Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Acceptable age to have kids up to

193 replies

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 12:05

So in light of the other thread of the pregnant lady in her late 50s , what is seen as the acceptable age to go up to ?
These days with women focusing more on their careers and starting later , or just having trouble conceiving there are a lot more “ older mothers “
In some areas children into your 40s is not seen as a problem whereas other places it maybe not the done thing . Why is this ?

lots of celebrities are having children later, Anne Hathaway pregnant at 43 , Hallie berry had kids at 41 and 47 and more recently Hilary swank confirmed she was pregnant at the age of 52 .
many women don’t have their first child until late 30s / 40s for all sorts of reasons.

so is it unreasonable to want a baby at a later age and what age is just too far ?
what age up to do you think is acceptable and what isn’t ?
why are some people ok about it and others not ?

OP posts:
Mummymaybeormaybenot · Today 17:41

Sunnyphoenix · Today 17:41

I thought the other thread was about a woman being pregnant at 59 and this was a more general question about the accetaptable age to have kids. Most of the answers focus on women, and the OP is a woman, but the question seems more general, which is why I am asking,

Apologies! I’m on both threads and mixed them :D but my point stands, this is about women

curliegirlie · Today 17:50

arethereanyleftatall · Yesterday 12:21

I think it would be completely foolish to only think about ‘can I cope with a baby at 40’ and not ‘can I cope with a difficult teen during menopause’ or ‘do I want to be still working at 65 to pay for this child.’

ask any woman how tired and stressed she is during menopause, or how much less energy they have at 50 rather than 30, before making a decision

Completely depends on circumstances though. A) we have a DC with Down’s syndrome who we’ll have to support (born when I was 33) so I’d be unable to lay down my active parenting hat at 65 anyway, and B) we’ll both have pretty decent Civil Service pensions at the point we do end up retiring. I had DD3 at 43. I’m only 9 months in, admittedly, but no regrets so far.

BlueSherbet · Today 17:51

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Today 17:35

i started my period at 11 and could therefore conceive naturally, is that acceptable?
40+ is too old just like how under 20s is too young.

Good point - thanks for raising that - I should have said within the bounds of legality, of course!

20 is perhaps seen as too young these days in the context of other aspects of life (eg if the woman is a student, or is not financially stable on her own or with a partner) but not in the context of simply being a mother.

Equally, I don't think being over 40 is too old either. Women are still healthy, able bodies etc, and of an age that they will comfortably see their child into adulthood and likely become a grandmother.

The expectations and pressures of modern life do have an effect on shaping our attitudes to these things, but as far as possible women should resist those external pressures which are themselves nothing to do with motherhood.

Im very wary of people being made to feel 2nd class or inferior, if they have a life event outside someone else's idea of an optimal age range.

trossardmartinelli · Today 17:52

ThePeppyOpalScroller · Yesterday 12:29

Excect a mothers decisions affect the child. I don't think it's fair on a child to have them so late, that you get mistaken for their grandparents. Having a child in your late 40s means "grandparents" at the school gates and attending graduations in your late 60s.

I had the opposite problem. My nan always got mistaken for my mum as she was 38 when I was born.

Hiredgun · Today 17:52

It’s a personal decision. However, Mother Nature worked some of this out for us being the wise auld woman that she is. Modern life is making it harder to align with that of course.

curliegirlie · Today 17:54

BlueSherbet · Today 17:30

I think its acceptable for a woman to have a child at any age where she can conceive a child naturally.

I would like to see an end to terms such as "an old mother" or "a very young mother". It should just be "a mother" - her child raising ability and the depth of her love is not altered by age.

I think IVF should be banned, especially for people whose natural fertility has come to an end - its an example of NHS mission creep and is also immoral given it destroys human embryos. At the same time, I recognise that infertility is a very difficult thing.

Most trusts have age cut offs for NHS IVF, sometimes as early as 35.

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Today 17:56

curliegirlie · Today 17:54

Most trusts have age cut offs for NHS IVF, sometimes as early as 35.

35 isn’t early

saffy2 · Today 17:57

I’m 42. I have a 2 year old, and I think realistically I’d struggle to do it again. But I do have 2 older ones aswell, 16 and 8. So the house is hectic and I am tired. I feel old. I can’t imagine going through another pregnancy at this age or later.
where I am older is very normal really. I was seen as young with my eldest. And middle with my middle, I will certainly be one of the older ones with my youngest at school but probably not the oldest.
i just think for me, I don’t think I could have another at this age or older.

Twoshoesnewshoes · Today 18:14

I think over 45 is really pushing it.
for the child, but also commitments.
paying our dc’s rent whilst they were at uni (£700 a month) meant we both needed to work almost full time, and now we are helping with deposits for flats so still need our nose th the grindstone.
it feels mostly doable at 50, but I would not want to be committed to that at 60+.

whippersnapper55 · Today 18:16

I think the perception of an 'acceptable age' has shifted in the last few decades - when my mum was pregnant with me at 29, my gran said to her don't you think you're a bit old to have another baby!

My MIL had her last baby at 40 and said it was her easiest pregnancy and birth. I had mine young and I'm glad now that I'm in my 50s and menopause that I did - not sure I'd still like to be coping with young children at this age!

I think it comes down to individual choice - if you're fit and healthy and feel up to it, then having babies in your mid to late 40s is fine. Personally I think anyone having babies in their 50s is bonkers!

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Today 18:18

whippersnapper55 · Today 18:16

I think the perception of an 'acceptable age' has shifted in the last few decades - when my mum was pregnant with me at 29, my gran said to her don't you think you're a bit old to have another baby!

My MIL had her last baby at 40 and said it was her easiest pregnancy and birth. I had mine young and I'm glad now that I'm in my 50s and menopause that I did - not sure I'd still like to be coping with young children at this age!

I think it comes down to individual choice - if you're fit and healthy and feel up to it, then having babies in your mid to late 40s is fine. Personally I think anyone having babies in their 50s is bonkers!

My mum was put in a geriatric pregnancy unit at 32 😆😆

Thatsalineallright · Today 18:27

I'm the youngest of my siblings and my mum had me at 39. It means my dad died when I was still in my 20s. My mum is elderly and has needed a lot of support at a time in life where I'm juggling children of my own. I am envious of my siblings who had energetic, present parents for longer than I did.
So based on that I don't think people should be having kids past 40 tbh. Though obviously it is everyone's own choice.

Flaskfan · Today 18:43

Like pp have said, you need to look at what the other side might look like.

If you have a child at 45, then the chances of you being fit and healthy when they hit late teens is going to be smaller.

And also, personally, I thought i was knackered in my early 30s with smalls. Didn't sleep for nearly 8 years overall. No idea how I'd do it now. I need my sleep. And I really, really like my space and freedom.

Having a baby at 50 just seems insane. I'm fit; can run for miles etc, but I'm still a lot creakier and injury prone. Wouldn't fancy pregnancy damage on top.

PhotoFirePoet · Today 18:55

I gave birth to my daughter at age 38, nearly 39, and personally, I wouldn’t have wanted to be any older.

catabhaile · Today 18:59

RatsCatsandPuppies · Yesterday 14:24

I’m having a difficult time in perimenopause (late 40s) and the idea of dealing with this plus a baby or toddler…. No thank you! I can hardly deal with the fatigue when I’m having 10 hours of sleep every night!!

I sailed through menopause which was lucky as I did have a toddler. I didn't realise I was going through menopause till afterwards really.

OpalMoonflower · Today 19:00

Mildredandherflowers · Today 17:33

I am 44 and since I can remember, all I ever wanted was to have loads of children. I was the first to offer to babysit for my parent's friends and children gravitated towards me my entire life. I even did some voluntary work with children with disabilities when I was a child. It was supposed to be for a month but I asked to stay on for longer. I went on to become an early years teacher and have been working with young children for over 2 decades.

As soon as I got married we tried for a baby immediately. I was 32. Two years later I had another and then when I was 39 I had my third. I work full time with 4 years olds too. Children are my life and I have a calling to make a difference to theirs.

I absolutely adore motherhood. I am a very loving attentive conscientious and caring mother and my children are all very kind, creative, caring and respectful people. I raise them to make the world a better place. They love me too and I just know that I am contributing to people who will make a difference.

Recently my husband and I discussed having another. I am 44. My heart absolutely leapt when he said it and we stopped preventing just this month. There is so much noise in my head about everything that can go wrong but I just can't not try. This isn't a flash in the pan premenopausal hormone spike. Its who I am. I always said that if my husband would have allowed it , I would have just kept going until it literally didn't happen any more. Children are a gift to me, and I know i do a good job. My home is full of laughter, joy, noise and chaos and I love it. If I can naturally conceive, I will gladly take that gift.

We are financially solid, the children are all very emotionally healthy, very happy and I think they would love it too. The newborn stuff doesn't bother me. The teenage stuff doesn't either. I just love children and watching them grow into wonderful people. My emotional and physical space for children seems infinite.

Sending you lots of good luck wishes with it 🍀🍀

OP posts:
Thefsm · Today 19:04

From a genetic perspective 35 for both partners. After that risks of mutated sperm and damaged eggs increases

ElizaMulvil · Today 19:04

In the end it's the quality of the person as a parent that matters, not their age. Margaret Beaufort, Henry Seventh's mother was 13 when she had him. Reputedly she was an excellent mother. On the other hand, my grandmother had 8 children and was an excellent mother to them - they all said. The first at 17 and the last at 41. She was just as interested in the youngest as the oldest. All did well in life despite coming from a very poor background. The secret was, I believe, that my grandparents thought their children were all wonderful and told them so. They responded to that.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page