Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed that MIL made herself a copy of our house key without asking us?

318 replies

TiredAF123 · Yesterday 00:02

I'm flabbergasted.

We gave a key to MIL as we needed some help with school collection and minding of our little boy this afternoon. She's had the key 3 days. When she was saying goodbye this evening, she casually mentioned she had made herself a copy of the key incase of any other instances like this.

To be clear, we don't rely on her for childcare. We have a childminder. This was a one off occasion that we actually didn't need her for but she volunteered to spend time with child. We have lived in this house for almost 8 years and this is the first time we have had to give her a key. And she goes and makes herself a copy.

I feel like this is a huge boundary overstep! I don't feel comfortable at all with her having a key to my house. And the cheek of making it without asking! In the moment I was so taken back that I didn't really say anything. But I'm considering having my DH talk to her about how inappropriate it was to do that and to ask for the key back.

OP posts:
TeaCupTinsel · Yesterday 06:17

Massive overstep. It's all well and good for those saying that their in-laws/parents have keys but the difference is 'consent'.

I'd send your DH to get the key back and to let her know it was a massive overstep. If she won't hand it over then change the locks.

PoolDepth · Yesterday 06:25

My MIL had a key for our old door as she drives 3 hours to visit and on occasion we’d be delayed getting back from work to let her in. Then she started letting herself in when she arrived, even if we were in the house. Really pissed me off!!

We then got a new door after building work and I never gave her a new key. It’s a banham lock so can’t be copied except by them and with a PIN code. She sometimes has use of the spare key when needed whilst she’s staying with us, but thankfully can’t copy it!!

YANBU. It’s an invasion of privacy.

menopausequeen · Yesterday 06:27

What do you think she will do with the key?

jelikats · Yesterday 06:39

BreadInCaptivity · Yesterday 00:24

No it’s not acceptable without asking.

That said my parents have spare keys for my house and vice versa, in case of an emergency.

However this was all discussed and neither of us would or ever have, used the keys to gain access without permission (or in an emergency which has thankfully not happened).

As such I think the issues are that she didn’t consult you and a worry that she would overstep further by using it without consent - not that a relative holding a spare key is an issue per se.

This is a very sensible and balanced view.

To me, the main issue here is not that she has had a key cut, but her motive for doing so, as you say that you say she has broken ‘lots of little boundaries’ recently. So I would be worried that she might abuse the situation and use the key to let herself in now when she visits rather than knocking at the door. This would be intolerable and would understandably make you feel continually anxious. .

She shouldn’t have done it and I do get it completely that her taking the liberty to get another key cut without your permission is your main concern, but I’m more interested in her motives and future implications if she has a problem with boundaries.

A conversation clearly needs to be had with an aim of either retrieving the key or setting very rigid boundaries on its future use.

.
.

JustaSongAboutPingPong · Yesterday 06:56

TeaCupTinsel · Yesterday 06:17

Massive overstep. It's all well and good for those saying that their in-laws/parents have keys but the difference is 'consent'.

I'd send your DH to get the key back and to let her know it was a massive overstep. If she won't hand it over then change the locks.

I wouldn’t do this personally. She’s told you that she’s had one copied, how do you know that she’s told you there’s one copy but she’s actually had two copies made for just this eventuality?

Not naturally devious myself, I’ve had to start thinking along the lines of WWMMD (What would my Mother do?).

With most houses changing the lock is very simple. There’ll be a video on YouTube and you can get the parts from B&Q.

If it’s a wooden door you could get a deadlock fitted instead which would have the double bonus of making your house more secure.

Chickpeacurrywithrice · Yesterday 07:00

Boreded · Yesterday 00:30

You’re happy to trust her to look after your child but can’t trust her to have a key.

I find this bizarre, I have all my family’s keys…they have mine. That way in an emergency (like my neice being locked out of my FILs last week when she forgot her key and he wasn’t finished work) someone can pop down the road and let them in.

Where you given a key or did you take it upon yourself to just get various keys cut? Which is frankly weird!

Motnight · Yesterday 07:08

She's broken boundaries. Her having a key cut without consent means that she is happily planning to break more boundaries.

RobertaHack · Yesterday 07:08

AmnesiacDream · Yesterday 01:39

It is very common for families to hold keys for each other. While I understand it being a shock and seeming like overstepping if you are not used to it, you may be attributing a sense of entitlement to the action that isn't there. It wouldn't have occurred to my mum, for instance, that it wasn't just a helpful thing to do but she'd never have abused having the key.

If she has form for trying to muscle in on your life where she isn't wanted you may be right to be wary and consider how to best get the key or change the locks. But otherwise perhaps a more soft touch approach would be judicious? Having helpful family around is a form of wealth. Doing something to jeopardise that because you have mismatched views of a small action (if you don't think she'd actually abuse having the key) isn't very circumspect. Treating her as though this is a terrible thing to have done will likely make her feel like she isn't really trusted or appreciated.

I agree with this. It's all about intention isn't it. If she's a lovely MIL usually, she probably just thought she was doing you a favour, saving any faff with the key another time. Yes, she should have asked, but bloody hell there's some hyperbole in these posts.

RobertaHack · Yesterday 07:09

Motnight · Yesterday 07:08

She's broken boundaries. Her having a key cut without consent means that she is happily planning to break more boundaries.

No it doesn't. It might mean she thought she was being helpful.

JustaSongAboutPingPong · Yesterday 07:10

Motnight · Yesterday 07:08

She's broken boundaries. Her having a key cut without consent means that she is happily planning to break more boundaries.

Totally agree. Next she’ll be coming around to move your furniture because “it looks better that way” or go into your bedroom and “rearrange the things in your drawers” or other bonkers things my “D”M did until we changed the locks.

damemaggiescurledupperlip · Yesterday 07:12

I’d change the alarm code rather than the lock.

rhen she’ll
be massively caught out if she tries to sneak in when you’re out.

CherryBlossom321 · Yesterday 07:13

Whilst I can understand why people suggest changing the locks instead, I think it’s important that you and husband actually speak to her to claim it back - an overstep like this could just pave the way for future problems of a similar nature unless she is confronted directly.

damemaggiescurledupperlip · Yesterday 07:15

Or get a Ring camera so you can see what she does. After all, if she has the key but never tries to use it for the next 10 years , it would indicate that she really was only trying to be helpful about future emergencies, however tone-deaf

Moonnstarz · Yesterday 07:16

I think it's the slyness of getting the key cut and mentioning it afterwards that's the issue some posters don't seem to get.
She kept the initial key longer than necessary and without reason (she was by my take only looking after the grandchild one afternoon, yet somehow kept hold of the key for 3 days). If she had been looking after the little one and had then said, I was thinking maybe it would be useful if I had my own key, then that would be a fair comment.
To take the key and then report back that she had made a copy seems strange.
I think because she was secretive over this it does make you wonder what she would want the key for - maybe it is innocent and she is thinking of if they ever get locked out then she would have a copy, or maybe it is because she is someone who doesn't understand boundaries and would use the key to let herself in, maybe when OP and her husband aren't there and again 'helpfully' tidying up (as someone else posted above...also known as snooping, and then being the one who is left upset when confronted, again claiming only wanting to be useful).

Booboobagins · Yesterday 07:17

Change the lock and be done with it.

ItsWouldHaveNotWouldOf · Yesterday 07:19

OneMoreProfiterole · Yesterday 03:20

To be clear, we don't rely on her for childcare. We have a childminder. This was a one off occasion that we actually didn't need her for but she volunteered to spend time with child.

Useful free childcare? Where does she say that?

The OP contradicted herself as her first sentence said We gave a key to MIL as we needed some help with school collection and minding of our little boy this afternoon. So in the first sentence OP needed help with collection and minding, and later said they didn't actually need her.

At most OP I'd either get your DH to have a word about how inappropriate it was or, if you've feel inclined, get the barrel changed in the lock. However, if you have a Ring doorbell, it will alert you if someone comes to your door, so you'll see if MIL ever tries to use it when you're not there.

TheGreatDownandOut · Yesterday 07:20

JMSA · Yesterday 03:11

Wouldn’t bother me at all.

I’m glad the free childcare was useful to you though.

Let me guess…. You’ve copied someone’s front door key without their consent hence this response?

Its not normal behaviour. It is a massive overstep.

FOJN · Yesterday 07:26

Why are so many posters telling OP that family members holding spare keys is normal. No one cares if you choose to give your entire extended family and the whole street a spare key. The issue is that MIL was given a key to use for a few hours and decided to cut herself a spare without asking. That's not OK. I wouldn't change the locks but I would ask for the key back. I would tell her I was not happy that she'd made a copy without asking.

tomorrowfollowstoday · Yesterday 07:28

Solmum1964 · Yesterday 00:08

I would also change the locks but go for a brand like Ultion where you have to have a code to get more cut.

This is what I would do too.
It's annoying but it solves the problem.

AvidMauveCrab · Yesterday 07:28

YANBU. Ask for the key back.

FOJN · Yesterday 07:30

ItsWouldHaveNotWouldOf · Yesterday 07:19

The OP contradicted herself as her first sentence said We gave a key to MIL as we needed some help with school collection and minding of our little boy this afternoon. So in the first sentence OP needed help with collection and minding, and later said they didn't actually need her.

At most OP I'd either get your DH to have a word about how inappropriate it was or, if you've feel inclined, get the barrel changed in the lock. However, if you have a Ring doorbell, it will alert you if someone comes to your door, so you'll see if MIL ever tries to use it when you're not there.

I interpreted that sentence to mean that OP could easily have made other arrangements for school collection and after school care but MIL offered because she wanted to spend time with her grandchild so OP accepted. In that sense they didn't NEED her for childcare.

PerfectPaula · Yesterday 07:31

Opus3 · Yesterday 00:04

Change the locks. What an odd thing for her to do.

That's expensive and unnecessary. Just ask for it back. Or let her keep it for emergencies (it might come in really useful if ever you are locked out or need her to go there on your behalf at short notice) but get a Ring doorbell camera so she can never let herself in without you knowing about it.

TheBlueKoala · Yesterday 07:31

To all those saying that it's normal for relatives to have spare keys- you are missing the point here!

@TiredAF123 My Mil has a key to our house because we have given her one. If she would have taken it upon herself to make a copy I would have been outraged!!! Take it back immediately !! (Send dh).

Theroadt · Yesterday 07:33

Change the locks but have a key hide with combi in case of emergencies.

Thegirlwhowent · Yesterday 07:35

I can see that maybe MIL thought she was being helpful and she probably didn't give it enough thought to realise what an overstep it was. I think you will both (or DH?) have to explain that you're not happy with her having a key. Maybe frame it as not being happy with anybody having a key?