Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why Black and Asian children have not experienced the same rise in SN diagnoses?

536 replies

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:14

I’ve been reading a bit about the rise in SEN and neurodevelopmental diagnoses (autism, ADHD, etc.) in the UK lately, and it got me wondering whether the increase is happening evenly across Black and Asian children compared to White British children.
From looking at DfE stats and UK research (like the Born in Bradford studies and Children’s Commissioner reports), it seems like the picture is actually really uneven:
Asian / South Asian children still have much lower diagnosis rates overall and a noticeably slower rise in diagnoses compared to White British kids.
Black children have higher rates of school-based SEN support in certain categories (especially SEMH – Social, Emotional and Mental Health), yet are actually under-represented in clinical ADHD diagnoses. There’s research showing Black boys in particular are more likely to have sensory overload, distress, or rigid thinking treated as defiance or a behavioural/SEMH issue rather than being referred for an autism or ADHD assessments.
Thoughts on why these might be?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Ionlymakejokestodistractmyself · Yesterday 21:28

painswick · Yesterday 17:23

Please clarify this statement. What are the objective tests that don't rely on either patient/parent report or clinical observation that cannot be faked? I am presuming some sort of scan or other objective metric? Please confirm what this is and how widespread its use is.

My son had a computer test for ADHD alongside school and parent reports. They were actually on the fence about giving him an ADHD diagnosis until they got the test results. It's not an exact science / cannot be used in isolation.

Redpaisley · Yesterday 21:28

distinctpossibility · Yesterday 16:27

I think there are potentially many and varied reasons.

Racism? Would there be a tendency for school staff to blame atypical behaviour in a Black boy on parenting, while being determined to find a 'reason' for a white child to struggle. Plus, system racism and injustice leading Black and Asian families to distrust the medical system so be reluctant to pursue a diagnosis?

I am just trying to think of a reason beyond "there are inherently lower rates in some communities" and "white parents push for diagnosis". In the FivesTimeMore campaigns investigating why Black mothers and babies were five times more likely than white mothers and babies to die in childbirth, it was largely due to systemic racism within the medical paradigm so to me, that's a variable that would need investigating first.

Edited

It’s far more complex than how you have described. I am guessing you are not from any of these cultures.

There’s lack of awareness and stigma around these issues in S Asian culture. Some fear these diagnosis will harm their children in some ways. S Asian parents also want their children to do well in future career, and they wouldn’t want their children to miss on any opportunities due to any labelling. I don’t know about black culture.
Having said that, attitudes are changing.

MalateOxaloacetate · Yesterday 21:29

Monty36 · Yesterday 18:36

Japan has a low % of children diagnosed with any neurodiverse issues. They have a tendency as a nation to pick themselves up, dust themselves down and sort out problems. They have a very cohesive society. Huge levels of tech used all the time. Far ahead of ours. So I don’t think technology is the problem.

They do have a society that is very cohesive. A strong work ethic. Manners are important. Their diet is different. They have a great deal of civic pride. All of these positive things will feed through to children. Of course some will have neurological difficulties. Which will account for the low % comparative to ours. And perhaps they are less rigid in the boxes they put people in. I know nothing about benefits which are attached to disabilities in Japan.

Edited

I lived in Japan and can assure you the nation is not one big cohesive family of high tech people. Their local councils are absolutely fossilised and still use stamps to approve things and they’re only opened like 100 days a year to do anything and if you want to get anything official done prepare to be sat there for hours. Especially in Hokkaido. There are also alcohol problems and major depression issues.

Ionlymakejokestodistractmyself · Yesterday 21:32

I am just trying to think of a reason beyond "there are inherently lower rates in some communities" and "white parents push for diagnosis". In the FivesTimeMore campaigns investigating why Black mothers and babies were five times more likely than white mothers and babies to die in childbirth, it was largely due to systemic racism within the medical paradigm so to me, that's a variable that would need investigating first.

Interesting, I have also observed middle class parents be more successful in getting school on board and their children onto waiting lists for ND assessments compared to working class / less affluent parents. Through our own process I insisted my DH was involved and while I can't prove it I'm almost certain having a well spoken white man in the room had its advantages and meant we were listened to 🙄

CrispySquid · Yesterday 21:33

Jane3212 · Yesterday 21:17

Hmm, I mostly agreed with pp's reply and while ChatGPT can be useful, it's often quite unreliable,,especially on the free tier.

Otoh this is a good point: 'if a cultural environment places particularly high expectations on academic achievement, discipline and conformity, it could conceivably make some forms of neurodivergence less visible, rather than less prevalent.', I was thinking exactly this.

In the threads I was reading, the husbands also often struggled with expressing affection openly, with childcare & housework. These might be less visible depending on culture: eg. A more reserved culture might mean less verbal displays of affection required, a culture where women do most of the housework & childcare etc would mean that would be less visible .

I agree with both myself and some of Chat GPT! And I promise I certainly don’t think some cultures are genetically superior! I just don’t think I’m terribly articulate! There are good and bad points of all sorts of cultures (not necessarily in equal proportion). There was parenting that my white British friends received that I absolutely craved and holistically needed as a child. I think Western parenting knocks the ball out of the park in some areas. Other things I am very grateful towards my Asian parents for culturally. As always, with most things, the truth is probably somewhere in the middle.

CentralStati0n · Yesterday 21:33

Anonusernameforthispost · Yesterday 21:24

South Asian here. 2nd gen, almost 3rd gen. So have watched grandparents who were very old fashioned and preserved their way life, parents who were more integrated and me who feels British and culturally assimilated. And now my kids who live the same trials and tribulations that their white counterpart Gen Z and Gen Alpha face.

There is generally a ‘pull yourself together and crack on’ attitude in our culture.

And d’you know what. It works. I’m sorry to say that the over indulgence of even the slightest neurodivergence and turning your kids into victims really does them a disservice. It is not kind and it is not helpful. I am not saying neurodivergence is t real or impactful but in western cultures it is made into people’s entire personality. The cult of victimhood is setting us back. Let’s stop this.

By over indulgence of neurodiversity- you mean getting diagnosed.

Many people in South Asian households lack culturally familiar terms to describe traits like autism or ADHD. Differences may be misread as laziness, stubbornness, or behavioral issues, leading to delayed or missed diagnoses. Fear of judgment, family reputation concerns ("what will people say?"), or myths linking disability to parenting or spiritual causes often push families toward secrecy and isolation. Because difference is sometimes discouraged or hidden, many neurodivergent individuals mask their traits and only seek clarity or diagnosis later in life. Availability of specialised assessments, school accommodations, and culturally informed care differs sharply between urban centres, rural areas, and diaspora countries.

Sounds awful. No thanks

Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 21:34

Autism and adhd have been underdiagnosed for years in the uk particularly for women, girls and people of colour. We are now better informed. It has been clarified that there is no evidence for overdiagnosis claims
This is core of the issue. What it comes down to is that the criteria and the evidence required to get a diagnosis has changed drastically. For a start, parents left it to the professionals to form an opinion before a consideration of diagnosis was ever made. Nowadays, parents go to get a diagnosis having already done their own diagnosis. You just to read the posts on this thread with the comments about how obvious one child or adult was/ is ADHD or autistic.

Assessments in the 80s for instance were much more in depth. They often took more than one meeting, there was more observations undertaken. A diagnosis was something parents prayed wouldn't be the outcome. Nowadays, parents desperately need validation through the process of diagnosis. Parents have educated themselves with the use of key words to throw to Rick the right boxes.

It's not a matter of under/over diagnosis. It's a matter of what you do with it. That's the big concern because the moment a diagnosis is made, it comes with an automatic access to support, adaptations, extra understanding, sympathy and the rest, which in my views (and that of many professionals) is doing much more damage than good.

It pushes these diagnosed children to believe that the world I've them the above and they shall apart when they don't receive it. They become reliant on others and convinced that they are absolved of being responsible for their needs.

As more and more people fall under that category, we have fewer and fewer people able, and then willing to provide adaptability, understanding and support, whilst those who can't function without it increase year on year.

It's not the diagnosis that is the concern, it's how people use it.

VioletsTale · Yesterday 21:34

Anonusernameforthispost · Yesterday 21:24

South Asian here. 2nd gen, almost 3rd gen. So have watched grandparents who were very old fashioned and preserved their way life, parents who were more integrated and me who feels British and culturally assimilated. And now my kids who live the same trials and tribulations that their white counterpart Gen Z and Gen Alpha face.

There is generally a ‘pull yourself together and crack on’ attitude in our culture.

And d’you know what. It works. I’m sorry to say that the over indulgence of even the slightest neurodivergence and turning your kids into victims really does them a disservice. It is not kind and it is not helpful. I am not saying neurodivergence is t real or impactful but in western cultures it is made into people’s entire personality. The cult of victimhood is setting us back. Let’s stop this.

But does it always work? Or does it work when you have the “right” material to work with let’s say? For example our children with severe learning difficulties that are S Asian ; there’s no “suck it up buttercup” for them. They are non verbal, some still in nappies, constantly stimming , self harming , at a toddler level etc. Then there’s the ones where we can see signs of various things. We talk to parents, we advise , we suggest. Their solution is almost always getting a tutor and “is he/she doing better yet?”. The answer is mostly no, because a tutor can’t and won’t tackle the underlying issues , be those academical or behavioural. Never mind the automatic 11+ exam route and the surprise and anger when they don’t pass. It’s like the 4 previous years of conversations never happened.

Sprostongreeen · Yesterday 21:35

friedaklein · Yesterday 16:17

As a S Asian I have many thoughts on this, but MN is absolutely the wrong place to share them.

That’s annoying. The thing I love about Mumsnet is the anonymity and the ability to find out how other people really feel about something (that they would be too polite to say to your face)

VioletsTale · Yesterday 21:40

Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 21:34

Autism and adhd have been underdiagnosed for years in the uk particularly for women, girls and people of colour. We are now better informed. It has been clarified that there is no evidence for overdiagnosis claims
This is core of the issue. What it comes down to is that the criteria and the evidence required to get a diagnosis has changed drastically. For a start, parents left it to the professionals to form an opinion before a consideration of diagnosis was ever made. Nowadays, parents go to get a diagnosis having already done their own diagnosis. You just to read the posts on this thread with the comments about how obvious one child or adult was/ is ADHD or autistic.

Assessments in the 80s for instance were much more in depth. They often took more than one meeting, there was more observations undertaken. A diagnosis was something parents prayed wouldn't be the outcome. Nowadays, parents desperately need validation through the process of diagnosis. Parents have educated themselves with the use of key words to throw to Rick the right boxes.

It's not a matter of under/over diagnosis. It's a matter of what you do with it. That's the big concern because the moment a diagnosis is made, it comes with an automatic access to support, adaptations, extra understanding, sympathy and the rest, which in my views (and that of many professionals) is doing much more damage than good.

It pushes these diagnosed children to believe that the world I've them the above and they shall apart when they don't receive it. They become reliant on others and convinced that they are absolved of being responsible for their needs.

As more and more people fall under that category, we have fewer and fewer people able, and then willing to provide adaptability, understanding and support, whilst those who can't function without it increase year on year.

It's not the diagnosis that is the concern, it's how people use it.

Do you have any sources for any of that , or is it once again , opinion?

Jane3212 · Yesterday 21:41

MeshMesh · Yesterday 21:22

Which bit do you think is “unreliable”?

As someone with professional and personal experience in this area I think it’s perfectly good information.

I can see the appeal of the heroic genetically superior aspirational migrant narrative means less SEND in those communities, you seem keen on, but I think you’ll fail to find any good supporting evidence for it.

I don't think your post is unreliable, sorry, I meant ChatGPT generally can be unreliable. I've had cases before where it recommended films to me that turned out not to exist!

But no, I think it made relevant points in your post & I agree that IQ of parents is probably not a big factor in whether a child is SN. Pp is right about immigrants then being more educated on average etc when they came, though. I don't think that's 'eugenic' : it's factual that IQ is to some degree heritable and so is SN, as she claimed.

OP posts:
Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 21:41

By over indulgence of neurodiversity- you mean getting diagnosed
No over indulgence in expecting others to put them on a pedestral, to see their needs met before anyone else's, to expect a level of flexibility regardless of the impact it has on anyone else. Children grow up to think their needs are special and a priority. When they are treated as such, they become victims of an unfair system that owes them security and stability. They, on the other hand, should be allowed to bake efforts when it suits and at their own speed.

ILikeMathematics · Yesterday 21:42

CentralStati0n · Yesterday 19:34

My child has severe autism and is verbal and highly intelligent.

I think you need to educate yourself .

What does he do now?

Popstarrrrr · Yesterday 21:42

alcovecupboards · Yesterday 16:47

Medical racism is a huge issue. A friend of mine has three SEN boys, all of whom it's been an absolute battle for her to get diagnosed despite anyone who spends any time at all with them knowing full well that they are SEN. Her eldest in particular was treated as naughty and a problem child for so long. They're black.

I completely concur with this. Black children are 3 times as likely to enter mental health services via the criminal justice service than white children. Both black and Asian children are more likely to enter mental health services at crisis point compared to white children.

Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 21:44

Do you have any sources for any of that , or is it once again , opinion?
Where are we? Oh yes, AIBU, where we discuss opinions, not review scientific papers!

Funny how this question ever only comes up when the argument goes against ones opinion. It's never asked when one agrees with the poster sharing their opinion!

CentralStati0n · Yesterday 21:45

Monty36 · Yesterday 18:36

Japan has a low % of children diagnosed with any neurodiverse issues. They have a tendency as a nation to pick themselves up, dust themselves down and sort out problems. They have a very cohesive society. Huge levels of tech used all the time. Far ahead of ours. So I don’t think technology is the problem.

They do have a society that is very cohesive. A strong work ethic. Manners are important. Their diet is different. They have a great deal of civic pride. All of these positive things will feed through to children. Of course some will have neurological difficulties. Which will account for the low % comparative to ours. And perhaps they are less rigid in the boxes they put people in. I know nothing about benefits which are attached to disabilities in Japan.

Edited

Incorrect

Reported diagnosis for autism and ADHD are often higher in Japan than in the UK.Reported autism rates are generally higher, with some global estimates placing Japan around 1 in 55 children and rising diagnosis trends across both children and adults. A 2026 analysis of Japanese insurance claims projected that, at 2023 rates, 15.7% would receive an autism diagnosis by age 49—reflecting clinic diagnosis and support-access trends rather than true community prevalence.UK estimates commonly place autism prevalence at roughly 1- 1.7% of the general population (at least 700,000 autistic people),

Re ADHD community level surveys in Japan estimate ADHD prevalence around 5.8% to 7.7% in children and adolescents and roughly 1.65% yo 1.7% in adults. Global modelling data (GBD 2023) also shows a higher reported rate per 100,000 in Japan (1,216) than in the UK .UK adult ADHD estimates are often cited around 3% to 4% under NICE guidelines.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 21:46

CrispySquid · Yesterday 21:33

I agree with both myself and some of Chat GPT! And I promise I certainly don’t think some cultures are genetically superior! I just don’t think I’m terribly articulate! There are good and bad points of all sorts of cultures (not necessarily in equal proportion). There was parenting that my white British friends received that I absolutely craved and holistically needed as a child. I think Western parenting knocks the ball out of the park in some areas. Other things I am very grateful towards my Asian parents for culturally. As always, with most things, the truth is probably somewhere in the middle.

I agree with this and I think your post was articulate. I didn't agree with what ChatGPT said about it sounding 'eugenic'. ChatGPT is programmed not to offend and sometimes this goes too far & it labels things as offensive which aren't.

OP posts:
CentralStati0n · Yesterday 21:46

Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 21:41

By over indulgence of neurodiversity- you mean getting diagnosed
No over indulgence in expecting others to put them on a pedestral, to see their needs met before anyone else's, to expect a level of flexibility regardless of the impact it has on anyone else. Children grow up to think their needs are special and a priority. When they are treated as such, they become victims of an unfair system that owes them security and stability. They, on the other hand, should be allowed to bake efforts when it suits and at their own speed.

None of that actually happens so 🤷‍♀️

VioletsTale · Yesterday 21:47

Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 21:44

Do you have any sources for any of that , or is it once again , opinion?
Where are we? Oh yes, AIBU, where we discuss opinions, not review scientific papers!

Funny how this question ever only comes up when the argument goes against ones opinion. It's never asked when one agrees with the poster sharing their opinion!

You can’t claim something as fact “assessments were done more in depth”- for example- when it’s not a fact , just an assumption/opinion, and an uninformed assumption/opinion at that.

ETA You did the same when claiming there were fewer NEETS. They weren’t a thing!! No one counted them. Or fewer exclusions , again , officially they didn’t bother to keep track much.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 21:48

Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 21:41

By over indulgence of neurodiversity- you mean getting diagnosed
No over indulgence in expecting others to put them on a pedestral, to see their needs met before anyone else's, to expect a level of flexibility regardless of the impact it has on anyone else. Children grow up to think their needs are special and a priority. When they are treated as such, they become victims of an unfair system that owes them security and stability. They, on the other hand, should be allowed to bake efforts when it suits and at their own speed.

To clarify, do you think most cases of neurodivergence are not real and the children don't usually have these conditions?

Or do you think most cases are real, but that diagnosis and professional support are not helpful?

Or something else?

OP posts:
CentralStati0n · Yesterday 21:49

VioletsTale · Yesterday 21:40

Do you have any sources for any of that , or is it once again , opinion?

It’s well known. Decades of clinical data, population studies, and historical medical reviews provide clear evidence that autism and ADHD shave been significantly underdiagnosed in women and girls and people of colour. Diagnostic frameworks were originally built around young, white male populations, creating systemic blind spots that still affect who gets recognised today.

VioletsTale · Yesterday 21:52

CentralStati0n · Yesterday 21:49

It’s well known. Decades of clinical data, population studies, and historical medical reviews provide clear evidence that autism and ADHD shave been significantly underdiagnosed in women and girls and people of colour. Diagnostic frameworks were originally built around young, white male populations, creating systemic blind spots that still affect who gets recognised today.

I know that. PP claimed assessments in the 80s were more in depth. I asked for some evidence for that considering they keep claiming things that aren’t true.

ThreeLocusts · Yesterday 21:52

Sunshineheres · Yesterday 16:22

Yes. There's also a subset of white Britosh parents who will move heaven and earth to get a diagnosis. I've never met a child (or adult) who went for a private ADHD assessment and didn't get the diagnosis they sought.

Well, meet me! I tried to get myself diagnosed mostly to ward off a nightmare colleague who made very heavy weather of her own diagnosis. And because I have concentration and memory problems to do with MS, but thought it would be easier to get accommodations and possibly treatment with this diagnosis.

Cynical, I know, but don't judge me too harshly. My problems are real, and I would have loved some medication to try

I was a bit taken aback when they went 'nah, no ADD here', but it slightly increased my trust in the private diagnostics industry.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 21:53

MalateOxaloacetate · Yesterday 21:29

I lived in Japan and can assure you the nation is not one big cohesive family of high tech people. Their local councils are absolutely fossilised and still use stamps to approve things and they’re only opened like 100 days a year to do anything and if you want to get anything official done prepare to be sat there for hours. Especially in Hokkaido. There are also alcohol problems and major depression issues.

Yes,I'm interested in Japan and they slowed down after being very forward in phone production etc due to some issues with companies running more old fashioned systems which made it harder to adapt, I think. I've also read they still use stuff like faxes and CDs a lot(though the latter seems a good idea to me, I like physical media)..

OP posts:
Jane3212 · Yesterday 21:54

Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 21:34

Autism and adhd have been underdiagnosed for years in the uk particularly for women, girls and people of colour. We are now better informed. It has been clarified that there is no evidence for overdiagnosis claims
This is core of the issue. What it comes down to is that the criteria and the evidence required to get a diagnosis has changed drastically. For a start, parents left it to the professionals to form an opinion before a consideration of diagnosis was ever made. Nowadays, parents go to get a diagnosis having already done their own diagnosis. You just to read the posts on this thread with the comments about how obvious one child or adult was/ is ADHD or autistic.

Assessments in the 80s for instance were much more in depth. They often took more than one meeting, there was more observations undertaken. A diagnosis was something parents prayed wouldn't be the outcome. Nowadays, parents desperately need validation through the process of diagnosis. Parents have educated themselves with the use of key words to throw to Rick the right boxes.

It's not a matter of under/over diagnosis. It's a matter of what you do with it. That's the big concern because the moment a diagnosis is made, it comes with an automatic access to support, adaptations, extra understanding, sympathy and the rest, which in my views (and that of many professionals) is doing much more damage than good.

It pushes these diagnosed children to believe that the world I've them the above and they shall apart when they don't receive it. They become reliant on others and convinced that they are absolved of being responsible for their needs.

As more and more people fall under that category, we have fewer and fewer people able, and then willing to provide adaptability, understanding and support, whilst those who can't function without it increase year on year.

It's not the diagnosis that is the concern, it's how people use it.

'Assessments in the 80s for instance were much more in depth. They often took more than one meeting, there was more observations undertaken'

  • did you have family or friends who took part in them? If not, where does your knowledge come from?
OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread