Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Existing PIP awards for under 25 should be honoured

479 replies

HonourExistingClaimants · Today 12:55

If changes have to be made there needs to be a clear date for changes for new claims from that point. Existing claims should be honoured till the review date and then changed.

Surely anything else would be really wrong?

OP posts:
BurntBroccoli · Today 19:00

AirborneElephant · Today 17:43

That’s a really misleading statistic. The total cost of disability benefits is now more like £77bn, and projected to reach £120bn by 2030. It’s not some small number that we can keep ignoring, it needs major change right now.

The thread is about PIP

BruFord · Today 19:01

On the other side of the argument, I also know a couple of people IRL who likely are eligible for some support but don't/won't claim it!

A friend's son in his early 20's has significant LD and is functionally illiterate. He has a manual job and probably would be eligible for PIP but has never applied for it (obviously his parents would need to help him do this). Similarly, I have elderly relatives who won't apply for Attendance Allowance. Some people don't want to.

Kirbert2 · Today 19:05

campingwoes · Today 18:56

I saw this:

A new, higher-rate long-term payment (above current maximum benefit rates) with no qualifying period and no expectation of work, reserved for young people with the most profound disabilities or 24-hour care needs.

So he probably won't be expected to work or train if he can't. I'm sure there will be plenty of case by case families that will need specialist help transitioning to the new system but overall I think the recommendations seem sensible.

and that is why plenty of parents of even severely disabled children/young people are worried.

'probably' etc isn't very comforting.

Shardonneigghhh · Today 19:07

Talkingtomyhouseplants · Today 18:43

Of course - but I think that’s kind of the point of the reforms. It’s less money in their pocket but more money for other things to get them in work (scheme and apprenticeships - the devil will be in the detail as always). I suppose the reasoning is a 20 yo living at home doesn’t really need a lot of money

A 20 year old disabled person living at home is still an adult. They need to be able to provide for themselves, or have the financial means for someone to support them to provide for themselves.
A parent of a disabled child may have to reduce hours or give up work to care for them, as well as provide for the additional expenditure associated with their specific disability. DLA and Carers element/allowance offsets these costs. Then the child turns 16 and ages out of DLA. They may still be education until 19 or longer. They are still disabled. Their care needs haven't changed, meaning their parents cannot earn more money. The household costs have not reduced. But now there are no disability benefits but the the same, often higher bills to pay (increased food and clothing costs, transport to post 16 education etc). The 16 year old is unable to get a part time job due to their needs. Now what? The expectation on the parents to support them indefinitely, or at least until 25 when they can apply for PIP.
It will be the parents propping up the gap, whether they can afford it or not.

LakieLady · Today 19:13

Itchthescratch · Today 15:17

The percentage of people claiming disability benefits wasn't so high in the past and there was also less recognition of milder conditions. Many cases of ADHD and ASD were missed entirely. This combines to make people more suspicious of just how impaired some people are that are claiming disability benefits or not working. ADHD and anxiety are the new 'bad back'.

A young person can triple their benefits if they qualify for the highest level of disability benefit. Like it or not, there is a clear incentive for people with dodgy intentions to try and maximise their payouts.

Some academics have posited the theory that, as medicine and neonatal care have advanced, children with lifelong disabling conditions survive to adulthood that would not have made it a few decades ago.

That might account for some of the increase in adults with disabilities.

WeatherDependant · Today 19:15

PestoPastaPizza · Today 13:11

I have a 19 year old with severe learning disabilities and autism who needs constant support. He will never live independently or work. He has no sense of stranger danger, no roadsense, can't shower without support etc
He gets UC with disabled element and high rate PIP for mobility and care.

I'd love to know how he is supposed to come off benefits and work?

He won’t, obviously. Those with severe needs will still be looked after

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 19:17

BruFord · Today 19:01

On the other side of the argument, I also know a couple of people IRL who likely are eligible for some support but don't/won't claim it!

A friend's son in his early 20's has significant LD and is functionally illiterate. He has a manual job and probably would be eligible for PIP but has never applied for it (obviously his parents would need to help him do this). Similarly, I have elderly relatives who won't apply for Attendance Allowance. Some people don't want to.

why would you take money from the state if you didn’t need it? Not everyone is grabby.

hibernatinghedgehog · Today 19:17

Toomanyminifigs · Today 16:56

Benefits and Work have done a very helpful breakdown of all the proposed changes to PIP for young people.

I'm not sure if this has been picked up in the thread yet but it looks like the government is proposing to extend DLA to 18. I have long suspected this was coming. Given the increase in the number of DLA claims, it would seem a logical move to try and 'stop the flow' of those DC moving on to PIP so in the long term the numbers of people on disability benefits naturally decreases.

I also imagine there's not much political appetite to tackle DLA claims as 'going for' disabled children probably isn't great optics. So the idea - rather like what they're proposing with EHCPs will be that DC/YP will lose their entitlement to both at a transfer phase.

https://benefitsandwork.co.uk/news/milburn-review-final-report

Don’t be so sure that DLA is safe. Have a read of Child Disability Living Allowance: A Policy Exchange Research Note and the comments by Jean-André Prager who is one of the Timms review steering group.

Raising the age of DLA to 18 was mooted a few years ago then dropped off. I am surprised it hasn’t already happened. Existing CDP claimants in Scotland can stay on CDP until 18.

ThreadGuardDog · Today 19:19

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 13:27

Oh and disability assessments will be taken from the NHS and given to the job centre.

Disability assessments are not the job of the NHS now. DWP employ NHS staff as assessors via independent assessment providers and have done for a number of years. They report directly to DWP decision makers.

Chikenpotpoe · Today 19:21

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 13:32

That’s not correct. It has been stated that it will affect all current young claimants.

If that's true I find that appalling. It must be giving a lot of people anxiety. I am over 25 and don't claim PIP or know anyone under 25 that does but I think it's shocking.

ThreadGuardDog · Today 19:21

BurntBroccoli · Today 19:00

The thread is about PIP

Agree. Disability benefits are being deliberately conflated with out of work sickness benefits. The overall cost of them is £77b but PIP, which is what we’re talking about here, is £28b. And it’s worth noting that that £77b is half of what it costs to support adults and children across the benefits system.

Blackcat2026 · Today 19:22

BurntBroccoli · Today 17:23

Tax burden pensioners
£177 billion

Tax burden PIP
£27.3 billion

Pensioners who have worked, whether they wanted to or not, and contributed in taxation.

ThreadGuardDog · Today 19:23

Blackcat2026 · Today 19:22

Pensioners who have worked, whether they wanted to or not, and contributed in taxation.

With respect, PIP claimants will have contributed through taxation too.

BurntBroccoli · Today 19:25

LakieLady · Today 18:25

If you are serious about looking at benefits the. You have to look at benefits for vulnerable people. This is where the vast majority of money is spent.

I'd like to know how much of the "benefit bill" is housing costs. It's the biggest single item in the vast majority of UC claims I've looked at.

My SDIL rents a 2-bed flat for her and her daughter. She works and only gets UC because her housing costs are £1,300 a month for a 2-bed flat; if she was in social housing her rent would be half that and her UC entitlement would be negligible.

Yes - this payment is often forgotten about as if the claimant could spend this on whatever they wanted.

A huge proportion of tax payers’ money is going to private landlords as there isn’t enough housing.

Shardonneigghhh · Today 19:26

With regard to disability, I don't think whether someone has contributed to tax or not should matter. Why would we not want our taxes to look after those who cannot look after themselves?

Lambch0p · Today 19:27

Blackcat2026 · Today 19:22

Pensioners who have worked, whether they wanted to or not, and contributed in taxation.

Not all of them,plenty have not paid taxes prior to retirement.

Chikenpotpoe · Today 19:27

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 13:25

I can’t imagine past PIP claims would be honoured. The whole point is to get people off benefits and out working. The truly profoundly disabled will get enhanced packages. Those with mental health issues will be given treatment instead of cash and be expected to work. Let’s hope they roll it out to all age groups as soon as possible many disabled want help to get out working.

Firstly PIP can be paid to people who work anyway. Some of those who will be stripped of it - assuming what you are saying is true - are workers.

Also many people with PIP for mental health issues whether they are working or not are already receiving therapy anyway and/or on medication.

Treatment doesn't instantly just solve things and do you honestly believe they will receive adequate treatment when you consider the strain the NHS/mental health services are under?

You can force as many disabled people into work as you want but is the workforce ready for proper reasonable adjustments?

BurntBroccoli · Today 19:29

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 18:52

20% of people in Blackpool, Hartlepool and Liverpool are on PIP. So if it’s unbelievablely hard to get and most disabled people don’t qualify there must be a heck of a lot of people disabled in Liverpool for instance. Or a load of scammers.

Edited

Or that growing up in poverty has given them more health conditions…

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 19:30

Chikenpotpoe · Today 19:27

Firstly PIP can be paid to people who work anyway. Some of those who will be stripped of it - assuming what you are saying is true - are workers.

Also many people with PIP for mental health issues whether they are working or not are already receiving therapy anyway and/or on medication.

Treatment doesn't instantly just solve things and do you honestly believe they will receive adequate treatment when you consider the strain the NHS/mental health services are under?

You can force as many disabled people into work as you want but is the workforce ready for proper reasonable adjustments?

Edited

A very small fraction of PIP recipients work. And if you think that the 8.2% of English under 25s that currently claim PIP are so ill they can never work you are very naive.

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 19:32

BurntBroccoli · Today 19:29

Or that growing up in poverty has given them more health conditions…

But what’s your solution? Because currently we’re handing them money to lower their aspirations to a life on benefits. Millburn has produced a strategy to improve these people’s long term prospects and this thread is packed with whinging. Should we just palm them off with cash for life? Is that good for the person? Or the country?

ThisHazelPeer · Today 19:32

HonourExistingClaimants · Today 12:55

If changes have to be made there needs to be a clear date for changes for new claims from that point. Existing claims should be honoured till the review date and then changed.

Surely anything else would be really wrong?

I find it strange that there are whole generations of children who are disabled in some way. Why is this happening in the 21st century? Is it immunisations causing it? Is there something in the water? Is it because women are old when they have babies? Are we deliberately being poisoned by some airborne drug? There have always been disabled people, but definitely never in these absurd numbers. What will happen to these dependant children when their parents die?

Laura95167 · Today 19:32

Tbh OP what about anyone 18 - 25 needing it now or in the future

So if a child is disabled and leaves school the year they turn 19 and then struggle to find work or are unable to what are we expecting them to do until theyre 25 to survive? Baring in mind theyre legally no longer their parents responsibility?

BruFord · Today 19:32

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 19:17

why would you take money from the state if you didn’t need it? Not everyone is grabby.

@Ohmygiddygirl Because it would make their lives easier? Allow them to have taxis (they can't drive), for example, instead of going on the bus.

Many under-25's will fight to be independent as possible, thank goodness.

thatsgotit · Today 19:33

GiaGia16 · Today 15:15

Then the usual starving and workhouses hyperbole starts up

It's not hyperbole. A month or so ago a poster was advocating, in all seriousness, for a return to the workhouses on a thread not dissimilar in tone to this one. And there is food poverty in this country, whether you want to accept it or not. (If you don't believe me, google 'deaths from malnutrition in the UK'.) If you think that sounds far-fetched I suggest you check your privilege.

Mistymagic77 · Today 19:34

Isobel201 · Today 13:27

Existing claimaints won't be affected, it would only be for new claimants. They had already brought in some changes which doesn't affect me because I'm an existing claimant, like being able to make meals in microwaves that they have reduced the points needed for.

Yes they will - eventually.

Swipe left for the next trending thread