Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why Black and Asian children have not experienced the same rise in SN diagnoses?

536 replies

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:14

I’ve been reading a bit about the rise in SEN and neurodevelopmental diagnoses (autism, ADHD, etc.) in the UK lately, and it got me wondering whether the increase is happening evenly across Black and Asian children compared to White British children.
From looking at DfE stats and UK research (like the Born in Bradford studies and Children’s Commissioner reports), it seems like the picture is actually really uneven:
Asian / South Asian children still have much lower diagnosis rates overall and a noticeably slower rise in diagnoses compared to White British kids.
Black children have higher rates of school-based SEN support in certain categories (especially SEMH – Social, Emotional and Mental Health), yet are actually under-represented in clinical ADHD diagnoses. There’s research showing Black boys in particular are more likely to have sensory overload, distress, or rigid thinking treated as defiance or a behavioural/SEMH issue rather than being referred for an autism or ADHD assessments.
Thoughts on why these might be?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
NotMrsTumble · Yesterday 20:01

Sunshineheres · Yesterday 16:22

Yes. There's also a subset of white Britosh parents who will move heaven and earth to get a diagnosis. I've never met a child (or adult) who went for a private ADHD assessment and didn't get the diagnosis they sought.

Well I have. My youngest is one of them. Scored really highly as adhd in self and parental reporting, but as school don't see a problem, no diagnosis. With two older ND siblings (one NHS diagnosis, one private diagnosis confirmed later by NHS consultant), and further ND diagnoses on both sides of the family, he is statistically VERY likely to be ND given it's genetic heritability, and it's not like we as parents are blissfully unaware of the signs anymore.
Oh how I chuckle at my nonchalant "but everyone is like that" with my first. Not so funny was the anxiety induced burnout and actual physical harm that resulted before a diagnosis. Thankfully, now that we are more aware of how ND brains work and what accommodations work for our kids, we can put scaffolding in place to keep them from hitting rock bottom. Perversely rock bottom is probably what is needed to get a diagnosis.
Also very aware that this comes from a privileged position of being able to afford to seek a private diagnosis, to invest time and money in coping and support strategies, of being educated and able to research and advocate.

realsavagelike · Yesterday 20:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

choccytime · Yesterday 20:02

Am absolutely gobsmacked by some of these posts , how did we grow up ,(me in the 70;s ) without all these labels not one child in my primary or grammar school had anything like this . Is this why weve got the NEETS situation now

CentralStati0n · Yesterday 20:04

choccytime · Yesterday 20:02

Am absolutely gobsmacked by some of these posts , how did we grow up ,(me in the 70;s ) without all these labels not one child in my primary or grammar school had anything like this . Is this why weve got the NEETS situation now

You’re gobsmacked that young people have diagnoses to inform treatment?

PottingCompost · Yesterday 20:07

dontcookwontcook · Yesterday 19:58

You sent your kid to OT for dyslexia and dyspraxia? Ok.

The poster you're replying to didn't even mention dyslexia as a diagnosis. So where did you pull that from?

dontcookwontcook · Yesterday 20:09

PottingCompost · Yesterday 20:07

The poster you're replying to didn't even mention dyslexia as a diagnosis. So where did you pull that from?

i apologise I read dyslexia and dyspraxia when she wrote dyspraxia diagnosis

(I actually have dyslexia and dyspraxia)

and well… OT for dyspraxia? I mean, really?

Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 20:10

If I hear about a child experiencing burnout one more time, I'll scream out loud!

FFS, life is exhausting! A child that goes to bed having experienced no anxiety, no emotional challenge, no need to think and adapt their behaviour is a a child who is not exposed to normal life and/or given the chance to learn social standing.

dontcookwontcook · Yesterday 20:11

CentralStati0n · Yesterday 20:00

No her paediatrician did because it is severe, she couldn’t hold a knife and fork and struggled to do many things.

Edited

Ok

realsavagelike · Yesterday 20:11

choccytime · Yesterday 20:02

Am absolutely gobsmacked by some of these posts , how did we grow up ,(me in the 70;s ) without all these labels not one child in my primary or grammar school had anything like this . Is this why weve got the NEETS situation now

Just because you were not aware of something doesn't mean it didn't exist. Think how many of those kids grew up with their self esteem in the toilet for the rest of their lives just because we didn't know any better then, and they were written off as naughty or lazy. How many were weeded out of your secondary school before even starting if they had to sit an entrance exam?

seanconneryseyebrow · Yesterday 20:12

Sunshineheres · Yesterday 16:22

Yes. There's also a subset of white Britosh parents who will move heaven and earth to get a diagnosis. I've never met a child (or adult) who went for a private ADHD assessment and didn't get the diagnosis they sought.

I run a private assessment service. We give out negative result everyday.

choccytime · Yesterday 20:12

How did little old me and DH manage to raise 4 kids without sticking a label on one of them

realsavagelike · Yesterday 20:14

choccytime · Yesterday 20:12

How did little old me and DH manage to raise 4 kids without sticking a label on one of them

Dunno - let's label it 'Neurotypical Privilege'

MeshMesh · Yesterday 20:16

choccytime · Yesterday 20:02

Am absolutely gobsmacked by some of these posts , how did we grow up ,(me in the 70;s ) without all these labels not one child in my primary or grammar school had anything like this . Is this why weve got the NEETS situation now

Rather uninformed post.

In the 1970s there were plenty of SEND kids whose issues went undiagnosed and unsupported. As a result they were left at higher risk of exclusion from school, achieving no qualifications, developing addiction issues, resorting to criminality and so on.

The other thing to understand is that in the 1970s it was in some ways easier to forge a path through the teenage years and into adulthood without requiring support. Someone could leave school at 16 with few qualifications and pick up labouring work, factory work, or possibly an apprenticeship. Rent was more affordable. Less focus on office work. Less requirement to attend college or uni. We also now have less flexible, more exam focussed (vs the 1990), more measured schooling regime which exposes the issues for some kids who previously would have drifted through the system.

There are almost certainly just as many SEND kids in Black and Asian families. It’s unlikely ‘resilience’ and ‘aspiration’ help these kids overcome these issues per se, although one can see why people like to use this explanation. What’s far more likely is that shame and use of community/religious/family support mean fewer diagnoses are made and more muddling through and masking occurs.

Also the situation with NEETS isn’t simply the result of ‘labels’ being too readily adopted. It’s to a far far greater extent the result of structural changes to work and the economy, lack of opportunity etc. In fact, in the late 1970s and early 1980s there was also mass youth unemployment and a great deal of anxiety about a “lost generation” which led to the creation of new training schemes.

CentralStati0n · Yesterday 20:17

dontcookwontcook · Yesterday 20:09

i apologise I read dyslexia and dyspraxia when she wrote dyspraxia diagnosis

(I actually have dyslexia and dyspraxia)

and well… OT for dyspraxia? I mean, really?

You really do need to educate yourself

Children have occupational therapy OT to build practical movement skills, adapt daily tasks, and gain independence at home and school. Dyspraxia affects how the brain plans and coordinates movements, making everyday actions harder even when a child understands what to do. OT helps with fine and gross motor skills. Therapists practice hand control for writing, cutting, and buttoning clothes, alongside whole-body balance, running, and ball skills. OTs breaks down routines like dressing, tying shoelaces, using cutlery, and brushing teeth into manageable steps. Therapists suggest practical supports—such as pencil grips, adapted seating, or task strategies—to help with classroom work and PE. Many children with dyspraxia experience sensory differences or trouble sequencing steps, so OT helps them regulate responses and plan actions. It helps build confidence and emotional wellbeing as succeeding at daily tasks reduces frustration and builds self-esteem.

Her paediatrician said she needed OT!

VioletsTale · Yesterday 20:17

choccytime · Yesterday 20:02

Am absolutely gobsmacked by some of these posts , how did we grow up ,(me in the 70;s ) without all these labels not one child in my primary or grammar school had anything like this . Is this why weve got the NEETS situation now

Did they have allergies, asthma , eczema, diabetes etc.? Because no one I went to school ever did. They must’ve not existed then. Just… poof!

PottyBreak · Yesterday 20:17

Sunshineheres · Yesterday 16:22

Yes. There's also a subset of white Britosh parents who will move heaven and earth to get a diagnosis. I've never met a child (or adult) who went for a private ADHD assessment and didn't get the diagnosis they sought.

Can you think of a reason why this might be the case?

I have no skin in the game but think about who might put themselves forward for a diagnosis, and why? And who would never dream of doing so, and why?

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 20:17

choccytime · Yesterday 20:02

Am absolutely gobsmacked by some of these posts , how did we grow up ,(me in the 70;s ) without all these labels not one child in my primary or grammar school had anything like this . Is this why weve got the NEETS situation now

In my primary class in the 1970s there was a boy with autism, his parents didn’t want him to go to special school which was unusual at the time.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 20:19

CrispySquid · Yesterday 19:55

Also, Indian, Chinese and Japanese children are very different academically and culturally to children from Pakistan, Bangladesh, Philippines, Vietnam etc. Parenting, culture, values, attitudes around education and child development are sometimes diametrically opposite. You have to be very careful about using Asian as an umbrella term for cultures that are as different from each other as night is from day. The former ethnicities (Chinese, Indian, Japanese) have the lowest rates of SEND, the lowest rates of behavioural problems/exclusions and the highest academic and life outcomes (and earnings) compared to other groups (including native brits) by an obscenely wide margin. Other Asian cultures not at all and are in-line with White Brit diagnosis and exclusion and academic rates or faring even worse. Many Pakistani children have SEND for example due to being the product of close family/cousin relationships that isn’t the norm in other Asian ethnicities.

Likewise, Black cultures are all very different. There is a big difference in the academic outcomes and rate of SEND diagnosis between Afro-Caribbean children for example and Nigerian children, the latter of which are doing rather well at school.

Edited

I think Vietnamese and Filipino families tend to value education too. Vietnam is also a Confucian-influenced culture like China & Japan.

Agree re differences between groups generally, though.

From your posts it seems you think parenting can influence whether a child has SEN or not? Or have I misunderstood? I don't think that- what I do think is that it can influence how it presents.

It's worth noting cultures like Japan, Korea & China have strong norms towards group harmony which would give an additional incentive to mask.

OP posts:
Jane3212 · Yesterday 20:20

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 20:17

In my primary class in the 1970s there was a boy with autism, his parents didn’t want him to go to special school which was unusual at the time.

Exactly, there may have been less diagnosed then but it's also unsurprising people remember fewer at school if they were generally not in mainstream.

OP posts:
VioletsTale · Yesterday 20:21

MeshMesh · Yesterday 20:16

Rather uninformed post.

In the 1970s there were plenty of SEND kids whose issues went undiagnosed and unsupported. As a result they were left at higher risk of exclusion from school, achieving no qualifications, developing addiction issues, resorting to criminality and so on.

The other thing to understand is that in the 1970s it was in some ways easier to forge a path through the teenage years and into adulthood without requiring support. Someone could leave school at 16 with few qualifications and pick up labouring work, factory work, or possibly an apprenticeship. Rent was more affordable. Less focus on office work. Less requirement to attend college or uni. We also now have less flexible, more exam focussed (vs the 1990), more measured schooling regime which exposes the issues for some kids who previously would have drifted through the system.

There are almost certainly just as many SEND kids in Black and Asian families. It’s unlikely ‘resilience’ and ‘aspiration’ help these kids overcome these issues per se, although one can see why people like to use this explanation. What’s far more likely is that shame and use of community/religious/family support mean fewer diagnoses are made and more muddling through and masking occurs.

Also the situation with NEETS isn’t simply the result of ‘labels’ being too readily adopted. It’s to a far far greater extent the result of structural changes to work and the economy, lack of opportunity etc. In fact, in the late 1970s and early 1980s there was also mass youth unemployment and a great deal of anxiety about a “lost generation” which led to the creation of new training schemes.

Edited

In 1970 children stopped being labelled as “uneducable “ and actually allowed to attend school. Until then they were under the remit of the health board. Let’s be honest, that change didn’t instantly happen that year did it? It took years to enroll them and integrate them in schools, most of them in special schools anyway.But you know, they didn’t exist because PP didn’t see them.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 20:21

Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 20:10

If I hear about a child experiencing burnout one more time, I'll scream out loud!

FFS, life is exhausting! A child that goes to bed having experienced no anxiety, no emotional challenge, no need to think and adapt their behaviour is a a child who is not exposed to normal life and/or given the chance to learn social standing.

I don't think autistic or ADHD burnout is simply anxiety/emotional challenge.

OP posts:
PottingCompost · Yesterday 20:21

dontcookwontcook · Yesterday 20:09

i apologise I read dyslexia and dyspraxia when she wrote dyspraxia diagnosis

(I actually have dyslexia and dyspraxia)

and well… OT for dyspraxia? I mean, really?

Dyspraxia, like many other neurological conditions, is a spectrum. At the most severe levels, we're talking difficulty with coordination that impairs everyday living, like going up stairs (gross motor coordination) or getting dressed in anything that has zips or buttons (fine motor coordination). Imagine being 13 years old and not being able to button up a school shirt without someone else doing it for you.

NotMrsTumble · Yesterday 20:21

choccytime · Yesterday 20:02

Am absolutely gobsmacked by some of these posts , how did we grow up ,(me in the 70;s ) without all these labels not one child in my primary or grammar school had anything like this . Is this why weve got the NEETS situation now

Neither of my two adult ND children are NEETS. Both have jobs in fields that interest them and pay their own way. One has a masters degree. Both partly attribute this to the fact that diagnosis helped them understand their strengths and weaknesses.
There are some people who are ND who will struggle to navigate adult life regardless of accommodations, and there are many more who can use the diagnosis to help work out what they are and aren't capable of in an ND world. In the same vein that there are some people with physical disabilities or mental health difficulties that may restrict what they can achieve, the key is understanding what the limitations might be, what accommodations might help and might be realistic.

ByKindOpalPoet · Yesterday 20:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

SorrelSeaglass · Yesterday 20:22

choccytime · Yesterday 20:02

Am absolutely gobsmacked by some of these posts , how did we grow up ,(me in the 70;s ) without all these labels not one child in my primary or grammar school had anything like this . Is this why weve got the NEETS situation now

During the 1980s Britain had serious youth unemployment, we just didn’t call it NEET.