Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Existing PIP awards for under 25 should be honoured

429 replies

HonourExistingClaimants · Today 12:55

If changes have to be made there needs to be a clear date for changes for new claims from that point. Existing claims should be honoured till the review date and then changed.

Surely anything else would be really wrong?

OP posts:
plasticplate · Today 13:58

ilovebrie8 · Today 13:53

The amount his is receiving in a month must be about £1800 per month as a rough guess.

Pip in a month would be £843 per month if you work out a monthly equivalent.

UC with disabled would be even more.

Genuinely, that is a heck of a lot for someone of 19.

He clearly cannot work; but how can benefits be so high when your ordinary person doesn’t make that in a month working full time?

Under the new system he is likely to get a higher amount in benefits so the type of comment you are making is pointless.

Heatedblankettime · Today 13:58

TigerRag · Today 13:56

PIP is for the extra costs of being disabled. The average cost of which is over £1000 per month

But it's not a binary of disabled /not disabled. Lots of people who don't get benefits will have all kinds of additional costs in their lives due to chronic health problems/other adversity.

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 13:58

Heatedblankettime · Today 13:54

I disagree. I reckon I have at least 3 different conditions that would qualify me for PIp and indeed given me an excuse not to work. I do work but mainly spend the rest of my life housebound and recovering. And yes they cost me more, but people go through all sorts of adversity in life that costs them. That's just part of life

I am so glad I have chosen to work (and grateful to my supportive employers). I have a career, a network of friends and colleagues and a decent pension fund.

We need better legislation so everyone can experience the same support to work I have. But we should be enabling people to work wherever possible

Agreed. And I look at so many parents and think about what confining their child to a life on benefits is doing. Yes some people are severely disabled and unable to work, but the answer to anxiety/ depression / high functioning asd is absolutely NOT a life of benefits but being helped to cope with life and working.

KitsyWitsy · Today 14:00

ilovebrie8 · Today 13:53

The amount his is receiving in a month must be about £1800 per month as a rough guess.

Pip in a month would be £843 per month if you work out a monthly equivalent.

UC with disabled would be even more.

Genuinely, that is a heck of a lot for someone of 19.

He clearly cannot work; but how can benefits be so high when your ordinary person doesn’t make that in a month working full time?

my son gets about 900 UC and 500 pip plus notability car. The pip payment goes entirely back to the council for his care package. He doesn't get to keep it and that will be the case for a lot of people who receive care packages from the council. Other people who don't have the expenses or need for a care package can indeed just keep the money and do whatever. Quite a disparity really. My son doesn't have money to pay for anything big that he needs and so we still have to support him.

TheodoreisntBeth · Today 14:00

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 13:58

Agreed. And I look at so many parents and think about what confining their child to a life on benefits is doing. Yes some people are severely disabled and unable to work, but the answer to anxiety/ depression / high functioning asd is absolutely NOT a life of benefits but being helped to cope with life and working.

How many times? Claiming PIP is not a life on benefits! It supports many disabled people to be able to work. It's not for living off it's for the extra expenses of being disabled

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 14:03

TheodoreisntBeth · Today 14:00

How many times? Claiming PIP is not a life on benefits! It supports many disabled people to be able to work. It's not for living off it's for the extra expenses of being disabled

The vast majority of people receiving PIP don’t work. And look at the person described above whose PIP goes entirely on care services whereas others without the care needs get to keep the cash. Why on earth aren’t we supplying the services rather than cash? It would be much fairer.

Moonlightfrog · Today 14:05

PestoPastaPizza · Today 13:11

I have a 19 year old with severe learning disabilities and autism who needs constant support. He will never live independently or work. He has no sense of stranger danger, no roadsense, can't shower without support etc
He gets UC with disabled element and high rate PIP for mobility and care.

I'd love to know how he is supposed to come off benefits and work?

I am in the same position with dd2 (20), she will never work without a huge amount of support (1:1) and won’t live independently. As a single parent I am her full time care and claiming carers allowance, she also has a mobility car. I a, scared all this will get taken away. she’s currently in a 3 day educational placement and attends a day centre once a week that she pays for out of her benefits (£68 a week). If her benefits stop then she can’t attend day service, if we lose her mobility car I can’t get her to day service. I will lose career allowance and will be made to job search and to attend the job centre, which I can’t do whilst caring for dd. The fear of being possibly made homeless, carless and unable to fund her care costs is awful.

I know severely disabled young people will likely keep their benefits, but where is the cut off line? Who decided who is severely disabled enough and who isn’t?

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 14:05

People won't suddenly become not disabled because their not getting pip it just means all they will do is pass the cost on to the nhs,social care and local councils. Which means longer waiting lists, higher council tax. All will cause more disability to people who are currently healthy. Less people in work will mean more on different types off benefits

Chewbecca · Today 14:06

No, because all claims should be reassessed regularly anyway.

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 14:07

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 14:05

People won't suddenly become not disabled because their not getting pip it just means all they will do is pass the cost on to the nhs,social care and local councils. Which means longer waiting lists, higher council tax. All will cause more disability to people who are currently healthy. Less people in work will mean more on different types off benefits

Yes and alan Milburn has specifically said that instead of cash benefits those with certain conditions (ADHD, anxiety etc) should be given help to overcome them.

yogzig · Today 14:08

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 13:27

Oh and disability assessments will be taken from the NHS and given to the job centre.

NHS don’t do assessments for benefits?

DisabilityCosts · Today 14:09

Heatedblankettime · Today 13:45

I do know that

But I am also very aware of the advice given out to people to teach them to game the system by embellishing and exaggerating in their applications

But herein lies the issue. Many, many, bodily disabled people get no help because they are able to get on with their lives, they might struggle, its really bloody hard, but they carry on despite it, and it costs them more than an able person in terms of medical requirements, often mobility, and definitely at cost to their mental health and daily fatigue. However, with certain mental health issues, the points system favours the lack of, and I'm struggling to find the right word, but of "incentive", if you like. I'm not knocking the mental health aspect, mental health can severely impact your life, but you can score so many points from just being demotivated to engage in life. When a person with, extreme example, an amputee, wouldn't qualify for help if they can get out of bed, wash, cook, do their banking etc, because they are motivated to do it all themselves.

I'm not articulating very well, but having had a child who has recently joined the disabled community and doesn't qualify for anything, I am somewhat aghast at the criteria for assistance.

KitsyWitsy · Today 14:10

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 14:07

Yes and alan Milburn has specifically said that instead of cash benefits those with certain conditions (ADHD, anxiety etc) should be given help to overcome them.

But they won't will they? People on the Humber bridge threatening to throw themselves off are supposed to get help but they are there all the time. They don't actually get proper help and neither will people losing their PIP. But I agree in principle, a lot of people who receive pip don't use it for their health condition and don't pay for therapy help.

TigerRag · Today 14:10

Chewbecca · Today 14:06

No, because all claims should be reassessed regularly anyway.

Why? I was recently reassessed for LCWRA. It was a waste of time. I still can't, like last time, read large print. What I have is incurable. I'm only going to get worse as I get older

Motnight · Today 14:12

needastrongone · Today 13:32

In answer, the government has accepted the report in full (or as far as I can tell in full, listening to Pat McFadden’s response in the Commons).

And existing claimants will be affected, to a previous poster.

Thank you, I didn't know that

x2boys · Today 14:12

Chewbecca · Today 14:06

No, because all claims should be reassessed regularly anyway.

All claimants?
My son is 16 with severe autism and learning disabillties hes cogntivly around 2 or3 totally non verbal and can only conmunicate very basic needs
I think its clear that his needs are not going to change
What would your justification be for him to be reassesed regularly.?

BoredBug · Today 14:13

I understood the review as a way to reduce people using ADHD/Anxiety as a reason to not work.

It says severely disabled people will continue to be supported, as they should and the young people mentioned in this thread seem severely disabled, 24/7 support, constant supervision etc

Maybe I am being naïve.

Ubertomusic · Today 14:13

bababamama · Today 13:22

one, this was a report rather than the legal process to change the law, anyone already with an award will have years before by change due to time it takes to pass laws and implementation. Two, people with severe disability will be protected, I’ve already spoken to my mp about this. By severe we are talking about conditions with 24/7 pain, mobility so limited that they cannot operate a conventional keyboard needing special equipment, learning disabilities requiring full time support, multiple seizures a day requiring 24/7 supervision… my dsd comes into several of these categories, hence asking my mp when I happened to have opportunity last week.

The groups affected will be people like my dd who have asd, bright, capable of work but mental health fluctuating and hitting rock bottom at some points requiring hospitalisation. Though with a supportive employer, adaptations and a no nonsense approach from me, she is now working in creative role - in all honesty she could have been neet if she hadn’t been pushed gently encouraged to work over and over again and my attitude that we manage to work (all neurodivergent here) do so must she (I also forced her to school daily despite her rarely making it past 11am at one point, after 6 months or so they got her to a point she would stay.

Where do you usually find supportive employers?

plasticplate · Today 14:13

Chewbecca · Today 14:06

No, because all claims should be reassessed regularly anyway.

One of the points in the review is that this isn't needed for some claims.

Simonjt · Today 14:15

Chewbecca · Today 14:06

No, because all claims should be reassessed regularly anyway.

Yeah, we don’t want limbs growing back, or down syndrome being cured to slip through the net.

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 14:15

Ubertomusic · Today 14:13

Where do you usually find supportive employers?

I think we should bring in mandatory requirements for businesses over a certain size to meet certain levels of disabled employees.

luckylavender · Today 14:15

PestoPastaPizza · Today 13:11

I have a 19 year old with severe learning disabilities and autism who needs constant support. He will never live independently or work. He has no sense of stranger danger, no roadsense, can't shower without support etc
He gets UC with disabled element and high rate PIP for mobility and care.

I'd love to know how he is supposed to come off benefits and work?

But that is not what is being suggested

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 14:15

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 14:07

Yes and alan Milburn has specifically said that instead of cash benefits those with certain conditions (ADHD, anxiety etc) should be given help to overcome them.

Im pretty sure waiting lists for things like adhd are already 2 plus years long. I don't know how long waiting lists are for cbt for anxiety. I have bpd and the gold standard treatment is dbt and they don't even offer it in my area so I can't have it. We don't all live in big cities with all these resources

Ubertomusic · Today 14:16

Heatedblankettime · Today 13:27

We have to shift away from the "handouts for everything" culture. It's created a country of people who don't want to work. So yes it will be painful but it needs to happen

Benefits should be a safety net not a lifestyle choice

Is your disability a lifestyle choice?

HermioneWeasley · Today 14:16

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 14:07

Yes and alan Milburn has specifically said that instead of cash benefits those with certain conditions (ADHD, anxiety etc) should be given help to overcome them.

And rightly so. It’s a disgrace to park people with these conditions on benefits as opposed to help with treatment or coping mechanisms