Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed that MIL made herself a copy of our house key without asking us?

318 replies

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 00:02

I'm flabbergasted.

We gave a key to MIL as we needed some help with school collection and minding of our little boy this afternoon. She's had the key 3 days. When she was saying goodbye this evening, she casually mentioned she had made herself a copy of the key incase of any other instances like this.

To be clear, we don't rely on her for childcare. We have a childminder. This was a one off occasion that we actually didn't need her for but she volunteered to spend time with child. We have lived in this house for almost 8 years and this is the first time we have had to give her a key. And she goes and makes herself a copy.

I feel like this is a huge boundary overstep! I don't feel comfortable at all with her having a key to my house. And the cheek of making it without asking! In the moment I was so taken back that I didn't really say anything. But I'm considering having my DH talk to her about how inappropriate it was to do that and to ask for the key back.

OP posts:
LuckyBamboob · Yesterday 00:04

No, that’s not ok at all.

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 00:04

Just adding to be clear that when we gave her the key, it was always just for this afternoon and not to be kept. So she knew she would be giving it back...

OP posts:
Opus3 · Yesterday 00:04

Change the locks. What an odd thing for her to do.

Wreckinball · Yesterday 00:05

Don’t say anything but change the lock, expensive but gets round it. If she tries to come round when you’re out she’ll get a shock!

Solmum1964 · Yesterday 00:08

I would also change the locks but go for a brand like Ultion where you have to have a code to get more cut.

TeaAndTooManyThoughts · Yesterday 00:21

My MIL did this and the key was swiftly removed from her by my DH. Not on at all - massive overstepping boundaries!!

BreadInCaptivity · Yesterday 00:24

No it’s not acceptable without asking.

That said my parents have spare keys for my house and vice versa, in case of an emergency.

However this was all discussed and neither of us would or ever have, used the keys to gain access without permission (or in an emergency which has thankfully not happened).

As such I think the issues are that she didn’t consult you and a worry that she would overstep further by using it without consent - not that a relative holding a spare key is an issue per se.

Boreded · Yesterday 00:30

You’re happy to trust her to look after your child but can’t trust her to have a key.

I find this bizarre, I have all my family’s keys…they have mine. That way in an emergency (like my neice being locked out of my FILs last week when she forgot her key and he wasn’t finished work) someone can pop down the road and let them in.

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 00:36

Boreded · Yesterday 00:30

You’re happy to trust her to look after your child but can’t trust her to have a key.

I find this bizarre, I have all my family’s keys…they have mine. That way in an emergency (like my neice being locked out of my FILs last week when she forgot her key and he wasn’t finished work) someone can pop down the road and let them in.

It's not about trusting her to have a key. It's that she made herself a copy without asking us if that was OK or if that was something we thought would be helpful...

If we wanted her to have a spare key, that should be our choice to give her one

OP posts:
BMW6 · Yesterday 00:37

Boreded · Yesterday 00:30

You’re happy to trust her to look after your child but can’t trust her to have a key.

I find this bizarre, I have all my family’s keys…they have mine. That way in an emergency (like my neice being locked out of my FILs last week when she forgot her key and he wasn’t finished work) someone can pop down the road and let them in.

That's fine, but are you claiming that you had copies of keys made without consent? And that other people got your keys copied without your consent?

HowDoYouSolveAProblemLikeMyRear · Yesterday 00:40

In most families I know, parents/adult children/siblings tend to have copies of each other's keys, unless they live a long way away from each other and visit rarely.

So I can understand why it might not have occurred to your MIL that it was helpful rather than cheeky to copy the key.

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 00:41

BreadInCaptivity · Yesterday 00:24

No it’s not acceptable without asking.

That said my parents have spare keys for my house and vice versa, in case of an emergency.

However this was all discussed and neither of us would or ever have, used the keys to gain access without permission (or in an emergency which has thankfully not happened).

As such I think the issues are that she didn’t consult you and a worry that she would overstep further by using it without consent - not that a relative holding a spare key is an issue per se.

This exactly.

I get that relatives having spare keys is normal. It's going and making a copy without asking us that is absolutely not ok.

We have had lots of little boundaries being broken of late and this has pushed me to my limit!

Also for context, nobody else has a spare key to our house. So it's not like she felt it would be ok because such and such has one. We leave a key with a trusted neighbour if we leave the country, but so far in these 8 years, we haven't felt the need to give out spares.

OP posts:
Delphiniumandlupins · Yesterday 00:54

I would ask for the key back. Probably best coming from your DH. If you want to avoid any drama, offer to refund her for the copy. Does your DH have a key to her house?

PollyBell · Yesterday 00:58

If she is going to case the joint yes listen to over dramatic change the locks advice but I presume normal people would just ask for the key back

suki1964 · Yesterday 01:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Isittimeformynapyet · Yesterday 01:04

HowDoYouSolveAProblemLikeMyRear · Yesterday 00:40

In most families I know, parents/adult children/siblings tend to have copies of each other's keys, unless they live a long way away from each other and visit rarely.

So I can understand why it might not have occurred to your MIL that it was helpful rather than cheeky to copy the key.

So I can understand why it might not have occurred to your MIL that it was helpful rather than cheeky to copy the key.

Surely that should be the other way round? It didn't occur to her that it would be cheeky rather than helpful?

MyOtherCarIsASatsuma · Yesterday 01:10

I would be flabbergasted too. As she would, probably, if you took it upon yourself to have your own copy cut of her keys without asking.

MN is a funny place sometimes. Someone owning a key to your home that you did not give them is far from "pretty normal, totally acceptable".

squarecrow · Yesterday 01:16

MyOtherCarIsASatsuma · Yesterday 01:10

I would be flabbergasted too. As she would, probably, if you took it upon yourself to have your own copy cut of her keys without asking.

MN is a funny place sometimes. Someone owning a key to your home that you did not give them is far from "pretty normal, totally acceptable".

This. And being annoyed that someone had copied your key without asking means you “think they’re going to case the joint”.

whistlesandbells · Yesterday 01:23

YANBU, I would feel completely violated by this.

I would expect my DH to get the key back and say why it was not acceptable. It would also be the last visit for MIL in my home alone.

RudePhthaloDalmadoodle · Yesterday 01:29

I'd be careful even if you get it back from her or change the locks; she'd only needs a minute alone with the key to make an impression in her makeup compact and get a new one cast in secret. However, I'd also suspect that if confronted she'll plead good intentions and pretend not to understand the issue: after all, she DID tell you she'd had it made!

PollyBell · Yesterday 01:32

squarecrow · Yesterday 01:16

This. And being annoyed that someone had copied your key without asking means you “think they’re going to case the joint”.

To me asking for the key back would be normal changing the locks would be as dramatic as thinking they are going to case the joint

ByRoseSnake · Yesterday 01:35

Yeah, this happened to me years back with an ex partner who had seriously invasive parents. It started along similar lines - no agreement or discussion, having a key cut under the premise of 'emergencies', but they started showing up out of nowhere and just waltzing in...
His dad banged repeatedly on the door, and then unlocked the front door once, while myself and ex were having a lazy Sunday morning (read: sex fuelled Sunday morning lol)
Apparently he was 'worried' because we didn't open up immediately at 10am on a Sunday... and all that he wanted to do was ask my ex about where he was having his next MOT?!... urgh... so infuriating.

Oh yes, and the lovely time that his mum just showed up and let herself in when I was recovering from a minor operation. Apparently I was the bitch because she'd shown up with grapes and smoothies for me, but honestly, the last thing I needed when curled up in bed after keyhole surgery was MIL breathing over me, counselling me on the tidiness of the house, offering to let herself back in and cook us both dinner for the next few nights, etc 🙃

Hate to say it, but his parents and their bloody keys were some of the main reasons we split up.

Nip it in the bud!!!!

Mrsclaude · Yesterday 01:38

I’d just change the locks - having said that, I switched to digital locks on my front entrance that I could program various codes for. It meant Cleaner A has her own code that works at scheduled times, I can delete access if she moves on and I get a new cleaner without the hassle of getting new codes, it also records when and which code has opened the door. Eg. Mums code was used at 2:30pm to unlock door and door locked again at 2:36pm

My parents have free access to my house and me to theirs - there is no boundary issues though and it’s a respectful positive relationship. This isn’t something I’d be comfortable with for just anyone, including a MIL who took what wasn’t offered.

AmnesiacDream · Yesterday 01:39

It is very common for families to hold keys for each other. While I understand it being a shock and seeming like overstepping if you are not used to it, you may be attributing a sense of entitlement to the action that isn't there. It wouldn't have occurred to my mum, for instance, that it wasn't just a helpful thing to do but she'd never have abused having the key.

If she has form for trying to muscle in on your life where she isn't wanted you may be right to be wary and consider how to best get the key or change the locks. But otherwise perhaps a more soft touch approach would be judicious? Having helpful family around is a form of wealth. Doing something to jeopardise that because you have mismatched views of a small action (if you don't think she'd actually abuse having the key) isn't very circumspect. Treating her as though this is a terrible thing to have done will likely make her feel like she isn't really trusted or appreciated.

Nofeckingway · Yesterday 02:03

In 8 years they haven't felt the need to get a copy made and give it to her . She went behind their backs and did this . Very very CF thing to do . I'd just get DH to give her the money she spent and get it back off her .