Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask my daughter’s teacher to check she’s dressed properly after PE?

259 replies

Gertrudethechicken · Yesterday 19:50

My daughter is five and came home from school today after PE wearing her trousers back to front, her shoes on the wrong feet and, bizarrely, with no T-shirt on at all (just her jumper).
It’s November!

I appreciate that children need to learn independence and I’m certainly not expecting someone to get her dressed from head to toe. However, she’s five, and she still needs a bit of help getting dressed. She needs help at home too, and we’re working on developing those skills.

I’ve politely messaged her teacher asking if someone could give her a little hand after PE and just check she’s properly dressed before sending her home.

I’m not asking for anything unreasonable, or am I? I have quite a lot of anxiety about her at school as we’ve had afew issues already and I don’t feel the school have been great at communication.

AIBU to expect a member of staff to make sure a five-year-old has actually got all her clothes on properly before leaving school? Or am I being silly?

OP posts:
Pobblewob · Yesterday 22:10

YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 22:06

Enlighten me please.

In legal and social contexts, the doctrine refers to a person or organization assuming some of the parental rights, duties, and responsibilities for a minor child without having full, formal legal parenthood or adoption.

Nothing about making sure the kid is dressed properly. She was wearing clothes, decently covered up so there's no safeguarding issue. The teacher has done enough by their duty of care too ensuring the child is covered up and retains dignity.

After that, it's the parents job to practise getting dressed.

Grammarnut · Yesterday 22:16

Ligesani · Yesterday 19:56

Yanbu, she's still very little and this is part of a teacher's job.

It's not part of the teacher's job. A five year old should be able to dress itself. There are 29 other children in the class, if every one of them required help dressing then the teacher would be doing it all day!

augustuss · Yesterday 22:17

FunPartyIdeas · Yesterday 20:36

A teacher is there to teach; the clue is in the name. They are not childcare.

So for six hours a day, every week day, we leave our five year olds without childcare?

babyproblems · Yesterday 22:17

My son is in a class of 20 and they go swimming with school ages 3-5. In the changing room it’s chaos but there’s 5 or 6 adults helping them all get dressed. I think your dd should be able to manage it mostly at 5 but they could help with zips etc!

Skippythemagnificent · Yesterday 22:20

That’s an awful lot that she got wrong and sorry, but at 5 years old, that is not normal. Teach her how to get dressed and stop expecting teachers to do jobs which need to be done at home.

YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 22:23

Pobblewob · Yesterday 22:10

In legal and social contexts, the doctrine refers to a person or organization assuming some of the parental rights, duties, and responsibilities for a minor child without having full, formal legal parenthood or adoption.

Nothing about making sure the kid is dressed properly. She was wearing clothes, decently covered up so there's no safeguarding issue. The teacher has done enough by their duty of care too ensuring the child is covered up and retains dignity.

After that, it's the parents job to practise getting dressed.

Thank you, wonder what would happen if a parent sent them into school with back to front clothes and wrong foot schools. Also thinking of care experienced children or those who are adopted. Such a minefield....teach them to brush their teeth but clothes are meh. I think the remit of schools is both too broad and also too narrow. Nobody is particularly happy right now and teachers are stretched beyond belief, so are children. Think it will take a few more coroner reports for the government to clarify what they expect from both parents and school.

YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 22:25

augustuss · Yesterday 22:17

So for six hours a day, every week day, we leave our five year olds without childcare?

Yep, until it suddenly is when they want money for residential trips or inset days

cityliving99 · Yesterday 22:26

I always remember hearing a reception teacher answer a parent, who wanted more challenging homework for their child. They suggested that maybe the best homework would be to teach their child how to get dressed by themselves!

Pobblewob · Yesterday 22:26

YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 22:23

Thank you, wonder what would happen if a parent sent them into school with back to front clothes and wrong foot schools. Also thinking of care experienced children or those who are adopted. Such a minefield....teach them to brush their teeth but clothes are meh. I think the remit of schools is both too broad and also too narrow. Nobody is particularly happy right now and teachers are stretched beyond belief, so are children. Think it will take a few more coroner reports for the government to clarify what they expect from both parents and school.

I'd assume the child dressed themselves, probably mention the shoes and get on with the day. If it was regular I'd ask parents to check before coming in.

Schools shouldn't really be teaching tooth brushing either imo.

Cherish707 · Yesterday 22:27

Ligesani · Yesterday 19:56

Yanbu, she's still very little and this is part of a teacher's job.

I am a teacher. This is not a teacher's job to check. Obviously, if she had no skirt on, the teacher would tell her to put it on. A teacher would not check under a junmper to see if she had put a t-shirt on. You should teach her this at home.

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · Yesterday 22:28

This is very much your a fault.

She's 5 years old not 5 months.

She's had at least 2-3 years to learn how to get dressed properly, how have you not taught her this already???

Zingyweaver · Yesterday 22:28

Ligesani · Yesterday 19:56

Yanbu, she's still very little and this is part of a teacher's job.

It really isn't part of a teacher's job to do this.

This is basic, and is the responsibility of the parents to make sure their child is prepared for school.

WhatsYourNameTony · Yesterday 22:28

A pp made a good point too that sometimes it's not worth correcting a child who is incorrectly dressed in order to show the parent what they be child is actually capable of, and to prompt the parents to encourage independence. Eg if a parent of a 5yo is still doing too much for them, the child won't be able to put their jumper on the right way round. . The parent might not really have noticed this lack of skill if they are subconsciously doing it for the child every day.

There have definitely been children in previous classes whose parents do everything for them then the children don't have age-appropriate skills (and no, there was nothing to suggest it was unavoidable lack of skill caused by SEN, they were learning as expected in other areas). Some parents get used to acting a certain way and won't notice an issue they need to work on until actually confronted with the result (ie the child comes home with clothes back to front when others are correctly dressing themselves).

Wonderfulwonder · Yesterday 22:29

I'm a head of year 7
We are still supporting some 11 year olds with changing after PE. I'm surprised so many here think a teacher can't just help your child by saying to her 'your trousers are on backwards', for example. I'm sure you will do lots of practice with her at home too.

canonlydoblue · Yesterday 22:30

Maybe the teacher genuinely didn't realise your daughter wasn't wearing a t - shirt. Quite often shirt collars get stuck under the tops of the jumpers and it looks as though they're not wearing one. The trousers and shoes wouldn't have been obvious anyway. I taught a mixed R-2 class for four years and have seen many of my own children through reception. Even with 'only' 20 in the class, can you imagine how long it would take a teacher and a TA to help everyone? Find a few little tricks to help your daughter remember which way her clothes go and she'll soon get the hang of it.

Cherish707 · Yesterday 22:30

I think the important thing is no harm is done if she is not dressed properly.

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · Yesterday 22:31

augustuss · Yesterday 22:17

So for six hours a day, every week day, we leave our five year olds without childcare?

It's not the teachers job to show kids how to get dressed. The parents should have taught this years ago.

They should have had at least 2-3 years DAILY PRACTICE of putting clothes on properly.

If a 5 year old doesn't know what way round to put a pair of trousers on then that's entirely the parents fault for not giving them opportunities to learn this basic skill.

YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 22:31

Pobblewob · Yesterday 22:26

I'd assume the child dressed themselves, probably mention the shoes and get on with the day. If it was regular I'd ask parents to check before coming in.

Schools shouldn't really be teaching tooth brushing either imo.

But they do teach it now in many settings and assuming the child dressed themselves would throw up red flags for neglect. Its the continuity that gets me. I dont disagree that children need to dress themselves BTW.

justasking111 · Yesterday 22:32

Ilovefoodandwine · Yesterday 19:55

Most schools go in to school on pe days in kitchen now. I'd be contacting the school to discuss this option

My grandchildren at two different primaries have PE wear days.

Zingyweaver · Yesterday 22:33

augustuss · Yesterday 22:17

So for six hours a day, every week day, we leave our five year olds without childcare?

You're confusing education with childcare. Teaching should not be viewed as childcare, not should teachers be shouldered with the basic skills that parents should be responsible for.

It's quite telling how easily some parents absolve themselves of so many core aspects of being a parent, and palm it off on to professional teachers.

I'm not a teacher btw, and yes I am a parent myself.

Pobblewob · Yesterday 22:35

YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 22:31

But they do teach it now in many settings and assuming the child dressed themselves would throw up red flags for neglect. Its the continuity that gets me. I dont disagree that children need to dress themselves BTW.

Why would assuming a 5yo dressed themselves flag neglect?

Repeatedly turning up incorrectly dressed perhaps, as a one off though.

What do you mean by continuity? Schools are only doing teeth brushing to support better public health outcomes.

IndieRocknRoll · Yesterday 22:39

YABU. It was your job as a parent to teach her how to dress independently before starting school.
I’m a y1 teacher so have skin in the game!
30 children coming up to me each break time unable to zip up their coats, kids sent to school in trainers with laces that they cannot tie…Send help!!

YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 22:40

Pobblewob · Yesterday 22:35

Why would assuming a 5yo dressed themselves flag neglect?

Repeatedly turning up incorrectly dressed perhaps, as a one off though.

What do you mean by continuity? Schools are only doing teeth brushing to support better public health outcomes.

Why would schools assume children aren't brushing thier teeth? It may be a one off.🤷

stargirl1701 · Yesterday 22:40

Is PE last thing? There is no time to check before taking the line out to the playground.

I would say if I noticed, but I am not checking.

Pobblewob · Yesterday 22:41

YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 22:40

Why would schools assume children aren't brushing thier teeth? It may be a one off.🤷

What are you on about?

There is a targeted government initiative to get children in primary schools brushing their teeth to avoid public spend on dentistry.

There is no such scheme for getting dressed.