Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why Black and Asian children have not experienced the same rise in SN diagnoses?

535 replies

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:14

I’ve been reading a bit about the rise in SEN and neurodevelopmental diagnoses (autism, ADHD, etc.) in the UK lately, and it got me wondering whether the increase is happening evenly across Black and Asian children compared to White British children.
From looking at DfE stats and UK research (like the Born in Bradford studies and Children’s Commissioner reports), it seems like the picture is actually really uneven:
Asian / South Asian children still have much lower diagnosis rates overall and a noticeably slower rise in diagnoses compared to White British kids.
Black children have higher rates of school-based SEN support in certain categories (especially SEMH – Social, Emotional and Mental Health), yet are actually under-represented in clinical ADHD diagnoses. There’s research showing Black boys in particular are more likely to have sensory overload, distress, or rigid thinking treated as defiance or a behavioural/SEMH issue rather than being referred for an autism or ADHD assessments.
Thoughts on why these might be?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Marieb19 · Yesterday 18:28

nearlylovemyusername · Yesterday 16:26

Private ASD/ADHD diagnosis costs 3k+. It requires input from school, not just parental and child's responses.
I think people go for this expense when they are really sure that there is an issue and want to get help which can be only obtained when diagnosis is established.

No it doesn't - ADHD diagnosis online costs a few hundred pounds. One of the reasons the Government are looking to close it down.

LumberPainJackie · Yesterday 18:29

@FriggadyDiggady DD goes to a private school because she has dyslexia and autism. She is in set 1 with 8 of the SEN group for the year group, some of which are Asian and all are predicted grades in the top 10% of the country. If the same educational support were available in state schools, these kids would not have been sent to private. It is parental attitudes that make the difference with diagnostics, not the population they are from being different on a biological or genetic level. These kids all hyper-focus but because they are all girls they were often told they were overly sensitive, independent or not getting on with peers in Primary. They don't have the same interests as the girls in other sets and thanks to all of us parents recognising this and asking why, they have been supported and diagnosed. Many girls from all backgrounds in state schools will not have that luxury. Not one of them gets extra time in exams, I might add. They don't need it.

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 18:30

Marieb19 · Yesterday 18:28

No it doesn't - ADHD diagnosis online costs a few hundred pounds. One of the reasons the Government are looking to close it down.

HealthHero (one of the private providers) has closed itself down today, not taking any new referrals.

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 18:31

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 18:11

Dyslexia occurs across the cognitive continuum. Wealthier people can afford diagnostic assessments. It’s offensive to refer to dyslexic people as stupid.

My point was that they didn't have dyslexia.

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 18:33

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 18:31

My point was that they didn't have dyslexia.

How do you know? Do you have access to their scores on the psychometric tests?

aCatCalledFawkes · Yesterday 18:33

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 18:31

My point was that they didn't have dyslexia.

How do you know that? That's a wild statement to make.

ILikeMathematics · Yesterday 18:33

As an Asian person myself my parents just were very heavily pushy on education. I agree and am grateful for what they did. The Asian mentality is one of hard work, determination and frankly studying. I probably have some ND, I'm unsure though, not been tested. But my parents instilled in me the values of hard work.

But it's not like all Asians are super smart. Many are. A lot are..I think a lot of our success is due to our motivation and drive. But I knew so many kids in my primary who were Asian (the school was mostly Asian) and were years behind in expected attainment.

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Yesterday 18:34

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 18:31

My point was that they didn't have dyslexia.

Please can you share how you know this?

MalateOxaloacetate · Yesterday 18:34

Kingdomofsleep · Yesterday 18:12

But you run the (extremely likely) risk of averaging out different populations with opposite needs. Like the Hong kong immigrants in St Albans and the refugees from Afghanistan. If they have similar SEN rates, I promise you that there is not the same reason for both.

I have read a lot about the concept of medical racism and even in that, people from different parts of Asia may well have extremely different experiences, because of cultural views around pain and stoicism and misogyny/matriarchy varying widely across the continent.

So I hear what you're saying but I still think any "BAME" stats are deeply unhelpful, and i stand by the word bollocks. I know it is not you personally who has generated the bollocks.

Edited

And that’s a completely fair point to make. Grouping together groups like this does introduce inaccuracies absolutely and it’s not a perfect system. But there are areas where it is a more useful method than trying to quantify each group individually.

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 18:34

aCatCalledFawkes · Yesterday 18:33

How do you know that? That's a wild statement to make.

@FriggadyDiggady can’t possibly know.

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 18:34

LumberPainJackie · Yesterday 18:29

@FriggadyDiggady DD goes to a private school because she has dyslexia and autism. She is in set 1 with 8 of the SEN group for the year group, some of which are Asian and all are predicted grades in the top 10% of the country. If the same educational support were available in state schools, these kids would not have been sent to private. It is parental attitudes that make the difference with diagnostics, not the population they are from being different on a biological or genetic level. These kids all hyper-focus but because they are all girls they were often told they were overly sensitive, independent or not getting on with peers in Primary. They don't have the same interests as the girls in other sets and thanks to all of us parents recognising this and asking why, they have been supported and diagnosed. Many girls from all backgrounds in state schools will not have that luxury. Not one of them gets extra time in exams, I might add. They don't need it.

"It is parental attitudes that make the difference with diagnostics, not the population they are from being different on a biological or genetic level."
Indeed.

Monty36 · Yesterday 18:36

Japan has a low % of children diagnosed with any neurodiverse issues. They have a tendency as a nation to pick themselves up, dust themselves down and sort out problems. They have a very cohesive society. Huge levels of tech used all the time. Far ahead of ours. So I don’t think technology is the problem.

They do have a society that is very cohesive. A strong work ethic. Manners are important. Their diet is different. They have a great deal of civic pride. All of these positive things will feed through to children. Of course some will have neurological difficulties. Which will account for the low % comparative to ours. And perhaps they are less rigid in the boxes they put people in. I know nothing about benefits which are attached to disabilities in Japan.

aCatCalledFawkes · Yesterday 18:36

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 18:34

@FriggadyDiggady can’t possibly know.

Of course they can't. Dyslexia wasn't always accepted by LEAs and had to be campaigned to be accepted. I had a test when I was 9yrs and when I was 22yrs. Both positive consistent with each other. I bet if I took it again at 48yrs if would still say the same thing.

Marieb19 · Yesterday 18:36

Two of my children would have been diagnosed with anxiety/ocd/adhd if they were in education today. I got some brilliant advice from an older teacher, that we should be focusing on what they can do, not what they can't. They all achieved at school, got degrees and are in painful employment.
I am of the opinion, that if there were no benefits attached to these conditions, there would be significantly less demand for assessments and treatment.

LumberPainJackie · Yesterday 18:39

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 18:34

"It is parental attitudes that make the difference with diagnostics, not the population they are from being different on a biological or genetic level."
Indeed.

Glad you agree Asians are just as likely to have SEN and it is whether the parents are open to helping their children with needs whether they get a diagnosis. Many people can't afford it, which creates a huge disparity in society which is unfair and one people like Wes Streeting seem to want to perpetuate with rubbish about it being a negative to a child to understand why they are different. What is negative is having kids who can achieve well burning out, bullied and not going to school because they aren't diagnosed and supported in our education system.

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 18:39

Marieb19 · Yesterday 18:36

Two of my children would have been diagnosed with anxiety/ocd/adhd if they were in education today. I got some brilliant advice from an older teacher, that we should be focusing on what they can do, not what they can't. They all achieved at school, got degrees and are in painful employment.
I am of the opinion, that if there were no benefits attached to these conditions, there would be significantly less demand for assessments and treatment.

I’m an older teacher working in HE with disabied students and I see, every single day, the benefits of early diagnosis as opposed to years of struggling.

bryceQ · Yesterday 18:40

I realise anecdotal data isn't always helpful but, my son attends a specialist school (London) and there are many more black and south asian children in his class than white. My son is mixed. In the entire school I have only seen one East Asian child. I think at specialist level it is more “obvious” that these children can’t manage mainstream… all in the class are non verbal. But to be honest you have to constantly fight for support, the local authorities make it very difficult. If English isn't first language it's incredibly challenging.

Monty36 · Yesterday 18:41

Marieb19 · Yesterday 18:36

Two of my children would have been diagnosed with anxiety/ocd/adhd if they were in education today. I got some brilliant advice from an older teacher, that we should be focusing on what they can do, not what they can't. They all achieved at school, got degrees and are in painful employment.
I am of the opinion, that if there were no benefits attached to these conditions, there would be significantly less demand for assessments and treatment.

The teacher is absolutely right. I have a disability. Thanks to my mother, for all the wrong reasons, I was treated as if I had nothing wrong with me. And that is how I saw myself. And managed to work and hold down a good job.

When I worked with disabled people that was my take. Not what they could not do. What could they do.

There were no benefits for my parents to ever claim.
It has never occurred to me to claim anything either. I probably should have but my not seeing myself as disabled gets in the way. Even though I realise I am and it does cost me. I may have to one day. But not so far.

emuloc · Yesterday 18:41

distinctpossibility · Yesterday 16:27

I think there are potentially many and varied reasons.

Racism? Would there be a tendency for school staff to blame atypical behaviour in a Black boy on parenting, while being determined to find a 'reason' for a white child to struggle. Plus, system racism and injustice leading Black and Asian families to distrust the medical system so be reluctant to pursue a diagnosis?

I am just trying to think of a reason beyond "there are inherently lower rates in some communities" and "white parents push for diagnosis". In the FivesTimeMore campaigns investigating why Black mothers and babies were five times more likely than white mothers and babies to die in childbirth, it was largely due to systemic racism within the medical paradigm so to me, that's a variable that would need investigating first.

Edited

This.

VioletsTale · Yesterday 18:42

From my experience, Asian families are quite reluctant to accept the need for a diagnosis (unless their child is severely affected) . On the other hand, black children are more likely to be seen as disruptive, rude etc. than having SEND, so there is a lack of recognition and support coupled with some reluctance as well.

LumberPainJackie · Yesterday 18:42

Monty36 · Yesterday 18:36

Japan has a low % of children diagnosed with any neurodiverse issues. They have a tendency as a nation to pick themselves up, dust themselves down and sort out problems. They have a very cohesive society. Huge levels of tech used all the time. Far ahead of ours. So I don’t think technology is the problem.

They do have a society that is very cohesive. A strong work ethic. Manners are important. Their diet is different. They have a great deal of civic pride. All of these positive things will feed through to children. Of course some will have neurological difficulties. Which will account for the low % comparative to ours. And perhaps they are less rigid in the boxes they put people in. I know nothing about benefits which are attached to disabilities in Japan.

Edited

High suicide rate too...wonder why that might be, heard of burnout and hyper-focus? What do you think happens when large groups of people aren't diagnosed and struggle to "push through"....

ILikeMathematics · Yesterday 18:45

Monty36 · Yesterday 18:36

Japan has a low % of children diagnosed with any neurodiverse issues. They have a tendency as a nation to pick themselves up, dust themselves down and sort out problems. They have a very cohesive society. Huge levels of tech used all the time. Far ahead of ours. So I don’t think technology is the problem.

They do have a society that is very cohesive. A strong work ethic. Manners are important. Their diet is different. They have a great deal of civic pride. All of these positive things will feed through to children. Of course some will have neurological difficulties. Which will account for the low % comparative to ours. And perhaps they are less rigid in the boxes they put people in. I know nothing about benefits which are attached to disabilities in Japan.

Edited

I feel at sone point okay someone is ND, but they should do their best to fit in society, work hard, study well and eventually get a job aligned to their skills and interested. Not just to label themselves as something to claim PIP

Mookie81 · Yesterday 18:45

Sunshineheres · Yesterday 16:45

I don't think the Sencos at the two schools I work with would agree - they have strong views about the way these diagnosis are achieved, but even if that's true it will absolutely be a factor in the prevelence of ADHD among white British children compared to other groups.

In my many years teaching experience, there is a certain demographic of white British families who push for a diagnosis for certain reasons. They are not in the position to pay privately and they get a diagnosis from the nhs without or with very little school input. The children generally have behavioural issues that stem from parenting that present like ADHD.
People can knock me all they want, I've seen it enough.

LoveItaly · Yesterday 18:46

swingingbackwardsandforwards · Yesterday 16:21

I would genuinely be interested in your thoughts.

So would I. I wish people could more freely share their musings, without fear of being jumped on for offending someone (within reason, obviously).

VioletsTale · Yesterday 18:47

Monty36 · Yesterday 18:36

Japan has a low % of children diagnosed with any neurodiverse issues. They have a tendency as a nation to pick themselves up, dust themselves down and sort out problems. They have a very cohesive society. Huge levels of tech used all the time. Far ahead of ours. So I don’t think technology is the problem.

They do have a society that is very cohesive. A strong work ethic. Manners are important. Their diet is different. They have a great deal of civic pride. All of these positive things will feed through to children. Of course some will have neurological difficulties. Which will account for the low % comparative to ours. And perhaps they are less rigid in the boxes they put people in. I know nothing about benefits which are attached to disabilities in Japan.

Edited

And yet 2% of the population are completely opting out of any social interaction and confining themselves at home. So much so , that it is seen as an epidemic and worthy of intervention.