Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed that MIL made herself a copy of our house key without asking us?

318 replies

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 00:02

I'm flabbergasted.

We gave a key to MIL as we needed some help with school collection and minding of our little boy this afternoon. She's had the key 3 days. When she was saying goodbye this evening, she casually mentioned she had made herself a copy of the key incase of any other instances like this.

To be clear, we don't rely on her for childcare. We have a childminder. This was a one off occasion that we actually didn't need her for but she volunteered to spend time with child. We have lived in this house for almost 8 years and this is the first time we have had to give her a key. And she goes and makes herself a copy.

I feel like this is a huge boundary overstep! I don't feel comfortable at all with her having a key to my house. And the cheek of making it without asking! In the moment I was so taken back that I didn't really say anything. But I'm considering having my DH talk to her about how inappropriate it was to do that and to ask for the key back.

OP posts:
SwingAndRelax · Yesterday 09:04

The number of people who can't differentiate between 'being given' and 'taking' is a bit worrying.

SwingAndRelax · Yesterday 09:05

she’s hardly gonna let herself in when you’re not there

Exactly, she'll be using the keys as decoration or to make a necklace out of.

Soontobe60 · Yesterday 09:06

SwingAndRelax · Yesterday 09:04

The number of people who can't differentiate between 'being given' and 'taking' is a bit worrying.

But she was given the key - she didn’t take it.

BeeDavis · Yesterday 09:06

Rumplestiltz · Yesterday 08:57

Well for us because we are always losing keys and never have enough.
i get the “sneakiness” point - but the reactions here are incredible and the fact that she didn’t have a spare key in the first place..it’s just all very sad.
many of us are probably mils in waiting to future dils and if the discussions on mumsnet are anything to go by it is not a role to look forward to.

Honestly my boys are 5 and 5 months.. i’m already dreading them bringing home someone like the DIL’s on MN. Would break my heart if I was treated like the way some of them on here treat their MIL. I wouldn’t dream of treating mine like that.

Thegirlwhowent · Yesterday 09:07

BeeDavis · Yesterday 09:03

Just me that wouldn’t give a shit about this? She probably thought she was doing you a favour, she’s hardly gonna let herself in when you’re not there and start running naked around your house ffs.

How do you know what MIL is likely to do?!

Rumplestiltz · Yesterday 09:07

SwingAndRelax · Yesterday 09:04

The number of people who can't differentiate between 'being given' and 'taking' is a bit worrying.

The number of people using language like “I would be completely violated by this” is extraordinary, completely over the top and a tragic insight into modern family life.

Pedant61 · Yesterday 09:07

It's unacceptable. If she won't return it, change the locks.

BeeDavis · Yesterday 09:08

SwingAndRelax · Yesterday 09:05

she’s hardly gonna let herself in when you’re not there

Exactly, she'll be using the keys as decoration or to make a necklace out of.

Yeah just casually miss out the next part of my post which said “and start running naked around your house”

🫪🫪

ThreadGuardDog · Yesterday 09:08

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I think it depends on the individual and the type of person they are. MiL only lived a short distance from us and asked us on several occasions for a key, to be able to ‘help out’, even offering to do housework while we’re at work. We fielded the offers successfully - was never going to happen because we both knew that she would absolutely snoop. Sad but true.

Janetwin · Yesterday 09:09

OneMoreProfiterole · Yesterday 03:20

To be clear, we don't rely on her for childcare. We have a childminder. This was a one off occasion that we actually didn't need her for but she volunteered to spend time with child.

Useful free childcare? Where does she say that?

The very first sentence of the post was “we needed some help with school collection and minding of our little boy this afternoon”. She contradicts this later.

Thegirlwhowent · Yesterday 09:09

Soontobe60 · Yesterday 09:06

But she was given the key - she didn’t take it.

She wasn't given the key to keep - she took a copy and took advantage.

StoatMilk · Yesterday 09:09

whistlesandbells · Yesterday 01:23

YANBU, I would feel completely violated by this.

I would expect my DH to get the key back and say why it was not acceptable. It would also be the last visit for MIL in my home alone.

‘Completely violated’ crikey 🙄

ThreadGuardDog · Yesterday 09:12

Janetwin · Yesterday 09:09

The very first sentence of the post was “we needed some help with school collection and minding of our little boy this afternoon”. She contradicts this later.

It was a one off, and she wasn’t asked, but volunteered. It doesn’t make what she did any more acceptable.

Blogswife · Yesterday 09:13

My family member did this and used to enter the house when I wasn’t there . I only found out when I came home early one day and caught them !
I removed the key from them immediately. They keep suggesting that they should hold a key to my new house and I’ve told them in no uncertain terms that’s never going to happen !

Neuronimo · Yesterday 09:14

Are you going to explain that you are uncomfortable and ask for the key back OP? I'd have hated this.

Janetwin · Yesterday 09:16

Oz8788 · Yesterday 05:00

These replies are so OTT .The fact that she offered the information that she had a key cut really doesn't suggest that she is going to be sneaking into the house to have a good old nose around! She was probably just trying to use her initiative.

OTT is an understatement… there must be some awful MILs out there… change the locks, demand the keys back, instal a camera, no more unsupervised visits, careful she doesn’t make an impression in her make up compact of your key and use that to make another copy!!! Who are these psychopathic MILs?! Such a pity they can’t trust them as it must be handy to have someone that can “help with school collection and minding of our little boy this afternoon when needed”.

Lookingforwardtospringnextyear · Yesterday 09:18

Franjipanl8r · Yesterday 03:30

This personally wouldn’t bother me at all, but I trust my MIL not to rock up uninvited and she lives an hour away. I’ve got keys to my parents house, I don’t use them to let myself in and invade their privacy, they’re just for emergencies.

Fair enough if it wouldn't bother you. But that is irrelevant, as us your relationship with your MiL..It bothers OP. Firstly because of the sheer cheek and breach of trust to go off and do this without any discussion. And secondly becaus OP m, quite rightly, values her privacy.
Do you really think if her MiL has absolutely no problem with unilaterally getting a key cut to a house that isn't hers she is going to have any respect for OP and her family's privacy?

Friendlygingercat · Yesterday 09:20

I have always been very secretive with keys. The only person who has keys to my house is my nephew who lives a short walk away.

Even when I rented the LL did not have keys because I changed all the locks once I moved in.

ThreadGuardDog · Yesterday 09:21

Seeingadistance · Yesterday 08:52

If you'd be thrilled that your MIL had a key for your house, would you not just give her a key? Why would you wait in the hope that she'd take the rare opportunity of having a key for a specific reason and then get a spare cut without asking?

Why do so many people not understand that it's the sneakiness of it that's the problem? And that someone who gets a key cut in this way is very likely to use it to pry.

Absolutely this. She wasn’t given the key and knew she had to return it, so she was presenting OP with a fait accompli instead of asking first - presumably because she knew the answer would be no. You do have to ask yourself what she wanted the key for.

justasking111 · Yesterday 09:25

We have keys to two DC's homes for emergency because they have pets. If they go out for the day DH or I go there to feed and let the pets out and in again. It's peace of mind for them.

But to get a key cut ourselves is something we just wouldn't do.

StencilCupChair · Yesterday 09:26

Change the locks to these, https://www.abs-secure.co.uk/products/abs-ultimate-keys

You can then give that key to anyone who needs it but it can never be copied without the master code that comes on a plastic credit card. Just make sure they can never gain access to the master code. We have these locks in all our doors.

You can have one key for all your door locks or different ones. We went with different ones. We also had to give a spare key to someone for a short while and this gave us the security that they could never copy it.

ABS Ultimate Keys

Need ABS Ultimate Keys and Cylinders? Our network of approved specialists can cut your keys while you wait. Find a Key Centre >

https://www.abs-secure.co.uk/products/abs-ultimate-keys

DiscoCherries · Yesterday 09:29

Definitely not okay @TiredAF123 has DH spoken to her about it yet?

My in laws used to have keys and we had to take them back. One occasion I came home from shopping, and heard noises upstairs - then heard someone running down the stairs; I’ve never been so frightened - was my sodding FIL. ‘Oh I was in the area and thought I’d fix that broken hinge’ but hadn’t text or called to say so and just let himself in and got on with it.

A few months later I’m in the bath on my day off, and hear the key in the lock (doorbell didn’t even go!) and it was MIL letting herself in. She’d been at a friends nearby and thought she’d pop round. Zero comms to check first.

DH took them both back!!

TenderChicken · Yesterday 09:29

Ah, my mother did this. She collects the children from school a couple times a week (like you, this is to include her, not because we actually need childcare). We did give her a key to keep.

I learned she had made a copy when I lost my housekey and she volunteered a spare! She'd actually made it for my dad, who lives abroad but when he's here collects the children with her. He's only collected them once by himself. But hey, despite living abroad and never collecting the children, she felt he needed his own key to our house...

I let it go because I know she would absolutely make herself the aggreived party, and neither of them enter our house when not doing childcare, so it wasn't causing a problem per se (though it certainly felt like a violation).

Wavebreaker8 · Yesterday 09:31

ThreadGuardDog · Yesterday 09:21

Absolutely this. She wasn’t given the key and knew she had to return it, so she was presenting OP with a fait accompli instead of asking first - presumably because she knew the answer would be no. You do have to ask yourself what she wanted the key for.

I don't know the OP's MIL nor do I know the family dynamics so it is impossible to say what the intentions truly were behind MIL cutting a key. However if my MIL, " casually mentioned she had made herself a copy of the key incase of any other instances like this..."
then I would have believed her. Having a key to let herself and my child into the house after collecting him from school without having to go to the hassle of arranging to collect the key beforehand does make sense to me but then my MIL is lovely.
I just cannot believe that her intentions were bad if she told the OP about the key. I think she is just not great at recognising boundaries. People like this usually aren't if it is something that wouldn't bother them personally if it happened to them.

AlwaysExtraHot · Yesterday 09:31

Unacceptable. Your DH – not you! – needs to get the key back off her and make clear that this is not OK.