Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed that MIL made herself a copy of our house key without asking us?

318 replies

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 00:02

I'm flabbergasted.

We gave a key to MIL as we needed some help with school collection and minding of our little boy this afternoon. She's had the key 3 days. When she was saying goodbye this evening, she casually mentioned she had made herself a copy of the key incase of any other instances like this.

To be clear, we don't rely on her for childcare. We have a childminder. This was a one off occasion that we actually didn't need her for but she volunteered to spend time with child. We have lived in this house for almost 8 years and this is the first time we have had to give her a key. And she goes and makes herself a copy.

I feel like this is a huge boundary overstep! I don't feel comfortable at all with her having a key to my house. And the cheek of making it without asking! In the moment I was so taken back that I didn't really say anything. But I'm considering having my DH talk to her about how inappropriate it was to do that and to ask for the key back.

OP posts:
Nearly50omg · Yesterday 15:21

Change the locks!!!’

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 15:21

TheBoldRedHam · Yesterday 15:00

This whole thread is absolutely bonkers .... Based on a couple of assumtions

a) She hasnt or will not use the key to enter your house with prior notice and permission

b) She has told you she got a key cut - It isnt something she has hidden.

So based on these assumptions Im going to suggest this a complete over reaction on the OP part ..... to the point i would suggest ungrateful. Its a total loss of perspective.

She is your partners/husbands mother .... what do you think she is likely to do with the key, break in when you are out at work, or turn up unnanouced in the evenings? ..... Im guessing probably not. You are happy for her to look after your child, so im going to also assume your MIL is a reasonable person of sound mind?

My advice is dont sweat this small stuff, dont be so paranoid, it such a small issue (unless she uses key for her own benefit) and dont risk upsetting your MIL for such a trivial matter, and who probably genuinely thought she was doing a good thing

Using a key unnannounced = Overstepping

Getting a key cut at her own expense and informing you = Not overstepping

I actually feel a bit sorry for her if this is the reaction.

Edited

I feel more than a bit sorry for people like you who think this is ok.

Jom222 · Yesterday 15:27

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 11:33

Hahaa!! While I would never withhold that particular joy, I did mention to him that one of my fears is that they show up, don't get an answer at the bell and let themselves in during one of our child free afternoons! That certainly got him thinking!! A reminder that we both work remotely and all children are of school going age... we take our opportunities where we can 🤣

a coworker's Anne's* mother had a key to her house and one day Anne and her husband had taken advantage of a few hours alone, she said they'd left clothing in a trail from the kitchen ultimately ending in the bedroom. In the midst of it she heard her mother calling out, she'd been picking up their discarded clothes and was at the bedroom door when coworker yelled for her to stop.

She said THAT put a quick stop to mother stopping by uninvited and letting herself in. Mother had been given a key for similar childcare reasons-Anne didn't know her mother had been dropping by midday for no known reason!

Get that key back or change the locks OP

*her name isn't really Anne

Highlightsnomore · Yesterday 15:29

Our old neighbour had a key for emergencies but used it to let herself in when she had taken in a parcel for me.
I know she did it with good intentions but it wasn’t appropriate!
I found an excuse to get it back from her at some point saying I needed it for a tradesman and just never gave it back.

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 15:31

TheBoldRedHam · Yesterday 15:00

This whole thread is absolutely bonkers .... Based on a couple of assumtions

a) She hasnt or will not use the key to enter your house with prior notice and permission

b) She has told you she got a key cut - It isnt something she has hidden.

So based on these assumptions Im going to suggest this a complete over reaction on the OP part ..... to the point i would suggest ungrateful. Its a total loss of perspective.

She is your partners/husbands mother .... what do you think she is likely to do with the key, break in when you are out at work, or turn up unnanouced in the evenings? ..... Im guessing probably not. You are happy for her to look after your child, so im going to also assume your MIL is a reasonable person of sound mind?

My advice is dont sweat this small stuff, dont be so paranoid, it such a small issue (unless she uses key for her own benefit) and dont risk upsetting your MIL for such a trivial matter, and who probably genuinely thought she was doing a good thing

Using a key unnannounced = Overstepping

Getting a key cut at her own expense and informing you = Not overstepping

I actually feel a bit sorry for her if this is the reaction.

Edited

What a weird post.

MatriarchCaz · Yesterday 15:42

Sounds as if she had it cut on the spur of the moment? Maybe she was going past somewhere and thought you may not have any spares?

Either way just say, thanks but we don't like handing keys out, I'll pay you the money and if you could give it to me please that would be fab.

No need for anything further.

WouldRatherBeOnaBeach · Yesterday 15:44

This is definitely NOT normal!!!

I would get the locks professionally changed and then send her the bill! 😂😂😂😂😂

Wavebreaker8 · Yesterday 16:01

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 15:18

I can't understand how anyone can thinks it's appropriate to get a key cut for someone else's house.

I think if you read my post, you will find that I didn't think it was appropriate as I said it was wrong for her to do so. What I can't understand is how so many people jump to the conclusion that she will up to no good having now got herself a key when she hasn't given any indication that this may be the case at all. She could just as easily have done so for the perfectly innocent reason she gave. 🤷

Whatseatinggilbertsgrape · Yesterday 16:17

Is she the burgling type?

Thegirlwhowent · Yesterday 16:22

Wavebreaker8 · Yesterday 14:59

Not all families are the same for sure. However, in this case, the MIL is apparently OK (apart from having made some unfortunate choices re decisions concerning her family). The OP has lived in the house for 8 years but doesn't seem to have concerns about snooping etc. which could just as easily be done whilst childminding the GS if she was that way inclined. Was she wrong to get the key cut? .... absolutely and isn't something that I would personally do but a lot of people on here are assuming it was done with awful intent. Only the OP + DH know MIL well and what she could be capable of but perhaps this was just another of MIL's unfortunate decisions and she really just has the best of intentions however misguided they are.

I agree - MIL probably thought she was being helpful. But OP doesn't want her to have a key and as it's her house, she's entitled to say who has a key. People in here seem to think that because they are ok with their MIL/friend/neighbours having a key, she should too. I'm happy for others to have keys to my place but I'd feel a bit miffed if they made a copy without asking me first!

Thegirlwhowent · Yesterday 16:23

Whatseatinggilbertsgrape · Yesterday 16:17

Is she the burgling type?

That's irrelevant.

Littlebitpsycho · Yesterday 16:31

All these people saying its normal, do you not think that if OP wanted her to have a key, she might, shocking as the idea might be, have given her one before?

Getting a copy done without permission is beyond overstepping!

TheBoldRedHam · Yesterday 16:45

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 15:21

I feel more than a bit sorry for people like you who think this is ok.

No need to feel sorry for me .... i am obviously surrounded by far better people for this issue to not even register as a problem.

TheBoldRedHam · Yesterday 16:47

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 15:31

What a weird post.

Seriously ... To use the word "weird" as a reply .... You have bigger problems than someone else's spare key dilemma

SwingAndRelax · Yesterday 16:47

Beerhy · Yesterday 14:12

How weird that you’d withhold help if your children or their partners wanted to keep their own house private. Very controlling tbh and totally not the same thing at all.

Yep, that's bonkers!

Wavebreaker8 · Yesterday 16:48

Littlebitpsycho · Yesterday 16:31

All these people saying its normal, do you not think that if OP wanted her to have a key, she might, shocking as the idea might be, have given her one before?

Getting a copy done without permission is beyond overstepping!

I don't think anyone has said that it is normal to have a key cut without permission but normal for some families to have keys to each other's houses as they wish. The OP doesn't want MIL to have a key... that's her prerogative of course it is. I personally would feel a bit surprised if my MIL had done this but I know my MIL and would understand that she had done this with the best of intentions and most certainly wouldn't fall out with her over it.

TheBoldRedHam · Yesterday 16:57

Wavebreaker8 · Yesterday 16:01

I think if you read my post, you will find that I didn't think it was appropriate as I said it was wrong for her to do so. What I can't understand is how so many people jump to the conclusion that she will up to no good having now got herself a key when she hasn't given any indication that this may be the case at all. She could just as easily have done so for the perfectly innocent reason she gave. 🤷

My guess is some of us are lucky to have better people around us, ..... or maybe we dont have that sense of self importance that the world is that interested in our world/home life .... or we are just better at keeping things in perspective

Aiming4Optimistic · Yesterday 17:11

I think this depends on whether she's the type of person to use it in your absence or is a nice woman who would keep it for a true emergency. She told you that she'd had it made - someone who intended to take advantage probably wouldn't have mentioned it. If she starts just letting herself in without knocking, then by all means object. But I think if you start talking about 'boundaries' she might be less inclined to do you favours when you need them - she's your husband's mum, not some random person.
I get why you don't like it and I agree she ought to have asked, but you could easily shoot your self in the foot if you make her feel like she's good enough to do you favours but not good enough to be trusted with possession of a key!

Boreded · Yesterday 17:33

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 10:24

I didn't change story. In my second paragraph on OP I said ....

To be clear, we don't rely on her for childcare. We have a childminder. This was a one off occasion that we actually didn't need her for but she volunteered to spend time with child.

You’ve literally just described changing the story…

Boreded · Yesterday 17:37

SpainToday · Yesterday 11:21

You should tell your DH that until he reclaims the key (or has the locks changed) there will be no more s*x, because you can't relax when you're worried about being interrupted.

Because that’s exactly what people should do, use sex as a tool to control someone…FFS

Boreded · Yesterday 17:42

B1anche · Yesterday 13:37

That is fascinating but what has it got to do with this thread?

Same question to you?

Chickpeacurrywithrice · Yesterday 17:43

SpainToday · Yesterday 11:21

You should tell your DH that until he reclaims the key (or has the locks changed) there will be no more s*x, because you can't relax when you're worried about being interrupted.

Why would OP want to stop her sex life?

Boreded · Yesterday 17:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Ah nothing like a bit of aggression and unnecessary comment 👍 thanks

MyLittleNest · Yesterday 17:49

Wow, she majorly overstepped. This is your house, your decision to make about spare keys and who should have them.

Would she do this with a sister, brother, or other relative? Or is it that she cannot view your DH has a grown adult, whose house is his own? She definitely seems to have very blurred boundaries. I would be very put out by this!

Boreded · Yesterday 17:52

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 15:21

I feel more than a bit sorry for people like you who think this is ok.

This is a bit of an unnecessarily harsh comment no?