Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Acceptable age to have kids up to

193 replies

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 12:05

So in light of the other thread of the pregnant lady in her late 50s , what is seen as the acceptable age to go up to ?
These days with women focusing more on their careers and starting later , or just having trouble conceiving there are a lot more “ older mothers “
In some areas children into your 40s is not seen as a problem whereas other places it maybe not the done thing . Why is this ?

lots of celebrities are having children later, Anne Hathaway pregnant at 43 , Hallie berry had kids at 41 and 47 and more recently Hilary swank confirmed she was pregnant at the age of 52 .
many women don’t have their first child until late 30s / 40s for all sorts of reasons.

so is it unreasonable to want a baby at a later age and what age is just too far ?
what age up to do you think is acceptable and what isn’t ?
why are some people ok about it and others not ?

OP posts:
FlatStanley50 · Yesterday 13:28

I had my one and only at 41 with no fertility issues or health problems and definitely had enough energy to deal with young children at the time. Now I’m menopausal and she’s 12 and whilst Inwould love to spend my Sundays sitting around reading I don’t because I have a 12 year old to entertain / actually these days we are mainly taxiing her around. So I guess in that way it does keep you young. Several of her friends have parents the same age and the majority are only about 5 years younger. The young (had them in their 20s parents) are much rarer. And whilst I’m envious of them being done with parenting by 50 I did have a lot of fun in my 20s and 30s and arguably had more energy to do so then, so swings and roundabouts. We definitely have always done as many activities, if not more than the younger parents. This summer we were paragliding and canyoning, have always done cycling/ swimming/ hiking etc with her. You’re not decrepit in your 40s/50s!

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 13:28

sHREDDIES19 · Yesterday 13:25

I had my last at 37 and I felt amazing, looked so youthful, full of energy. To me, that doesn't seem at all old but I base it on how I felt at that age.

I think this is what I’m basing this on too , I think a lot of how you feel yourself matters a lot.

OP posts:
HallowenStorm · Yesterday 13:30

There is a difference between what society thinks is ok, what you as a person feel is ok and what is biologically possible

Personally, I have no judgement about a woman who gets pregnant until mid 40 to early 50s (aka until menopause). Simply because they biologically can (even if much less likely). My aunt was conceived that way. And I dint think society should judge either
On a very personal pov, I took the decision to not have a child after 39yo. I simply didn’t want to still be looking after a teen and then a young dependent adult as I was retiring (pension age was much lower when I had my kids!). I’m now 55yo and very happy I made that choice. I couldn’t see myself with a teen or younger.

I am more judgemental about women who ‘get pregnant’ after the menopause. Mainly because that child is going to loose their mum (and likeky their father too) very early on. I dint think it’s fair. That’s in top of the generational difference, risk of the parent being ill (the health span is 65yo so half of those mothers and fathers will be chronically ill by that age).

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 13:31

FlatStanley50 · Yesterday 13:28

I had my one and only at 41 with no fertility issues or health problems and definitely had enough energy to deal with young children at the time. Now I’m menopausal and she’s 12 and whilst Inwould love to spend my Sundays sitting around reading I don’t because I have a 12 year old to entertain / actually these days we are mainly taxiing her around. So I guess in that way it does keep you young. Several of her friends have parents the same age and the majority are only about 5 years younger. The young (had them in their 20s parents) are much rarer. And whilst I’m envious of them being done with parenting by 50 I did have a lot of fun in my 20s and 30s and arguably had more energy to do so then, so swings and roundabouts. We definitely have always done as many activities, if not more than the younger parents. This summer we were paragliding and canyoning, have always done cycling/ swimming/ hiking etc with her. You’re not decrepit in your 40s/50s!

This made me smile a lot , thank you , has made me feel a lot better! I agree I know so many people who are full of life of them ages , and people who are a lot older look back at their 40/50s thinking how young they still were then !
lovely to hear you have had a positive experience and it’s keeping you young 😊

OP posts:
OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 13:32

HallowenStorm · Yesterday 13:30

There is a difference between what society thinks is ok, what you as a person feel is ok and what is biologically possible

Personally, I have no judgement about a woman who gets pregnant until mid 40 to early 50s (aka until menopause). Simply because they biologically can (even if much less likely). My aunt was conceived that way. And I dint think society should judge either
On a very personal pov, I took the decision to not have a child after 39yo. I simply didn’t want to still be looking after a teen and then a young dependent adult as I was retiring (pension age was much lower when I had my kids!). I’m now 55yo and very happy I made that choice. I couldn’t see myself with a teen or younger.

I am more judgemental about women who ‘get pregnant’ after the menopause. Mainly because that child is going to loose their mum (and likeky their father too) very early on. I dint think it’s fair. That’s in top of the generational difference, risk of the parent being ill (the health span is 65yo so half of those mothers and fathers will be chronically ill by that age).

That’s a really good reply thank you , I agree with alot of what you have said there 😊

OP posts:
Additup · Yesterday 13:33

I'd say its up to the individual. If a woman at any age can naturally get pregnant and carry the baby full term then clearly she's not too old to have a baby otherwise she wouldn't have managed to get pregnant in the first place.

Post menopausal women who, through medical procedures, get pregnant are imo too old.

Also, imo once a man gets to a similar age as a post menopausal woman it's probably for the best if he stops having children because of sperm degradation.

Obviously I'm NOT suggesting anyone gives up recreational sex post 50s 😁

Echobelly · Yesterday 13:34

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 12:29

Yes like I said above those women having the menopause and with a small child I take my hat off to them . Even a small bit of PMS and I’m not myself , so I bow down to them !

I always feel both happy and a bit sorry for parents in their mid 40s with under 5s. They do always look really shattered, but I'm also happy for them because maybe it took them time to meet the right person, or to get fertility treatment or whatever, so you know they would really have wanted these children, even if it's exhausting!

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 13:35

Ilikeyoga · Yesterday 13:03

My x2 great grandma had a baby in her late 40s… but it was actually the baby of her unwed daughter. She just pretended the baby was hers.

Wow ! That’s a interesting story , I think this happened a lot back then didn’t it , and there was a time when young mothers would get sent away to have the baby and then the baby given away , so think a lot of family’s had this situation to protect their family.

OP posts:
OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 13:36

Additup · Yesterday 13:33

I'd say its up to the individual. If a woman at any age can naturally get pregnant and carry the baby full term then clearly she's not too old to have a baby otherwise she wouldn't have managed to get pregnant in the first place.

Post menopausal women who, through medical procedures, get pregnant are imo too old.

Also, imo once a man gets to a similar age as a post menopausal woman it's probably for the best if he stops having children because of sperm degradation.

Obviously I'm NOT suggesting anyone gives up recreational sex post 50s 😁

Edited

Yes they would be up in arms if they had to give up sex 🤣🤣😅😅

OP posts:
CorgiOctopus · Yesterday 13:37

TheAmberKoala · Yesterday 12:57

I had my last kid in my 40s. dont give a shiny shit if its 'not the done thing' although Ive literally never come across anyone who thought that. Its very common where I am, but it was normal everywhere before contraception was available to have kids in your 40s. Anyone who says otherwise just comes across as jealous honestly.

Agree, but also the exact same for younger women in their 20s.

Certainly on here, I’m so tired of people trying to prove they did it at the best age. Fertility lasts for decades - its nature. Unless circumstances are objectively poor or disadvantageous, not anyone’s business.

Additup · Yesterday 13:38

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 13:36

Yes they would be up in arms if they had to give up sex 🤣🤣😅😅

I would up in arms. One of the reasons post menopause sex is great is because there's no risk of pregnancy 😁

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 13:40

CorgiOctopus · Yesterday 13:37

Agree, but also the exact same for younger women in their 20s.

Certainly on here, I’m so tired of people trying to prove they did it at the best age. Fertility lasts for decades - its nature. Unless circumstances are objectively poor or disadvantageous, not anyone’s business.

Yes I feel you are right a lot of younger mothers get a lot of judgement too, but there are so many great young mothers out there . They can get a bad rep too like the older mothers too.

OP posts:
OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 13:42

Additup · Yesterday 13:38

I would up in arms. One of the reasons post menopause sex is great is because there's no risk of pregnancy 😁

See I think we need a whole other thread about this , as I always wonder what happens to women after the menopause ! I hear so much about women not wanting it during menopause etc etc the whole thing puts terror in me.
I think davina seems to talk a lot of sense and back women about life after the menopause, need more positivity like that for sure . Good on you I say , and no pregnancy’s risks , win win 😅😅😅

OP posts:
Bumbelinaaa · Yesterday 13:44

Had my 3rd at 38, now mid 40’s and if I won the lottery I’d seriously consider fertility treatment to have another one. Not once has it crossed my mind to wonder if others find it acceptable!

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 13:45

Bumbelinaaa · Yesterday 13:44

Had my 3rd at 38, now mid 40’s and if I won the lottery I’d seriously consider fertility treatment to have another one. Not once has it crossed my mind to wonder if others find it acceptable!

Love this thank you ! Yes a nice money win would be good to have too 🤣🤣

OP posts:
Additup · Yesterday 13:48

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 13:42

See I think we need a whole other thread about this , as I always wonder what happens to women after the menopause ! I hear so much about women not wanting it during menopause etc etc the whole thing puts terror in me.
I think davina seems to talk a lot of sense and back women about life after the menopause, need more positivity like that for sure . Good on you I say , and no pregnancy’s risks , win win 😅😅😅

I think everyone is different. Some women post menopause are sexually active, some aren't, like pre menopause really. There is a lot of inaccurate stuff banded about re: menopause but the truth is it affects all women differently.

You should read some of the sexless marriage threads on MN. Both men and women bemoaning their partners lack of sex drive. It must be truely awful to be in that position.

AllyOP · Yesterday 13:48

The NHS IVF limit is under 43 and that sounds about right to me.

DeftGoldHedgehog · Yesterday 13:51

40s isn't a problem though obviously there are more risks as it goes on. It's up to the individual to decide what is acceptable, we have freedom of procreation in the UK.

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 13:53

Additup · Yesterday 13:48

I think everyone is different. Some women post menopause are sexually active, some aren't, like pre menopause really. There is a lot of inaccurate stuff banded about re: menopause but the truth is it affects all women differently.

You should read some of the sexless marriage threads on MN. Both men and women bemoaning their partners lack of sex drive. It must be truely awful to be in that position.

That’s so true , can be a lot of men and women younger who don’t have sex and are in unhappy relationships.
thats a really positive take on it though and need to hear more of this than the doom and gloom we do , as like you say , people of all ages can struggle.

OP posts:
Blondeshavemorefun · Yesterday 13:55

As I replied on other post - I am torn on this as I’m an older mum. Was almost 44 when had mini blondes tho ttc for 10yrs but Mother Nature wasn’t playing ball. Finally my 5th implant from a frozen 3rd cycle implanted and I was overjoyed

she is now nearly 10 and I’m 53

I do wonder why she left it so long after her youngest who is 7 I think now

why didn’t she start 6yrs ago for example

I do wonder what her 37 thinks

yes almost 60 is old to give birth - but guessing they have the money to look after /help with childcare etc

my first dh died when we were 37 and joined way and so many children lost a parent early due to illness cancer accidents etc so I don’t think you can say not to have a child due to age as will die before they are old

I wish them well

my dad is almost 90 and fitter then me and adores mini blondes and their love for each other melts my heart

so they may not die early leaving their child alone

I do find this is often split into 2 camps. Tho who had their kids young and so at 40/45 back to living their lives again and then grandkids possibly happening

and think it’s hell on earth having a baby later in life as they are now tired (maybe as being parents for 20yrs)

v

like me an older mum - I have a good career - time - energy - own home and settled in life (tho now divorced and a single mum so a new mr blondes would be nice ) 😊😛

I only stopped having periods at 51 and sailed tho the menopause with no issues much to many of my friends annoyance 😂 who suffered from sweats memory loss etc

other friends were late 30’s or early 40’s so it really can vary with woman

Chizzit26 · Yesterday 13:56

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 13:12

I guess I do , maybe stupidly worry about how others would judge and if I’m being stupid in making the decision too, and just how people would be etc and all the other worries you have along the way with a child anyway.

For the record I do have a child so know what I’d be getting myself into and I have just turned 41 . I think for me personally I wouldn’t want to try after I’m 42 and a half to 43 but like everyone has said on here , everyone’s personal cut off is different and for all sorts of reasons and I respect that totally and don’t judge others.

I guess I have been wondering if I’m insane for trying 😁🙈

I really hope you can step away from this worry about judgement and put it in its place.

I don't mean that you should 'stop' worrying about it (I don't believe anyone can make ourselves do that) or that you are somehow silly or wrong to worry about it (because we are all human, and humans are social creatures, and worrying about how others will judge us is completely understandable).

However, there is a time to notice when fear of judgement is having a role in our decision-making that we do not want it to have, and to say 'no thank you. I acknowledge you but I won't let you rule me.'

People will always judge us for something if they want to. There is no age at which to have a child or set of life choices that is immune from some person saying or thinking something bad about us. But it's your life and your body and the decision to try for a child or not is so personal, and frankly it is just all too bloody important for other people's ideas about 'acceptability' to rule this.

I also want to push back this time on the idea that we should let nature decide. So many women are incredible mothers but have only had that chance thanks to some sort of medical support / intervention. So what? If we let nature take its course, half of our children would die and hardly anyone would reach their forties / fifties, let alone have the chance to bring a life into the world. Our bodies do have limits and sometimes we can't have the children we hope for but interpreting that as evidence that our bodies were somehow unfit or whatever is not the way to go (not least because our bodies don't exist in isolation and we are all shaped by so many environmental and social forces that impact on our biology and on our life decisions!).

Bringing a kid into the world, or choosing not to try to do so, is always acceptable in my book. And sure, we can speculate on what time would be more or less ideal, but frankly it's all a guessing game anyway. Granted, my DH (who was in his mid-50 when we had our child) isn't having to cope with the menopause but he is an incredibly wonderful and energetic dad most of the time - far more so than plenty of men I know who are 20 years younger. I just don't think age means much inherently.

Good luck with finding the way you want to go forwards and don't let judgement - or the fear of judgement - be the boss of your family life and body.

Londonrach1 · Yesterday 13:56

Life didn't give me a child until I was 41. I'd have loved to have one earlier but only fell pregnant at 40 naturally. I now have a pre teen and it's great. Certainly no lack of energy. I think every age gives you positives and negatives. Personally I think it's when your body can't have a baby naturally is when you shouldn't.

BirdLandedonmyHead · Yesterday 13:56

Ive just turned 40. I cant imagine wanting a baby now...

But thats largely due to the exhaustion from patenting two teens, working full time, and dealing with my patents health issues.

If i didnt have al that, i would orobably feel more able to do it!

mamaof4losingmymind · Yesterday 13:57

Personally I wouldn't have kids past 30

wildnwilde · Yesterday 13:58

When nature demons you can’t . It’s that simple for me . Unless you age health(physical or mental ) implications that would affect your abilities. I don’t agree with post menopausal women getting pregnant . Your body has evolved beyond childbearing after that .