I’m sharing what ChatGPT makes of the comment (which captures my pre-existing opinion) as there’s so much wrong with it I don’t have time to type it all out:
This is a particularly revealing comment because it presents itself as a relatively sophisticated explanation of ethnic differences in SEND identification, but it actually makes several quite serious conceptual and scientific errors. And yes, the underlying argument comes uncomfortably close to suggesting that certain ethnic populations are genetically superior to others.
I'd break the critique into six parts.
1. The genetic selection argument is deeply problematic
This is the most troubling part:
"It’s a big selection bias as the successful immigrants selected for had traits that would be uncommon in neurodiverse people hence very little neurodiversity passed down so you don’t see it in the population of Indian and Chinese children so much."
There are several problems here.
First, it conflates educational and occupational success with an absence of neurodivergence.
There is no scientific basis for assuming that highly educated, professionally successful people are unlikely to be autistic, have ADHD, dyslexia or other neurodevelopmental differences.
Indeed:
There are plenty of highly intelligent autistic people.
ADHD is found across the intelligence spectrum.
Dyslexia is entirely compatible with high academic achievement.
Neurodivergence is not synonymous with low intelligence or poor educational attainment.
The author seems to be working with an implicit hierarchy in which neurotypicality, intelligence, conscientiousness and professional success are closely aligned. They aren't.
Second, it misunderstands genetic heritability.
Yes, many neurodevelopmental conditions have substantial genetic components. But this doesn't mean that parents without an identified SEND condition will have children without one.
Heritability is a population-level statistical measure. It doesn't mean that a particular characteristic is genetically predetermined in an individual, nor does it allow us to make straightforward predictions about the prevalence of SEND in the children of a particular occupational or educational group.
A parent might have undiagnosed ADHD, autistic traits or dyslexia. They might have compensated for their difficulties throughout their lives, particularly in an environment where such conditions weren't recognised.
Their children might present quite differently.
Third, it makes an enormous leap from immigrant selection to genetic superiority.
Even if we accept that some early migration cohorts were positively selected for educational qualifications, professional skills or entrepreneurial ability, that tells us very little about the prevalence of neurodevelopmental conditions among their descendants.
The implicit argument is that the Indian and Chinese populations which migrated to Britain were genetically predisposed towards higher intelligence and lower neurodiversity.
That is an extraordinarily ambitious claim for which the poster offers absolutely no evidence.
And there's an uncomfortable historical resonance here: the suggestion that certain populations possess a more desirable inherited combination of characteristics than others is recognisably eugenic in its underlying logic.
It isn't necessarily a consciously racist argument, but it is an argument that needs considerably more scrutiny than the author gives it.
2. It misunderstands what SEND actually encompasses
The comment treats SEND as though it were a relatively coherent category of inherited impairment.
It isn't.
SEND encompasses an extraordinarily heterogeneous collection of conditions and difficulties, including:
Autism.
ADHD.
Dyslexia and other specific learning difficulties.
Speech, language and communication needs.
Physical disabilities.
Hearing and visual impairments.
Social, emotional and mental health difficulties.
Moderate, severe and profound learning difficulties.
These have different aetiologies, different relationships with genetics and different relationships with environmental circumstances.
There is no single genetic characteristic that makes someone more or less likely to have SEND.
The suggestion that an immigrant population could have been selected for a general absence of SEND is therefore conceptually very crude.
3. The argument confuses absence of diagnosis with absence of condition
This is arguably the biggest problem with the comment's overall reasoning.
The poster initially makes an interesting observation: some immigrant families might have cultural frameworks which interpret learning difficulties differently.
That is entirely plausible.
For example, a family might interpret a child's difficulties as:
Poor discipline.
Insufficient effort.
Lack of concentration.
Immaturity.
A failure of parental authority.
Something that will resolve with age.
There may also be stigma associated with disability or mental health conditions.
But none of this means the underlying conditions aren't present.
In fact, it potentially means that they are less likely to be recognised, diagnosed or recorded.
This distinction is crucial:
The prevalence of SEND in a population is not the same thing as the recorded prevalence of SEND in schools.
Differences in diagnosis and identification can reflect differences in:
Parental awareness and willingness to seek assessment.
Teacher expectations and referral practices.
Access to diagnostic services.
Language and communication barriers.
Cultural interpretations of behaviour.
Institutional and professional biases.
The author acknowledges cultural differences in recognition but then seems to use those differences as supplementary evidence for a genetic explanation.
That's a rather extraordinary logical manoeuvre.
4. The immigration history is oversimplified
The description of early Indian and Chinese immigration as predominantly consisting of highly educated, middle-class, professionally successful people is also questionable.
Post-war South Asian migration to Britain was highly varied.
It included workers recruited into manufacturing, transport and the NHS; people arriving from rural and urban backgrounds; family reunification; and East African Asians, some of whom had considerable professional and commercial experience.
There were certainly highly qualified and professionally successful migrants, but the suggestion that the relevant populations were overwhelmingly composed of an educationally and economically exceptional elite is a caricature.
The histories of Indian, Pakistani, Bangladeshi and Chinese migration are also quite different. Treating them as a single phenomenon is unhelpful.
And even where educational selection occurred, it doesn't follow that it selected against neurodevelopmental differences.
5. There's an implicit and rather narrow understanding of intelligence
Something else interests me about the comment.
The author seems to assume that the characteristics associated with successful migration – intelligence, conscientiousness, ambition, resilience and educational attainment – are essentially the opposite of neurodivergence.
This is an outdated understanding of neurodevelopmental conditions.
Consider the relationship between autism and intelligence, for example. Autistic people have an extremely varied range of intellectual abilities. Some have significant learning disabilities; others have exceptional intellectual abilities.
ADHD is similarly heterogeneous.
The idea that a population of academically successful immigrants would consequently have very little neurodiversity is simply not credible.
It also overlooks the possibility that certain cognitive characteristics associated with neurodivergence might coexist with, or sometimes contribute to, particular forms of occupational or academic achievement.
6. The argument is potentially self-reinforcing
There's a particularly problematic circularity here.
The argument runs something like this:
Indian and Chinese children appear to have relatively low levels of SEND.
Their parents were disproportionately successful, highly educated immigrants.
Successful, highly educated people are assumed to have fewer neurodevelopmental conditions.
Their children therefore inherit fewer neurodevelopmental conditions.
The apparently low prevalence of SEND confirms the original assumption.
But the initial observation hasn't actually been established.
Are we talking about lower rates of diagnosed SEND? Lower rates of particular diagnoses? Lower rates of special educational provision? Or genuinely lower underlying prevalence?
Those are very different things.
The author doesn't distinguish between them.
My overall assessment
I think the comment contains one potentially worthwhile observation wrapped around a rather dubious explanation.
The worthwhile observation is that cultural attitudes, family expectations and different understandings of disability can influence whether children are identified as having additional needs.
That's a legitimate subject for sociological and educational research.
The dubious explanation is that Indian and Chinese children have fewer SEND conditions because their parents were genetically selected from a particularly successful, intelligent and neurotypical immigrant population.
That proposition is unsupported, rests on a misunderstanding of heritability and makes some very questionable assumptions about the relationship between intelligence, educational attainment and neurodivergence.
The central distinction the poster fails to grasp is the difference between a population having fewer SEND conditions and a population having fewer SEND conditions recognised and recorded by educational institutions.
And there's a further irony: if a cultural environment places particularly high expectations on academic achievement, discipline and conformity, it could conceivably make some forms of neurodivergence less visible, rather than less prevalent.
A child who is bright, academically capable and outwardly compliant but struggling with ADHD or autism might never be identified.
That is a much more plausible explanation to investigate than the idea that successful Indian and Chinese immigrants somehow brought a genetically superior, less neurodiverse population into Britain.