Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Existing PIP awards for under 25 should be honoured

429 replies

HonourExistingClaimants · Today 12:55

If changes have to be made there needs to be a clear date for changes for new claims from that point. Existing claims should be honoured till the review date and then changed.

Surely anything else would be really wrong?

OP posts:
mamaof4losingmymind · Today 14:17

Chewbecca · Today 14:06

No, because all claims should be reassessed regularly anyway.

Well that would cost a fortune

Nutmuncher · Today 14:18

Forcing low skilled / ability challenged young people into work when in the next 2-3 years most entry level jobs and low pay work will be completely eliminated with Super Intelligence and robotics seems very off

Jesseland · Today 14:19

I've just read through the report. It says "I envisage that every area should have a YOS or equivalent service in place by 2029 and young people entering the welfare system for the first time should move onto the new benefits system, with phased rollout starting within the lifetime of this Parliament, subject to legislation."

From my experience of previous benefit changes (DLA to PIP, Income Support to UC), any time estimate in an initial report like this was always wildly optimistic, and would get delayed through technical issues, legal appeals and lack of staff capacity. So I think many young people already claiming will simply age out by the time they come to transfer over, certainly if they are at the older end of the age band.

Noras · Today 14:19

PestoPastaPizza · Today 13:11

I have a 19 year old with severe learning disabilities and autism who needs constant support. He will never live independently or work. He has no sense of stranger danger, no roadsense, can't shower without support etc
He gets UC with disabled element and high rate PIP for mobility and care.

I'd love to know how he is supposed to come off benefits and work?

I have just travels through the report and he will be ok if he is classed as profound or needs 24/7 care. He will have enhanced benefits in fact.

Ubertomusic · Today 14:19

KitsyWitsy · Today 13:49

Oh come on. People without disabilities find it hard enough finding work. What will happen is disabled people will now not be able to find/do work AND won't have enough money to live on.

They'll starve and die. Problem solved.

Noras · Today 14:20

Jesseland · Today 14:19

I've just read through the report. It says "I envisage that every area should have a YOS or equivalent service in place by 2029 and young people entering the welfare system for the first time should move onto the new benefits system, with phased rollout starting within the lifetime of this Parliament, subject to legislation."

From my experience of previous benefit changes (DLA to PIP, Income Support to UC), any time estimate in an initial report like this was always wildly optimistic, and would get delayed through technical issues, legal appeals and lack of staff capacity. So I think many young people already claiming will simply age out by the time they come to transfer over, certainly if they are at the older end of the age band.

Yes read this and thought that’s us out as DS is already aged 23 next month.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 14:20

HermioneWeasley · Today 14:16

And rightly so. It’s a disgrace to park people with these conditions on benefits as opposed to help with treatment or coping mechanisms

I agree but that needs to be sorted first and when where in a position where people can get proper long term treatment within a few weeks then they can talk about taking money away you don't take people's income away before you sort out the state of the nhs and social care. If you needed surgery and couldn't work until you had it but the waiting list was years long what would you do?

TemperanceWest · Today 14:20

TheodoreisntBeth · Today 13:35

PIP is for disabled adults to cover the extra costs associated with being disabled. Many people on PIP use it to work eg to cover taxis if they can't drive due to their disability. It is not a means tested benefit, and being disabled is not a 'lifestyle choice '

People like the pp don't care about the truth when it cones to PIP, sadly. They should 🙏 they aren't ever in a position to find out. Or their loved ones.

thatsgotit · Today 14:21

Heatedblankettime · Today 13:27

We have to shift away from the "handouts for everything" culture. It's created a country of people who don't want to work. So yes it will be painful but it needs to happen

Benefits should be a safety net not a lifestyle choice

Not that old chestnut again. 🙄

We don't have a "handouts for everything" culture. We have a culture of low pay, high prices, not enough jobs to go round, and no means for many people to survive other than on benefits. Instead of scapegoating the vulnerable, why not try pointing the finger at the businesses that aren't paying their staff enough to live on? Not to mention, of course, the rampant ableism in our culture that means the playing field is a long way from being level for those with health conditions.

Clearly you've never been on benefits yourself, otherwise you'd know subsisting on them is not a 'lifestyle'. Oh, and I take it you do realise a lot of people on PIP actually do work? Just checking.

TemperanceWest · Today 14:22

Jesseland · Today 14:19

I've just read through the report. It says "I envisage that every area should have a YOS or equivalent service in place by 2029 and young people entering the welfare system for the first time should move onto the new benefits system, with phased rollout starting within the lifetime of this Parliament, subject to legislation."

From my experience of previous benefit changes (DLA to PIP, Income Support to UC), any time estimate in an initial report like this was always wildly optimistic, and would get delayed through technical issues, legal appeals and lack of staff capacity. So I think many young people already claiming will simply age out by the time they come to transfer over, certainly if they are at the older end of the age band.

You are right. The DLA to PIP rollout is not even fully complete.

Survivingnotthriving24 · Today 14:22

I will never be able to wrap my head around age being a protected characteristic of the equality act, yet it's perfectly acceptable to propose things like this and NMW being lower for young people. That's before we get to the ableism, why are the disabled being targeted and not the lazy? I'd rather see all benefits removed from those that do not seek opportunities that would allow them to support themselves and contribute to society, despite being perfectly capable of doing so.

HermioneWeasley · Today 14:22

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 14:20

I agree but that needs to be sorted first and when where in a position where people can get proper long term treatment within a few weeks then they can talk about taking money away you don't take people's income away before you sort out the state of the nhs and social care. If you needed surgery and couldn't work until you had it but the waiting list was years long what would you do?

My understanding is that’s what Milburn is suggesting, which is why total costs will go up at first and in 10 years time there will be a small saving

HonourExistingClaimants · Today 14:23

BoredBug · Today 14:13

I understood the review as a way to reduce people using ADHD/Anxiety as a reason to not work.

It says severely disabled people will continue to be supported, as they should and the young people mentioned in this thread seem severely disabled, 24/7 support, constant supervision etc

Maybe I am being naïve.

If that was the case why would they be stopping all under 25 getting PIP? Surely they’d go through things on an individual basis and move only certain claimants to a new scheme and retain PIP/CA/motability for all others ?

OP posts:
mamaof4losingmymind · Today 14:25

HermioneWeasley · Today 14:22

My understanding is that’s what Milburn is suggesting, which is why total costs will go up at first and in 10 years time there will be a small saving

Then i think thats reasonable if done properly. To many people are suffering due to the state off the nhs

KitsyWitsy · Today 14:25

Noras · Today 14:20

Yes read this and thought that’s us out as DS is already aged 23 next month.

My middle son is 24 next month so hopefully this won't affect him but it is still worrying. He lost his pip 15 months ago and it's taken me this long to get it back. I was finally able to breathe and now this.

Ubertomusic · Today 14:25

Heatedblankettime · Today 13:56

If you read the detail more money will go to therapy instead and it sounds like they need therapy far more than benefits

Therapy for incurable conditions? Great idea!

TofuTuesday · Today 14:25

Also what fantasy land are they living in in thinking there is any help at all for people with mental illness or emotional wellbeing needs? It’s impossible now let alone when it’s mandatory for people who were/are claiming.

  1. dc went to the GP in January , dc has severe mental illness which is now intolerable and a specific illness. It took 8 months of pratting around with yet more referrals to talking therapies and a chance meeting with someone who said actually this isn’t ok (not part of the system, completely by luck we had someone clued up) and finally seeing a psychiatrist. No support except medication and next appointment January when we might discuss treatment. Mean while I’m slowly losing any will to live managing a severely ill young ‘NEET’ with no support. PIP took months to get, recently awarded.
let’s see how fast all these other NEETs get into work in the queue behind mine. i genuinely despair at the idea help is out there, waiting in its empty clinic, desperate for people to come get cured.
thatsgotit · Today 14:26

Ubertomusic · Today 14:19

They'll starve and die. Problem solved.

I think that would probably suit some people just fine, unfortunately. 😕

TofuTuesday · Today 14:26

I’m in the Midlands btw, I doubt it’s better everywhere else.

LakieLady · Today 14:28

TravellingSpoon · Today 13:06

If it comes in, what will happen to the undreds of families, ours included, who use PIP towards a motability car? And those who claim carers allowance?

I'm concerned about that, too.

I have a friend whose 18YO is on PIP + UC, and she gets UC, including the carer's element of around £200 a month, and carer's allowance (which is deducted from her UC). She's also exempt from the non-dependant deduction applied to UC for claimants with adult children living with them.

The loss of her son's PIP would cost them around £600 a month altogether. And he uses his PIP for counselling/psychotherapy for all the MH issues the government seems to think that young people don't have and the NHS seems to make fuck all provision for.

Happyindevon · Today 14:28

PestoPastaPizza · Today 13:11

I have a 19 year old with severe learning disabilities and autism who needs constant support. He will never live independently or work. He has no sense of stranger danger, no roadsense, can't shower without support etc
He gets UC with disabled element and high rate PIP for mobility and care.

I'd love to know how he is supposed to come off benefits and work?

Well he won’t will he? They didn’t say stopping all benefits for all under 25s

ilovesooty · Today 14:33

Pieceofpurplesky · Today 13:50

Reading it through it sounds like nobody will be worse off, it's just renamed and there is a move to help young people to get in to work IF they are able. Support and flexibility. This combined with the youth employment changes is a positive thing. Those who are the most severely disabled will get more by the looks of it, not less.

I hope that's the case for the mother I heard on the radio this morning. Her son has autism and learning difficulties with an IQ of 70. He attended specialist education in school and college and had a supported internship where he thrived. When that finished he was moved to a zero hour contract and then laid off. He's back at home with no support and has regressed. She sounded very worried and upset.

Ubertomusic · Today 14:34

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 14:15

I think we should bring in mandatory requirements for businesses over a certain size to meet certain levels of disabled employees.

We should? And when exactly are you planning to introduce this?

Blackcat2026 · Today 14:36

Jesseland · Today 13:18

It sounds pretty brutal to families with disabled young people and I'm relieved that DS is late 20s now so has dodged it. He's autistic and has been on PIP since he was 18, UC with LCWRA since he was 20. People don't think of it as a severe condition but he went to a special school for autism and he never had any problems claiming at the highest rates. He would have lost out on a lot if he was under this new system and our whole family would have been affected.

Usually most benefit changes take time to implement and existing claimants are grandfathered in. DS still gets the higher rate of LCWRA payment.

People don't think of it as a severe condition because so many people are now diagnosed with it! People who were once deemed 'socially awkward' or 'picky', people who were once diagnosed with Aspergers and could work.

This dilution is extremely unhelpful to people with classically autistic people in their care and this is what the government are striving to move away from. It's targeting young people who might find work more difficult than some others do, but who are work capable. Young people with anxiety, who are sitting home on games consols or puffing on joints in their parents' houses, instead of overcoming their difficulties and getting out in the world. If the already overweight tax burden is not relieved soon, life is going to be very difficult for everyone - there simply won't be enough tax payers to pay.

lifeturnsonadime · Today 14:40

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 13:58

Agreed. And I look at so many parents and think about what confining their child to a life on benefits is doing. Yes some people are severely disabled and unable to work, but the answer to anxiety/ depression / high functioning asd is absolutely NOT a life of benefits but being helped to cope with life and working.

It's a good job that THAT is the purpose of pip isn't it?

To support people to be able to work.

I am not sure what part of it not being an 'out of work' benefit you are not grasping here!!!