Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why Black and Asian children have not experienced the same rise in SN diagnoses?

535 replies

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:14

I’ve been reading a bit about the rise in SEN and neurodevelopmental diagnoses (autism, ADHD, etc.) in the UK lately, and it got me wondering whether the increase is happening evenly across Black and Asian children compared to White British children.
From looking at DfE stats and UK research (like the Born in Bradford studies and Children’s Commissioner reports), it seems like the picture is actually really uneven:
Asian / South Asian children still have much lower diagnosis rates overall and a noticeably slower rise in diagnoses compared to White British kids.
Black children have higher rates of school-based SEN support in certain categories (especially SEMH – Social, Emotional and Mental Health), yet are actually under-represented in clinical ADHD diagnoses. There’s research showing Black boys in particular are more likely to have sensory overload, distress, or rigid thinking treated as defiance or a behavioural/SEMH issue rather than being referred for an autism or ADHD assessments.
Thoughts on why these might be?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
justasking111 · Yesterday 18:47

BrilliantBetty · Yesterday 16:29

I wonder if it has anything to do with men being more ‘in charge’ in those households with regard to finances. Not explaining this theory well. My DC is Autistic and had my husband got his way we would not have had a private diagnosis. He was very resistant in the early days when school and nursery made comments about possible autism. If I had not had my own financial autonomy and paid for it myself it may have not happened for several years as the NHS wait list is long and he did not want to pay for it (or there to be an official diagnosis). Now we are both in agreement that the diagnosis was necessary and helpful and we are working together to parent in a way that is better for autistic child who has specialist education provision in the form of 1:1 TA at the moment. But if I had not lead this, it would not have happened efficiently. I have seen with other families men are the reluctant ones.

It's like this in my wider family, father and grandfather would not accept that a diagnosis was required. The mother paid for it privately. Father has come round, grandfather is still obstinate about the whole thing.

So yes you make a good point

ILikeMathematics · Yesterday 18:47

LumberPainJackie · Yesterday 18:42

High suicide rate too...wonder why that might be, heard of burnout and hyper-focus? What do you think happens when large groups of people aren't diagnosed and struggle to "push through"....

https://www.nippon.com/en/articles/-/19211

Number of Suicides in Japan Falls Below 20,000 | Nippon.com

The total number of suicides in Japan decreased below 20,000 in 2025, reaching its lowest point since records began in 1978. However, the number of schoolchildren who took their lives remained high.

https://www.nippon.com/en/articles/-/19211

DontBuyAnotherBook · Yesterday 18:52

Marieb19 · Yesterday 18:36

Two of my children would have been diagnosed with anxiety/ocd/adhd if they were in education today. I got some brilliant advice from an older teacher, that we should be focusing on what they can do, not what they can't. They all achieved at school, got degrees and are in painful employment.
I am of the opinion, that if there were no benefits attached to these conditions, there would be significantly less demand for assessments and treatment.

No benefits would also leave many families in poverty as parents like myself have to leave work or work very little.

aCatCalledFawkes · Yesterday 18:54

ILikeMathematics · Yesterday 18:45

I feel at sone point okay someone is ND, but they should do their best to fit in society, work hard, study well and eventually get a job aligned to their skills and interested. Not just to label themselves as something to claim PIP

Why should they fit in with society? Why can't society be a bit more flexible and not built for just NT people? Why can't schools be more set up for everyone? Your statement makes it sounds like we are an NT country and everyone else needs to fit in around that.

FWIW, I think my sons ASD/ADHD come from my side of the family including me and also I have dyslexia. I have worked all my life since I was 15 and we have never raised him to believe he would live a life on PIP. There are situations in my life though I wish people could see the other side.

Canonlythinkofthisone · Yesterday 18:55

I cannot speak for anyone really. But in my experience. Discipline is still strong in Asian families (I am NOT saying this in a negative way) but I do feel that Asian children in 2026 are still parented in a way that British children in the 80s would have been. Potentially leading to more masking etc.
My personal opinion is that SEN is no more prevalent now than it was. It is simply more diagnosed as parents seek support for their children. A simple look at the statistics in diagnosis will highlight the fact that more and more adults are now seeking diagnosis as the stigma dilutes.

MeshMesh · Yesterday 18:56

LiteraryBambi · Yesterday 17:31

I'm S. Asian. It's not as stigmatised as perhaps it once was, so I don't think that explains most of the difference.

The rise in SEND nationally is driven largely by autistic spectrum diagnosis and social and emotional mental health.

Unless quite acute, these are issues which we don't seek to label. Through routine, good parenting and aspirations, our parents and our generation tend to rely less on the need for a label.

It's the same when we look at the issue of white working class kids. No one is stating the obvious that the reason why ethnic kids tend to do better, even when we control for poverty, is largely down to parenting and aspirations. We weren't allowed to just sit at home and do nothing.

What is it poor Asian kids are doing at home rather than sitting around doing nothing?

Grammarnut · Yesterday 18:58

JHound · Yesterday 16:33

Why do you think men are “more in charge in those households”?

Because frequently they are. I have a background within Asian family life and women are very much second place.

JulietteRoche · Yesterday 18:58

Frankly, because we have better things to do than constant navel gazing!

Trottersup · Yesterday 19:03

JulietteRoche · Yesterday 18:58

Frankly, because we have better things to do than constant navel gazing!

Is that a reply to someone's comment, or are you opining that getting a child who is struggling diagnosed is 'navel gazing'?

Beeloux · Yesterday 19:03

Because it isn’t recognised in many of them cultures.

One of my ds is half Arab and the other is half Eastern European. Youngest ds’s dad was a GP and admitted he didn’t believe in ASD or ADHD.

Im fairly certain XH had ADHD or ASD but he wouldn’t have been diagnosed.

I have a friend living in the Gulf and her son had ASD. It isn’t covered by insurance and she’s forking out thousands for private SEN therapy.

Monty36 · Yesterday 19:04

LumberPainJackie · Yesterday 18:42

High suicide rate too...wonder why that might be, heard of burnout and hyper-focus? What do you think happens when large groups of people aren't diagnosed and struggle to "push through"....

Well the suicide rate is interesting. They have a large contingent of shame within their culture. And many are complete workaholics. So I expect that his impacts on the figures.

I disagree with your premise that large numbers are undiagnosed and struggle to push through though. We do not know enough as to why our country is so affected comparative to some others.

Salviania · Yesterday 19:06

In my son's primary the only children with any diagnosis were white. It was very obvious that 2 of the SE Asian kids had some sort of neurodivergance but it didn't seem to be anywhere on the parents' radar and it's not the sort of thing you can bring up.

A different SE Asian parent said it can be hard for some parents from that background to acknowledge their child might be struggling. Class was about 40% white and 60% non white FWIW.

Monty36 · Yesterday 19:06

ILikeMathematics · Yesterday 18:45

I feel at sone point okay someone is ND, but they should do their best to fit in society, work hard, study well and eventually get a job aligned to their skills and interested. Not just to label themselves as something to claim PIP

I completely agree with you.

Grammarnut · Yesterday 19:06

LumberPainJackie · Yesterday 17:00

Pakistani and Bangladeshi rates are on par with white British children, which strongly points towards a cultural lack of desire for diagnoses by other Asian groups rather than absence of ND.
I don't think you have much experience of SEN if you think these kids get "special pleading or concessions".

Pakistani and Bangladeshi families are also more likely to have cousin marriages generation on generation, which may affect SEN rates. Hindus forbid cousin marriage in all close degrees - they practice strict exogamy when arranging marriages and that you do not marry your cousin is culturally ingrained so will affect marriages of affection as well - which may explain less SEN.

Dogsceptic · Yesterday 19:08

friedaklein · Yesterday 16:17

As a S Asian I have many thoughts on this, but MN is absolutely the wrong place to share them.

Why not MN?

ThatUmberCritic · Yesterday 19:12

JHound · Yesterday 16:33

Why do you think men are “more in charge in those households”?

because there are more traditional gender roles across other cultures. And from what I’ve seen as well I would agree that men are less likely to be the ones pushing for diagnoses .

HIYAitsRuth · Yesterday 19:12

MaltesersDeath · Yesterday 16:42

Good investment financially though if it leads on to DLA and carers allowance.

Its not just a diagnosis that leads to dla and carers allowance. Evidence of extra care needs is required

Destiny123 · Yesterday 19:13

Stigma, fear, ignorance, in denial. I've got loads of ND Dr mates from ethnic minorities

Charley50 · Yesterday 19:13

I work in SEN in London and the ethnic makeup of the SEN students reflects the local area, which is largely black African or Caribbean heritage, mixed heritage and Turkish heritage. Also South Asian but maybe not as many as one might expect compared to the population. White British are underrepresented in SEN where I work, but this reflects the demographic of the area. The black children have ADHD, autism, SEMH or moderate learning difficulties diagnosed, as do the others. There are cultural barriers to diagnosis at times.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 19:14

Lexibletheflexible · Yesterday 18:23

Because I think it's obvious what people mean on here when they say Asian since it is a British site. If it was (most of) reddit, then I'd agree clarification might be in order.

When I said Asian I was thinking of from Asia in general : that would include people of Pakistani, Bangladeshi etc heritage as well as Chinese, Korean etc. I do agree re the difference in US vs British usage.

OP posts:
Jane3212 · Yesterday 19:16

Grammarnut · Yesterday 19:06

Pakistani and Bangladeshi families are also more likely to have cousin marriages generation on generation, which may affect SEN rates. Hindus forbid cousin marriage in all close degrees - they practice strict exogamy when arranging marriages and that you do not marry your cousin is culturally ingrained so will affect marriages of affection as well - which may explain less SEN.

Edited

Yes, I was thinking this.

OP posts:
Happyindevon · Yesterday 19:16

White culture is awful for health and the family unit 🤷‍♀️

ILikeMathematics · Yesterday 19:16

Canonlythinkofthisone · Yesterday 18:55

I cannot speak for anyone really. But in my experience. Discipline is still strong in Asian families (I am NOT saying this in a negative way) but I do feel that Asian children in 2026 are still parented in a way that British children in the 80s would have been. Potentially leading to more masking etc.
My personal opinion is that SEN is no more prevalent now than it was. It is simply more diagnosed as parents seek support for their children. A simple look at the statistics in diagnosis will highlight the fact that more and more adults are now seeking diagnosis as the stigma dilutes.

I'm happy at how I was disciplined. I think it was a bit over harsh at times. But definitely needed some strict rules and boundaries and not the crazy "oh can't control them, let them do whatever they want" philosophy. Good discipline, starts early.

queenofthewild · Yesterday 19:17

I work in a specialist SEN nursery. The majority of our children with profound needs are not white British. Most of our families are in denial that their children will need support for life - they think a specialist nursery will “make them better”. It’s also common for these children not to have been born in the UK. I think the families are often hiding their preschoolers from their families and communities at home. It’s very sad.