Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why Black and Asian children have not experienced the same rise in SN diagnoses?

537 replies

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:14

I’ve been reading a bit about the rise in SEN and neurodevelopmental diagnoses (autism, ADHD, etc.) in the UK lately, and it got me wondering whether the increase is happening evenly across Black and Asian children compared to White British children.
From looking at DfE stats and UK research (like the Born in Bradford studies and Children’s Commissioner reports), it seems like the picture is actually really uneven:
Asian / South Asian children still have much lower diagnosis rates overall and a noticeably slower rise in diagnoses compared to White British kids.
Black children have higher rates of school-based SEN support in certain categories (especially SEMH – Social, Emotional and Mental Health), yet are actually under-represented in clinical ADHD diagnoses. There’s research showing Black boys in particular are more likely to have sensory overload, distress, or rigid thinking treated as defiance or a behavioural/SEMH issue rather than being referred for an autism or ADHD assessments.
Thoughts on why these might be?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Jane3212 · Yesterday 20:36

Happyindevon · Yesterday 19:16

White culture is awful for health and the family unit 🤷‍♀️

Ofc white British culture has bad points (ther ar many white cultures, just like other types).

But that doesn't warrant such a sweeping and frankly offensive statement.

Are you white?

OP posts:
NotMrsTumble · Yesterday 20:37

VioletsTale · Yesterday 20:26

Well, in my case , DD has been on the waiting list for a year and a half. She is 15, and once she reaches 16 , if she’s still not seen, she will have to start all over again under adult services. The clock is literally ticking, so I am looking to have her privately seen.

This is why we ended up going private for DC2. They were booted off the child list, and on their way to further education. That diagnosis was later confirmed by adult services, when they finally reviewed them with a view to the NHS taking over their care.
It was an expensive, exhausting process that didn't end with diagnosis, and further time and financial input was required until the NHS were able to take over. From our viewpoint, the difference between embarking on further education without a diagnosis and being unsupported and starting a course with a plan and support in place was worth every penny. But again, very aware of how privileged we were to be able to go down this route.

MerchistonTrouble · Yesterday 20:37

I work in education and in general the black African and East Asian families are extraordinarily resistant to any form of formal diagnosis. The level of need that is being funded without an ECHP or any form of diagnosis in mainstream schools would blow a lot of minds.

Happyindevon · Yesterday 20:39

Jane3212 · Yesterday 20:36

Ofc white British culture has bad points (ther ar many white cultures, just like other types).

But that doesn't warrant such a sweeping and frankly offensive statement.

Are you white?

Yes I am.

CrispySquid · Yesterday 20:39

Jane3212 · Yesterday 20:19

I think Vietnamese and Filipino families tend to value education too. Vietnam is also a Confucian-influenced culture like China & Japan.

Agree re differences between groups generally, though.

From your posts it seems you think parenting can influence whether a child has SEN or not? Or have I misunderstood? I don't think that- what I do think is that it can influence how it presents.

It's worth noting cultures like Japan, Korea & China have strong norms towards group harmony which would give an additional incentive to mask.

Apologies, my post wasn’t the clearest. I don’t think it’s the case that they think their parenting can influence whether a child has SEN or not or even that it influences how it presents but rather more radically, I don’t think a lot of individuals from these cultures think SEN even exists in the first place. My Indian parents who immigrated here in the 1970s certainly wouldn’t have. Any impairment or lack of attainment in learning in a child would be seen to be the result of lack of discipline, lack of contentiousness of the child, lack of resilience or a lack of proper early socialisation. They would never have believed or still don’t believe it is a partly genetic or biological condition, outside all but the most severe cases.

Furthermore, most of the Chinese and Indian second and third generation children who are in schools now will be the children or grandchildren of high-achieving, aspirational parents who came over decades ago in the early immigration waves. Skilled, middle-class, highly-qualified and successful business-wise. Both intelligence and learning needs have a big genetic heritability component. Most of these parents would not have had SEND so their children and grandchildren don’t have it either. It’s a big selection bias as the successful immigrants selected for had traits that would be uncommon in neurodiverse people hence very little neurodiversity passed down so you don’t see it in the population of Indian and Chinese children so much. I’m sure there are many Indian and Chinese people with learning and emotional needs back in India and China but they weren’t the kind of immigrants coming over in the first waves. It’s this selection effect that plays a big part (amongst several other things) I think!

Sartre · Yesterday 20:39

I genuinely think we are over diagnosing kids. When my brother was small in the early 00s his nursery teacher wanted to label him ADHD because he was full to the brim with energy and wouldn’t stop. My mum took him to the GP who basically laughed her out of the room and said he was a typical 3 year old boy. I can confirm he did eventually calm down and he most definitely doesn’t have ADHD. Nowadays I’m certain they’d have diagnosed him.

Some white parents are desperate for diagnosis, I wonder if it makes them feel special in some way or gives them an excuse for their children’s shit behaviour.

I liked this SubwayTakes https://youtube.com/shorts/oiIeT-7P5v8?si=ZRn4mda8a40r-Igk

Before you continue to YouTube

https://youtube.com/shorts/oiIeT-7P5v8?si=ZRn4mda8a40r-Igk

ifonlytheydlisten · Yesterday 20:39

Money and culture re diagnosis as not being ‘normal’

Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 20:40

I'm not fully convinced this way was wholly better. If you read the long running threads about women married to autistic men, the lack of diagnosis seems to have impacted the men's personal lives a lot (if not their work lives)
MN women moaning about husbands who they diagnose themselves! Yes, that's very reliable information 😁

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Yesterday 20:40

Happyindevon · Yesterday 20:39

Yes I am.

Doesn’t make your comment any less disgusting. Despite the fact there’s no such thing as ‘white culture’.

Cyclebabble · Yesterday 20:40

I am.ethnically Indian. In my experience Imdian families will look for SEN support but there would be pressure from family to try other options first. More discipline is likely to be a starting point, but also borrowing from family to fund private educational support ( which may in reality be SEND type support but not labelled as such). In very extreme cases I have seen children sent abroad for their schooling.

So.in reality the reluctance to look for SEND support means that overall we would see something of a degree of under reporting.

CentralStati0n · Yesterday 20:42

Sartre · Yesterday 20:39

I genuinely think we are over diagnosing kids. When my brother was small in the early 00s his nursery teacher wanted to label him ADHD because he was full to the brim with energy and wouldn’t stop. My mum took him to the GP who basically laughed her out of the room and said he was a typical 3 year old boy. I can confirm he did eventually calm down and he most definitely doesn’t have ADHD. Nowadays I’m certain they’d have diagnosed him.

Some white parents are desperate for diagnosis, I wonder if it makes them feel special in some way or gives them an excuse for their children’s shit behaviour.

I liked this SubwayTakes https://youtube.com/shorts/oiIeT-7P5v8?si=ZRn4mda8a40r-Igk

Autism and adhd have been underdiagnosed for years in the uk particularly for women, girls and people of colour. We are now better informed. It has been clarified that there is no evidence for overdiagnosis claims.

MidnightMusing5 · Yesterday 20:42

redbullsurvivor · Yesterday 16:16

I would say culturally there is still shame and non belief in this type of SEN. So Asian families will either deny and move forward and survive without a diagnosis.

I think that also mixes with White British having a tendency to over diagnose and want there to be a label / excuse for everything.

Came here to say exactly this. I work in schools.

MeshMesh · Yesterday 20:44

Passaggressfedup · Yesterday 20:24

In the 1970s there were plenty of SEND kids whose issues went undiagnosed and unsupported. As a result they were left at higher risk of exclusion from school, achieving no qualifications, developing addiction issues, resorting to criminality and so on
No, as a result, the majority learn to adapt, cope and become more resilient. There were fewer exclusions, fewer qualifications but much higher employability. No NEETs or very few.

So it worked much better.

You need to go back and read the rest of my post again.

If we simply turned the clock back in terms of recognising SEND conditions, as you seem to suggesting, we’d have an even bigger problem on our hands.

Compared to the 1970s the nature of education and work have fundamentally changed. Now, you might ask why can’t we change these things? Perhaps we should over the long term, but it’s not going to happen anytime soon so we need to help kids thrive in the world as it is right now.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 20:45

Happyindevon · Yesterday 20:39

Yes I am.

So do you believe that about you own culture, then?

OP posts:
TheCappyEffect · Yesterday 20:46

The same reason why you don’t see many black and Asian people in care homes. The families’s manage it themselves.

Happyindevon · Yesterday 20:47

Jane3212 · Yesterday 20:45

So do you believe that about you own culture, then?

Yes I do.

I’m not saying it doesn’t have its good points. But the rampant individualism, drugs, alcohol, vaping, and helpless permissive parenting aren’t some of them.

chirrupybird · Yesterday 20:49

If this is true it may be that it's not so acceptable and they think minor problems will work out OK which they often do. Some parents actually push for some sort of diagnosis when their children do not have a serious problem to get extra help at school. It seems really unlikely that serious learning difficulties have really gone up so much recently. Although I know many disabled children never got into main stream school in the past.

NightHeron · Yesterday 20:49

seanconneryseyebrow · Yesterday 20:30

Yes I know. Thats my point. They are done very poorly because they are paid so little and barely cover the costs. Therefore the NHS assessments are far inferior to the private ones. We dont want NHS contracts for this reason. We want to do the assessments properly.

We had an independent assessment done on DD1 by an NHS consultant child psychiatrist, who was used by lawyers as an expert witness, and his report was 25 pages long. I had to fill in questionnaires before we went, and the appointment was several hours long. He clearly did read research papers on an aspect of DD1’s physical health, because he discussed them towards the end of his report.
IIRC, it was £2,500 fourteen years ago.

It was one of the best reports I’d read on DD1, and we’d appealed three times already to the SEND tribunal with independent reports by the Golden Circle educational psychologists, speech and language therapists and occupational therapists, my solicitor used. (In those days £1,500 - 2,500 each; nowadays £3,000)

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Yesterday 20:50

Happyindevon · Yesterday 20:47

Yes I do.

I’m not saying it doesn’t have its good points. But the rampant individualism, drugs, alcohol, vaping, and helpless permissive parenting aren’t some of them.

There’s no such thing as white culture. There’s English culture or white English culture but white people are all over the globe with varying cultures.

choccytime · Yesterday 20:51

Sartre · Yesterday 20:39

I genuinely think we are over diagnosing kids. When my brother was small in the early 00s his nursery teacher wanted to label him ADHD because he was full to the brim with energy and wouldn’t stop. My mum took him to the GP who basically laughed her out of the room and said he was a typical 3 year old boy. I can confirm he did eventually calm down and he most definitely doesn’t have ADHD. Nowadays I’m certain they’d have diagnosed him.

Some white parents are desperate for diagnosis, I wonder if it makes them feel special in some way or gives them an excuse for their children’s shit behaviour.

I liked this SubwayTakes https://youtube.com/shorts/oiIeT-7P5v8?si=ZRn4mda8a40r-Igk

Spot on

MeshMesh · Yesterday 20:51

Happyindevon · Yesterday 20:47

Yes I do.

I’m not saying it doesn’t have its good points. But the rampant individualism, drugs, alcohol, vaping, and helpless permissive parenting aren’t some of them.

In my neighbourhood all these things are engaged in by teenagers irrespective of their ethnic background, and we have pretty much all of them.

MeshMesh · Yesterday 20:52

choccytime · Yesterday 20:51

Spot on

Spot on in what sense? Because it certainly isn’t a compelling argument based on any meaningful research.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 20:53

Happyindevon · Yesterday 20:47

Yes I do.

I’m not saying it doesn’t have its good points. But the rampant individualism, drugs, alcohol, vaping, and helpless permissive parenting aren’t some of them.

'drugs, alcohol, vaping,'

  • well, that's not representative of a lot of white people. Otoh I agree these are issues in Britain generally but not only among white people.
OP posts:
VioletsTale · Yesterday 20:53

chirrupybird · Yesterday 20:49

If this is true it may be that it's not so acceptable and they think minor problems will work out OK which they often do. Some parents actually push for some sort of diagnosis when their children do not have a serious problem to get extra help at school. It seems really unlikely that serious learning difficulties have really gone up so much recently. Although I know many disabled children never got into main stream school in the past.

It really , really isn’t that unlikely if you consider genetics(in all the various forms ) and medical advancements at the very least.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 20:55

TheCappyEffect · Yesterday 20:46

The same reason why you don’t see many black and Asian people in care homes. The families’s manage it themselves.

Or rather, the women in the family have to manage it themselves...

I care for an elderly relative myself but she is luckily mentally healthy. I think it's good to do so if possible but we shouldn't underestimate the stress it can cause women (usually women) especially if it's culturally expected.

OP posts: