 but just to look presentable and fit in with friends. Looks great anyway without trying very hard! She was definitely a bit slow at getting dressed at five- I remember trying to make it fun and having a "race" and putting music on before school. Was worried she may be one of the slower ones getting ready for PE but she seemed to be ok. She was diagnosed with autism and combined ADHD as a teenager. It's funny as she has always been immensely physically gifted in terms of sport etc, very fast runner in particular, but those fine motor skills/attention were a struggle for a little while.

Most of them get there in the end.

TwilightAb · Today 10:47

Itwasthe90s · Yesterday 19:51

Your DD is still getting changed for PE?

I thought most schools abandoned the getting changed in school for PE thing since COVID, and that kids just wear their PE kit all day on PE days.

But to answer your question - Yes, YABU. The teacher has 30 kids to oversee, not just yours.

Edited

My childrens school were still getting changed in school up until this year, now changed to going in pe kit. It is so much easier sending them in a pe kit on pe days. I just have to remember the right days for each kid!

Passingthroughtwice · Today 11:10

Gertrudethechicken · Today 08:31

Rubbish. Schools should provide an element of care. They are children at the end of the day. If schools were expected to just teach then we would be taking our small children to school and remaining with them throughout the day, or employing a nanny or a childminder to do this. It’s inevitable that in a class of small children, afew might still need a hand with getting changed… are you seriously suggesting we don’t allow our kids to start school until they can get dressed entirely independently? I think not.

Schools DO provide an element of care, in that they provide a safe environment for your child to be taught in while safeguarding the wellbeing of all pupils. Standing over your kid to ensure she puts her trousers on properly is not part of it!

Passingthroughtwice · Today 11:16

augustuss · Today 10:12

Honestly, the responses on here are ridiculous and I’m sure those people would be feeling differently if it was their child. It’s very odd and I do hope the particularly mean ones are not working with young children.

And reducing a teacher’s job to teaching the curriculum only makes them very easily replaceable by some Kapow/Whiterose lessons slides.

Well, the teacher recruitment crisis is worsening every year because of the ridiculous expectations put upon them to be therapists/childminders/admin assistants/punch bag for parents, as well as educators, so at some point kids may well be taught by slides. Bet all the parents on this thread saying the teacher should dress the kid because they have a duty of care will be outraged, but you reap what you sow.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page