Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed that MIL made herself a copy of our house key without asking us?

318 replies

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 00:02

I'm flabbergasted.

We gave a key to MIL as we needed some help with school collection and minding of our little boy this afternoon. She's had the key 3 days. When she was saying goodbye this evening, she casually mentioned she had made herself a copy of the key incase of any other instances like this.

To be clear, we don't rely on her for childcare. We have a childminder. This was a one off occasion that we actually didn't need her for but she volunteered to spend time with child. We have lived in this house for almost 8 years and this is the first time we have had to give her a key. And she goes and makes herself a copy.

I feel like this is a huge boundary overstep! I don't feel comfortable at all with her having a key to my house. And the cheek of making it without asking! In the moment I was so taken back that I didn't really say anything. But I'm considering having my DH talk to her about how inappropriate it was to do that and to ask for the key back.

OP posts:
Lookingforwardtospringnextyear · Yesterday 02:05

AmnesiacDream · Yesterday 01:39

It is very common for families to hold keys for each other. While I understand it being a shock and seeming like overstepping if you are not used to it, you may be attributing a sense of entitlement to the action that isn't there. It wouldn't have occurred to my mum, for instance, that it wasn't just a helpful thing to do but she'd never have abused having the key.

If she has form for trying to muscle in on your life where she isn't wanted you may be right to be wary and consider how to best get the key or change the locks. But otherwise perhaps a more soft touch approach would be judicious? Having helpful family around is a form of wealth. Doing something to jeopardise that because you have mismatched views of a small action (if you don't think she'd actually abuse having the key) isn't very circumspect. Treating her as though this is a terrible thing to have done will likely make her feel like she isn't really trusted or appreciated.

It doesn't really matter if it is common for families to hold keys for each other -and I would question how true this is - because the whole point is OP doesn't want her MiL to have a key.
And may seem like overstepping
because it was massively overstepping.
And yes having helpful family around may be a good thing but unfortunately some people can't differentiate between being helpful and being intrusive.
She is the one who has breached OP's trust by having this key cut.

Ijwwm · Yesterday 03:05

AmnesiacDream · Yesterday 01:39

It is very common for families to hold keys for each other. While I understand it being a shock and seeming like overstepping if you are not used to it, you may be attributing a sense of entitlement to the action that isn't there. It wouldn't have occurred to my mum, for instance, that it wasn't just a helpful thing to do but she'd never have abused having the key.

If she has form for trying to muscle in on your life where she isn't wanted you may be right to be wary and consider how to best get the key or change the locks. But otherwise perhaps a more soft touch approach would be judicious? Having helpful family around is a form of wealth. Doing something to jeopardise that because you have mismatched views of a small action (if you don't think she'd actually abuse having the key) isn't very circumspect. Treating her as though this is a terrible thing to have done will likely make her feel like she isn't really trusted or appreciated.

What a bizarre outlook. The only thing you’ve got right is the fact that she won’t be trusted.

Normal behaviour is families/friends/who you trust discussing and agreeing to hold a spare key in case of emergency.

Not normal behaviour is being given a key, for the first time in X amount of years (for a specific reason), and then merrily announcing that you’ve had a copy taken.

JMSA · Yesterday 03:11

Wouldn’t bother me at all.

I’m glad the free childcare was useful to you though.

OneMoreProfiterole · Yesterday 03:20

JMSA · Yesterday 03:11

Wouldn’t bother me at all.

I’m glad the free childcare was useful to you though.

To be clear, we don't rely on her for childcare. We have a childminder. This was a one off occasion that we actually didn't need her for but she volunteered to spend time with child.

Useful free childcare? Where does she say that?

Franjipanl8r · Yesterday 03:30

This personally wouldn’t bother me at all, but I trust my MIL not to rock up uninvited and she lives an hour away. I’ve got keys to my parents house, I don’t use them to let myself in and invade their privacy, they’re just for emergencies.

PollyBell · Yesterday 03:41

Franjipanl8r · Yesterday 03:30

This personally wouldn’t bother me at all, but I trust my MIL not to rock up uninvited and she lives an hour away. I’ve got keys to my parents house, I don’t use them to let myself in and invade their privacy, they’re just for emergencies.

They live too far from us now but I gave mine a gey before with no issues but getting a key cut without checking is weird

alexdgr8 · Yesterday 03:46

Maybe this us why she volunteered the childcare.
With malice forethought to get and keep a key.
Add an extra lock.

AmnesiacDream · Yesterday 04:33

Lookingforwardtospringnextyear · Yesterday 02:05

It doesn't really matter if it is common for families to hold keys for each other -and I would question how true this is - because the whole point is OP doesn't want her MiL to have a key.
And may seem like overstepping
because it was massively overstepping.
And yes having helpful family around may be a good thing but unfortunately some people can't differentiate between being helpful and being intrusive.
She is the one who has breached OP's trust by having this key cut.

I'm pointing out that these are cultural attitudes, not laws of nature. It feels like overstepping to OP and it is for her, I'm pointing out that it may not to her MiL (even if the roles were reversed) and that assuming it was done in bad faith may be untrue and lead to an unnecessary break down in their relationship.

I'm not trying to suggest that OP should just roll over and let her MiL have a key because MiL wants it if OP is uncomfortable with the idea. I got the impression from one of her posts that it was MiL making the copy without asking that was the problem rather than her holding a key, but rereading all her posts I may have misread that.

Topseyt123 · Yesterday 04:36

I'd be demanding that she hand the copy over to me.

It would be the last time she made an unsupervised visit to my house. Cheeky fucker!

Maisymouse2 · Yesterday 04:38

Boreded · Yesterday 00:30

You’re happy to trust her to look after your child but can’t trust her to have a key.

I find this bizarre, I have all my family’s keys…they have mine. That way in an emergency (like my neice being locked out of my FILs last week when she forgot her key and he wasn’t finished work) someone can pop down the road and let them in.

This.
Why not ask for the newly cut key back if it tigger's you so much.
Im sure it isnt to ransack your house or small's

Error404FucksNotFound · Yesterday 04:39

Change the lock and dont tell her.

Nat6999 · Yesterday 04:44

I'd change the lock, say nothing & have a camera to film her trying to get in. If she says anything tell her you had to get the locks changed for the house insurance. Have you checked she doesn't have a key for the back door? I wouldn't put it past her having a copy of that one.

Thepossibility · Yesterday 04:47

Boreded · Yesterday 00:30

You’re happy to trust her to look after your child but can’t trust her to have a key.

I find this bizarre, I have all my family’s keys…they have mine. That way in an emergency (like my neice being locked out of my FILs last week when she forgot her key and he wasn’t finished work) someone can pop down the road and let them in.

That is not the same as someone sneaking off to get themselves a copy of a key that someone trusted them with for one afternoon AT ALL.

Celer · Yesterday 04:55

She did cross a line copying the key without checking with her son or you that it was ok. In our family it would be odd for her not to have had a set in the first place but that’s your prerogative.

it also sounds like you aren’t very keen on her anyway. Hard to know if that’s you, or her, or just personalities which don’t get on well.

How does her son feel about her?

Oz8788 · Yesterday 05:00

These replies are so OTT .The fact that she offered the information that she had a key cut really doesn't suggest that she is going to be sneaking into the house to have a good old nose around! She was probably just trying to use her initiative.

Platypusdiver · Yesterday 05:01

It’d ignore it until the first time she uses it inappropriately.

Yes, way out of order though.

AgentKim · Yesterday 05:03

RudePhthaloDalmadoodle · Yesterday 01:29

I'd be careful even if you get it back from her or change the locks; she'd only needs a minute alone with the key to make an impression in her makeup compact and get a new one cast in secret. However, I'd also suspect that if confronted she'll plead good intentions and pretend not to understand the issue: after all, she DID tell you she'd had it made!

Would a key smith not think it funny if someone asked for a key to be made from a cast made out off say, lip sealent.
Is her MIL a spy ? I would just ask my DH to ask why she did it and explain you would like to have the key back.

Thepossibility · Yesterday 05:10

Oz8788 · Yesterday 05:00

These replies are so OTT .The fact that she offered the information that she had a key cut really doesn't suggest that she is going to be sneaking into the house to have a good old nose around! She was probably just trying to use her initiative.

She didn't ask first, just assumed she'd get away with it because it was already done.
Normal people ask if they can have a key. Even better, wait until a key is offered. The fact one wasn't offered after all this time sends a clear message we don't want you to have a key to our home.

Mapletree1985 · Yesterday 05:39

Why is it inappropriate? Makes sense to me. In fact it always makes sense for somebody you trust to have a copy of your house key for emergencies. Do you have reason to believe she will come over while you're out and steal your TV or rearrange your kitchen? She probably should have asked you first, but since it was a sensible thing to do she probably couldn't imagine you would dislike it. "Massive overstep" is a bit of a hyperbole.

Batsuke1 · Yesterday 05:52

YANBU. If you wanted her to have a key to your house you would give her one! Making a copy without your permission is ridiculous.

Blimeyohreillythatsourgovernment · Yesterday 05:56

Oof, OP, I would be furious AND disappointed …that really is a massive overstep. I completely adored my MIL but that would have been regarded as wholly inappropriate, family or not. One simply doesn’t make keys, without specifically being asked to do so, to other peoples homes.

If your DH is as confrontation-averse as mine, and I wanted the key back, I probably would text her something like “Mum, I love you dearly, but having a spare key cut without checking with us first isn’t ok. Regardless of how well intended. We’ll reimburse you for the cost but I’d appreciate it if you could bring it round or drop it in the letterbox, xx”.

You don’t owe her an explanation as to WHY you don’t want her to have one, either.

Lippydeedee · Yesterday 05:59

My MIL did the same. And then insisted numerous times that we pay the £6 that it cost her to get them done.
Tell her or get your husband to tell her it’s not on and you want the keys back. My situation escalated and one day we had a huge row and I told her everything I’d ever wanted to say. I’ve never felt the same way about her.

MuchAdoAboutSomething26 · Yesterday 06:05

This wouldn’t bother me at all. But then I like my MIL. She already has a key to my house. As do my own parents, the cleaner and the dog walker! MIL leaves milk in the fridge and a cake on the table when we get back from holidays. I love it!

Blimeyohreillythatsourgovernment · Yesterday 06:14

Mapletree1985 · Yesterday 05:39

Why is it inappropriate? Makes sense to me. In fact it always makes sense for somebody you trust to have a copy of your house key for emergencies. Do you have reason to believe she will come over while you're out and steal your TV or rearrange your kitchen? She probably should have asked you first, but since it was a sensible thing to do she probably couldn't imagine you would dislike it. "Massive overstep" is a bit of a hyperbole.

You can’t be serious, Mapletree, surely?
Whether or not it is sensible is neither here nor there in this particular situation and not for the MIL to decide. Just because someone trusts you with the key to their home for a few days doesn’t mean they gave their consent for you to have a key cut!
If nothing else it is wildly disrespectful. Any teenage child moving to student accommodation would go ( rightfully) ballistic if their parent made a spare key to their digs without permission. But a full flung independent adult should meekly accept it because it is “sensible”? Come on ……the MIL overstepped normal interpersonal, civilised boundaries which DO exist for close family members, too.

Horses7 · Yesterday 06:17

I am a MILx2 and this is completely out of order - what was she thinking???
We do have keys btw but they were given to us (plus cute keyrings) but we wouldn’t dream of going into their houses unless we are asked to eg let a workman in etc.
We also make a point of never just ‘dropping in’ their houses - however they didn’t get the memo and drop in to ours often 🤣 We’re glad they do.
Btw one of my friends MILs went in and tidied up all her drawers (including bedroom) whilst they were on holiday!!!
Beggars belief 🤦‍♀️

Swipe left for the next trending thread