Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Acceptable age to have kids up to

194 replies

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 12:05

So in light of the other thread of the pregnant lady in her late 50s , what is seen as the acceptable age to go up to ?
These days with women focusing more on their careers and starting later , or just having trouble conceiving there are a lot more “ older mothers “
In some areas children into your 40s is not seen as a problem whereas other places it maybe not the done thing . Why is this ?

lots of celebrities are having children later, Anne Hathaway pregnant at 43 , Hallie berry had kids at 41 and 47 and more recently Hilary swank confirmed she was pregnant at the age of 52 .
many women don’t have their first child until late 30s / 40s for all sorts of reasons.

so is it unreasonable to want a baby at a later age and what age is just too far ?
what age up to do you think is acceptable and what isn’t ?
why are some people ok about it and others not ?

OP posts:
TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 12:11

I apply the same logic of their body their choice to every subject concerning a woman’s reproductive organs.

MajorSamanthaCarter · Yesterday 12:13

I think it's a personal choice but, once your body has been through menopause it's definitely time to stop.

Peonies12 · Yesterday 12:14

Personal choice. Personally I wouldn’t want to past 40.

Ablondiebutagoody · Yesterday 12:15

For me, with hindsight, 35

FallingfortheUnderdog · Yesterday 12:15

Not really something I have an opinion on, everyone's choice is personal to them, none of my business

DeeNiall · Yesterday 12:16

Not my circus, not my monkeys.

Pumpkinsaregrowingnicely · Yesterday 12:17

I've had dc in my teens, 20's,30's and last one at 43..
Pros and cons to all ages ime ! I def appreciate having one so late on.

ChilliLimes · Yesterday 12:18

my mum had my brother at 45 personally i feel that was too old im 37 and feel too old now.

moominontherun · Yesterday 12:19

I’m a bit more sanguine about this I think as I think a lot of people have kids who really shouldn’t, at any age, and I think a lot of kids and subsequently adults end up with much harder lives than any of the kids mentioned in your post will.

People having babies into their late 40s and early 50s tend to be pretty well off, so they are able to offer a different set of opportunities, with the flip side being they are likely to be around for less time. Are these children better to never have existed? You would hope that most people would rather be alive than not, which is what it comes down to really. And in most of these cases, the children grow up with privileged lives and are well provided for their adult lives too.

Having children is often an inherently selfish decision anyway, and there are plenty of posts from people on here who have had children in situations that aren’t ideal or who have regretted it.

i do find it interesting that Victoria Coren Mitchell never comes in for much criticism on here for this, I guess as she’s the ‘right’ kind of celebrity for MN!

But generally I think that if people are free to have babies with piece of shit men, when they can’t afford them, can’t dedicate emotional space to them, whatever, the age thing seems fairly minor in comparison.

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 12:19

Pumpkinsaregrowingnicely · Yesterday 12:17

I've had dc in my teens, 20's,30's and last one at 43..
Pros and cons to all ages ime ! I def appreciate having one so late on.

Ahh that’s a lovely comment

OP posts:
OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 12:21

moominontherun · Yesterday 12:19

I’m a bit more sanguine about this I think as I think a lot of people have kids who really shouldn’t, at any age, and I think a lot of kids and subsequently adults end up with much harder lives than any of the kids mentioned in your post will.

People having babies into their late 40s and early 50s tend to be pretty well off, so they are able to offer a different set of opportunities, with the flip side being they are likely to be around for less time. Are these children better to never have existed? You would hope that most people would rather be alive than not, which is what it comes down to really. And in most of these cases, the children grow up with privileged lives and are well provided for their adult lives too.

Having children is often an inherently selfish decision anyway, and there are plenty of posts from people on here who have had children in situations that aren’t ideal or who have regretted it.

i do find it interesting that Victoria Coren Mitchell never comes in for much criticism on here for this, I guess as she’s the ‘right’ kind of celebrity for MN!

But generally I think that if people are free to have babies with piece of shit men, when they can’t afford them, can’t dedicate emotional space to them, whatever, the age thing seems fairly minor in comparison.

You raise a very good point

OP posts:
arethereanyleftatall · Yesterday 12:21

I think it would be completely foolish to only think about ‘can I cope with a baby at 40’ and not ‘can I cope with a difficult teen during menopause’ or ‘do I want to be still working at 65 to pay for this child.’

ask any woman how tired and stressed she is during menopause, or how much less energy they have at 50 rather than 30, before making a decision

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 12:22

ChilliLimes · Yesterday 12:18

my mum had my brother at 45 personally i feel that was too old im 37 and feel too old now.

Thank you for your reply 😁 yes I guess everyone can feel old at all different ages can’t they and that depends on a lot of different factors.

OP posts:
Mummymaybeormaybenot · Yesterday 12:23

I personally view 25-40 to be the acceptable range but women can do as they please

MabelAnderson · Yesterday 12:23

Not everyone has a choice. I got married late and for me it was a choice of have a baby late or no baby. I had one at 41, another at 43. I would have far preferred to have them a decade earlier but it’s also lovely having teenagers older, a lot of fun.

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 12:23

arethereanyleftatall · Yesterday 12:21

I think it would be completely foolish to only think about ‘can I cope with a baby at 40’ and not ‘can I cope with a difficult teen during menopause’ or ‘do I want to be still working at 65 to pay for this child.’

ask any woman how tired and stressed she is during menopause, or how much less energy they have at 50 rather than 30, before making a decision

I do always wonder how women do menopause with a younger child , they must be warriors ! The job and working is a good point too.

OP posts:
BillieWiper · Yesterday 12:24

I don't know really. The norm to me would be no later than around 48?! But where that number came from I couldn't say.

My mum and her mum both had kids in their early 40s. And I considered to have your first child then to be quite old. When I was a kid a lot of my peers mums were in their late 20s- mid 30s.

But now I guess it's possible to do it a bit older so that needs to become more accepted?

arethereanyleftatall · Yesterday 12:24

Also, the women you have cited are loaded. They can buy in any help they need, so it’s not really relevant to your ordinary person.

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 12:25

MabelAnderson · Yesterday 12:23

Not everyone has a choice. I got married late and for me it was a choice of have a baby late or no baby. I had one at 41, another at 43. I would have far preferred to have them a decade earlier but it’s also lovely having teenagers older, a lot of fun.

Yes this exactly not everyone meets the person they want kids till later or have trouble conceiving etc . A lot of people always say it keeps them young having a younger child. I also do think it’s down to how each person is in their own health and that too .

OP posts:
Iheartlouie · Yesterday 12:27

I had mine at 22, 34 and 40

(age gaps as I have horrendous pregnancies with HG from 5 weeks until birth which even the strongest anti sickness drugs used for cancer patients didn’t touch, I have to blank out 8 months if my life to lay on the bathroom floor inbetween hospital admissions for dehydration).

40 was my limit and then only as dh (father of my two youngest) is 6 years younger than me.

I will say I was a far better mother in my 20s than I am now at 46, but that mainly due to life having ground me down.

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 12:28

BillieWiper · Yesterday 12:24

I don't know really. The norm to me would be no later than around 48?! But where that number came from I couldn't say.

My mum and her mum both had kids in their early 40s. And I considered to have your first child then to be quite old. When I was a kid a lot of my peers mums were in their late 20s- mid 30s.

But now I guess it's possible to do it a bit older so that needs to become more accepted?

My Nan had my mum when she was 40 and at the time I think it was seen as old . And my mum had me young , not sure if that was because she had an older mum or not . But I do think these days it’s not seen no where near as out of the ordinary as it may have been then .
I for one am so much healthier than when I was 20 🤣 but it differs from person to person doesn’t it .

OP posts:
Echobelly · Yesterday 12:28

I would say up to mid 40s, but it's people's choice.

If someone tomorrow announced a near 100%-success rate fertility treatment that would get you pregnant and having a healthy baby even in your 50s I could hardly begrudge women from whom IVF hadn't worked and still really wanted children going for it, though I think you'd be bloody knackered with a newborn and small kids past 40.

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 12:29

Echobelly · Yesterday 12:28

I would say up to mid 40s, but it's people's choice.

If someone tomorrow announced a near 100%-success rate fertility treatment that would get you pregnant and having a healthy baby even in your 50s I could hardly begrudge women from whom IVF hadn't worked and still really wanted children going for it, though I think you'd be bloody knackered with a newborn and small kids past 40.

Yes like I said above those women having the menopause and with a small child I take my hat off to them . Even a small bit of PMS and I’m not myself , so I bow down to them !

OP posts:
ThePeppyOpalScroller · Yesterday 12:29

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 12:11

I apply the same logic of their body their choice to every subject concerning a woman’s reproductive organs.

Excect a mothers decisions affect the child. I don't think it's fair on a child to have them so late, that you get mistaken for their grandparents. Having a child in your late 40s means "grandparents" at the school gates and attending graduations in your late 60s.

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 12:30

Iheartlouie · Yesterday 12:27

I had mine at 22, 34 and 40

(age gaps as I have horrendous pregnancies with HG from 5 weeks until birth which even the strongest anti sickness drugs used for cancer patients didn’t touch, I have to blank out 8 months if my life to lay on the bathroom floor inbetween hospital admissions for dehydration).

40 was my limit and then only as dh (father of my two youngest) is 6 years younger than me.

I will say I was a far better mother in my 20s than I am now at 46, but that mainly due to life having ground me down.

That sounds like such a rough time with the sickness that a lot to deal with the whole way through 😬

OP posts: