Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed that MIL made herself a copy of our house key without asking us?

318 replies

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 00:02

I'm flabbergasted.

We gave a key to MIL as we needed some help with school collection and minding of our little boy this afternoon. She's had the key 3 days. When she was saying goodbye this evening, she casually mentioned she had made herself a copy of the key incase of any other instances like this.

To be clear, we don't rely on her for childcare. We have a childminder. This was a one off occasion that we actually didn't need her for but she volunteered to spend time with child. We have lived in this house for almost 8 years and this is the first time we have had to give her a key. And she goes and makes herself a copy.

I feel like this is a huge boundary overstep! I don't feel comfortable at all with her having a key to my house. And the cheek of making it without asking! In the moment I was so taken back that I didn't really say anything. But I'm considering having my DH talk to her about how inappropriate it was to do that and to ask for the key back.

OP posts:
Lifelover16 · Yesterday 08:32

Topseyt123 · Yesterday 04:36

I'd be demanding that she hand the copy over to me.

It would be the last time she made an unsupervised visit to my house. Cheeky fucker!

Unless emergency childcare services are required of course.

WitchesBritches · Yesterday 08:32

RudePhthaloDalmadoodle · Yesterday 01:29

I'd be careful even if you get it back from her or change the locks; she'd only needs a minute alone with the key to make an impression in her makeup compact and get a new one cast in secret. However, I'd also suspect that if confronted she'll plead good intentions and pretend not to understand the issue: after all, she DID tell you she'd had it made!

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Ant1cs · Yesterday 08:33

I'd also change the locks. It's a really simple thing to do and can be framed as improving the security of your property.

You don't owe anyone an explanation or justification for doing so (not your MIL or anyone else on MN.)

Seeingadistance · Yesterday 08:36

Wreckinball · Yesterday 00:05

Don’t say anything but change the lock, expensive but gets round it. If she tries to come round when you’re out she’ll get a shock!

This is what I'd do.

Applewisp · Yesterday 08:38

Why wouldn’t you WANT her to have a key just in case of emergencies?

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 08:47

Momon45 · Yesterday 08:15

I'm a MIL , all my kids and partners have given me keys and I them . If it bothers you then change the locks but never ask her to do childcare for you . You can't have it both ways .

We didn't ask her. She volunteered to spend time with DS. We have a childminder.

OP posts:
Dreamingofsnowymornings · Yesterday 08:48

fivefoottwowitheyesofblue · Yesterday 08:03

Wow! That is not ok.
I need to know more!
Surely he knew you worked nights? How did he know you were in bed? He came in to your bedroom?? How did he respond when you took the key off him?

So this was 15 ish years ago. FIL was a very chauvinistic person. He was convinced that I led a life if idleness while DH worked because he had no concept that some people work nights . So weeks when I was on nightshift he assumed I wasnt working 🤷‍♀️.
He knew I was home because he saw my car as he was on his way to his friends house . He did often let himself in if we were out to use the loo as he had some medical issues - we were fine with that, he only ever used the spare downstairs loo in the garage.
When I was shaken awake half an hour after Id gone to bed I was firstly terrified then furious- he was angry that I was sleeping in so shouting on both sides. I rang DH and told him to come and sort his dad out, which he did.
The fall out lasted months. DMIL and DSMIL ( his second wife) were both adamant that he was a moron and had it coming - he dug his feet in and refused to apologise for about 4 months.
Eventually he did apologise but was never given a key again.

Pumpkinsaregrowingnicely · Yesterday 08:51

If its a upvc door the barrels are like 35 quid ..easy to replace...

squarecrow · Yesterday 08:52

Momon45 · Yesterday 08:15

I'm a MIL , all my kids and partners have given me keys and I them . If it bothers you then change the locks but never ask her to do childcare for you . You can't have it both ways .

You were given keys. And she did not ask MIL to do childcare.

Honestyatalltimes · Yesterday 08:52

My son & dil gave me a key for situations as your mil described or for emergencies & they have a copy of ours. I don't see the issue although I agree doing so without your permission is unusual.

Seeingadistance · Yesterday 08:52

Rumplestiltz · Yesterday 07:41

This is so weird and sad. If my mil cut a key for our house so she had another spare I would be thrilled.
and for those saying the point is that she cut it not that she had it, the question is why didn’t she have one in the first place?
the changing the locks and then hiding the key again in case she makes an imprint in her make up compact - I am assuming that was a joke and if so very funny! If not this thread is such a rich seam for a modern anthropologist of the break down of family life and the complete atomisation of households.

If you'd be thrilled that your MIL had a key for your house, would you not just give her a key? Why would you wait in the hope that she'd take the rare opportunity of having a key for a specific reason and then get a spare cut without asking?

Why do so many people not understand that it's the sneakiness of it that's the problem? And that someone who gets a key cut in this way is very likely to use it to pry.

Offleyhoo · Yesterday 08:54

I would imagine she thought it could be helpful but if there's a backstory and she's overstepped then just ask for it back.

Gentlydoesit2 · Yesterday 08:54

Not ok. Total overstep

Rumplestiltz · Yesterday 08:57

Seeingadistance · Yesterday 08:52

If you'd be thrilled that your MIL had a key for your house, would you not just give her a key? Why would you wait in the hope that she'd take the rare opportunity of having a key for a specific reason and then get a spare cut without asking?

Why do so many people not understand that it's the sneakiness of it that's the problem? And that someone who gets a key cut in this way is very likely to use it to pry.

Well for us because we are always losing keys and never have enough.
i get the “sneakiness” point - but the reactions here are incredible and the fact that she didn’t have a spare key in the first place..it’s just all very sad.
many of us are probably mils in waiting to future dils and if the discussions on mumsnet are anything to go by it is not a role to look forward to.

Soontobe60 · Yesterday 08:57

Boreded · Yesterday 00:30

You’re happy to trust her to look after your child but can’t trust her to have a key.

I find this bizarre, I have all my family’s keys…they have mine. That way in an emergency (like my neice being locked out of my FILs last week when she forgot her key and he wasn’t finished work) someone can pop down the road and let them in.

Same here! In fact this post has reminded me that I need to sort out all the keys to my DDs present and past houses - they’ve each lived in 4 different houses and both had new front doors to their current house. I’ve got a massive pile of the bastards that I have to go through every time I use them 🤣
My DDs both have keys to my house too even though they’ve never lived here.
There’s been many a time I’ve been to their houses when they’ve not been in - waiting in for the plumber, collecting a sick grandchild from school and taking them home, cleaning the house after the builders have been in, taking them home dog for a walk when the dog walker cries off…
I would never just go round without them knowing and they know this - they trust me.

Wavebreaker8 · Yesterday 08:57

Seeingadistance · Yesterday 08:52

If you'd be thrilled that your MIL had a key for your house, would you not just give her a key? Why would you wait in the hope that she'd take the rare opportunity of having a key for a specific reason and then get a spare cut without asking?

Why do so many people not understand that it's the sneakiness of it that's the problem? And that someone who gets a key cut in this way is very likely to use it to pry.

Surely if she was being "sneaky" and intending to use it to pry (which to be fair she could still do while looking after her grandchild) then I very much doubt that she'd have mentioned anything at all about having the key cut in the first place.

OnlyOneAdda · Yesterday 08:57

Mrsclaude · Yesterday 01:38

I’d just change the locks - having said that, I switched to digital locks on my front entrance that I could program various codes for. It meant Cleaner A has her own code that works at scheduled times, I can delete access if she moves on and I get a new cleaner without the hassle of getting new codes, it also records when and which code has opened the door. Eg. Mums code was used at 2:30pm to unlock door and door locked again at 2:36pm

My parents have free access to my house and me to theirs - there is no boundary issues though and it’s a respectful positive relationship. This isn’t something I’d be comfortable with for just anyone, including a MIL who took what wasn’t offered.

This sounds great! Would you mind sharing a link or spec please?

Comtesse · Yesterday 08:58

Rumplestiltz · Yesterday 07:41

This is so weird and sad. If my mil cut a key for our house so she had another spare I would be thrilled.
and for those saying the point is that she cut it not that she had it, the question is why didn’t she have one in the first place?
the changing the locks and then hiding the key again in case she makes an imprint in her make up compact - I am assuming that was a joke and if so very funny! If not this thread is such a rich seam for a modern anthropologist of the break down of family life and the complete atomisation of households.

It’s not about the atomisation of family life it’s about someone being dead cheeky. It’s bizarre to assume you can go round copying people’s house keys and that they should be delighted with such initiative.

ToddlerSleep · Yesterday 08:58

As soon as I saw this I knew there would be a pattern of overstepping boundaries!

YANBU, change the locks without telling her. You don’t know how many copies exist.

specialmintapplecranberrysauce · Yesterday 08:59

My mum had a spare key to my house but then she started letting herself in if she had popped round unannounced and I hadn't heard the door. Once I was in the garden and then saw someone moving around in my kitchen - it was my mum.

I really hate this kind of thing so I had to get my key back. She hasn't been given one since.

Soontobe60 · Yesterday 09:00

whistlesandbells · Yesterday 01:23

YANBU, I would feel completely violated by this.

I would expect my DH to get the key back and say why it was not acceptable. It would also be the last visit for MIL in my home alone.

Violated???

Fran2023 · Yesterday 09:01

Wrong.Wrong.Wrong.

We frequently look after our grandchild in his own home. I never take the house key out of the house unless I have asked beforehand!

And no that it is a type of violation. It is a huge breach of a boundary.

Soontobe60 · Yesterday 09:02

PoolDepth · Yesterday 06:25

My MIL had a key for our old door as she drives 3 hours to visit and on occasion we’d be delayed getting back from work to let her in. Then she started letting herself in when she arrived, even if we were in the house. Really pissed me off!!

We then got a new door after building work and I never gave her a new key. It’s a banham lock so can’t be copied except by them and with a PIN code. She sometimes has use of the spare key when needed whilst she’s staying with us, but thankfully can’t copy it!!

YANBU. It’s an invasion of privacy.

So she was given a key to let herself in when you weren’t there but wasn’t supposed to use it when you were - presumably if she was coming from 3 hours drive away, you knew she was coming and what time she’d be arriving? I couldn’t get worked up about this.

Thegirlwhowent · Yesterday 09:02

Rumplestiltz · Yesterday 07:41

This is so weird and sad. If my mil cut a key for our house so she had another spare I would be thrilled.
and for those saying the point is that she cut it not that she had it, the question is why didn’t she have one in the first place?
the changing the locks and then hiding the key again in case she makes an imprint in her make up compact - I am assuming that was a joke and if so very funny! If not this thread is such a rich seam for a modern anthropologist of the break down of family life and the complete atomisation of households.

For whatever reason, OP chose not to give a key to MIL 'in the first place'. It doesn't matter what that reason is - it's none of our business! OP has a right to control who has access to her own house. Your relationship with your MIL has no bearing on this situation.

BeeDavis · Yesterday 09:03

Just me that wouldn’t give a shit about this? She probably thought she was doing you a favour, she’s hardly gonna let herself in when you’re not there and start running naked around your house ffs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread