Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why Black and Asian children have not experienced the same rise in SN diagnoses?

535 replies

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:14

I’ve been reading a bit about the rise in SEN and neurodevelopmental diagnoses (autism, ADHD, etc.) in the UK lately, and it got me wondering whether the increase is happening evenly across Black and Asian children compared to White British children.
From looking at DfE stats and UK research (like the Born in Bradford studies and Children’s Commissioner reports), it seems like the picture is actually really uneven:
Asian / South Asian children still have much lower diagnosis rates overall and a noticeably slower rise in diagnoses compared to White British kids.
Black children have higher rates of school-based SEN support in certain categories (especially SEMH – Social, Emotional and Mental Health), yet are actually under-represented in clinical ADHD diagnoses. There’s research showing Black boys in particular are more likely to have sensory overload, distress, or rigid thinking treated as defiance or a behavioural/SEMH issue rather than being referred for an autism or ADHD assessments.
Thoughts on why these might be?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
JHound · Yesterday 18:10

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Yesterday 18:09

Specifically in my area it is Ghanaian, Jamaican and South Indian communities. Coming from early years and primary education I saw it frequently with those communities and less often with White British or other minority groups. Of course, as I said in my first post you replied to, this is my experience.

I was just wondering which cultures you meant specifically.

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 18:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Dyslexia occurs across the cognitive continuum. Wealthier people can afford diagnostic assessments. It’s offensive to refer to dyslexic people as stupid.

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Yesterday 18:11

JHound · Yesterday 18:10

I was just wondering which cultures you meant specifically.

Then ask that question outright. Anyway, I answered.

JHound · Yesterday 18:12

Kingdomofsleep · Yesterday 17:44

BAME people in the UK are more likely to be deprived

Sorry to be blunt but I hate bollocks like this. Hong Kong Chinese first gen immigrants living in St Albans are not more likely to be deprived. Refugees from Afghanistan (say), are more likely to be deprived.

All this BAME nonsense just lumps together everyone who isn't white, in a way that becomes totally unhelpful and is borderline indirectly racist against white people by drawing a line between them and everyone else.

Same. I never get why people speak of those from BAME backgrounds as if it’s one community.

Lexibletheflexible · Yesterday 18:12

JHound · Yesterday 18:09

“Both”?

OP said black and Asian. Black is not synonymous with African and there are many black and Asian cultures.

I think it's fairly safe to say that here, when we say Asian, we typically mean the South Asian continent vs Americans who are more commonly referring to people from SE Asia. We tend to be more specific when speaking about SE Asian communities rather than group.

Kingdomofsleep · Yesterday 18:12

MalateOxaloacetate · Yesterday 18:06

It depends on the level of research and the area. In Healthcare it can allow you to see racism and bias to separate white people from BAME people as if all the BAME people face worse outcomes then you can say racism may be at play. If you are looking at things like obesity, black Caribbean, African, South Asian, Middle Eastern and other Asian groups are all more at risk of health issues at a lower weight and lower waist size than white British people.

Of course it would be good to have stats on each minority from there however some sample sizes are so small that they are not comparative and so the method falls apart.

Edited

But you run the (extremely likely) risk of averaging out different populations with opposite needs. Like the Hong kong immigrants in St Albans and the refugees from Afghanistan. If they have similar SEN rates, I promise you that there is not the same reason for both.

I have read a lot about the concept of medical racism and even in that, people from different parts of Asia may well have extremely different experiences, because of cultural views around pain and stoicism and misogyny/matriarchy varying widely across the continent.

So I hear what you're saying but I still think any "BAME" stats are deeply unhelpful, and i stand by the word bollocks. I know it is not you personally who has generated the bollocks.

JHound · Yesterday 18:13

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Yesterday 18:11

Then ask that question outright. Anyway, I answered.

I did ask outright.

Velumental · Yesterday 18:13

In my son's class there are 2 boys, 1 of Asian descent and 1 who is black who very much exhibit the same traits my son does , only difference being my son is very well supported in school and therefore his behavior in class is very good and not problematic, these other 2 boys are clearly thought of as just badly behaved. My son is a fair way down the referral process and these boys have no referral in place. I do think it's probably cultural for parents and unconscious racism from teachers and I think it's a shame because these boys are missing out on support because of the still existing stigma of ASD/ADHD.

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Yesterday 18:13

JHound · Yesterday 18:13

I did ask outright.

You didn’t but there’s no need for either of us to be pedantic and derail a thread.

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 18:14

LiberteLynx · Yesterday 17:57

sigh, it is white privilege. White people at the whole population level have better access to healthcare.

I’m well aware of that, on a population level.

Trwkaw · Yesterday 18:15

I saw black children had higher rates which surprised me.

However i think some ethnicities are more strict so some of what may/may not be adhd where in whites could be parenting issues/low aspirations doesnt happen with the other minorities ethnicity as often.
Basically some have become very soft.
There are a couple of cases i know where parents were too soft and either throughout school or by secondary the kids became defiant/rude walking out of lessons.
lower aspirations play into this.
Culturally perhaps indian or Chinese see L1 asd /aspergers as not an issue / its not an issue to them socially.

i know a few who have persued asd diagnosis for kids and the kids were 100% average kids. So perhaps were looking for special treatment for kids.

i dont know stats in other cultures but 5%+ kids have fasd but uk dont diagnose that in non adopted kids. In one case the most severe asd presenting child had an alcoholic mum. Another was on meds for a condition which the meds are know to cause asd issues.

Also are other ethnicities having kids late 30s or 40+? As often have more family support or may live with them longer.

Education is generally better in london, there is more academic competition, more school choice. This may impact as here we have severe sen staying right through primary and also in mainstream secondary.

Some of the L1 asd kids and maybe adhd kids would be more suited to selective education/grammar. There isnt any here.
i think either grammar or private and dc1 wouldnt have struggled anywhere near as much and wouldnt have needed a diagnosis…

London has schools where they actually target grade 7-9

JHound · Yesterday 18:16

Lexibletheflexible · Yesterday 18:12

I think it's fairly safe to say that here, when we say Asian, we typically mean the South Asian continent vs Americans who are more commonly referring to people from SE Asia. We tend to be more specific when speaking about SE Asian communities rather than group.

I don’t get your reference to the USA as I was not referencing that (although it’s inaccurate as per how census data is captured).

Even with a focus on solely Britons of South Asian descent it’s still not a monoculture among various South Asian groups. Indian, Referring to “both cultures” in the context of “black and Asian groups” is bonkers!

PottingCompost · Yesterday 18:17

Anecdotally, I have experience of British Indian parents dismissing suggestions from educators that they should look into getting their children assessed for ASD. I would bet a month's mortgage on the children in question being diagnosed, but...

JHound · Yesterday 18:18

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Yesterday 18:13

You didn’t but there’s no need for either of us to be pedantic and derail a thread.

I did. I ask in which cultures is it taboo.

But interestingly your personal experience conflicts with what OP noted in her OP.

NewMonsteraLeaf · Yesterday 18:18

A lack of presentation to diagnostic services?

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Yesterday 18:19

PottingCompost · Yesterday 18:17

Anecdotally, I have experience of British Indian parents dismissing suggestions from educators that they should look into getting their children assessed for ASD. I would bet a month's mortgage on the children in question being diagnosed, but...

Yes this has been my experience.

realsavagelike · Yesterday 18:19

Voneska · Yesterday 17:13

I'm not an expert, but just a lay person and other people might have a different opinion than mine but the first thing that comes to mind is that Asian have a more secure family support system and so The Offspring feel more secure and are thriving without various health issues. My views may differ from others but I accept that.

I'm so glad this band is thriving.

Scamworried · Yesterday 18:22

Sunshineheres · Yesterday 16:22

Yes. There's also a subset of white Britosh parents who will move heaven and earth to get a diagnosis. I've never met a child (or adult) who went for a private ADHD assessment and didn't get the diagnosis they sought.

We went private because the wait was so long and my child needed support long before but we couldn't wait any longer as lack of support in school was causing more and more issues.

Private is expensive and we really didn't have the money to spare but we also didn't have much other option as our child needed support.
I do know people who haven't got a diagnosis but generally no one is going to pay a huge amount for assessment unless they are pretty sure their child has needs

Waitingfordoggo · Yesterday 18:22

FriggadyDiggady · Yesterday 17:27

That's interesting - do you have stats to back it up though?

No, not at all. Just speculation and the first thing that popped into my head on reading the thread title. Just wondered if it might be a factor, as we know that older parents (particularly older fathers?) are more likely to have a child with ASC (I don’t know if the same is true for ADHD).

MoonlitMess · Yesterday 18:23
  • Profound and Multiple Learning Disabilities (PMLD) - University of Bristol research shows that Pakistani pupils are 2 to 2.5 times more likely to be identified with PMLD, multi-sensory impairments, or severe sensory impairments than White British pupils. Higher rates are also recorded among Bangladeshi children. 1, 2, 3]
  • Higher prevalence in younger South Asian cohorts: Academic studies cited by the Royal College of Psychiatrists indicate that severe intellectual disabilities are up to three times more prevalent among British South Asian children and young adults (ages 5–32) compared to other communities. 1, 2]

https://www.bristol.ac.uk/media-library/sites/cmpo/migrated/documents/stevestrand.pdf

Lexibletheflexible · Yesterday 18:23

JHound · Yesterday 18:16

I don’t get your reference to the USA as I was not referencing that (although it’s inaccurate as per how census data is captured).

Even with a focus on solely Britons of South Asian descent it’s still not a monoculture among various South Asian groups. Indian, Referring to “both cultures” in the context of “black and Asian groups” is bonkers!

Because I think it's obvious what people mean on here when they say Asian since it is a British site. If it was (most of) reddit, then I'd agree clarification might be in order.

Mummyoflittledragon · Yesterday 18:25

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 18:11

Dyslexia occurs across the cognitive continuum. Wealthier people can afford diagnostic assessments. It’s offensive to refer to dyslexic people as stupid.

Exactly. @FriggadyDiggady maybe you’re not familiar with the term stealth dyslexia. It’s where someone is dyslexic, but also highly intelligent and can more readily mask and compensate.
Edit - to add, named stealth, because it isn’t easy to detect and often goes unnoticed.

Totaldramallama · Yesterday 18:26

I don't know about nationally but working with children in east London for several years I noted a very high level of need in the Asian children, often. Bangladeshi background, however whether they would seek diagnosis or manage at home in mixed generation households I can't say

Scamworried · Yesterday 18:27

MaltesersDeath · Yesterday 16:42

Good investment financially though if it leads on to DLA and carers allowance.

DLA is needs based not diagnosis based. And quite frankly while we get DLA and carers this does not cover the additional costs of a disabled child. I also can't work and carers is no comparison to what I want in a professional role I loved

aCatCalledFawkes · Yesterday 18:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I'm dyslexic and educated to degree level from a middle class family, my exH is dyslexic and his council estate parents (and I'm saying this with love as I got on with them) had to beg for money from family to get him assessed. He has no GCSE's and went in to trade.

Our dyslexic daughter is now living her best life at Durham University.

Given the price of assessments at the time it's not a surprise that the majority of diganoses were with families who could afford it.