Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask my daughter’s teacher to check she’s dressed properly after PE?

259 replies

Gertrudethechicken · Yesterday 19:50

My daughter is five and came home from school today after PE wearing her trousers back to front, her shoes on the wrong feet and, bizarrely, with no T-shirt on at all (just her jumper).
It’s November!

I appreciate that children need to learn independence and I’m certainly not expecting someone to get her dressed from head to toe. However, she’s five, and she still needs a bit of help getting dressed. She needs help at home too, and we’re working on developing those skills.

I’ve politely messaged her teacher asking if someone could give her a little hand after PE and just check she’s properly dressed before sending her home.

I’m not asking for anything unreasonable, or am I? I have quite a lot of anxiety about her at school as we’ve had afew issues already and I don’t feel the school have been great at communication.

AIBU to expect a member of staff to make sure a five-year-old has actually got all her clothes on properly before leaving school? Or am I being silly?

OP posts:
PurpleThistle7 · Today 08:34

It is definitely a parent’s responsibility to teach their kids basic self care. Now if a child needs additional support then it’s worth exploring options - adaptable clothing or stickers in the shoes or an iron in patch on the back of leggings or a laminated picture of exact steps etc. I just don’t think it’s fair to rely on one person to physically check each child for the hundred different things that could be wrong.

Honestly the best thing you could do here is ask to ask the school to consider kids wearing PE kit to school. My school did one better and relaxed uniform entirely so my son is always ready to play. They don’t even change at high school, they just wear leggings and joggers and t shirts to school and are active whenever they like (lunchtime and after school sports clubs plus PE plus my daughter is doing her dance higher). It’s much easier for everyone.

FatCatSociety · Today 08:50

When my son was 5 we had an issue with him losing all his things, lunchboxes, water bottles coats... I couldn't parent him from home while he was at school. I worried that he wouldn't have his drink if he lost his drink or have to walk home without a coat, so it was something I approached the teachers about. He had undiagnosed inattentive adhd. He loses a lot less now but it took him longer than the average 5 year old to be able to manage his stuff.
Putting shoes on the wrong feet and forgetting a top completely also sounds like it could be an attention span issue to me. Or this little girl might need a bit more practice and a bit more time. Either way it's harsh to accuse op of not teaching her child to get dressed properly when all children are different and we don't know why this 5 year old might need a bit of extra help.
As I said before I would bring it up with the teacher in a respectful way, not putting blame on the teacher for not noticing but make them aware your child still needs help with this.

mrsm43s · Today 08:51

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TheCompactPussycat · Today 08:58

BendingSpoons · Today 07:15

Actually if this child is in Reception, then getting dressed is part of the EYFS. Under Personal, Social and Emotional Development, there is a section on Managing Self, which includes things like getting dressed.

If this child is in reception she will be one of the older ones at 5.

A child sent home incorrectly dressed is a lesson for the parent. It's November. If this is the first time it's happened, we can presume that the teacher/TA has been helping up until now. The parent now knows that a bit more work on getting dressed correctly is needed so they can work on that at home.

Pobblewob · Today 09:06

Gertrudethechicken · Today 08:31

Rubbish. Schools should provide an element of care. They are children at the end of the day. If schools were expected to just teach then we would be taking our small children to school and remaining with them throughout the day, or employing a nanny or a childminder to do this. It’s inevitable that in a class of small children, afew might still need a hand with getting changed… are you seriously suggesting we don’t allow our kids to start school until they can get dressed entirely independently? I think not.

They did provide care, she was adequately covered up.

JigsawPuzzler2 · Today 09:09

Babying a child is the opposite of 'love and kindness'.It is harmful, potentially creating low self esteem, anxiety, laziness, entitlement and lack of resourcefulness.

Ablondiebutagoody · Today 09:16

Gertrudethechicken · Today 08:31

Rubbish. Schools should provide an element of care. They are children at the end of the day. If schools were expected to just teach then we would be taking our small children to school and remaining with them throughout the day, or employing a nanny or a childminder to do this. It’s inevitable that in a class of small children, afew might still need a hand with getting changed… are you seriously suggesting we don’t allow our kids to start school until they can get dressed entirely independently? I think not.

Yes. Most kids are taught that stuff by 3 or 4 years old. It's not for teachers to pick up the job of lazy parents who are still "working on developing those skills"

Lexibletheflexible · Today 09:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You realise "generally" means there are outliers, right? So there are kids from decent homes who just haven't developed the dexterity and spatial awareness to get dressed correctly every time at the age of 5. Just like there are 5 year olds who aren't "dry" at night, yet. Or 5 year olds who struggle with phonics.

Lexibletheflexible · Today 09:21

Ablondiebutagoody · Today 09:16

Yes. Most kids are taught that stuff by 3 or 4 years old. It's not for teachers to pick up the job of lazy parents who are still "working on developing those skills"

Nobody expects those skills to be mastered by 5. People do expect adults to supervise 5 year olds appropriately.

mrsm43s · Today 09:28

Lexibletheflexible · Today 09:20

You realise "generally" means there are outliers, right? So there are kids from decent homes who just haven't developed the dexterity and spatial awareness to get dressed correctly every time at the age of 5. Just like there are 5 year olds who aren't "dry" at night, yet. Or 5 year olds who struggle with phonics.

Quite. That's why I asked if there were SEN or other reasons. If not, then it's simply a case of lazy parenting.

mrsm43s · Today 09:32

Lexibletheflexible · Today 09:21

Nobody expects those skills to be mastered by 5. People do expect adults to supervise 5 year olds appropriately.

Yes, I'd pretty much expect those skills to be mastered by 5 unless there was an underlying problem assuming they've been properly parented.

The teacher is adequately supervising. The child was safe and decent.

This is a failure of the parent, not the teacher.

Lexibletheflexible · Today 09:36

mrsm43s · Today 09:28

Quite. That's why I asked if there were SEN or other reasons. If not, then it's simply a case of lazy parenting.

No, you obviously didn't or can't read my posts. Is that a sign of lazy parenting?

If you could read my posts, you would have seen this part:

"So there are kids from decent homes who just haven't developed the dexterity and spatial awareness..."

I bolded and underlined the important parts.

Now, see if you can tell me how your follow-up post fell short now I've highlighted the parts you missed the first time around.

"

Differentforgirls · Today 09:40

I’ve actually never met a five year old that can’t get dressed. Maybe not tying laces but putting on clothes?

FatCatSociety · Today 09:40

mrsm43s · Today 09:28

Quite. That's why I asked if there were SEN or other reasons. If not, then it's simply a case of lazy parenting.

Sen isn't always diagnosed by the age of 5 especially in little girls.

Lexibletheflexible · Today 09:40

mrsm43s · Today 09:32

Yes, I'd pretty much expect those skills to be mastered by 5 unless there was an underlying problem assuming they've been properly parented.

The teacher is adequately supervising. The child was safe and decent.

This is a failure of the parent, not the teacher.

Then you don't understand much about child development. But that's okay. We can't all know everything.

This type of ignorance is what leads lots of middle classed (mostly) white British parents to force inappropriate diagnoses for children who are perfectly fine, just aren't as "quick" in some areas of their development. So when their 5 year old can't quite master dressing, they assume they must have some condition that would explain why they haven't measured up to their uneducated expectations. Just referring to the other thread about diagnosis trends and ethnic background...

mrsm43s · Today 09:42

Lexibletheflexible · Today 09:36

No, you obviously didn't or can't read my posts. Is that a sign of lazy parenting?

If you could read my posts, you would have seen this part:

"So there are kids from decent homes who just haven't developed the dexterity and spatial awareness..."

I bolded and underlined the important parts.

Now, see if you can tell me how your follow-up post fell short now I've highlighted the parts you missed the first time around.

"

Yes, again, those extra needs to which I refer.

In the absence of extra needs (e.g issues with spacial awareness or dexterity, for example), then it's a case of lazy parenting.

Good grief!

Lexibletheflexible · Today 09:42

Differentforgirls · Today 09:40

I’ve actually never met a five year old that can’t get dressed. Maybe not tying laces but putting on clothes?

I see lots of 5 year olds in the street who have tried to get dressed and have done well, but their parents havent bothered to just tidy them up and as a result, they look homeless. All because they can't be bothered to provide their child care past 5 years old.

Soontobe60 · Today 09:43

Boomer55 · Today 07:51

Not really. I’m not a teacher, never was, and don’t see them as sacred, but I’d expect a 5 year old to be fully toilet trained and able to get changed, without needing the teacher to help. It’s the parents’ job to sort this out.

If the 5 year old is in Reception, there may very well be children in the same class that have only just turned 4 at the end of August, so a year behind the 5 year olds. At that age, this is a massive difference developmentally.

Differentforgirls · Today 09:44

Lexibletheflexible · Today 09:42

I see lots of 5 year olds in the street who have tried to get dressed and have done well, but their parents havent bothered to just tidy them up and as a result, they look homeless. All because they can't be bothered to provide their child care past 5 years old.

The parents? Both mine started school at 4. One was 4 and 10 months and the other 4 and 8 months. Both could get dressed!

Lexibletheflexible · Today 09:45

mrsm43s · Today 09:42

Yes, again, those extra needs to which I refer.

In the absence of extra needs (e.g issues with spacial awareness or dexterity, for example), then it's a case of lazy parenting.

Good grief!

No thats the point. Good grief indeed. That you think a child who has a developmental "weakness" in one area must have "additional needs" is indicative of your ignorance and demonstrates the cultural tendency to overdiagnose neurodiversity to epidemic levels instead of addressing your unrealistic expectations of parenthood and child development.

You're the type of parent who would be inappropriately pushing professionals for a diagnosis.

Lexibletheflexible · Today 09:47

Differentforgirls · Today 09:44

The parents? Both mine started school at 4. One was 4 and 10 months and the other 4 and 8 months. Both could get dressed!

Sure. There were likely other things they couldn't do as well as they could get dressed. And that wouldn't have been indicative of much on its own. Not at 5.

2chocolateoranges · Today 09:47

When we meet parents of children who will attend our nursery in the future they always ask what they need to teach them before they come to nursery, will we teach them to write their name or teach them their numbers and we always say teach them to get dressed, put their jacket on, put their shoes on. Some days at nursery we have 70 children and if the majority can get shoes and jackets on without assistance it really helps.

mrsm43s · Today 09:49

Lexibletheflexible · Today 09:40

Then you don't understand much about child development. But that's okay. We can't all know everything.

This type of ignorance is what leads lots of middle classed (mostly) white British parents to force inappropriate diagnoses for children who are perfectly fine, just aren't as "quick" in some areas of their development. So when their 5 year old can't quite master dressing, they assume they must have some condition that would explain why they haven't measured up to their uneducated expectations. Just referring to the other thread about diagnosis trends and ethnic background...

Oh. Trying to belittle me because I don't agree with you lol!

Most children, who have been adequately parented, will have mastered getting dressed independently by 5.

Yes, there will be a few outliers with extra needs that will need help, and those who haven't been taught by their parents will need help. The latter group is much larger than the first one. Yes, some children will need more parental intervention than others, and some will pick it up quicker, but if they can't put on shoes, t-shirt, sweater and pull on trousers by 5, there's a problem in one way or another.

It is not for the teacher to do the parents' job. It is up to OP to step up and parent her child so she learns these basic skills.

FluffMagnet · Today 09:55

See, this is why I started my two beginning to dress themselves at 2 (when they both wanted to start trying), rather than insisting I did it all myself. Yes sometimes they have a top on back to front (my 5 yo DS insists having his PE sweatshirt on backwards is the correct way, and from seeing photos, he is supported by a number of his friends there), and when he was in nursery he would often go in wearing shoes on the wrong feet - short walk from the carpark and they remove them once inside, and he had the pride of doing it himself.

OP, kindly, your daughter is 5, not a baby. Let her be more independent. She will learn through her mistakes.

EveryoneUsingOutro · Today 09:55

Unless there’s some additional needs, your 5 year old should be able to dress herself reasonably well. I expect it’s because they were rushed out of the changing room for time, and she just threw on whatever.

Might be more reasonable to ask how long they get to dress, and practice doing that at home, than ask teacher to supervise 30+ kids have shoes on the correct feet.