Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why Black and Asian children have not experienced the same rise in SN diagnoses?

536 replies

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:14

I’ve been reading a bit about the rise in SEN and neurodevelopmental diagnoses (autism, ADHD, etc.) in the UK lately, and it got me wondering whether the increase is happening evenly across Black and Asian children compared to White British children.
From looking at DfE stats and UK research (like the Born in Bradford studies and Children’s Commissioner reports), it seems like the picture is actually really uneven:
Asian / South Asian children still have much lower diagnosis rates overall and a noticeably slower rise in diagnoses compared to White British kids.
Black children have higher rates of school-based SEN support in certain categories (especially SEMH – Social, Emotional and Mental Health), yet are actually under-represented in clinical ADHD diagnoses. There’s research showing Black boys in particular are more likely to have sensory overload, distress, or rigid thinking treated as defiance or a behavioural/SEMH issue rather than being referred for an autism or ADHD assessments.
Thoughts on why these might be?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
queenofthewild · Yesterday 19:39

Happyindevon · Yesterday 19:19

What conditions do they have, broadly speaking?

Developmental delays, likely profound autism (though not always diagnosed because of waiting lists), usually pre verbal, lack of eye contact, usually requiring 1 to 1 support.

YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 19:40

Happyindevon · Yesterday 19:27

Ffs did I even remotely say that

Honestly this place

No you said white culture is awful for health and family culture.

Cherrysoup · Yesterday 19:41

redbullsurvivor · Yesterday 16:16

I would say culturally there is still shame and non belief in this type of SEN. So Asian families will either deny and move forward and survive without a diagnosis.

I think that also mixes with White British having a tendency to over diagnose and want there to be a label / excuse for everything.

I absolutely agree. As a teacher l I’ve referred students to the SEND department and had them come to tell me that this particular child has been referred by multiple teachers but his parents refused to accept that there were any issues when it’s really obvious eg a processing issue/emotional/social issues etc. This year it was South Asian boys. Formerly, black boys. I wouldn’t say it’s exclusive to boys, but they are in a certain hierarchy within the family. There is less resistance with girls ime.

Dutch1e · Yesterday 19:42

OutsideLookingOut · Yesterday 17:00

Many reasons but one I will give is that we may not present the same (like not as many girls were not diagnosed in the past).

I wondered about this too. Diagnoses like this surely have some element of cultural bias on the part of the diagnosers(s)?

Perhaps in the same way that white and white-raised doctors need additional training to recognise skin-based symptoms on black skin, like bruising or rashes, when diagnosing physical illnesses?

CrispySquid · Yesterday 19:43

friedaklein · Yesterday 16:17

As a S Asian I have many thoughts on this, but MN is absolutely the wrong place to share them.

Completely agree. Also being Indian myself, I know exactly why the rates are higher in white children/white cultures instead of Asian cultures. Almost anyone from these cultures could tell you why in a heartbeat but I’m not going to touch this one with a bargepole on Mumsnet. Stigma is one but not even the top 5 biggest reasons I don’t think. I don’t think people are truly ready to have a really raw, introspective, honest debate about this in good faith.

I also think the first reply to the OP nails it as usual.

Thistoo2023 · Yesterday 19:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Do you mean coping with? 🙄

CentralStati0n · Yesterday 19:45

JulietteRoche · Yesterday 19:36

What's the point of having these diagnoses? After a time you just have to get on with it. Honestly, I get confused with all the new nomenclature and all the special accommodations people require. What's the point of having an alphabet's worth of diagnoses?

You’re making yourself look quite ignorant and silly.

She needed her dyspraxia diagnosis to access occupational therapy, her hypermobility and physical condition to access physio, her severe sensory processing to access OT, her ADHD to access medication and psychotherapy that helps manage it, her autism diagnosis so she could have her treatment for severe mental illness and medication adjusted for autism and to enable her to go on the dynamic support register to keep her out of inpatient, her CPTSD diagnosis to inform her therapist and psychiatrist for treatment …

Happyindevon · Yesterday 19:45

YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 19:40

No you said white culture is awful for health and family culture.

It is! That doesn’t mean my ideal is a culture where the women get beaten. But this is MN so the hysteria and massive leaps will continue

Happyindevon · Yesterday 19:46

CentralStati0n · Yesterday 19:45

You’re making yourself look quite ignorant and silly.

She needed her dyspraxia diagnosis to access occupational therapy, her hypermobility and physical condition to access physio, her severe sensory processing to access OT, her ADHD to access medication and psychotherapy that helps manage it, her autism diagnosis so she could have her treatment for severe mental illness and medication adjusted for autism and to enable her to go on the dynamic support register to keep her out of inpatient, her CPTSD diagnosis to inform her therapist and psychiatrist for treatment …

…right.

PTSD from what??

JulietteRoche · Yesterday 19:47

CentralStati0n · Yesterday 19:45

You’re making yourself look quite ignorant and silly.

She needed her dyspraxia diagnosis to access occupational therapy, her hypermobility and physical condition to access physio, her severe sensory processing to access OT, her ADHD to access medication and psychotherapy that helps manage it, her autism diagnosis so she could have her treatment for severe mental illness and medication adjusted for autism and to enable her to go on the dynamic support register to keep her out of inpatient, her CPTSD diagnosis to inform her therapist and psychiatrist for treatment …

Good lord. Is this a joke!?

Itsthewoluff · Yesterday 19:47

The SN school I’ve had reason to be involved with, has a high proportion of Asian and black children compared to the general town population.

CentralStati0n · Yesterday 19:48

Happyindevon · Yesterday 19:46

…right.

PTSD from what??

I beg your parson

Happyindevon · Yesterday 19:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

CentralStati0n · Yesterday 19:49

JulietteRoche · Yesterday 19:47

Good lord. Is this a joke!?

Young people managing multiple conditions like this is not a joke.

Happyindevon · Yesterday 19:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

tooloololoo · Yesterday 19:50

Yeh my ds has autism . Indian background
4.5 not talking yet

JulietteRoche · Yesterday 19:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Yellowbelliedsapsuckeristaken · Yesterday 19:53

Jane3212 · Yesterday 16:36

It's worth asking also if at least some may have less screen time. I don't think screens cause SN of course, but excess screen time from a younger age may make it more visible.

No.
It's worth informing yourself before making silly posts on Mumsnet. Unless you actually have some understanding of the communities you are talking about (which you do not), please dont make such statements. Or provide at least comprehensive data in terms of black and Asian children screen time and correlation with diagnosis. Nothing? Didnt think so.

Balloonhearts · Yesterday 19:54

Genetic maybe? Aren't there some drugs that work better for black people than white people? We're obviously not quite the same biologically, maybe there is a genetic component or predisposition.

CrispySquid · Yesterday 19:55

Also, Indian, Chinese and Japanese children are very different academically and culturally to children from Pakistan, Bangladesh, Philippines, Vietnam etc. Parenting, culture, values, attitudes around education and child development are sometimes diametrically opposite. You have to be very careful about using Asian as an umbrella term for cultures that are as different from each other as night is from day. The former ethnicities (Chinese, Indian, Japanese) have the lowest rates of SEND, the lowest rates of behavioural problems/exclusions and the highest academic and life outcomes (and earnings) compared to other groups (including native brits) by an obscenely wide margin. Other Asian cultures not at all and are in-line with White Brit diagnosis and exclusion and academic rates or faring even worse. Many Pakistani children have SEND for example due to being the product of close family/cousin relationships that isn’t the norm in other Asian ethnicities.

Likewise, Black cultures are all very different. There is a big difference in the academic outcomes and rate of SEND diagnosis between Afro-Caribbean children for example and Nigerian children, the latter of which are doing rather well at school.

Happyindevon · Yesterday 19:56

Yellowbelliedsapsuckeristaken · Yesterday 19:53

No.
It's worth informing yourself before making silly posts on Mumsnet. Unless you actually have some understanding of the communities you are talking about (which you do not), please dont make such statements. Or provide at least comprehensive data in terms of black and Asian children screen time and correlation with diagnosis. Nothing? Didnt think so.

This is such a Mumsnet response to a casual comment

dontcookwontcook · Yesterday 19:58

CentralStati0n · Yesterday 19:45

You’re making yourself look quite ignorant and silly.

She needed her dyspraxia diagnosis to access occupational therapy, her hypermobility and physical condition to access physio, her severe sensory processing to access OT, her ADHD to access medication and psychotherapy that helps manage it, her autism diagnosis so she could have her treatment for severe mental illness and medication adjusted for autism and to enable her to go on the dynamic support register to keep her out of inpatient, her CPTSD diagnosis to inform her therapist and psychiatrist for treatment …

You sent your kid to OT for dyslexia and dyspraxia? Ok.

CentralStati0n · Yesterday 20:00

dontcookwontcook · Yesterday 19:58

You sent your kid to OT for dyslexia and dyspraxia? Ok.

No her paediatrician did because it is severe, she couldn’t hold a knife and fork and struggled to do many things.

LiteraryBambi · Yesterday 20:00

MeshMesh · Yesterday 18:56

What is it poor Asian kids are doing at home rather than sitting around doing nothing?

We had to go to schools, college or work. School refusal would not be accepted.

Not saying there are not any Asian kids with SEND, of course there are. But there is generally less of a need to label it because families just crack on(when those needs are not acute).

PDAalltheway · Yesterday 20:01

MaltesersDeath · Yesterday 16:42

Good investment financially though if it leads on to DLA and carers allowance.

DLA is based on care needs, not diagnosis. So having an assessment done would noticed to DLA/carers.

IME parents don't fork out for private assessment unless they're pretty firmly convinced that the child will be given a diagnosis. Too expensive otherwise.

When it's a 4 year wait for a child neurodevelopmental assessment - and they will only look at one eg autism and then put you to the back of the queue for e.g. ADHD assessment, it's no surprise that parents go private.

@painswickthe very well-established provider who assessed my DC, and who were the NHS's chosen partner to deliver all the ND-related training for our area on behalf of CAMHS went bust not long ago because they just couldn't make enough money. So I'm not sure it's always as straightforward as that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread