Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Existing PIP awards for under 25 should be honoured

429 replies

HonourExistingClaimants · Today 12:55

If changes have to be made there needs to be a clear date for changes for new claims from that point. Existing claims should be honoured till the review date and then changed.

Surely anything else would be really wrong?

OP posts:
placemats · Today 14:40

needastrongone · Today 13:16

From listening to Alan Milburn’s speech, listening to a lot of his interviews in the media recently, those claimants with the greatest level of need will receive an enhanced package of support, with fewer reviews.

Yes this is key. It makes no sense to constantly review those with long term health conditions from birth as it's a waste of money and time.

Ubertomusic · Today 14:40

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 14:20

I agree but that needs to be sorted first and when where in a position where people can get proper long term treatment within a few weeks then they can talk about taking money away you don't take people's income away before you sort out the state of the nhs and social care. If you needed surgery and couldn't work until you had it but the waiting list was years long what would you do?

No one is going to sort out the NHS. It's much easier to rob the helpless.

(NHS is probably beyond repair anyway)

BooksAndHooks · Today 14:41

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 13:45

This news is great. It’s all about getting disabled people off benefits and into work, giving them a proper future to look forward to. What is the issue? Why the negativity? A life on benefits is surely the worst possible option for someone.

PIP is not an out of work benefit. Working has nothing to do with it, many disabled do work. The changes mean those under 25 will not be entitled to PIP or the youth allowance if they work, meaning they have no support for the cost of their disability, no carers as carers allowance is also lost and they are expected to manage the additional cost of their disabilities whilst often earning minimum wage or lower wage due to reduced hours. This means the PIP often used to be able to work at all will make it more difficult to work at all.

lifeturnsonadime · Today 14:41

Survivingnotthriving24 · Today 14:22

I will never be able to wrap my head around age being a protected characteristic of the equality act, yet it's perfectly acceptable to propose things like this and NMW being lower for young people. That's before we get to the ableism, why are the disabled being targeted and not the lazy? I'd rather see all benefits removed from those that do not seek opportunities that would allow them to support themselves and contribute to society, despite being perfectly capable of doing so.

I am certain it will be challenged legally on this basis.

BooksAndHooks · Today 14:43

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 14:03

The vast majority of people receiving PIP don’t work. And look at the person described above whose PIP goes entirely on care services whereas others without the care needs get to keep the cash. Why on earth aren’t we supplying the services rather than cash? It would be much fairer.

There are many hidden costs of disability that are not as simple as a service.

Itchthescratch · Today 14:44

If you reform the system then it should apply equally to everyone otherwise you end up with a two tier system where two people with exactly the same level for impairment are eligible for different levels of state benefit. That's obviously unfair and I don't see how anyone can support this

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 14:45

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 13:25

I can’t imagine past PIP claims would be honoured. The whole point is to get people off benefits and out working. The truly profoundly disabled will get enhanced packages. Those with mental health issues will be given treatment instead of cash and be expected to work. Let’s hope they roll it out to all age groups as soon as possible many disabled want help to get out working.

“Those with mental health issues will be given treatment instead of cash and be expected to work”

Sounds easy when you say it like that. I look forward to being cured after 45 years of mental illness.

DontEatTheMushies · Today 14:45

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 13:45

This news is great. It’s all about getting disabled people off benefits and into work, giving them a proper future to look forward to. What is the issue? Why the negativity? A life on benefits is surely the worst possible option for someone.

By taking away extra money that provides them the equity to start from a similar point to all of those without a disability?

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 14:46

lifeturnsonadime · Today 14:40

It's a good job that THAT is the purpose of pip isn't it?

To support people to be able to work.

I am not sure what part of it not being an 'out of work' benefit you are not grasping here!!!

Most people who get PIP don’t work. I’m not sure what you’re not understanding here.

LakieLady · Today 14:47

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 13:25

I can’t imagine past PIP claims would be honoured. The whole point is to get people off benefits and out working. The truly profoundly disabled will get enhanced packages. Those with mental health issues will be given treatment instead of cash and be expected to work. Let’s hope they roll it out to all age groups as soon as possible many disabled want help to get out working.

Given treatment? I'd like to know how, and how quickly.

It took 5 years for CAMHS to get round to assessing my friend's son, and he's never had anything resembling treatment or therapy. He's 18 now, and friend can't even get an answer as to whether he's been transferred to adult MH services.

He desperately needs EMDR therapy for PTSD (among other things), and the wait for that is 3-5 years in our NHS trust. If he has to go to the bottom of the waiting list again, I think my friend will need MH support as she's under tremendous stress from caring for him.

They've both been fucked over by successive governments, and it seems that this one is going to fuck them over even more.

Periperi2025 · Today 14:47

TravellingSpoon · Today 13:06

If it comes in, what will happen to the undreds of families, ours included, who use PIP towards a motability car? And those who claim carers allowance?

Presumably you would have a car anyway as the majority of people in the UK do.
When my Dad had a brain tumour we quickly and easily sourced a second hand Berlingo with a ramp and sold it again no problem when he died a year later. Probably best to get in quick though if you need an adapted vehicle as the cost of second hand ones will presumably start the rise with these changes.

WiddlinDiddlin · Today 14:47

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 14:07

Yes and alan Milburn has specifically said that instead of cash benefits those with certain conditions (ADHD, anxiety etc) should be given help to overcome them.

That support, help, therapy, treatment should already exist, along with many many other things the NHS is supposed to supply.

It doesn't, and until the government prove they can actually do this - by doing it - taking away benefits should be off the table entirely.

Remember the Community Care Act 1990? Closing all those psychiatric hospitals, old asylums, institutions, awful places that many were, was going to free up resources to look after people in the community...

It didn't. It was a fucking disaster. It resulted in homelessness, poverty, as funds were siphoned off elsewhere or simply never materialised in the first place, a burden on the community health care system and social work teams that could not handle it... more crises, more detentions under the mental health act...

This will be the same.

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 14:48

BooksAndHooks · Today 14:41

PIP is not an out of work benefit. Working has nothing to do with it, many disabled do work. The changes mean those under 25 will not be entitled to PIP or the youth allowance if they work, meaning they have no support for the cost of their disability, no carers as carers allowance is also lost and they are expected to manage the additional cost of their disabilities whilst often earning minimum wage or lower wage due to reduced hours. This means the PIP often used to be able to work at all will make it more difficult to work at all.

Only 20% of people on PIP work.

Happyindevon · Today 14:48

LakieLady · Today 14:47

Given treatment? I'd like to know how, and how quickly.

It took 5 years for CAMHS to get round to assessing my friend's son, and he's never had anything resembling treatment or therapy. He's 18 now, and friend can't even get an answer as to whether he's been transferred to adult MH services.

He desperately needs EMDR therapy for PTSD (among other things), and the wait for that is 3-5 years in our NHS trust. If he has to go to the bottom of the waiting list again, I think my friend will need MH support as she's under tremendous stress from caring for him.

They've both been fucked over by successive governments, and it seems that this one is going to fuck them over even more.

What is the PTSD from ?

Itchthescratch · Today 14:48

BooksAndHooks · Today 14:43

There are many hidden costs of disability that are not as simple as a service.

Yes, but I have literally debated with someone on MN about how her PIP being spent on beauty treatments was a completely valid use of taxpayer money. She stated that she would paint her nails herself if she wasn't disabled but because she couldn't do this anymore, she had to pay £50 a month to get them done professionally. According to her this was a legitimate extra cost associated with her disability. The fact that the people funding these salon visits through their taxes often couldn't afford to go to the salon themselves or even find the time to paint their own nail was apparently irrelevant. At this point I became very cynical about how some people viewed 'extra costs' associated with their disability.

lifeturnsonadime · Today 14:49

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 14:46

Most people who get PIP don’t work. I’m not sure what you’re not understanding here.

Well I know a few people who are on PIP and also work/ go to university.

In fact I don't personally know anyone on PIP who doesn't work, although I know that there are people who are!

What makes you think that taking support away from disabled people will help them to get jobs? You, like all supporters of this, appear to be oblivious to what the purpose of PIP is.

Attacking and removing support from the disabled/ vulnerable is not something one should expect from a civilised society. No issue with looking at benefits but removing from the vulnerable will be a low blow, especially from what is supposedly a Labour government.

CatchALeaf · Today 14:50

KitsyWitsy · Today 13:49

Oh come on. People without disabilities find it hard enough finding work. What will happen is disabled people will now not be able to find/do work AND won't have enough money to live on.

Exactly this, no employer will take them on, or they won't cope in work, and they will be denied benefits, then what

mummymeister · Today 14:50

Around 15% of PIP claimants work. so that means 85% do not - the overwhelming majority. I am on a local gossip facebook forum. every day - yes every single day - someone posts asking how they can get an adhd or whatever diagnosis so that they can go on PIP and get more money as they arent working and unemployment benefits arent enough.

and other posters say they will private message them with their PIP forms so that they can lie and know what to put.

If you think this isnt going on across the whole country, then you are deluded.

we have a limited amount of money. do you want it spent keeping the 85% not working or do you want those that can never work due to their disability getting more money and those that can work being helped into work or do you want us to be where we are now. Its an absolute timebomb no one is talking about. if this many under 25s arent in work now they will never work. they will never pay taxes and those of us on this forum over 50 will never see pensions because of it.

I hope Millburn grows a pair unlike starmer and tells his back benchers who oppose this to fuck off.

I do not begrudge paying extortionate taxes if they go to people who genuinely cannot ever work. I would pay more to help them. but currently I know I am paying for a load of people to sit on their arses, watch daytime telly and hang out in spoons because they can.

Sadcafe · Today 14:50

Whatever people think of the reports proposal, the reality of the situation is the welfare budget is destroying the country, it is bigger than the combined health and education budget and is simply unaffordable in the long term

TemperanceWest · Today 14:51

Happyindevon · Today 14:48

What is the PTSD from ?

Why do you feel the need to know?

lifeturnsonadime · Today 14:51

I'd have more support for removing child benefit than for this. People make a conscious decision to have children, which should include working out if they can afford it. No one chooses to be disabled.

Itchthescratch · Today 14:52

lifeturnsonadime · Today 14:49

Well I know a few people who are on PIP and also work/ go to university.

In fact I don't personally know anyone on PIP who doesn't work, although I know that there are people who are!

What makes you think that taking support away from disabled people will help them to get jobs? You, like all supporters of this, appear to be oblivious to what the purpose of PIP is.

Attacking and removing support from the disabled/ vulnerable is not something one should expect from a civilised society. No issue with looking at benefits but removing from the vulnerable will be a low blow, especially from what is supposedly a Labour government.

Edited

The majority of people that receive state benefits are vulnerable. They are either old, disabled, in poor health or have other factors that make them vulnerable. Those that aren't vulnerable are often paid far less in benefits, they are subject to benefits caps and often they are working and need benefits to top up their wages.

If you are serious about looking at benefits the. You have to look at benefits for vulnerable people. This is where the vast majority of money is spent.

TigerRag · Today 14:52

Sadcafe · Today 14:50

Whatever people think of the reports proposal, the reality of the situation is the welfare budget is destroying the country, it is bigger than the combined health and education budget and is simply unaffordable in the long term

Half of the welfare bill is pensions

Happyindevon · Today 14:53

mummymeister · Today 14:50

Around 15% of PIP claimants work. so that means 85% do not - the overwhelming majority. I am on a local gossip facebook forum. every day - yes every single day - someone posts asking how they can get an adhd or whatever diagnosis so that they can go on PIP and get more money as they arent working and unemployment benefits arent enough.

and other posters say they will private message them with their PIP forms so that they can lie and know what to put.

If you think this isnt going on across the whole country, then you are deluded.

we have a limited amount of money. do you want it spent keeping the 85% not working or do you want those that can never work due to their disability getting more money and those that can work being helped into work or do you want us to be where we are now. Its an absolute timebomb no one is talking about. if this many under 25s arent in work now they will never work. they will never pay taxes and those of us on this forum over 50 will never see pensions because of it.

I hope Millburn grows a pair unlike starmer and tells his back benchers who oppose this to fuck off.

I do not begrudge paying extortionate taxes if they go to people who genuinely cannot ever work. I would pay more to help them. but currently I know I am paying for a load of people to sit on their arses, watch daytime telly and hang out in spoons because they can.

I see this all the time too. And agree with all you’ve said.

Happyindevon · Today 14:54

TemperanceWest · Today 14:51

Why do you feel the need to know?

Don’t tell me, school …