Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask my daughter’s teacher to check she’s dressed properly after PE?

257 replies

Gertrudethechicken · Yesterday 19:50

My daughter is five and came home from school today after PE wearing her trousers back to front, her shoes on the wrong feet and, bizarrely, with no T-shirt on at all (just her jumper).
It’s November!

I appreciate that children need to learn independence and I’m certainly not expecting someone to get her dressed from head to toe. However, she’s five, and she still needs a bit of help getting dressed. She needs help at home too, and we’re working on developing those skills.

I’ve politely messaged her teacher asking if someone could give her a little hand after PE and just check she’s properly dressed before sending her home.

I’m not asking for anything unreasonable, or am I? I have quite a lot of anxiety about her at school as we’ve had afew issues already and I don’t feel the school have been great at communication.

AIBU to expect a member of staff to make sure a five-year-old has actually got all her clothes on properly before leaving school? Or am I being silly?

OP posts:
augustuss · Yesterday 22:43

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · Yesterday 22:31

It's not the teachers job to show kids how to get dressed. The parents should have taught this years ago.

They should have had at least 2-3 years DAILY PRACTICE of putting clothes on properly.

If a 5 year old doesn't know what way round to put a pair of trousers on then that's entirely the parents fault for not giving them opportunities to learn this basic skill.

No one is actually demanding teachers teach children how to dress. They are saying the five year old’s MISTAKE should have been noticed (shoes on wrong feet especially as it’s a tripping hazard) and someone at some point should have prompted the child to correct their mistake.

Honestly, I can’t believe actual parents are looking for excuses here as to why this is such an impossible ask. Do we need more staff in schools - Yes! Let’s shift collective focus on demanding that from decision makers. Don’t settle for what is inadequate.

Anon501178 · Yesterday 22:43

CurlyhairedAssassin · Yesterday 19:55

She should be able to do that before starting school to be honest. It's basic.

I disagree.5 is still very young...I think schools push little hildren too hard too soon with this kind of stuff, same as toileting.Some of those kids are barely 4! Doing buttons, laces, tights etc is something staff need to expect to help with.A child should not be going around half dressed due to being expected to do something they can't manage....not their fault the class sizes are too big!

LetsGoOutside · Yesterday 22:43

If your daughter can’t dress herself I assume it’s because you help her. How would you find helping 20 children at the same time?

Pobblewob · Yesterday 22:45

LetsGoOutside · Yesterday 22:43

If your daughter can’t dress herself I assume it’s because you help her. How would you find helping 20 children at the same time?

Nope, most kids can have a decent go at dressing themselves at 3 (SEN aside). Most kids SHOULD be toilet trained by 3 (SEN aside).

This is the issue, low expectations of what children are capable of doing.

Itsthewoluff · Yesterday 22:48

The teacher isn’t just sitting there watching. Some kids are super quick getting changed, then they need occupying. Some need to be hurried up. Some kids will be asking for help, some will be misbehaving. The teacher may be setting up the next lesson. The teacher will be being pulled this way and that. They literally won’t have time to focus on one child in particular.

EatMoreChocolate44 · Yesterday 22:53

I teach 5 and 6 year olds OP and my day is constant stress, noise, distractions, drama etc. Home time comes and I think I have left enough time to get lined up but 2 children have lost their jumpers (no names on the found jumpers that they say aren't theirs 🙈), one child their coat, someone needs their shoe laces tied, another needs the toilet, my ASD child is kicking off because they aren't first in the line, another child is trying to tell me that it's their granny's birthday while another tells me that they just got hit by a lunch box and they are crying, I need to remember to give the child which was absent yesterday their homework folder and grab a parent at the gates to tell them their child fell at lunchtime. I am pulled in 10 different directions all day every day. I literally don't have time (with all the will in the world) to check every child has their uniform on correctly.

It's hilarious, exhausting, rewarding but thankless and chaotic. A dark room is required at the end of every day but then I've to go home to my own children and remember all the things I need to do at home as well as prepare for the next day. And yes, you will now be that parent. 😂

loopsydo · Yesterday 23:01

Our child came home from school without her skirt after PE (winter coat on so not immediately obvious). We had a laugh and worked on dressing strategies at home.

Youhadrambledonfor18pages · Yesterday 23:02

No it’s not the teacher’s job, it’s your job.

There are plenty of ways to help kids remember/work out which shoe for which foot.

Practise “getting dressed after pe” at home and remind her about putting her T-shirt on before her jumper, which way round her trousers go etc etc

CherryKerry · Yesterday 23:04

Gertrudethechicken · Yesterday 20:06

😂😂😂
No, state primary… just a small school.

😂 That did make me laugh, city folk have no idea about rural schools with 10 pupils on the roll.

Thegirlwhowent · Yesterday 23:04

Motheranddaughter · Yesterday 21:30

I can’t see any reason why Teacher/TA can’t ensure kids are properly dressed

Try ensuring that 20+ children are properly dressed, while answering questions, sorting out arguments, finding someone's lost sock etc. in the few minutes you have spare before you settle them down to teach them. You might discover the reason then.

Motheranddaughter · Yesterday 23:04

Pobblewob · Yesterday 21:31

Because there's 30 kids....

And?
Presumably not all of them need help

yellowbobble · Yesterday 23:06

Another parent who thinks it’s school’s job to teach their child basic skills.

A 5 year old is not ‘tiny’ and should be able to reliably get dressed independently. They might put their jumper on inside out, t-shirt back to front or shoes on the wrong feet - it’s either a non issue that doesn’t bother them or it is IS uncomfortable and does bother them and this is how they learn to recognise they’ve not put them on correctly. It is not the teacher’s job to teach them how to get dressed, that’s your job as the parent.

Helicopter parents who do everything for their children are creating an epidemic of children with zero independent skills or resilience. It is exhausting for school staff to have a handful of children like this, but believe me it is now the norm to have the majority of the class be like this. I’m talking really basic things - wiping bottoms, putting shoes on, putting coats on. It is ridiculous.

I am genuinely surprised these days when I come across a child who can tie their own shoelaces by year 6. Most children say “I can’t - don’t know how” (but are sent to school by parents in lace up shoes anyway). A lot of parents seem to be no longer teaching their children these things - I don’t know who they expect will do it, or whether they think their children will just suddenly develop the skills of their own accord.

BlackeyedSusan · Yesterday 23:08

Things have changed a bit over the years.
I used to have a queue of reception kids each side, one for ties and one for shoe laces and buckles. By the time my kids went to school, they didn't help at all. It wasn't difficult to teach them some things if parents hadn't. (Not shoes and ties) You are supervising anyway. The quicker you teach them, the less time it takes for them to get dressed. (No TA, more than 30 kids in a class)
Used it to teach maths language.

We used to teach them to do up coats and turn sleeves the right way too.

SP2024 · Yesterday 23:08

My just turned 3 year old can dress himself mostly (needs help with socks). My nearly five year old is fully capable of dressing himself without problem and has been for well over a year. You need to do more practice at home. I’m surprised the teacher didn’t notice the shoes on the wrong feet )or your daughter realise it’s uncomfortable) but the rest of it I can see is easily overlooked.

Pobblewob · Yesterday 23:09

Motheranddaughter · Yesterday 23:04

And?
Presumably not all of them need help

Other people have better described the reality of 30 children changing and the supervision needed.

Thegirlwhowent · Yesterday 23:09

@EatMoreChocolate44 I used to teach 11-14 year olds. One woman said to me that she'd hate to be a teacher because 'it must be so boring just sitting and watching them do the work you've set them.' Boredom was not the reason I gave up teaching!

Princessconsuelabananahammock9 · Yesterday 23:15

Gertrudethechicken · Yesterday 20:05

She still needs help at home but We are trying to teach her to do it independently. I’m not asking them to teach her how to get dressed or to dress her. I mean, what am I to do… delay starting school until she can reliably put her shoes on the right feet and trousers the right way? All teacher would need to do is look at her and notice she has no T-shirt and shoes on the wrong feet, and just give her a verbal prompt to correct this. She wouldn’t even have to physically lift a finger.. is that really asking too much?

At home you supervise but don’t help her. She needs to do it herself so take extra time in the morning to make sure she gets practice.

CarpeVitam · Yesterday 23:18

Bramblezz · Yesterday 21:18

Yanbu I think when children go to school as young as 4 then reception teachers need to accept the job will involve an element of ass wiping and helping the kids with their basic needs.

OMG!😦 🙄

JudgeJ · Yesterday 23:21

Ligesani · Yesterday 19:56

Yanbu, she's still very little and this is part of a teacher's job.

To check that maybe 30 children are properly dressed when a parent hasn't taught 1 child to dress herself? They're all very little but should be able to dress themselves before starting school.

dottyboo2 · Yesterday 23:22

Yanbu. My dd is in reception. There are still a few kids having toileting accidents, many who get wet/muddy through the day and need help changing clothes. They are still tiny and learning. Obviously you’ll get told she should be able to do all this already because many posters like to humble brag about how capable and independent their kids are. But the facts are if a foundation age child is wearing shoes on the wrong feet or struggling to dress, someone should help them. Especially the shoes, that can’t have been comfortable.

JigsawPuzzler2 · Yesterday 23:41

My kids had button up long sleeved shirts and proper ties even in reception and within a few weeks all the kids could manage it.
Your expectations for your child are too low. At 5 years old they should have been dressing themselves in the simple clothing you describe for a couple of years.
You will raise a few eyebrows if you message school-as someone else said they are not your staff! You have no clue what managing large groups of 4,5,6 year old is like if you think there is time to get round 30 kids to check they are all dressed correctly. Moreover 1)if they are not, there is no time to wait for them to sort themselves out
2) I would be aiming to encourage age-appropriate independence in what sounds like a rather babied 5 year old and so for this reason in itself, I would not aquiesce to your request.

WearyAuldWumman · Yesterday 23:47

Gertrudethechicken · Yesterday 19:58

Actually it’s a composite class of less than twenty… big variation in ages too

So still too many for two people to cope with in a short period of time.

PurpleThistle7 · Yesterday 23:53

I have no idea why they’re changing for PE - thankfully our schools don’t do that anymore so it’s all much easier. They do have 5 weeks of swimming when they’re 9 which was their first experience changing at school (and last!). I went along to chaperone and it was carnage in the changing rooms. Can’t imagine the scenes if younger ones had to do this! I of course wasn’t allowed to touch anyone but I did help with hair and organising. The teacher could point out issues but couldn’t touch them either. Thinking about it, I’d be pretty uncomfortable with a teacher checking under my kids’ jumper or helping them physically get dressed (barring additional needs of course).

I feel like your daughter should have noticed her shoes and if she didn’t it wasn’t bothering her. No idea why her teacher would know what was on under her jumper. And not sure how she’d know her trousers were backwards unless she was specifically looking.

CloveRinse · Yesterday 23:55

@Gertrudethechicken This is something you need to work on at home with your child honestly. Teachers are managing lots of children and trying to teach, not nanny. Just keep practicing with your DD at weekends until she gets it.

SkyBlueTopper · Today 00:03

Ligesani · Yesterday 19:56

Yanbu, she's still very little and this is part of a teacher's job.

Its a parents job to teach them. Unless they have significant SEN. Mine all are ND and it took a long time to teach them.thr basic but we got there.
OP when she gets dressed in the morning get her to do it herself. Dont over help

Swipe left for the next trending thread