Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why Black and Asian children have not experienced the same rise in SN diagnoses?

536 replies

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:14

I’ve been reading a bit about the rise in SEN and neurodevelopmental diagnoses (autism, ADHD, etc.) in the UK lately, and it got me wondering whether the increase is happening evenly across Black and Asian children compared to White British children.
From looking at DfE stats and UK research (like the Born in Bradford studies and Children’s Commissioner reports), it seems like the picture is actually really uneven:
Asian / South Asian children still have much lower diagnosis rates overall and a noticeably slower rise in diagnoses compared to White British kids.
Black children have higher rates of school-based SEN support in certain categories (especially SEMH – Social, Emotional and Mental Health), yet are actually under-represented in clinical ADHD diagnoses. There’s research showing Black boys in particular are more likely to have sensory overload, distress, or rigid thinking treated as defiance or a behavioural/SEMH issue rather than being referred for an autism or ADHD assessments.
Thoughts on why these might be?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Jane3212 · Yesterday 19:17

Canonlythinkofthisone · Yesterday 18:55

I cannot speak for anyone really. But in my experience. Discipline is still strong in Asian families (I am NOT saying this in a negative way) but I do feel that Asian children in 2026 are still parented in a way that British children in the 80s would have been. Potentially leading to more masking etc.
My personal opinion is that SEN is no more prevalent now than it was. It is simply more diagnosed as parents seek support for their children. A simple look at the statistics in diagnosis will highlight the fact that more and more adults are now seeking diagnosis as the stigma dilutes.

I suspect this is a factor though I do think it may genuinely be more common now, also harder to mask for various reasons.

OP posts:
ILikeMathematics · Yesterday 19:17

Monty36 · Yesterday 19:06

I completely agree with you.

Thank you ❤️

Happyindevon · Yesterday 19:19

queenofthewild · Yesterday 19:17

I work in a specialist SEN nursery. The majority of our children with profound needs are not white British. Most of our families are in denial that their children will need support for life - they think a specialist nursery will “make them better”. It’s also common for these children not to have been born in the UK. I think the families are often hiding their preschoolers from their families and communities at home. It’s very sad.

What conditions do they have, broadly speaking?

MrsMariaReynolds · Yesterday 19:21

Hot take--they don't seek diagnosis even if strongly suspected by schools. I have worked in primary schools for years and have seen this phenomenon first hand.

Canonlythinkofthisone · Yesterday 19:22

ILikeMathematics · Yesterday 19:16

I'm happy at how I was disciplined. I think it was a bit over harsh at times. But definitely needed some strict rules and boundaries and not the crazy "oh can't control them, let them do whatever they want" philosophy. Good discipline, starts early.

Not saying I disagree. I was brought up in quite a strict household. Not as strict as some of my Chinese friends however. So I do 100% believe this has an impact on diagnosis in children.

Bushmillsbabe · Yesterday 19:25

Sunshineheres · Yesterday 16:22

Yes. There's also a subset of white Britosh parents who will move heaven and earth to get a diagnosis. I've never met a child (or adult) who went for a private ADHD assessment and didn't get the diagnosis they sought.

And that's an issue. We would like DD to be assessed for ADHD, and our nhs wait list is 4 years so probably have to go private. But we actually want her fully assessed, on the basis we aren't 100% sure, we dont just want someone telling us yes automatically, as otherwise you aren't paying for an assessment, you are paying for a diagnosis, which is very different and very wrong. So we don't really know what to do - we don't want to leave her waiting on nhs lost if she does have it, but we don't want to buy a diagnosis either, especially if it's incorrect

Beeloux · Yesterday 19:25

Happyindevon · Yesterday 19:16

White culture is awful for health and the family unit 🤷‍♀️

Being able to beat your spouse without any repercussions is better for the family unit?

Before you start spouting nonsense, I’ve lived in numerous Gulf countries and seen it happen first hand.

Trottersup · Yesterday 19:26

ILikeMathematics · Yesterday 18:45

I feel at sone point okay someone is ND, but they should do their best to fit in society, work hard, study well and eventually get a job aligned to their skills and interested. Not just to label themselves as something to claim PIP

You obviously have no experience of severe ASD. My DS couldn't even attend school. There was nowhere local that could meet his needs. So despite the education system denying him the education he was legally entitled to, you think he should be working. He'd probably kill himself if he were forced into that position. Might be worth you researching ASD and ADHD before making such sweeping statements. People aren't a homogeneous lump.

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 19:26

LumberPainJackie · Yesterday 18:39

Glad you agree Asians are just as likely to have SEN and it is whether the parents are open to helping their children with needs whether they get a diagnosis. Many people can't afford it, which creates a huge disparity in society which is unfair and one people like Wes Streeting seem to want to perpetuate with rubbish about it being a negative to a child to understand why they are different. What is negative is having kids who can achieve well burning out, bullied and not going to school because they aren't diagnosed and supported in our education system.

Yes, I agree that Asians are just as likely to have SEN.
They're less likely to be "neurospicy".

Happyindevon · Yesterday 19:27

Trottersup · Yesterday 19:26

You obviously have no experience of severe ASD. My DS couldn't even attend school. There was nowhere local that could meet his needs. So despite the education system denying him the education he was legally entitled to, you think he should be working. He'd probably kill himself if he were forced into that position. Might be worth you researching ASD and ADHD before making such sweeping statements. People aren't a homogeneous lump.

By severe ASD do you mean nappies and non verbal, or just very anxious?

Happyindevon · Yesterday 19:27

Beeloux · Yesterday 19:25

Being able to beat your spouse without any repercussions is better for the family unit?

Before you start spouting nonsense, I’ve lived in numerous Gulf countries and seen it happen first hand.

Ffs did I even remotely say that

Honestly this place

JulietteRoche · Yesterday 19:27

Trottersup · Yesterday 19:03

Is that a reply to someone's comment, or are you opining that getting a child who is struggling diagnosed is 'navel gazing'?

Edited

It's a reply to the question in the OP. I am mixed black and white and my parents wouldn't have entertained any of the nonsense that a lot of parents entertain now. That may be an age rather than a race thing, but I'm not sure that it is entirely. Most crunchy granola knit your own yoghurt types whose kids have five different diagnonses seem to be white IME.

MrsKateColumbo · Yesterday 19:28

@bushmillsbabe you want to go for someone who is also an NHS consultant. I.e. they aren't going to risk their reputation on an inaccurate diagnosis

Beeloux · Yesterday 19:29

Happyindevon · Yesterday 19:27

Ffs did I even remotely say that

Honestly this place

I’d prefer to bring my children up in ‘white culture’ than that sort of environment.

Clearly doesn’t fit your narrative.

VioletsTale · Yesterday 19:29

JulietteRoche · Yesterday 19:27

It's a reply to the question in the OP. I am mixed black and white and my parents wouldn't have entertained any of the nonsense that a lot of parents entertain now. That may be an age rather than a race thing, but I'm not sure that it is entirely. Most crunchy granola knit your own yoghurt types whose kids have five different diagnonses seem to be white IME.

In our severe learning difficulties class , BAME children outnumber white children by 3:1. Make of that what you will.

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 19:29

Trottersup · Yesterday 19:26

You obviously have no experience of severe ASD. My DS couldn't even attend school. There was nowhere local that could meet his needs. So despite the education system denying him the education he was legally entitled to, you think he should be working. He'd probably kill himself if he were forced into that position. Might be worth you researching ASD and ADHD before making such sweeping statements. People aren't a homogeneous lump.

I don’t think people are aware of the higher suicide rates in neurodivergent populations, or the over-representation of neurodivergent individuals in prisons. They’re too focused on PIP.

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 19:31

Happyindevon · Yesterday 19:27

By severe ASD do you mean nappies and non verbal, or just very anxious?

“Just very anxious” can be severely disabling.

CentralStati0n · Yesterday 19:33

JulietteRoche · Yesterday 19:27

It's a reply to the question in the OP. I am mixed black and white and my parents wouldn't have entertained any of the nonsense that a lot of parents entertain now. That may be an age rather than a race thing, but I'm not sure that it is entirely. Most crunchy granola knit your own yoghurt types whose kids have five different diagnonses seem to be white IME.

My white child has 5 NHS diagnoses. Is that not allowed?She didn’t want them and would rather not have her live significantly impacted by them.

Notaverageinanyway · Yesterday 19:33

They don’t look for diagnosis unless there is absolutely no alternative .

CentralStati0n · Yesterday 19:34

Happyindevon · Yesterday 19:27

By severe ASD do you mean nappies and non verbal, or just very anxious?

My child has severe autism and is verbal and highly intelligent.

I think you need to educate yourself .

Charley50 · Yesterday 19:36

Happyindevon · Yesterday 19:16

White culture is awful for health and the family unit 🤷‍♀️

Are you being sarcastic?!

MysteryParcel · Yesterday 19:36

I’m of South Asian origin and only got diagnosed with ADHD as an adult. I remember ADHD being brought up to my parents in both primary and secondary school though but they wouldn’t entertain it insisting there was “nothing wrong with me” and how dare the school try to stigmatise me; to them it was nonsense as my grades were so good (they used to stand over me with a slipper coaching me with my homework).

To help get diagnosed as an adult, the provider suggested getting letters from my parents regarding my childhood and they both refused as to this day, they still think it’s shameful.

My DB had autism and they had no choice but to go along with the assessments as there was definitely no hiding it so I think that made them even more reluctant to get me diagnosed as it would be extra shame.

JulietteRoche · Yesterday 19:36

CentralStati0n · Yesterday 19:33

My white child has 5 NHS diagnoses. Is that not allowed?She didn’t want them and would rather not have her live significantly impacted by them.

What's the point of having these diagnoses? After a time you just have to get on with it. Honestly, I get confused with all the new nomenclature and all the special accommodations people require. What's the point of having an alphabet's worth of diagnoses?

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 19:39

JulietteRoche · Yesterday 19:36

What's the point of having these diagnoses? After a time you just have to get on with it. Honestly, I get confused with all the new nomenclature and all the special accommodations people require. What's the point of having an alphabet's worth of diagnoses?

Treatment, and reasonable adjustments.

MissingMeadow · Yesterday 19:39

Happyindevon · Yesterday 19:16

White culture is awful for health and the family unit 🤷‍♀️

In what way?

Swipe left for the next trending thread