Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Acceptable age to have kids up to

193 replies

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 12:05

So in light of the other thread of the pregnant lady in her late 50s , what is seen as the acceptable age to go up to ?
These days with women focusing more on their careers and starting later , or just having trouble conceiving there are a lot more “ older mothers “
In some areas children into your 40s is not seen as a problem whereas other places it maybe not the done thing . Why is this ?

lots of celebrities are having children later, Anne Hathaway pregnant at 43 , Hallie berry had kids at 41 and 47 and more recently Hilary swank confirmed she was pregnant at the age of 52 .
many women don’t have their first child until late 30s / 40s for all sorts of reasons.

so is it unreasonable to want a baby at a later age and what age is just too far ?
what age up to do you think is acceptable and what isn’t ?
why are some people ok about it and others not ?

OP posts:
malefields · Yesterday 12:53

I would say mid 40s, mostly because my grandma had my mother at 43 (and then another one at 45) and my mother always said she hated the generational divide being so big.

Selfishly, also because I’m late 30s and I cannot imagine having to deal with a newborn all over again now, let alone in 5-6 years.

PeachBlossom1234 · Yesterday 12:53

When I was with my XH we had infertility issues that required IVF (MF infertility) and I said I was happy to try up to being 42. We split when I was 32, and fell pregnant by my next BF at 33. I have to say that I am the second oldest mum in our school year group, and I'm old enough to be the teachers mum which isn't a great feeling.
I was diagnosed with breast cancer at 39 and went through the menopause as part of my treatment so that stage of my life is now over, but tbh, when I turned 42 and had that reflection, there's no way I'd have a newborn at that age!!

Dairythree · Yesterday 12:54

I think letting nature decide is a good rule of thumb. I had my eldest in my early 40s with no fertility help and I've not had any health issues and haven't found it too tiring. Our bodies are good at assessing what they can handle.

TheAmberKoala · Yesterday 12:57

I had my last kid in my 40s. dont give a shiny shit if its 'not the done thing' although Ive literally never come across anyone who thought that. Its very common where I am, but it was normal everywhere before contraception was available to have kids in your 40s. Anyone who says otherwise just comes across as jealous honestly.

TheCabbageMerchant · Yesterday 13:01

I was 40 with my last and that was my absolute cut off for me. I’m late 40s now and whilst I still have bags of energy; I’m really locked into my career again so it wouldn’t be for me, I’d be horrified!

MajorProcrastination · Yesterday 13:01

I'd say other people can do what they like and what they can and what works best for them. I'm glad we had our 3 in our 20s as we're now in our 40s. Part of that has been seeing our now teens with their grandparents (who were also in their 20s when they had their children so have been really active and involved).

But I also know that's not necessarily a choice for everyone. Some people are in a better place emotionally, financially, whatever when they're in their 30s or 40s.

I wouldn't want to be doing it all over again at my age but I've had friends have their first/only in their late 30s, early 40s and that's been the difference between them being a parent or not and I've been happy for them.

Some people are terrible parents at whatever age they are. The "but what about when you die" argument lost its power when my mate died in her 30s when her kid was a toddler, none of us really know how long we'll be here for. And how energetic and healthy we are? Some people lack energy and health and fitness in their 20s and 30s.

We'd have had a bit more money if we'd left it later but we'd not have the exact teens/adults we have now. I don't think I'm a worse or a better mum than my son's mate's mum who's 15+ years older than me.

I think a difference though between me and the older mums I know has been the responsibilities for the generation above. My parents have been in good health and are only just going into their 70s, some of my son's mates' parents are in their mid-late 50s or early 60s so their parents are older and need more support, care and all that. But then anyone can become disabled, it's just statistically more likely you'll be caring for 2 generations if you're an older parent.

Ilikeyoga · Yesterday 13:01

Depends. If a woman is in her 40s and conceived naturally then fair enough. If a woman of a similar age used an egg donor and ivf then that makes me uncomfortable (ivf for younger women is fine as it’ll be due to health issues not related to age). I don’t believe the celebs getting pregnant in their late 40s or 50s did so naturally. I agree with the NHS cut off for IVF which is very early 40s.

TheCabbageMerchant · Yesterday 13:02

TheAmberKoala · Yesterday 12:57

I had my last kid in my 40s. dont give a shiny shit if its 'not the done thing' although Ive literally never come across anyone who thought that. Its very common where I am, but it was normal everywhere before contraception was available to have kids in your 40s. Anyone who says otherwise just comes across as jealous honestly.

It is true - there was only a relatively short period of time where it wasn’t usual - and that’s when women got the pill! I’ve spent decades on my family tree and more women had babies in their 40s than didn’t.

TheAmberKoala · Yesterday 13:02

Thereshewasjustwalkingdownthestreet · Yesterday 12:43

IMO, if you’re not going to cope with a baby and keep up with the lack of sleep, running around after a baby or be there throughout their life when they’ll need you, then you’re too old. I was 32 and my boy is 8 now and I struggle 😂

Also there are many more issues likely with the pregnancy, baby and birth as you get older so that also feels selfish.

In general, the age related 'issues' are massively overstated by people who actually dont have a clue. This is from speaking to experts in the field. The risks increase, but a small amount, not in the over dramatic way that people state.

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 13:03

TheAmberKoala · Yesterday 12:57

I had my last kid in my 40s. dont give a shiny shit if its 'not the done thing' although Ive literally never come across anyone who thought that. Its very common where I am, but it was normal everywhere before contraception was available to have kids in your 40s. Anyone who says otherwise just comes across as jealous honestly.

You make a good point only have see comments against it online , never see or heard anyone say it in real life as such .
In also wonder if people judge differently if the mum in her 40s looks younger too, I know that probably sounds stupid most likely.
good on you I say !

OP posts:
Ilikeyoga · Yesterday 13:03

TheCabbageMerchant · Yesterday 13:02

It is true - there was only a relatively short period of time where it wasn’t usual - and that’s when women got the pill! I’ve spent decades on my family tree and more women had babies in their 40s than didn’t.

My x2 great grandma had a baby in her late 40s… but it was actually the baby of her unwed daughter. She just pretended the baby was hers.

BusyGreySnail · Yesterday 13:04

i am turning 43 soon and we have till now been open to another child, but i think this is it for me now. I feel too old and tired like it would be too big a jump to start over again with babies. I think I'm also moving into perimenopause and throwing pregancy hormones and no sleep into the mix is a recipe for disaster.

Ideally you wouldn't be supporting a childn into you retirement, and realistically you are "supporting" a child untill 21 these days (assuming uni or in work training), so 47 for the oldest parent.

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 13:04

Dairythree · Yesterday 12:54

I think letting nature decide is a good rule of thumb. I had my eldest in my early 40s with no fertility help and I've not had any health issues and haven't found it too tiring. Our bodies are good at assessing what they can handle.

That’s actually a really good take on it 😊

OP posts:
Minasama · Yesterday 13:06

Have a baby when you naturally can ie up to about age 43 in most cases.

Veer younger so you can retire earlier!! We had our kids about 10 years later than friends and their kids are finishing uni whereas ours will be another 10 years or so, meaning they are looking at the sunlit uplands of retirement and we need to keep slogging away!!

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 13:06

Ilikeyoga · Yesterday 13:01

Depends. If a woman is in her 40s and conceived naturally then fair enough. If a woman of a similar age used an egg donor and ivf then that makes me uncomfortable (ivf for younger women is fine as it’ll be due to health issues not related to age). I don’t believe the celebs getting pregnant in their late 40s or 50s did so naturally. I agree with the NHS cut off for IVF which is very early 40s.

Yes I think if your body is able to do it naturally then means it’s still in good shape too.

OP posts:
OffTheMap · Yesterday 13:06

Personal choice, personal circumstances, if you are of childbearing age and want to go for it, do.

Can't stand the constant assessing, judgement and commentary on women's choices.

Just stop it

TheAmberKoala · Yesterday 13:08

arethereanyleftatall · Yesterday 12:21

I think it would be completely foolish to only think about ‘can I cope with a baby at 40’ and not ‘can I cope with a difficult teen during menopause’ or ‘do I want to be still working at 65 to pay for this child.’

ask any woman how tired and stressed she is during menopause, or how much less energy they have at 50 rather than 30, before making a decision

well retirement age here is 67, so you will still be working either way 🙄
I also didnt have heaps less energy at 50 than at 30 so its not universal.

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 13:12

OffTheMap · Yesterday 13:06

Personal choice, personal circumstances, if you are of childbearing age and want to go for it, do.

Can't stand the constant assessing, judgement and commentary on women's choices.

Just stop it

I guess I do , maybe stupidly worry about how others would judge and if I’m being stupid in making the decision too, and just how people would be etc and all the other worries you have along the way with a child anyway.

For the record I do have a child so know what I’d be getting myself into and I have just turned 41 . I think for me personally I wouldn’t want to try after I’m 42 and a half to 43 but like everyone has said on here , everyone’s personal cut off is different and for all sorts of reasons and I respect that totally and don’t judge others.

I guess I have been wondering if I’m insane for trying 😁🙈

OP posts:
TheAmberKoala · Yesterday 13:13

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 13:03

You make a good point only have see comments against it online , never see or heard anyone say it in real life as such .
In also wonder if people judge differently if the mum in her 40s looks younger too, I know that probably sounds stupid most likely.
good on you I say !

On the looks thing, I think people do look 'younger' into their 40s and 50s due to better health care, but I think nowadays there is better representation of different aged women in the media and that also helps fight ageism.

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 13:14

I think I’m judging myself at times 🤣🙈🙈
i guess a lot of women have this debate with themselves . I do feel like if it’s meant to be then to do it naturally for me , I don’t want to go down a ivf personally for me , but get lots of women do and that’s fine.

OP posts:
OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 13:15

TheAmberKoala · Yesterday 13:13

On the looks thing, I think people do look 'younger' into their 40s and 50s due to better health care, but I think nowadays there is better representation of different aged women in the media and that also helps fight ageism.

That’s so true ! I think women are smashing it , used to always be every saying about how older men looked good and not the women , but think we are taking over now 😅

OP posts:
TheHouseofBamboo · Yesterday 13:19

I had mine at 38 and 40.
After DC2 was born I would have liked another but decided to quit while we had two healthy children. So in hindsight a couple of years earlier would be ideal.
I had 20 adult years before having children and that was right for me. I would have struggled at a younger age. It felt like I had a whole new life at 38.
I retired before DC were fully fledged but that was a bonus.

BirdLandedonmyHead · Yesterday 13:20

Their choice, as long as they can legally and morally consent.

But everyone nneeds to remember its for 20+ years, not just a cute littlenewborn.

plasticplate · Yesterday 13:24

I think a naturally conceived pregnancy is fine at any age. If having help I think 50 is the limit although personally I wouldn't and didn't try beyond my early 40s.

sHREDDIES19 · Yesterday 13:25

I had my last at 37 and I felt amazing, looked so youthful, full of energy. To me, that doesn't seem at all old but I base it on how I felt at that age.