Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Existing PIP awards for under 25 should be honoured

494 replies

HonourExistingClaimants · Today 12:55

If changes have to be made there needs to be a clear date for changes for new claims from that point. Existing claims should be honoured till the review date and then changed.

Surely anything else would be really wrong?

OP posts:
BurntBroccoli · Today 18:17

Chiefunderling · Today 16:34

It’s not just completing a form though. You need to provide substantial legitimate evidence for everything you are claiming in the PIP form. This evidence is heavily scrutinised. You then get assessed, face to face or over the phone, by an assessor working for the DWP. This person is a healthcare professional employed by the DWP. This assessment will go over everything you put in the form & all the evidence you submitted. You can certainly lie in the form, but you won’t get PIP without a substantial amount of evidence to back up EVERYTHING you are claiming. Most of this evidence needs to come from professionals; Doctors, consultants, therapists, support workers, & Clinical Psychologists. You also need to give permission for the DWP to contact those treating you themselves.

There is a world of difference between applying for PIP & being successful in your application. In fact, many people who provide all of the above are still denied & end up in a tribunal (if they don’t take their owns lives first). Tribunals overturn approximately 60% of DWP PIP refusals. That tells us the DWP is not doing its job & is actually denying genuinely disabled people the money they need to survive. A tribunal panel is made up of multiple experts & a judge, & considers all the evidence provided in addition to your medical records. Scamming the system is incredibly hard to do. It’s so hard, genuine claimants are routinely denied PIP! This is the cold hard truth.

edited for typos.

Edited

Plus these interviews aren’t planned in. They will just call you randomly so you can’t prepare or get someone else to pretend they’re you. Very difficult to fake the questions they ask too.

LakieLady · Today 18:17

Happyindevon · Today 14:48

What is the PTSD from ?

His mother thinks it stems from falling through ice into a pond that was hidden by snow when he was very young, pre-school age. But his father was an utter arsehole and used to do things to frighten him, so impossible to be sure.

Then he was further traumatised by appalling bullying from a local child when he was on the school bus (they lived rurally, so all the local kids were bussed to secondary school). She used to explain in great detail how she was going to kill him.

He's autistic too, and is incredibly anxious about pretty much everything. He hides in his room when ever someone knocks on their door.

3DPrintedDragon · Today 18:18

FirmSnake · Today 17:57

What sort of holidays and hobbies can he manage? Are we talking knitting and a caravan park?

He went a a cruise earlier this year. With his family who organised it all. He just had to pack his clothing. He does some art at the groups he attends, and continues it at home if it is something that he enjoyed.

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 18:18

TigerRag · Today 18:16

Because some of us were just left to get on with it

I’m genuinely interested. What happened to you @TigerRag? Did you make it through school and get a job or have you never worked?

3DPrintedDragon · Today 18:21

Heatedblankettime · Today 17:57

And I work full time and pay taxes and claim no benefits yet I am too ill to holiday or have hobbies. So you can see why there's a need for debate and review . There's no binary here

Edited

Yes no binary.
My original point was to the PP that said you can't be too disabled to work yet also go on holiday, be in a relationship, have kids. All different things with different demands.

DecisionTime123 · Today 18:22

I've only skimmed so sorry if someone has already raised but why is the money for jobs going to large retailers etc? I saw a great suggestion earlier, use the allocated money for local authorities to employ young people! Put retirement ages back to 60-65, free up some jobs, and of course change NI contributions for under 25s. Surely all this needs examining rather than the gleeful pile on to YO on benefits etc.

Petalperfect · Today 18:24

My dc receives pip and I think it is generous and expected it to decrease over time. I don’t know if dc will be able to work full time and I know that I will probably be picking up the bill. There should be limitations to it those with severe needs should not be affected by this. I do know of someone who gave up full time work after a later in life diagnosis due to pip payments, this is what needs to change I think.

LakieLady · Today 18:25

If you are serious about looking at benefits the. You have to look at benefits for vulnerable people. This is where the vast majority of money is spent.

I'd like to know how much of the "benefit bill" is housing costs. It's the biggest single item in the vast majority of UC claims I've looked at.

My SDIL rents a 2-bed flat for her and her daughter. She works and only gets UC because her housing costs are £1,300 a month for a 2-bed flat; if she was in social housing her rent would be half that and her UC entitlement would be negligible.

Talkingtomyhouseplants · Today 18:30

Shardonneigghhh · Today 18:10

Who are the people the changes are aimed at? The kids whose parents have had to fight all the way through school to get the support they need? The ones who can't get a place at a specialist unit because they are too academically able yet they cannot cope in a mainstream school. The young people on the 7 year waiting list who get diagnosed and then immediately discharged with no support?

I recommend watching this.
These are the kids who cannot cope with school, and now will not be able to claim anything if they also can't cope with work. And it's their parents, predominantly their mothers, who will suffer for the rest of their lives in a multitude of ways because of it.

I’ve seen this - I’m fully aware of the difficulties some young people have in attending school and the impact it has on families as I work in a related field. I still think they should be given opportunities and support to find work and self actualise rather than write them off as incapable.

LakieLady · Today 18:32

GlomOfNit · Today 14:58

Me too. Mine is 15 so we still have PIP to claim for when he turns 16. I'm extremely nervous about how things will pan out. Our boys are never, ever going to be able to 'work' - any sort of work placement requires full time 1:1 supervision to stop absconding, accidents, etc. Essentially it's a daycare activity. I know I'll look back on my son's school years as the golden time, fraught though they have been occasionally.

What on earth are we meant to do with our adult children? Where and how will they live when we're gone?

I feel for you, and everyone in your position. It must be such a worry.

Someone I know had to get a full-time residential placement for her son eventually, when he got so big that she physically couldn't keep him safe.

3DPrintedDragon · Today 18:33

LakieLady · Today 18:25

If you are serious about looking at benefits the. You have to look at benefits for vulnerable people. This is where the vast majority of money is spent.

I'd like to know how much of the "benefit bill" is housing costs. It's the biggest single item in the vast majority of UC claims I've looked at.

My SDIL rents a 2-bed flat for her and her daughter. She works and only gets UC because her housing costs are £1,300 a month for a 2-bed flat; if she was in social housing her rent would be half that and her UC entitlement would be negligible.

A quick Google says housing support costs are 11.6% of the total welfare bill.

Meteorite87 · Today 18:36

@TofuTuesday wrote:
"Also what fantasy land are they living in in thinking there is any help at all for people with mental illness or emotional wellbeing needs? It’s impossible now let alone when it’s mandatory for people who were/are claiming."

Agreed.
It's difficult to get support when in a mental health crisis period, so how will there suddenly be enough money for every claimant who needs it to receive long-term, consistent treatment?

TheodoreisntBeth · Today 18:38

All these posters who know people who are boasting about scamming PIP, does it ever occur to you that they're lying to you, not to PIP?

I used to know a woman, very extrovert and confident, who'd loudly tell anyone that her daughter wasn't potty trained because she was too lazy to do it. Actually the daughter had a bowel issue but the mum would rather people think she was a lazy mother than tell people that, to preserve her daughter's privacy.

When I was too ill to work with anxiety and PTSD (from abuse which happened at work, irony) I used to tell people I was signed off because of a heart condition, because I didn't want to admit I had such crippling anxiety that I couldn't leave the house and had panic attacks in my sleep (and yes I was on both medication and therapy).

Some people think anxiety is what you feel about the dentist, actual diagnosed anxiety disorders can be extremely debilitating, and being open about them risks being judged by people like some posters on this thread, as being lazy or a scammer or that you have a bit of nervousness you can just get over.

You really don't know what's going on in other people's lives, and just because they tell you something, even boast about something, doesn't mean it's true.

Kirbert2 · Today 18:40

Talkingtomyhouseplants · Today 18:30

I’ve seen this - I’m fully aware of the difficulties some young people have in attending school and the impact it has on families as I work in a related field. I still think they should be given opportunities and support to find work and self actualise rather than write them off as incapable.

I think pp's point is that they are often written off and not given support way before that which makes it far more difficult when they do get older.

Shardonneigghhh · Today 18:40

Talkingtomyhouseplants · Today 18:30

I’ve seen this - I’m fully aware of the difficulties some young people have in attending school and the impact it has on families as I work in a related field. I still think they should be given opportunities and support to find work and self actualise rather than write them off as incapable.

Should they not be given opportunities and support to find work and self actualise as well as the financial support to survive independently as the disabled adults they are, whilst they find work and self actualise?

SupernaturalAddict · Today 18:41

My son is very likely to be one of the ones considered too complex to work. He was awarded pip at both enhanced rates on just the paperwork (lot's of documentation) and had high rates of both dla from age three years, without any appeals or reconsiderations etc (i've given those details to try to show how disabled he is and for how long it has been clear). He has severe autism, learning disability etc.

I don't believe for a second that he will end up with more money in his pocket so to speak (he doesn't/ can't look after his own money, he doesn't understand).

I'm concerned that they may award the profound/ complex insurance based on those who qualify for chc funding. We haven't applied for this for him yet as circumstances have meant that we have stopped most of our social care package while we get over a safeguarding incident and much of the health provision we have provided via his ehcp at the moment. We will have to start reintroducing social care in the next six months.

When he turns 19 or if we put in for a universal credit the LA will assess his contribution which will likely be most of his universal credit plus his daily living pip award (minus a small amount for disability related expenditure which the LA have to approve). He will get to keep the mobility component and roughly £100 a week to cover all costs inc food, gas, electricity, clothes, water, entertainment, transport, board/ rent and any disability expences the LA don't clear even though they exist. I will not be able to work still as he still requires constant care and supervision at all times when at home inc during the night when he wakes. It's at this point we had planned to apply/ fight for chc.

I do not believe that any money the Gov save from benefits will be trans to the nhs, la or any other agencies to improve the lives of anyone else not just the disabled. It never works like that (remember the millions on the brexit bus to be given to the nhs?).

I also wonder if the ability to claim the profound/ complex insurance or new benefit will then become an 'access' to other support outside of the state such as access passes/ queue skips at airports, theme parks etc or free carer passes with companies struggling to cope with demand and in some cases a large cost. I think if this goes through it'll be the start of many other changes.

Talkingtomyhouseplants · Today 18:43

Shardonneigghhh · Today 18:40

Should they not be given opportunities and support to find work and self actualise as well as the financial support to survive independently as the disabled adults they are, whilst they find work and self actualise?

Edited

Of course - but I think that’s kind of the point of the reforms. It’s less money in their pocket but more money for other things to get them in work (scheme and apprenticeships - the devil will be in the detail as always). I suppose the reasoning is a 20 yo living at home doesn’t really need a lot of money

LakieLady · Today 18:43

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 14:59

Unfortunately I think this is true. There are so many more parents on MN these days claiming DLA for their kids and carers allowance for themselves.

Anecdotally, I was on a bus recently and overheard two young mothers discussing their benefits. One had an unruly kid around 5 years old so she was claiming DLA for him and carers allowance for herself. She said she had been advised when getting help filling in her forms to say she couldn’t work due to anxiety so she had done and was now getting PIP as well. What incentive do they have to work when they can get more by claiming?

That sounds like she was talking bollocks to me, I'm afraid.

For a start, the PIP form doesn't include any questions about work, and plenty of people get PIP and work. And being a carer exempts you from any work requirements in UC, because you're already spending 35 hours a week caring for a vulnerable person.

And you need to provide medical evidence to confirm almost any diagnosis, but especially a MH diagnosis. No-one gets PIP for just filling in a form saying they suffer from anxiety. The assessor would give zero points for any activity that someone said was impossible for them if the sole reason was anxiety; I've seen many an assessor's report where they've added the comment "No evidence provided" for things like that.

BurntBroccoli · Today 18:43

LaAranaPequenita · Today 17:36

The government needs a massive drive to get employers to hire the under 25s. What happened to YTS schemes and training up in a vocation with college.

Apparently we are at the bottom of the EU youth unemployment list, just above Romania.

Its a catastrophe.

There isn’t any industry anymore for young people to work in. I was on YTS myself as a filing clerk - no need for those anymore either due to computerisation of records. No need for typing pools (that was another service that a few of the girls on my course did).

There are very few apprenticeships too.

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 18:45

LakieLady · Today 18:43

That sounds like she was talking bollocks to me, I'm afraid.

For a start, the PIP form doesn't include any questions about work, and plenty of people get PIP and work. And being a carer exempts you from any work requirements in UC, because you're already spending 35 hours a week caring for a vulnerable person.

And you need to provide medical evidence to confirm almost any diagnosis, but especially a MH diagnosis. No-one gets PIP for just filling in a form saying they suffer from anxiety. The assessor would give zero points for any activity that someone said was impossible for them if the sole reason was anxiety; I've seen many an assessor's report where they've added the comment "No evidence provided" for things like that.

I don’t know why they would be speaking bollocks

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 18:52

hoolaho · Today 16:47

Ok, not the actual whole town 😂 some people want to work.

I could name plenty of towns, starting with some I have lived in. But how would that help? It would just change the direction of this thread into a “shithole” bashing thread.

20% of people in Blackpool, Hartlepool and Liverpool are on PIP. So if it’s unbelievablely hard to get and most disabled people don’t qualify there must be a heck of a lot of people disabled in Liverpool for instance. Or a load of scammers.

Kirbert2 · Today 18:53

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 18:45

I don’t know why they would be speaking bollocks

Who knows but what she said makes no sense at all.

JLou08 · Today 18:53

It needs to just not happen. I work with people with lifelong disabilities, that disability doesn't disappear between the age of 18 when DLA ends and 25 when they will be able to claim PIP again. People depend on that money for all sorts, incontinence pads because NHS ones are shit, wheelchairs because the waiting list for a new one is 2 years. transport because they could never drive or travel alone on a bus, if they have a care package some of the PIP goes toward that. If their family are carers they need PIP so the family can claim carers allowance.

campingwoes · Today 18:56

PestoPastaPizza · Today 13:11

I have a 19 year old with severe learning disabilities and autism who needs constant support. He will never live independently or work. He has no sense of stranger danger, no roadsense, can't shower without support etc
He gets UC with disabled element and high rate PIP for mobility and care.

I'd love to know how he is supposed to come off benefits and work?

I saw this:

A new, higher-rate long-term payment (above current maximum benefit rates) with no qualifying period and no expectation of work, reserved for young people with the most profound disabilities or 24-hour care needs.

So he probably won't be expected to work or train if he can't. I'm sure there will be plenty of case by case families that will need specialist help transitioning to the new system but overall I think the recommendations seem sensible.

mybiggreenfrog · Today 19:00

PestoPastaPizza · Today 13:11

I have a 19 year old with severe learning disabilities and autism who needs constant support. He will never live independently or work. He has no sense of stranger danger, no roadsense, can't shower without support etc
He gets UC with disabled element and high rate PIP for mobility and care.

I'd love to know how he is supposed to come off benefits and work?

Hopefully there will be a safety net for people like your son.

Swipe left for the next trending thread