Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why Black and Asian children have not experienced the same rise in SN diagnoses?

537 replies

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:14

I’ve been reading a bit about the rise in SEN and neurodevelopmental diagnoses (autism, ADHD, etc.) in the UK lately, and it got me wondering whether the increase is happening evenly across Black and Asian children compared to White British children.
From looking at DfE stats and UK research (like the Born in Bradford studies and Children’s Commissioner reports), it seems like the picture is actually really uneven:
Asian / South Asian children still have much lower diagnosis rates overall and a noticeably slower rise in diagnoses compared to White British kids.
Black children have higher rates of school-based SEN support in certain categories (especially SEMH – Social, Emotional and Mental Health), yet are actually under-represented in clinical ADHD diagnoses. There’s research showing Black boys in particular are more likely to have sensory overload, distress, or rigid thinking treated as defiance or a behavioural/SEMH issue rather than being referred for an autism or ADHD assessments.
Thoughts on why these might be?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Allmarbleslost · Yesterday 20:23

Sunshineheres · Yesterday 16:22

Yes. There's also a subset of white Britosh parents who will move heaven and earth to get a diagnosis. I've never met a child (or adult) who went for a private ADHD assessment and didn't get the diagnosis they sought.

Do you know how much a private assessment costs? No parent is going to pay that unless they're 99% certain that their child has ADHD.

dontcookwontcook · Yesterday 20:24

CentralStati0n · Yesterday 20:17

You really do need to educate yourself

Children have occupational therapy OT to build practical movement skills, adapt daily tasks, and gain independence at home and school. Dyspraxia affects how the brain plans and coordinates movements, making everyday actions harder even when a child understands what to do. OT helps with fine and gross motor skills. Therapists practice hand control for writing, cutting, and buttoning clothes, alongside whole-body balance, running, and ball skills. OTs breaks down routines like dressing, tying shoelaces, using cutlery, and brushing teeth into manageable steps. Therapists suggest practical supports—such as pencil grips, adapted seating, or task strategies—to help with classroom work and PE. Many children with dyspraxia experience sensory differences or trouble sequencing steps, so OT helps them regulate responses and plan actions. It helps build confidence and emotional wellbeing as succeeding at daily tasks reduces frustration and builds self-esteem.

Her paediatrician said she needed OT!

Ok

dontcookwontcook · Yesterday 20:24

PottingCompost · Yesterday 20:21

Dyspraxia, like many other neurological conditions, is a spectrum. At the most severe levels, we're talking difficulty with coordination that impairs everyday living, like going up stairs (gross motor coordination) or getting dressed in anything that has zips or buttons (fine motor coordination). Imagine being 13 years old and not being able to button up a school shirt without someone else doing it for you.

Yes, I actually have it.

seanconneryseyebrow · Yesterday 20:24

painswick · Yesterday 17:07

This is incredibly naive. There has been an explosion in private providers of diagnosis, a large number of whom do not fully comply with nice guidelines and whose diagnostic process is questionable to say the least. It's one of the reasons many GPs are now reluctant to take on shared care. Equally there are plenty of professionals out there who will diagnose withouit any triangulating evidence from school etc.

IME the absolute worst assessments are done within the NHS under RTC. The do the bare minimum because what the NHS payrate for those assessments barely covers costs.

I work privately and we see all the time the shockingly poor assessments from people who come to us because they want it done properly.

Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 20:24

In the 1970s there were plenty of SEND kids whose issues went undiagnosed and unsupported. As a result they were left at higher risk of exclusion from school, achieving no qualifications, developing addiction issues, resorting to criminality and so on
No, as a result, the majority learn to adapt, cope and become more resilient. There were fewer exclusions, fewer qualifications but much higher employability. No NEETs or very few.

So it worked much better.

VioletsTale · Yesterday 20:26

PottyBreak · Yesterday 20:17

Can you think of a reason why this might be the case?

I have no skin in the game but think about who might put themselves forward for a diagnosis, and why? And who would never dream of doing so, and why?

Well, in my case , DD has been on the waiting list for a year and a half. She is 15, and once she reaches 16 , if she’s still not seen, she will have to start all over again under adult services. The clock is literally ticking, so I am looking to have her privately seen.

Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 20:27

I work privately and we see all the time the shockingly poor assessments from people who come to us because they want it done properly
The majority of NHS assessments are undertaken by private providers with NHS contracts!

Caniweartheseones · Yesterday 20:28

nearlylovemyusername · Yesterday 16:26

Private ASD/ADHD diagnosis costs 3k+. It requires input from school, not just parental and child's responses.
I think people go for this expense when they are really sure that there is an issue and want to get help which can be only obtained when diagnosis is established.

Nope. 1k in the UK. 400 euros in Western Europe.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 20:29

CrispySquid · Yesterday 19:43

Completely agree. Also being Indian myself, I know exactly why the rates are higher in white children/white cultures instead of Asian cultures. Almost anyone from these cultures could tell you why in a heartbeat but I’m not going to touch this one with a bargepole on Mumsnet. Stigma is one but not even the top 5 biggest reasons I don’t think. I don’t think people are truly ready to have a really raw, introspective, honest debate about this in good faith.

I also think the first reply to the OP nails it as usual.

Edited

I can understand fully why you don't want to discuss - I don't suppose you might want to discuss via PM though? I understand if not. I would be genuinely interested to discuss in good faith.

OP posts:
VioletsTale · Yesterday 20:29

Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 20:24

In the 1970s there were plenty of SEND kids whose issues went undiagnosed and unsupported. As a result they were left at higher risk of exclusion from school, achieving no qualifications, developing addiction issues, resorting to criminality and so on
No, as a result, the majority learn to adapt, cope and become more resilient. There were fewer exclusions, fewer qualifications but much higher employability. No NEETs or very few.

So it worked much better.

How would you know when neither exclusions nor NEETS were officially recorded , tracked or published in the 70s? Oh and what about the whole “uneducable” cohort?

FancyAnxiety · Yesterday 20:29

distinctpossibility · Yesterday 16:27

I think there are potentially many and varied reasons.

Racism? Would there be a tendency for school staff to blame atypical behaviour in a Black boy on parenting, while being determined to find a 'reason' for a white child to struggle. Plus, system racism and injustice leading Black and Asian families to distrust the medical system so be reluctant to pursue a diagnosis?

I am just trying to think of a reason beyond "there are inherently lower rates in some communities" and "white parents push for diagnosis". In the FivesTimeMore campaigns investigating why Black mothers and babies were five times more likely than white mothers and babies to die in childbirth, it was largely due to systemic racism within the medical paradigm so to me, that's a variable that would need investigating first.

Edited

This. And there is lots of research (including the maternity report mentioned) that supports this. It’s well known that there is systemic racism in healthcare.

PottingCompost · Yesterday 20:29

dontcookwontcook · Yesterday 20:24

Yes, I actually have it.

Goody gumdrops. Why does that mean you're opposed to those at the more severe end having professional support to develop their coordination?

Is this because you didn't learn to do buttons and you want others to suffer with you, or is because you learnt to use buttons and so can't fathom that others might need more support to acquire that skill?

seanconneryseyebrow · Yesterday 20:30

Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 20:27

I work privately and we see all the time the shockingly poor assessments from people who come to us because they want it done properly
The majority of NHS assessments are undertaken by private providers with NHS contracts!

Yes I know. Thats my point. They are done very poorly because they are paid so little and barely cover the costs. Therefore the NHS assessments are far inferior to the private ones. We dont want NHS contracts for this reason. We want to do the assessments properly.

CrispySquid · Yesterday 20:30

Jane3212 · Yesterday 20:19

I think Vietnamese and Filipino families tend to value education too. Vietnam is also a Confucian-influenced culture like China & Japan.

Agree re differences between groups generally, though.

From your posts it seems you think parenting can influence whether a child has SEN or not? Or have I misunderstood? I don't think that- what I do think is that it can influence how it presents.

It's worth noting cultures like Japan, Korea & China have strong norms towards group harmony which would give an additional incentive to mask.

Apologies, my post wasn’t the clearest. I don’t think it’s the case that they think their parenting can influence whether a child has SEN or not or even that it influences how it presents but rather more radically, I don’t think a lot of individuals from these cultures think SEN even exists in the first place. My Indian parents who immigrated here in the 1970s certainly wouldn’t have. Any impairment or lack of attainment in learning in a child would be seen to be the result of lack of discipline, lack of contentiousness of the child, lack of resilience or a lack of proper early socialisation. They would never have believed or still don’t believe it is a partly genetic or biological condition, outside all but the most severe cases.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 20:31

Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 20:24

In the 1970s there were plenty of SEND kids whose issues went undiagnosed and unsupported. As a result they were left at higher risk of exclusion from school, achieving no qualifications, developing addiction issues, resorting to criminality and so on
No, as a result, the majority learn to adapt, cope and become more resilient. There were fewer exclusions, fewer qualifications but much higher employability. No NEETs or very few.

So it worked much better.

I'm not fully convinced this way was wholly better. If you read the long running threads about women married to autistic men, the lack of diagnosis seems to have impacted the men's personal lives a lot (if not their work lives).

OP posts:
Unexpectedlysinglemum · Yesterday 20:32

Huge generalization. But Asian families can be worried about stigma and none wanting to marry their child.
also, think about to immigrates and how. Another huge generalization but Indian and west African immigrants are often doctor dentist nurses etc - very academic and not ones that might be as likely to have offspring with the kind of send that gets teachers attention if parents aren’t advocating for their child to have a diagnosis (eg a great scientist with social anxiety may be just a great scientist in some cultures but get an autism diagnosis in uk culture)

CentralStati0n · Yesterday 20:32

seanconneryseyebrow · Yesterday 20:30

Yes I know. Thats my point. They are done very poorly because they are paid so little and barely cover the costs. Therefore the NHS assessments are far inferior to the private ones. We dont want NHS contracts for this reason. We want to do the assessments properly.

NHS diagnoses are seen as superior and more thorough hence it being highlighted waiting lists need to be cut.

dontcookwontcook · Yesterday 20:33

PottingCompost · Yesterday 20:29

Goody gumdrops. Why does that mean you're opposed to those at the more severe end having professional support to develop their coordination?

Is this because you didn't learn to do buttons and you want others to suffer with you, or is because you learnt to use buttons and so can't fathom that others might need more support to acquire that skill?

blah blah blah these guilt trip/ overly emotional accusations don’t work on me

Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 20:33

Therefore the NHS assessments are far inferior to the private ones
Which a serious ethical concern. They could only have been granted contracts by claiming they could meet the service speciation which would have been set by nice and other guidelines. They lied to get the business and then provide questionable diagnosis that is causing much damage. Shameful.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 20:34

Unexpectedlysinglemum · Yesterday 20:32

Huge generalization. But Asian families can be worried about stigma and none wanting to marry their child.
also, think about to immigrates and how. Another huge generalization but Indian and west African immigrants are often doctor dentist nurses etc - very academic and not ones that might be as likely to have offspring with the kind of send that gets teachers attention if parents aren’t advocating for their child to have a diagnosis (eg a great scientist with social anxiety may be just a great scientist in some cultures but get an autism diagnosis in uk culture)

Edited

I don't think being high IQ parents mean SEN are that much less likely- especially as some types of SEN can coincide with high IQ.

OP posts:
CentralStati0n · Yesterday 20:34

Caniweartheseones · Yesterday 20:28

Nope. 1k in the UK. 400 euros in Western Europe.

In our area it’s £3k and best part of £1k for a psychs appointment before that to see if you should go through the diagnoses process.

VioletsTale · Yesterday 20:35

Jane3212 · Yesterday 20:31

I'm not fully convinced this way was wholly better. If you read the long running threads about women married to autistic men, the lack of diagnosis seems to have impacted the men's personal lives a lot (if not their work lives).

That poster is talking with (uninformed) opinions and prejudice not facts.

PottingCompost · Yesterday 20:36

dontcookwontcook · Yesterday 20:33

blah blah blah these guilt trip/ overly emotional accusations don’t work on me

"Emotional accusations"? Projecting emotions on people is very rude.

Those are the two options I can see that woukd explain your response, and I'd like to know which it is.

Zippidydoodah · Yesterday 20:36

redbullsurvivor · Yesterday 16:16

I would say culturally there is still shame and non belief in this type of SEN. So Asian families will either deny and move forward and survive without a diagnosis.

I think that also mixes with White British having a tendency to over diagnose and want there to be a label / excuse for everything.

The first paragraph, yes, this.

Your second paragraph…… 🤨