Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Acceptable age to have kids up to

193 replies

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 12:05

So in light of the other thread of the pregnant lady in her late 50s , what is seen as the acceptable age to go up to ?
These days with women focusing more on their careers and starting later , or just having trouble conceiving there are a lot more “ older mothers “
In some areas children into your 40s is not seen as a problem whereas other places it maybe not the done thing . Why is this ?

lots of celebrities are having children later, Anne Hathaway pregnant at 43 , Hallie berry had kids at 41 and 47 and more recently Hilary swank confirmed she was pregnant at the age of 52 .
many women don’t have their first child until late 30s / 40s for all sorts of reasons.

so is it unreasonable to want a baby at a later age and what age is just too far ?
what age up to do you think is acceptable and what isn’t ?
why are some people ok about it and others not ?

OP posts:
BatchCookBabe · Yesterday 21:51

100% 42-43 at the oldest. NO-ONE should be allowed IVF past that age.

This is my opinion.

And as I said on the other thread, I am not going to change it. No-one should be having babies past that age. It's so wrong on so many levels.

Jk987 · Yesterday 22:15

Late 40’s and 50’s will be from donor eggs or via surrogacy so it’s not the same. Having kids before menopause strikes is of course ok. Unless you think the there should be enforced contraception at 40!

PancakePatty · Yesterday 22:39

My only child was born via ivf when I was 41 and a half. 10 year infertility battle before I finally got pregnant.
I’m now 45 and the fertility ship has sailed.
We decided not to do a more ivf to try for a sibling, we felt the risks were too high and we needed to just breathe an enjoy our longed for child. Couldn’t be happier.

seahorsessky · Yesterday 22:48

arethereanyleftatall · Yesterday 12:21

I think it would be completely foolish to only think about ‘can I cope with a baby at 40’ and not ‘can I cope with a difficult teen during menopause’ or ‘do I want to be still working at 65 to pay for this child.’

ask any woman how tired and stressed she is during menopause, or how much less energy they have at 50 rather than 30, before making a decision

I see your point, but the fact is we don't know, we're all individuals. I know some young mums who have developed health problems making them really struggle, and some grans who haven't lived the healthiest lifestyle who seem capable of all day childcare at 70. I guess having a lot of people to help makes a difference too, which is maybe more likely when you're young.
A doctor told me 25 is best, but society isn't really set up to support that now.

Missey85 · Today 05:20

So women are free to make their own choices but only if they agree with you? 😂

GreyhpundGirl · Today 17:08

Shalalaa · Yesterday 12:31

I had mine at 29 33 and 35.

for me the cut off is around 40. I think I would still be happy for a friend at 40-42. After 42 I would judge a bit and be like hmm that’s not fair on the child.

I had my only at 43. How is that not fair on them? In what way? Please don't judge women.

WasFunbutnowOld · Today 17:09

Good on her, it sounds utterly exhausting to me but that's because I already have mine haha. I do understand that if you've longed for them and had to wait then it doesn't feel 'too late'. I think I'd be more worried about what ages the toddler and teen stages would hit ...

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Today 17:09

GreyhpundGirl · Today 17:08

I had my only at 43. How is that not fair on them? In what way? Please don't judge women.

Because your child will have elderly parents and possibly deal with age related complications at a young age. Many people believe it to be selfish to have children at an older age.

WitchesBritches · Today 17:15

Iheartlouie · Yesterday 12:27

I had mine at 22, 34 and 40

(age gaps as I have horrendous pregnancies with HG from 5 weeks until birth which even the strongest anti sickness drugs used for cancer patients didn’t touch, I have to blank out 8 months if my life to lay on the bathroom floor inbetween hospital admissions for dehydration).

40 was my limit and then only as dh (father of my two youngest) is 6 years younger than me.

I will say I was a far better mother in my 20s than I am now at 46, but that mainly due to life having ground me down.

Your youngest two are lucky to be alive!!

If I've been very ill with the pregnancy, the eldest would've been an only!!

Had I listened to people saying that you won't necessarily be that ill for subsequent pregnancies I might have been tempted into a second, but if I was there the second time there's no way I'd have had a third!!

I'm not sure if I think you were brave or mad!!

raininthemorning · Today 17:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Today 17:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What?

FFSItsTooHot · Today 17:19

I honestly think that having a baby after the age of 40 is a bit mad,but that's just my opinion. I had my DD very young (at 19) and with hindsight I'm so glad I did because since the age of 30,I've developed several health problems which have limited my mobility and leave me exhausted. At least having my DD at 19 meant that the bulk of her young years were out of the way whilst I was still fit and able. I shudder to think of the thought of having to have dealt with a young baby,then a toddler after I became ill. It was hard enough when she was 11,but I managed. But,if a woman feels that she is fit and able enough to cope with a pregnancy and looking after a newborn,then a toddler in her mid 40s or beyond,who am I to argue?

raininthemorning · Today 17:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Newsenmum · Today 17:21

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 12:11

I apply the same logic of their body their choice to every subject concerning a woman’s reproductive organs.

Even when it results in a live child?

RoseAndVioletCream · Today 17:24

Personal choice as most people have said. For me, I think 45 would be my limit

XenaSharples · Today 17:26

My friend had her only child at 47. My neighbour had her fourth at 48. My cousin had her only child at 42. Their children had great lives.

BlueSherbet · Today 17:30

I think its acceptable for a woman to have a child at any age where she can conceive a child naturally.

I would like to see an end to terms such as "an old mother" or "a very young mother". It should just be "a mother" - her child raising ability and the depth of her love is not altered by age.

I think IVF should be banned, especially for people whose natural fertility has come to an end - its an example of NHS mission creep and is also immoral given it destroys human embryos. At the same time, I recognise that infertility is a very difficult thing.

Mildredandherflowers · Today 17:33

I am 44 and since I can remember, all I ever wanted was to have loads of children. I was the first to offer to babysit for my parent's friends and children gravitated towards me my entire life. I even did some voluntary work with children with disabilities when I was a child. It was supposed to be for a month but I asked to stay on for longer. I went on to become an early years teacher and have been working with young children for over 2 decades.

As soon as I got married we tried for a baby immediately. I was 32. Two years later I had another and then when I was 39 I had my third. I work full time with 4 years olds too. Children are my life and I have a calling to make a difference to theirs.

I absolutely adore motherhood. I am a very loving attentive conscientious and caring mother and my children are all very kind, creative, caring and respectful people. I raise them to make the world a better place. They love me too and I just know that I am contributing to people who will make a difference.

Recently my husband and I discussed having another. I am 44. My heart absolutely leapt when he said it and we stopped preventing just this month. There is so much noise in my head about everything that can go wrong but I just can't not try. This isn't a flash in the pan premenopausal hormone spike. Its who I am. I always said that if my husband would have allowed it , I would have just kept going until it literally didn't happen any more. Children are a gift to me, and I know i do a good job. My home is full of laughter, joy, noise and chaos and I love it. If I can naturally conceive, I will gladly take that gift.

We are financially solid, the children are all very emotionally healthy, very happy and I think they would love it too. The newborn stuff doesn't bother me. The teenage stuff doesn't either. I just love children and watching them grow into wonderful people. My emotional and physical space for children seems infinite.

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Today 17:35

BlueSherbet · Today 17:30

I think its acceptable for a woman to have a child at any age where she can conceive a child naturally.

I would like to see an end to terms such as "an old mother" or "a very young mother". It should just be "a mother" - her child raising ability and the depth of her love is not altered by age.

I think IVF should be banned, especially for people whose natural fertility has come to an end - its an example of NHS mission creep and is also immoral given it destroys human embryos. At the same time, I recognise that infertility is a very difficult thing.

i started my period at 11 and could therefore conceive naturally, is that acceptable?
40+ is too old just like how under 20s is too young.

RosieHosie · Today 17:37

I became a grandparent at 47 and look after DGD one day a week. That is tiring enough. I can't imagine dealing with the relentlessness of parenting small children at that age FT (and working).

Sunnyphoenix · Today 17:37

Is this thread just about women having children or also men becoming fathers? There's always so much focus on female age, but much less on men, even though they are likely to have a much longer period in which they have the genuine possibility of becoming a (genetic) parent. Given that men are more likely than women to die at an early age, or suffer serious ill health, it's surprising it isn't talked about more.

Hadalifeonce · Today 17:38

I didn't meet DH until I was 40; I wasn't even thinking of having children at that stage in my life, but DH wanted them. I had DS and 42 and DD at 45. We did agree that if it didn't happen naturally, we wouldn't have them. Luckily, I am heathy and active.

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Today 17:38

Sunnyphoenix · Today 17:37

Is this thread just about women having children or also men becoming fathers? There's always so much focus on female age, but much less on men, even though they are likely to have a much longer period in which they have the genuine possibility of becoming a (genetic) parent. Given that men are more likely than women to die at an early age, or suffer serious ill health, it's surprising it isn't talked about more.

I think it’s the same for men but you’re welcome to make your own thread. This one is about a woman being pregnant at 59, men can’t be pregnant.

TheLovelinessOfDemons · Today 17:40

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 12:23

I do always wonder how women do menopause with a younger child , they must be warriors ! The job and working is a good point too.

Also, if you have a DC with ADHD, they're exhausting until they leave home, so consider whether that's a possibility. I had DS 15 at 44, he has ADHD and terrible impulse control. He needs a responsible adult with him at all times.

Sunnyphoenix · Today 17:41

Mummymaybeormaybenot · Today 17:38

I think it’s the same for men but you’re welcome to make your own thread. This one is about a woman being pregnant at 59, men can’t be pregnant.

I thought the other thread was about a woman being pregnant at 59 and this was a more general question about the accetaptable age to have kids. Most of the answers focus on women, and the OP is a woman, but the question seems more general, which is why I am asking,