Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Acceptable age to have kids up to

193 replies

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 12:05

So in light of the other thread of the pregnant lady in her late 50s , what is seen as the acceptable age to go up to ?
These days with women focusing more on their careers and starting later , or just having trouble conceiving there are a lot more “ older mothers “
In some areas children into your 40s is not seen as a problem whereas other places it maybe not the done thing . Why is this ?

lots of celebrities are having children later, Anne Hathaway pregnant at 43 , Hallie berry had kids at 41 and 47 and more recently Hilary swank confirmed she was pregnant at the age of 52 .
many women don’t have their first child until late 30s / 40s for all sorts of reasons.

so is it unreasonable to want a baby at a later age and what age is just too far ?
what age up to do you think is acceptable and what isn’t ?
why are some people ok about it and others not ?

OP posts:
MalateOxaloacetate · Yesterday 17:37

Cattyisbatty · Yesterday 17:24

I’d say 45 in the current era although it’s still pushing it.

As I said in the other thread, I was a child of older parents (41 & 42) and mine died young, I could’ve had them for 40 years, but they’d both gone by the time I was 30, that’s bad luck though really.

I’m not going to ‘tell’ someone what they can or can’t do, but I think you really need to think about who is around you family wise if you’re going to have a late in life pregnancy.

DH parents had him in their 40s. They are both currently healthier than he is… illness and death comes to many young.

Meadowfinch · Yesterday 17:45

I had my ds (my only) at 45y2m. My pregnancy wasn't planned, we weren't trying, I had no medical assistance.

I had a very easy pregnancy, no nausea, worked all the way through,natural birth, healthy baby. He now 18 and at uni. No issues.

My dm had babies at 42 and 44, my dsis had two babies in her 40s. My dgm had two in her 40s. No issues with any of them. Before the pill it just wasn't that rare, and we as a family clearly have no issue conceiving later. Good genes I guess.

Given all of that, why should anyone judge if I was fit to have a baby. At 63 I'm still running 10ks, I still swim,cycle etc, so I look after myself, maintain fitness.

Clearly my body was able to conceive & carry a child at 44 without assistance. That should really be the only limiter.

nomoreraintoday · Yesterday 17:47

To me it depends on whether it’s a first child or additional. To have e.g. a 3rd baby in mid 40s is unreasonable but if it’s a woman’s first chance to have a child then that feels more acceptable to me. Max age of 45 either way though.
Personally I aimed to have all my babies before 35.

LaurieFairyCake · Yesterday 17:48

Personal choice

I’d like to cut all the ‘young’ people under 40 a bit of slack because when I was young I’d likely have thought the same thing ‘menopause age seems a natural end’.

I don’t think that now as I’m literally surrounded by very elderly people in their late 80’s and 90’s still bloody driving and running everything. So as far as I’m concerned they could have had kids at 60 and still be fine.

I wouldn’t have thought that 20 years ago.

wishingonastar101 · Yesterday 17:54

I think 40 really is the limit...

Meadowfinch · Yesterday 17:55

nomoreraintoday · Yesterday 17:47

To me it depends on whether it’s a first child or additional. To have e.g. a 3rd baby in mid 40s is unreasonable but if it’s a woman’s first chance to have a child then that feels more acceptable to me. Max age of 45 either way though.
Personally I aimed to have all my babies before 35.

Why is it unreaonable for a woman to have a third in her 40s? My dm had her 5th & 6th in her 40s. We were all treated the same, and she lived another 45 years.

Her age made no difference to her,or to us.

myglowupera · Yesterday 18:02

Someone is always going to judge so you might as well do what you want to do anyway.

sittingonabeach · Yesterday 18:05

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 12:11

I apply the same logic of their body their choice to every subject concerning a woman’s reproductive organs.

Do you ever think of the potential child? So if they may bring a child into a complete shitshow

sittingonabeach · Yesterday 18:12

Meadowfinch · Yesterday 17:45

I had my ds (my only) at 45y2m. My pregnancy wasn't planned, we weren't trying, I had no medical assistance.

I had a very easy pregnancy, no nausea, worked all the way through,natural birth, healthy baby. He now 18 and at uni. No issues.

My dm had babies at 42 and 44, my dsis had two babies in her 40s. My dgm had two in her 40s. No issues with any of them. Before the pill it just wasn't that rare, and we as a family clearly have no issue conceiving later. Good genes I guess.

Given all of that, why should anyone judge if I was fit to have a baby. At 63 I'm still running 10ks, I still swim,cycle etc, so I look after myself, maintain fitness.

Clearly my body was able to conceive & carry a child at 44 without assistance. That should really be the only limiter.

Higher risk of complications both for women and the child with older parents.

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 18:24

Meadowfinch · Yesterday 17:45

I had my ds (my only) at 45y2m. My pregnancy wasn't planned, we weren't trying, I had no medical assistance.

I had a very easy pregnancy, no nausea, worked all the way through,natural birth, healthy baby. He now 18 and at uni. No issues.

My dm had babies at 42 and 44, my dsis had two babies in her 40s. My dgm had two in her 40s. No issues with any of them. Before the pill it just wasn't that rare, and we as a family clearly have no issue conceiving later. Good genes I guess.

Given all of that, why should anyone judge if I was fit to have a baby. At 63 I'm still running 10ks, I still swim,cycle etc, so I look after myself, maintain fitness.

Clearly my body was able to conceive & carry a child at 44 without assistance. That should really be the only limiter.

This is brilliant and really uplifting to read thank you ❤️

OP posts:
OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 18:27

LaurieFairyCake · Yesterday 17:48

Personal choice

I’d like to cut all the ‘young’ people under 40 a bit of slack because when I was young I’d likely have thought the same thing ‘menopause age seems a natural end’.

I don’t think that now as I’m literally surrounded by very elderly people in their late 80’s and 90’s still bloody driving and running everything. So as far as I’m concerned they could have had kids at 60 and still be fine.

I wouldn’t have thought that 20 years ago.

I totally get this mindset , the same when I was in my 20s and early 30s I think I would have had the same mindset too but like you say as you get older you realise you don’t feel loads different and have good examples of older people around you . So I totally agree .

OP posts:
catabhaile · Yesterday 18:53

I adopted my only child at 44 and I'm 63 now. It's worked fine for me, I still have tons of energy, work full time, gym, social life, hobbies etc. I guess for someone else it could be exhausting. It hasn't been for me though

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 19:08

catabhaile · Yesterday 18:53

I adopted my only child at 44 and I'm 63 now. It's worked fine for me, I still have tons of energy, work full time, gym, social life, hobbies etc. I guess for someone else it could be exhausting. It hasn't been for me though

This is how I like to see it , some people have bad lifestyle and probably can get in the way and be harder , but like you say it’s hasn’t stopped you and sounds like you are really thriving from it 🤩

OP posts:
sittingonabeach · Yesterday 19:19

My MIL was fit as flea at 70 (had more energy than me!). She used to complain about her friends all talking about their ailments. 3 years down the line her health has deteriorated significantly, and some days she struggles to walk. Her sibling (a few years older) again was reasonably fit until a couple of years ago, now in the depths of dementia. My DPs’ health started to wane after 75, again after being fit and hiking miles with the dog.

Simonjt · Yesterday 20:45

We didn’t want more than a 35 year age gap between us and our children, we just managed it, my husband was 29 and I was 34 when our youngest came home. I don’t know how older parents do it, especially birth parents as they start knackered and in recovery as well.

Crushed23 · Yesterday 20:48

moominontherun · Yesterday 12:19

I’m a bit more sanguine about this I think as I think a lot of people have kids who really shouldn’t, at any age, and I think a lot of kids and subsequently adults end up with much harder lives than any of the kids mentioned in your post will.

People having babies into their late 40s and early 50s tend to be pretty well off, so they are able to offer a different set of opportunities, with the flip side being they are likely to be around for less time. Are these children better to never have existed? You would hope that most people would rather be alive than not, which is what it comes down to really. And in most of these cases, the children grow up with privileged lives and are well provided for their adult lives too.

Having children is often an inherently selfish decision anyway, and there are plenty of posts from people on here who have had children in situations that aren’t ideal or who have regretted it.

i do find it interesting that Victoria Coren Mitchell never comes in for much criticism on here for this, I guess as she’s the ‘right’ kind of celebrity for MN!

But generally I think that if people are free to have babies with piece of shit men, when they can’t afford them, can’t dedicate emotional space to them, whatever, the age thing seems fairly minor in comparison.

Excellent post.

peanutForever · Yesterday 20:49

If you get pregnant naturally up to age 45- then thats the ideal age limit for me. In terms of everyone else if you are going beyond that and using donors etc id say its your choice what you do sometimes better to have a baby later than never

Ytrd · Yesterday 20:53

40

sittingonabeach · Yesterday 20:59

peanutForever · Yesterday 20:49

If you get pregnant naturally up to age 45- then thats the ideal age limit for me. In terms of everyone else if you are going beyond that and using donors etc id say its your choice what you do sometimes better to have a baby later than never

The child may not agree

Chilihealer · Yesterday 21:13

I like to think I have a mind my own business approach but part of me feels sad for the children, their inevitably going to get less time with their parents then their children even less time with grandparents. I understand all the reasons why people might not start having kids until later in life and I also understand a want to be a parent but I still feel sad for the kids and I think the parents don’t really consider this. I went to school with a girl whos parents had her in their 50s her dad was in his 70s when she left school and he died when she was early 20s. I’m early 30s and still have my grandma as does my partner in his mid thirties, my children will have strong memories of their great grandmas and I’m soo greatful for that. If we’d all started reproducing later this wouldn’t have been the case.

Saturdaysfairies · Yesterday 21:31

ThePeppyOpalScroller · Yesterday 12:29

Excect a mothers decisions affect the child. I don't think it's fair on a child to have them so late, that you get mistaken for their grandparents. Having a child in your late 40s means "grandparents" at the school gates and attending graduations in your late 60s.

We have never been mistanken for grandparents.
We had two kids in our early 30ties and a surprise one +40. Never been an issue.

ElanaohElana · Yesterday 21:33

I felt strongly I didn’t want to be over 35 for me personally for health reasons for me and the baby. But I think up to 45 is ‘acceptable’. I would worry for children born to a mum in their 50s just because I think losing your parent as a young adult would be so devastating.

Cherish707 · Yesterday 21:35

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 12:23

I do always wonder how women do menopause with a younger child , they must be warriors ! The job and working is a good point too.

Or a teenager! Young children are generally easier. What i did not realise that, as they get older, they need you far more. Maybe you don't need to be home for childcare when thry are older but it is more tiring emotionally.

Saturdaysfairies · Yesterday 21:41

Cherish707 · Yesterday 21:35

Or a teenager! Young children are generally easier. What i did not realise that, as they get older, they need you far more. Maybe you don't need to be home for childcare when thry are older but it is more tiring emotionally.

Tbh it's same same for us.
Maybe even esier with 3rd teen because we have done teenagers x2 and maybe because we don't work as many hours as we did buildning a career in our 30ties having young children and a morgage.

BatchCookBabe · Yesterday 21:51

100% 42-43 at the oldest. NO-ONE should be allowed IVF past that age.

This is my opinion.

And as I said on the other thread, I am not going to change it. No-one should be having babies past that age. It's so wrong on so many levels.