Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Existing PIP awards for under 25 should be honoured

429 replies

HonourExistingClaimants · Today 12:55

If changes have to be made there needs to be a clear date for changes for new claims from that point. Existing claims should be honoured till the review date and then changed.

Surely anything else would be really wrong?

OP posts:
Itchthescratch · Today 14:54

lifeturnsonadime · Today 14:51

I'd have more support for removing child benefit than for this. People make a conscious decision to have children, which should include working out if they can afford it. No one chooses to be disabled.

Children don't choose to be born.

Disability isn't some binary concept. Over half of people have a long term health condition. Where we draw the line and call someone disabled is subjective. Some people will want to be considered disabled as there is a financial incentive for this. You get more benefits and aren't subject to a benefits cap. Why not lean into the struggles that most people have? There is little incentive to do otherwise in this country.

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 14:55

Itchthescratch · Today 14:48

Yes, but I have literally debated with someone on MN about how her PIP being spent on beauty treatments was a completely valid use of taxpayer money. She stated that she would paint her nails herself if she wasn't disabled but because she couldn't do this anymore, she had to pay £50 a month to get them done professionally. According to her this was a legitimate extra cost associated with her disability. The fact that the people funding these salon visits through their taxes often couldn't afford to go to the salon themselves or even find the time to paint their own nail was apparently irrelevant. At this point I became very cynical about how some people viewed 'extra costs' associated with their disability.

I remember this thread well. My mind was totally blown. It’s what peaked me certainly.

RaggedRocks · Today 14:55

TigerRag · Today 14:52

Half of the welfare bill is pensions

Most pensioners have worked for 35 years plus. Many claimants haven't done even 35 days' work.

hoolaho · Today 14:56

mummymeister · Today 14:50

Around 15% of PIP claimants work. so that means 85% do not - the overwhelming majority. I am on a local gossip facebook forum. every day - yes every single day - someone posts asking how they can get an adhd or whatever diagnosis so that they can go on PIP and get more money as they arent working and unemployment benefits arent enough.

and other posters say they will private message them with their PIP forms so that they can lie and know what to put.

If you think this isnt going on across the whole country, then you are deluded.

we have a limited amount of money. do you want it spent keeping the 85% not working or do you want those that can never work due to their disability getting more money and those that can work being helped into work or do you want us to be where we are now. Its an absolute timebomb no one is talking about. if this many under 25s arent in work now they will never work. they will never pay taxes and those of us on this forum over 50 will never see pensions because of it.

I hope Millburn grows a pair unlike starmer and tells his back benchers who oppose this to fuck off.

I do not begrudge paying extortionate taxes if they go to people who genuinely cannot ever work. I would pay more to help them. but currently I know I am paying for a load of people to sit on their arses, watch daytime telly and hang out in spoons because they can.

Absolutely. I know several late teens/early 20s PIP claimants who have zero intention of getting a job because of their “anxiety”. They all helped each other with the forms after one girls mum paid for a copy of a strangers forms and an “answer guide” on Facebook.

This extreme anxiety didn’t stop them all going to a festival and taking a shitload of drugs. They didn’t “forget to eat” despite their ADHD, diagnosed by a fraud on Facebook obviously.

It’s disgusting. And other than the tax payer, the people who will suffer are genuine disabled people.

GlomOfNit · Today 14:58

PestoPastaPizza · Today 13:11

I have a 19 year old with severe learning disabilities and autism who needs constant support. He will never live independently or work. He has no sense of stranger danger, no roadsense, can't shower without support etc
He gets UC with disabled element and high rate PIP for mobility and care.

I'd love to know how he is supposed to come off benefits and work?

Me too. Mine is 15 so we still have PIP to claim for when he turns 16. I'm extremely nervous about how things will pan out. Our boys are never, ever going to be able to 'work' - any sort of work placement requires full time 1:1 supervision to stop absconding, accidents, etc. Essentially it's a daycare activity. I know I'll look back on my son's school years as the golden time, fraught though they have been occasionally.

What on earth are we meant to do with our adult children? Where and how will they live when we're gone?

Happyindevon · Today 14:58

hoolaho · Today 14:56

Absolutely. I know several late teens/early 20s PIP claimants who have zero intention of getting a job because of their “anxiety”. They all helped each other with the forms after one girls mum paid for a copy of a strangers forms and an “answer guide” on Facebook.

This extreme anxiety didn’t stop them all going to a festival and taking a shitload of drugs. They didn’t “forget to eat” despite their ADHD, diagnosed by a fraud on Facebook obviously.

It’s disgusting. And other than the tax payer, the people who will suffer are genuine disabled people.

Yep. I’m absolutely certain that following through the medical system to create a paper trail to claim PIP is far less arduous than actually working 8 hours a day.

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 14:59

mummymeister · Today 14:50

Around 15% of PIP claimants work. so that means 85% do not - the overwhelming majority. I am on a local gossip facebook forum. every day - yes every single day - someone posts asking how they can get an adhd or whatever diagnosis so that they can go on PIP and get more money as they arent working and unemployment benefits arent enough.

and other posters say they will private message them with their PIP forms so that they can lie and know what to put.

If you think this isnt going on across the whole country, then you are deluded.

we have a limited amount of money. do you want it spent keeping the 85% not working or do you want those that can never work due to their disability getting more money and those that can work being helped into work or do you want us to be where we are now. Its an absolute timebomb no one is talking about. if this many under 25s arent in work now they will never work. they will never pay taxes and those of us on this forum over 50 will never see pensions because of it.

I hope Millburn grows a pair unlike starmer and tells his back benchers who oppose this to fuck off.

I do not begrudge paying extortionate taxes if they go to people who genuinely cannot ever work. I would pay more to help them. but currently I know I am paying for a load of people to sit on their arses, watch daytime telly and hang out in spoons because they can.

PIP claims in the under 25’s has risen 2.3 x in the last 7 years. Totally unrealistic without widespread gaming the system.

LizzieW1969 · Today 14:59

Happyindevon · Today 14:54

Don’t tell me, school …

You just don’t have the right to know, simple as that. There are all sorts of possible reasons why a child might have PTSD. For example, my 2 DDs are adopted, which is a trauma in itself.

And yes, it might be school, which can and does cause trauma to some children.

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 14:59

mummymeister · Today 14:50

Around 15% of PIP claimants work. so that means 85% do not - the overwhelming majority. I am on a local gossip facebook forum. every day - yes every single day - someone posts asking how they can get an adhd or whatever diagnosis so that they can go on PIP and get more money as they arent working and unemployment benefits arent enough.

and other posters say they will private message them with their PIP forms so that they can lie and know what to put.

If you think this isnt going on across the whole country, then you are deluded.

we have a limited amount of money. do you want it spent keeping the 85% not working or do you want those that can never work due to their disability getting more money and those that can work being helped into work or do you want us to be where we are now. Its an absolute timebomb no one is talking about. if this many under 25s arent in work now they will never work. they will never pay taxes and those of us on this forum over 50 will never see pensions because of it.

I hope Millburn grows a pair unlike starmer and tells his back benchers who oppose this to fuck off.

I do not begrudge paying extortionate taxes if they go to people who genuinely cannot ever work. I would pay more to help them. but currently I know I am paying for a load of people to sit on their arses, watch daytime telly and hang out in spoons because they can.

Unfortunately I think this is true. There are so many more parents on MN these days claiming DLA for their kids and carers allowance for themselves.

Anecdotally, I was on a bus recently and overheard two young mothers discussing their benefits. One had an unruly kid around 5 years old so she was claiming DLA for him and carers allowance for herself. She said she had been advised when getting help filling in her forms to say she couldn’t work due to anxiety so she had done and was now getting PIP as well. What incentive do they have to work when they can get more by claiming?

mummymeister · Today 15:00

RaggedRocks · Today 14:55

Most pensioners have worked for 35 years plus. Many claimants haven't done even 35 days' work.

we need to move to a benefits system for all out of work benefits ( so I am NOT talking about PIP here but other benefits) where you are given benefits in proportion to what you have paid in. And this should apply to every benefit including child benefit and pensions. You dont pay in, you dont get out. really simple and straightforward but 100% guarantee the labour luvvies on the back benches will be clutching their sustainably sourced pearls at this and it will never happen.

we need a reset.

Ubertomusic · Today 15:03

Happyindevon · Today 14:58

Yep. I’m absolutely certain that following through the medical system to create a paper trail to claim PIP is far less arduous than actually working 8 hours a day.

So you are actually accusing NHS professionals of dishing out unsubstantiated diagnoses?

That's quite something.

TigerRag · Today 15:04

mummymeister · Today 15:00

we need to move to a benefits system for all out of work benefits ( so I am NOT talking about PIP here but other benefits) where you are given benefits in proportion to what you have paid in. And this should apply to every benefit including child benefit and pensions. You dont pay in, you dont get out. really simple and straightforward but 100% guarantee the labour luvvies on the back benches will be clutching their sustainably sourced pearls at this and it will never happen.

we need a reset.

And disabled people who can't work? Or do we just let them starve?

mummymeister · Today 15:04

GlomOfNit · Today 14:58

Me too. Mine is 15 so we still have PIP to claim for when he turns 16. I'm extremely nervous about how things will pan out. Our boys are never, ever going to be able to 'work' - any sort of work placement requires full time 1:1 supervision to stop absconding, accidents, etc. Essentially it's a daycare activity. I know I'll look back on my son's school years as the golden time, fraught though they have been occasionally.

What on earth are we meant to do with our adult children? Where and how will they live when we're gone?

And you and your family should be shouting the loudest for this because ultimately if we arent paying for the kids who can work and for their parents carers allowances then your son will get even more help and support as there will be money to do this. I want my taxes to be spent on him. Not the vast numbers sitting in spoons alll fecking day doing nothing.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 15:04

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 14:48

Only 20% of people on PIP work.

Thats because pip is very very hard to get so the majority of people on pip are severely disabled

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 15:07

Itchthescratch · Today 14:48

Yes, but I have literally debated with someone on MN about how her PIP being spent on beauty treatments was a completely valid use of taxpayer money. She stated that she would paint her nails herself if she wasn't disabled but because she couldn't do this anymore, she had to pay £50 a month to get them done professionally. According to her this was a legitimate extra cost associated with her disability. The fact that the people funding these salon visits through their taxes often couldn't afford to go to the salon themselves or even find the time to paint their own nail was apparently irrelevant. At this point I became very cynical about how some people viewed 'extra costs' associated with their disability.

And you fell for that 🤣 don't believe everything you read online

IzzyLeng · Today 15:07

I disagree. I saw a post on here from someone who’s 16yo gets PIP and spends it all on computer games. Why on earth are taxpayers funding a 16yo’s gamers shopping? Lots of comments on that thread about how PIP shouldn’t be policed and people can spend it on what they want, etc. whatever, I don’t think a 16yo who is attending college full time has any need for it. The whole system needs a massive overhaul. I’m all for benefits for people who genuinely need it. I do think it should be means tested.

My colleague gets it, she’s on 65k a year and gets full PIP. The only additional expenditure she has is an annual prescription charge and a cleaner. She’d probably have the cleaner anyway but I accept she would need one. But her cleaner doesn’t cost £700 a month! And she has gamed the system because when my Dd was diagnosed with the same condition she has she said “oh she can get pip now” and offered to help me fill out the forms. Out of curiosity I looked at the forms, says about needing help with personal care, food prep, etc. my colleague lives on her own and does everything herself. Well if she had been truthful she couldn’t have got enough points. Dd is also independent. Colleague told me to lie and say I need to do everything for her. I obviously never filled the form out.

LizzieW1969 · Today 15:08

mummymeister · Today 15:00

we need to move to a benefits system for all out of work benefits ( so I am NOT talking about PIP here but other benefits) where you are given benefits in proportion to what you have paid in. And this should apply to every benefit including child benefit and pensions. You dont pay in, you dont get out. really simple and straightforward but 100% guarantee the labour luvvies on the back benches will be clutching their sustainably sourced pearls at this and it will never happen.

we need a reset.

Child Benefit is for the children, though. Should they be forced into poverty because their parents are unable to work?

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 15:08

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 15:07

And you fell for that 🤣 don't believe everything you read online

A number of mn posters were defending this. ‘It’s her money, none of your business what she does with it’ etc.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 15:08

Happyindevon · Today 14:48

What is the PTSD from ?

That is absolutely none of your business

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:09

LizzieW1969 · Today 15:08

Child Benefit is for the children, though. Should they be forced into poverty because their parents are unable to work?

How do you know the parents spend it appropriately. Maybe they use it to get their nails done?

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:10

TigerRag · Today 15:04

And disabled people who can't work? Or do we just let them starve?

Honestly I reckon some on here think this is preferable.

I've said it before and I'll say it again, this is not how civilised societies treat the disabled.

Itchthescratch · Today 15:11

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 15:08

A number of mn posters were defending this. ‘It’s her money, none of your business what she does with it’ etc.

Yes, loads of posters were defending her. She definitely wasn't a troll. Others were gloating that they put their PIP towards a holiday etc. If you questioned it then you got accused of not wanting disabled people to have nice things and viewings them as lesser people.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 15:11

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 15:08

A number of mn posters were defending this. ‘It’s her money, none of your business what she does with it’ etc.

Mumsnet is about 80% high earners who hate anyone on benefits. Stick around for the my cousins boyfriends neighbour gets pip and theres nothing wrong with her she goes on 5 holidays a year and walks around in designer clothes

TigerRag · Today 15:11

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:10

Honestly I reckon some on here think this is preferable.

I've said it before and I'll say it again, this is not how civilised societies treat the disabled.

I sometimes wonder what century I'm living in with some of the comments. I don't remember it being this bad growing up

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 15:12

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 15:08

That is absolutely none of your business

Agreed. When I was on a psych ward, some of the other patients had PTSD as a consequence of the most horrendous childhood sexual abuse. It isn’t something to divulge lightly.