Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed that MIL made herself a copy of our house key without asking us?

318 replies

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 00:02

I'm flabbergasted.

We gave a key to MIL as we needed some help with school collection and minding of our little boy this afternoon. She's had the key 3 days. When she was saying goodbye this evening, she casually mentioned she had made herself a copy of the key incase of any other instances like this.

To be clear, we don't rely on her for childcare. We have a childminder. This was a one off occasion that we actually didn't need her for but she volunteered to spend time with child. We have lived in this house for almost 8 years and this is the first time we have had to give her a key. And she goes and makes herself a copy.

I feel like this is a huge boundary overstep! I don't feel comfortable at all with her having a key to my house. And the cheek of making it without asking! In the moment I was so taken back that I didn't really say anything. But I'm considering having my DH talk to her about how inappropriate it was to do that and to ask for the key back.

OP posts:
AbouttimeIhadanewusername · Yesterday 09:31

Momon45 · Yesterday 08:15

I'm a MIL , all my kids and partners have given me keys and I them . If it bothers you then change the locks but never ask her to do childcare for you . You can't have it both ways .

She should not have cut a key without asking.
I also have keys to our children’s homes but I have never used them without our children requesting us to do so.

SwingAndRelax · Yesterday 09:34

Rumplestiltz · Yesterday 09:07

The number of people using language like “I would be completely violated by this” is extraordinary, completely over the top and a tragic insight into modern family life.

That 'number' is one. One person has used that language. (I don't know what you consider to be "like" that).

I think it's massively over the top to say that's a tragic insight into modern family life due to one person saying it.

And none of that has anything to do with what I posted, so I don't know why you're quoting me!

squarecrow · Yesterday 09:34

Janetwin · Yesterday 09:09

The very first sentence of the post was “we needed some help with school collection and minding of our little boy this afternoon”. She contradicts this later.

She didn’t say they asked MiL to do it. They could have asked several other people, but MiL wanted to spend the time with the GC.

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 09:35

Thank you for all the comments! Some really balanced perspectives here. Some thoughts...

  1. It's almost definitely done with good intentions. But good intentions doesn't mean it's ok. She should have asked us first. It's our house and our key. Nobody else has copies of our keys.
  1. It's our choice not to give out keys to our house! I appreciate that lots of people here are happy for family members to have spare keys. That's your choice. Choice being the word there to focus on!
  1. Yes there is obviously a back story. There always is! She is a wonderful MIL. We get on very well. Never had an argument or disagreement. However, she often oversteps, can be quite the project manager, makes decisions without discussing them with us first in relation to our family and assumes we will go along with it. I don't want to go into the specifics on here. I usually speak to DH about it and if we deem it worth a discussion, he will talk to her about it. All of this past behaviour makes me think that now she has a key, she might let herself in for some reason, to do something she feels is helpful. But we don't want that. It makes me feel very uncomfortable.
  1. DH agrees that her intentions are mainly good, but that she can be overbearing and not consider our wishes at times. He is very good at discussing these things with her if necessary. They have a great relationship.
  1. I won't be changing the locks. That feels a bit much for me, but thanks to those who suggested it.
  1. I think DH will have a word. Let her know that it wasn't ok to do it without asking. Explain that nobody has keys to our house, we don't see the need. In 8 years we have never felt the need to have someone have a copy. If she offers to give it back, we will accept. If she doesn't offer, I'd probably just let her keep it to save the argument and awkwardness. But if she ever used it in a way that was inappropriate, we would ask for it back. We have cameras.
  1. Lastly, as I've already said, we don't rely on her for childcare. This was a one off where she wanted to spend time with our youngest boy. But for those suggesting that if we DID rely on her for childcare, that we should basically let her away with doing this, we can't have it both ways etc... I highly disagree! No matter what your arrangement, you should always feel safe to hold boundaries in your own home.
OP posts:
TiredAF123 · Yesterday 09:36

Applewisp · Yesterday 08:38

Why wouldn’t you WANT her to have a key just in case of emergencies?

Don't see the need. We both work remotely. One of us is almost always at home. If we leave the country, we leave a key with a trusted neighbour.

OP posts:
squarecrow · Yesterday 09:37

SwingAndRelax · Yesterday 09:34

That 'number' is one. One person has used that language. (I don't know what you consider to be "like" that).

I think it's massively over the top to say that's a tragic insight into modern family life due to one person saying it.

And none of that has anything to do with what I posted, so I don't know why you're quoting me!

Agreed. If “old fashioned family life” was having no boundaries from each other I’m quite glad to live in modern times where my parents can’t take things that don’t belong to them or make decisions about who gets a key to my house without asking.

Choccyp1g · Yesterday 09:39

I'd have held out my hand saying "thanks, that will come in handy".

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 09:42

Soontobe60 · Yesterday 09:06

But she was given the key - she didn’t take it.

She was given the key to use for one afternoon. She then went and made herself a copy of the key without asking us. She was never intended to keep the key or have a copy of the key forever.

I don't get what's so hard to understand about that point!

OP posts:
ShoveThatBallroomUpYourFatAss · Yesterday 09:42

If she doesn’t pay toward the mortgage, she doesn’t get a vote on who does/doesn’t get a key, emergencies or not. It is for the mortgage payers to decide the emergency setup.

Your DH needs to stand his ground, tell her that this is unacceptable, and take the key back. What a CF.

Janetwin · Yesterday 09:44

Friendlygingercat · Yesterday 09:20

I have always been very secretive with keys. The only person who has keys to my house is my nephew who lives a short walk away.

Even when I rented the LL did not have keys because I changed all the locks once I moved in.

Were you squatting?

coronafiona · Yesterday 09:44

I would actually have been glad about this. I don’t agree with her not asking your permission and I would address that with her, but emergencies do happen and it is sensible that someone can have access if needed.

Advocodo · Yesterday 09:44

You never know when there might be an emergency and a key is needed. Feel sure your MIL was just trying to be helpful and thinking ahead that you might need to use her. She was thinking she is probably saving you money by getting the key cut herself.

OVienna · Yesterday 09:46

Very individual thing.

I would absolutely have no issue with this if it were my parents or in-laws and would actually be grateful they thought to do without waiting for me to.

But there could be good reasons why you would not want her to.

Blueseaurchin · Yesterday 09:52

Completely unacceptable behaviour.

Your DH needs to speak to her and get the key back.

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 09:52

To those saying it's sensible, that someone should have a spare key etc...

That is our decision to make! Not hers. She took it upon herself to make a copy of our key without asking us if that is something we would like or find helpful.

OP posts:
Denim4ever · Yesterday 10:00

It's a good idea if a relative has a spare key, someone to call on should you need them. But the initiative should come from you

CalmTheFuckDownMargaret · Yesterday 10:03

Totally agree. You have to be invited to have a key to someone else’s home. You simply cannot cut yourself a key to give yourself access without discussing it first. My in-laws have a key as we gave them it. That’s nothing like them borrowing a key and copying it without asking. If they had done that, I’d have been really annoyed. On the plus side, at least she told you because some people on here have had in-laws just letting themselves in with keys they didn’t even know they had! 😳

Boreded · Yesterday 10:04

Thepossibility · Yesterday 04:47

That is not the same as someone sneaking off to get themselves a copy of a key that someone trusted them with for one afternoon AT ALL.

Nothing sneaky about it, she told them that she had done it. She did a thing that she thought would make things easier, and she told them that she did it.

She didn’t do it in secret, she did the equivalent of noticing someone was out of milk so grabbing one when she was at the supermarket.

If @TiredAF123 is that bothered she can ask for it back. But given it won’t be used I can’t see why it would be the hill she wants to die on.

Boreded · Yesterday 10:05

Oz8788 · Yesterday 05:00

These replies are so OTT .The fact that she offered the information that she had a key cut really doesn't suggest that she is going to be sneaking into the house to have a good old nose around! She was probably just trying to use her initiative.

This!!! But it’s very much a MIL can do nothing right mumsnet trope isn’t it.

Coconutcreamz · Yesterday 10:05

OP, what she did is completely inappropriate.
Two choices i believe.
Get the key back or a video door bell.
No one has a key to our house.
I wouldn't want it.

I think she is hugely presumptuous and presumptuous people are just the type to use the key for doing something "nice" like dropping in a cake or something while you are not there.....and have a wander.

Not on IMO.

GelatinousDynamo · Yesterday 10:07

My MIL has done the exact same thing, only she didn't tell us that she's had a copy made. We gave her the key for one afternoon, we were both at work and she wanted to park at our house and be able to use the bathroom because she had something to do in our town.

A few weeks later, I came home in the afternoon and just had this feeling that something was wrong and different. Couldn't pinpoint it though. And then it happened again a week later. So, totally spooked, I bought a ring doorbell and behold, a few days later, it picked up my MIL letting herself into our house. I was furious, I called her while she was inside and asked if she's home, because I'm on my way to pick up my baking tray, and she lied that she was at the doctor's. I LOST it at her, called her a lying sneak and told her to leave my house immediately.

My DH took her to court, but of course the floods of tears came as always, and he let it go in the end. I never found out what she was actually doing at our house, we had the locks changed anyway.

Our relationship has never recovered of course, but it wasn't good to begin with, she's done a few other crazy things over the years, this was just the culmination.

cupfinalchaos · Yesterday 10:07

Totally overstepping, she should’ve asked you first.

squarecrow · Yesterday 10:10

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 09:52

To those saying it's sensible, that someone should have a spare key etc...

That is our decision to make! Not hers. She took it upon herself to make a copy of our key without asking us if that is something we would like or find helpful.

I bet none of these posters would want someone making a copy of their house key without discussion.

namechange62 · Yesterday 10:12

I have keys to all my 3DCs houses. I give childcare to one and pick up at 7.30am and still knock rather than use the key. I wouldn't have dreamt of copying the keys.
Definitely get the key back. But probably better to change the lock because she could have got a few cut.

Boreded · Yesterday 10:14

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 08:47

We didn't ask her. She volunteered to spend time with DS. We have a childminder.

Why have you changed your story??

you said…
We gave a key to MIL as we needed some help with school collection and minding of our little boy this afternoon.