Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unvaccinated children shouldn't be allowed in mainstream childcare or school

430 replies

ApronSprings · 11/10/2026 21:42

To think children shouldn't be allowed in nurseries or schools if their parents refuse to vaccinate them..

I'm excluding children who medically can't have them for some reason, and this will be too rare to cause a problem, and they deserve the benefit of herd immunity.

But I'm growing tired of the nutcase conspiracy theorists who failed GCSE science but think they've somehow found something missed by experts.

The only argument against this is that it keeps them home with their quack parents and reduces the opportunity for them to be exposed to normal people. But I don't think we should risk other people's lives for it if their parents aren't willing to do the same.

OP posts:
ApronSprings · 14/10/2026 07:19

Didimum · 12/10/2026 17:32

You’re playing straw man here. You can try to construct a wasteful policy ‘targeted’ outline and then declare it as no good. But that’s nothing like I suggested – I suggested targeting based on outbreaks and identifying susceptible children.

Once again, blanket and mandatory exclusion penalised children for their parents’ choices and is disproportionate to risk. This further harms children who already face disadvantage.

What you are failing to grasp is it is their parents who are excluding them by not getting them vaccinated. It's like any safety measure.
Sensible parents don't let kids cycle without helmets, it's the same concept, or wearing a seatbelt. If you aren't willing to do safety precautions, then you don't get access to certain things.

OP posts:
ApronSprings · 14/10/2026 07:46

ArabellaScott · 12/10/2026 20:38

Same here. I check evidence for each.

The HPV vaccine is wonderful. MMR, ditto. The long standing ones are well tested and have saved many lives. Amazing!

The flu vaccine, depends on the year and other factors. Covid, I took twice but not the kids. Because, as I posted upthread, the Joint Committee didnt rec it for kids.

Being aggressively pro all vaccines is just as blinkered as rejecting them all out of hand, imo. It just becomes another issue to get angry about.

I don't think anyone has raised COVID injection as a requirement here. It's childhood vaccines we are discussing.
I imagine schools would encourage children to have flu jabs in order to reduce sickness/time off from school.

For what it's worth, I don't particularly agree with chicken pox as a vaccine for all, and I definitely don't agree with it being put with the MMR jab. We've had positive experiences in my children having caught chicken pox at nursery (every single child got it!) and were very content at home for a few days. The lotions and potions you get now stop the itching so it is just a funny memory of all the spots. My youngest had the jab as part of the MMR and I'm slightly sad that it's a childhood experience they won't have but of course there is always the risk of it being more serious. I wasn't going to not have the MMR just to avoid the CP jab.

For me when I started this thread I had the classic ones in mind, MMR, Polio, etc. I feel COVID and flu are separate conversations because the former has had quite a few side effects and issues which we don't really see in the ones which have been around a long time, and reasonable parents might feel more apprehensive.

OP posts:
Imanautumn · 14/10/2026 07:49

Alwaystired23 · 11/10/2026 21:58

Wouldn't the vaccinated children be protected?

🤣🤣 clearly they don’t have much faith in the vaccines…. Wonder why some people refuse to get them 🤣🤣

Timeforachange26 · 14/10/2026 07:50

ApronSprings · 14/10/2026 07:05

When children with vomiting have to be kept off school, do you consider it exclusion? Would you insist they're allowed at school, even though they would be spreading a vomiting bug?
The only difference between this and an unvaccinated child is that the parents have chosen not to vaccinate, so would be choosing not to have them at school..

Not quite as an unvacccinated child can't spread an illness they don't actually have.

The fact they are not vaccinated doesn't mean they ate carrying around mumps measles etc to spread

ApronSprings · 14/10/2026 07:50

Didimum · 12/10/2026 22:09

A population with sufficient vaccination does not allow transmission. Why do you think over time endemic measles has been declared stopped by numerous countries (obviously it can return if vaccination rates drop)? How do you think smallpox infection was driven out of the world?

This is false. It depends on the disease, how well the vaccine works, how long immunity lasts, and whether the pathogen can survive or spread in other ways. Interesting you bring up smallpox because it was actually a disease that didn’t require anywhere near 100% vaccination to be eliminated. It was able to be eliminated partly due to the kind of disease it was and it’s characteristics – and crucially because it was less contagious than modern pathogens today. Increase of urbanisation, population growth and international travel also contribute. This is not to say that vaccination is not the gold standard – it’s just to demonstrate that now, outbreaks are inevitable, regardless of vaccination uptake.

What does this mean? That appeals are made to the parents of unvaccinated children to get them jabbed during outbreaks? That’s not a policy, it’s not ‘shielding’, it’s an inevitable step late in the day to try to stop yet more suffering that should never have happened in the first place.

No. You misunderstand (again). My original
point on targeting was targeted exclusion of unvaccinated and otherwise susceptible children from schools during outbreaks, not appealing to vaccinate – though that can done too. In fact, it already is.

Exclusion, fines and segregation does not increase vaccination uptake or other public health aims. Education and accessibility do – that’s public policy 101.

Edited

Actually, it is very well observed that mandatory vaccines to attend school does increase uptake of immunisations by a lot. We know this because it's what happens in many civilised countries.

OP posts:
Scamworried · 14/10/2026 07:54

ApronSprings · 14/10/2026 07:46

I don't think anyone has raised COVID injection as a requirement here. It's childhood vaccines we are discussing.
I imagine schools would encourage children to have flu jabs in order to reduce sickness/time off from school.

For what it's worth, I don't particularly agree with chicken pox as a vaccine for all, and I definitely don't agree with it being put with the MMR jab. We've had positive experiences in my children having caught chicken pox at nursery (every single child got it!) and were very content at home for a few days. The lotions and potions you get now stop the itching so it is just a funny memory of all the spots. My youngest had the jab as part of the MMR and I'm slightly sad that it's a childhood experience they won't have but of course there is always the risk of it being more serious. I wasn't going to not have the MMR just to avoid the CP jab.

For me when I started this thread I had the classic ones in mind, MMR, Polio, etc. I feel COVID and flu are separate conversations because the former has had quite a few side effects and issues which we don't really see in the ones which have been around a long time, and reasonable parents might feel more apprehensive.

@ApronSprings
You do realise that some children have had awful complications from chicken pox.

What you fail to grasp is once vaccinations become law - you won't get to choose.

So this could very well mean that COVID vaccine and other risky vaccines are also mandatory.

Futhermore, in an earlier post you mention vomiting. Interestingly enough schools are quite happy to insist unwell children are in school when that child has had too many absences due to medical appointments or unmet needs.

Scamworried · 14/10/2026 07:59

ApronSprings · 14/10/2026 07:50

Actually, it is very well observed that mandatory vaccines to attend school does increase uptake of immunisations by a lot. We know this because it's what happens in many civilised countries.

Countries that had this rule in place when vaccine uptake was higher and before vaccine injuries were as well known as they are now.

After COVID vaccine highlighted all that can go wrong with vaccine do you really feel that mandatory vaccines are a good idea?

I am against enforcement despite the fact we opted to vaccinate all childhood vaccines. I also home educate so we wouldn't have to do future vaccines if a new one came in as a requirement of school but this sets a dangerous president especially in light of other political moves the government are floating

AmIReallyTheGrownup · 14/10/2026 08:03

Most states in Australia make universal preschool (kindergarten) access conditional on having an up to date vaccination record.

I’d have no issue with the 3 year old universal funding (15 hours) being conditional on vaccination. You can still send your child to a care setting, it’ll just cost you more.

Didimum · 14/10/2026 08:05

ApronSprings · 14/10/2026 07:05

When children with vomiting have to be kept off school, do you consider it exclusion? Would you insist they're allowed at school, even though they would be spreading a vomiting bug?
The only difference between this and an unvaccinated child is that the parents have chosen not to vaccinate, so would be choosing not to have them at school..

This is why I mentioned targeted exclusions at the time of outbreaks, as opposed to blanket exclusions.

mumumental · 14/10/2026 08:05

Scamworried · 14/10/2026 07:59

Countries that had this rule in place when vaccine uptake was higher and before vaccine injuries were as well known as they are now.

After COVID vaccine highlighted all that can go wrong with vaccine do you really feel that mandatory vaccines are a good idea?

I am against enforcement despite the fact we opted to vaccinate all childhood vaccines. I also home educate so we wouldn't have to do future vaccines if a new one came in as a requirement of school but this sets a dangerous president especially in light of other political moves the government are floating

Problems are rare but conspiracy theorists love to pretend they aren’t, because it justifies their idiotic position.

Didimum · 14/10/2026 08:06

ApronSprings · 14/10/2026 07:19

What you are failing to grasp is it is their parents who are excluding them by not getting them vaccinated. It's like any safety measure.
Sensible parents don't let kids cycle without helmets, it's the same concept, or wearing a seatbelt. If you aren't willing to do safety precautions, then you don't get access to certain things.

Not failing to grasp it at all. It’s still not the child’s choice to not partake in those safety precautions. They should still get access to something that will prevent further deprivation.

walrushurricane · 14/10/2026 08:07

AmIReallyTheGrownup · 14/10/2026 08:03

Most states in Australia make universal preschool (kindergarten) access conditional on having an up to date vaccination record.

I’d have no issue with the 3 year old universal funding (15 hours) being conditional on vaccination. You can still send your child to a care setting, it’ll just cost you more.

That probably works better than not letting them in schools.

Didimum · 14/10/2026 08:27

ApronSprings · 14/10/2026 07:50

Actually, it is very well observed that mandatory vaccines to attend school does increase uptake of immunisations by a lot. We know this because it's what happens in many civilised countries.

That observation also showed that the mandatory rule was most effective for parents who had delayed vaccinations or not aware they had missed vaccinations – not who were unwilling to at all. It also showed that it was dependent on the vaccine – the HPV vaccine, for example, was shown to have high public resistance despite mandates. And this was due to trust in healthcare and accessibility.

A simple comparison between countries with and without mandates can be misleading because, as above, uptakes depends on factors such as ease of accessibility, public trust in healthcare, the attitude to exemptions (be that religious or personal).

We know this because several countries, such as Denmark, Norway and Sweden have among the highest vaccine coverage (topping 97%), with no vaccine mandates. These are the countries that have the highest accessibility, quality of education and trust in government and healthcare.

ArabellaScott · 14/10/2026 08:57

ApronSprings · 14/10/2026 07:46

I don't think anyone has raised COVID injection as a requirement here. It's childhood vaccines we are discussing.
I imagine schools would encourage children to have flu jabs in order to reduce sickness/time off from school.

For what it's worth, I don't particularly agree with chicken pox as a vaccine for all, and I definitely don't agree with it being put with the MMR jab. We've had positive experiences in my children having caught chicken pox at nursery (every single child got it!) and were very content at home for a few days. The lotions and potions you get now stop the itching so it is just a funny memory of all the spots. My youngest had the jab as part of the MMR and I'm slightly sad that it's a childhood experience they won't have but of course there is always the risk of it being more serious. I wasn't going to not have the MMR just to avoid the CP jab.

For me when I started this thread I had the classic ones in mind, MMR, Polio, etc. I feel COVID and flu are separate conversations because the former has had quite a few side effects and issues which we don't really see in the ones which have been around a long time, and reasonable parents might feel more apprehensive.

Okay. So thats a bit more of a nuanced position than your OP. The whole point of mandatory vaccines is that you wouldn't get to make those decisions or distinctions. Once that very basic but crucial element of choice is lost a line is crossed.

Vaccine practises are changing constantly, making any kind of rule about mandating medical choices is fraught.

Political.decisons about vaccines dont always match up with health authorities' advice. Who gets to choose what is mandatory? Nicola Sturgeon? Health Secretary?

Scamworried · 14/10/2026 09:04

mumumental · 14/10/2026 08:05

Problems are rare but conspiracy theorists love to pretend they aren’t, because it justifies their idiotic position.

Are you children vaccinated for COVID?

Would you vaccinate your child no matter what your personal belief about a vaccine or would you prefer to make decision based on risk v benefit.

I have vaccinated my children but that doesn't mean I believe the choice should not be parents to make

ApronSprings · 14/10/2026 09:10

Scamworried · 14/10/2026 09:04

Are you children vaccinated for COVID?

Would you vaccinate your child no matter what your personal belief about a vaccine or would you prefer to make decision based on risk v benefit.

I have vaccinated my children but that doesn't mean I believe the choice should not be parents to make

Nobody is saying it shouldn't be parents choice to make. The question is if the parents exercise their right to not give their kids basic preventative healthcare, whether this should mean that right trumps other people's right to an education free of deadly diseases. If they want their kids to have polio and measles then absolutely go for it, but they aren't entitled to put other people at risk so would have consequences to those decisions.

I have a right to have a poo, but I don't have the right to poo on someone else. If someone says I can't poo on them it doesn't mean I'm not allowed to poo it just means I have to poo somewhere that it doesn't affect others.

OP posts:
ApronSprings · 14/10/2026 09:14

ArabellaScott · 14/10/2026 08:57

Okay. So thats a bit more of a nuanced position than your OP. The whole point of mandatory vaccines is that you wouldn't get to make those decisions or distinctions. Once that very basic but crucial element of choice is lost a line is crossed.

Vaccine practises are changing constantly, making any kind of rule about mandating medical choices is fraught.

Political.decisons about vaccines dont always match up with health authorities' advice. Who gets to choose what is mandatory? Nicola Sturgeon? Health Secretary?

I don't think it's that nuanced of a position, as far as I'm aware children don't get the COVID jab as standard.

OP posts:
walrushurricane · 14/10/2026 09:32

ApronSprings · 14/10/2026 09:10

Nobody is saying it shouldn't be parents choice to make. The question is if the parents exercise their right to not give their kids basic preventative healthcare, whether this should mean that right trumps other people's right to an education free of deadly diseases. If they want their kids to have polio and measles then absolutely go for it, but they aren't entitled to put other people at risk so would have consequences to those decisions.

I have a right to have a poo, but I don't have the right to poo on someone else. If someone says I can't poo on them it doesn't mean I'm not allowed to poo it just means I have to poo somewhere that it doesn't affect others.

I don't think they should be entitled to let their children get measles or polio tbh. They don't own them. They should be prosecuted if their child comes to harm because they are unvaccinated.

YourAmplePlumPoster · 14/10/2026 09:57

I lived in both Spain and France where vaccines are mandatory for school attendance. There don't seem to any major problems regarding exclusion.

ArabellaScott · 14/10/2026 09:58

ApronSprings · 14/10/2026 09:10

Nobody is saying it shouldn't be parents choice to make. The question is if the parents exercise their right to not give their kids basic preventative healthcare, whether this should mean that right trumps other people's right to an education free of deadly diseases. If they want their kids to have polio and measles then absolutely go for it, but they aren't entitled to put other people at risk so would have consequences to those decisions.

I have a right to have a poo, but I don't have the right to poo on someone else. If someone says I can't poo on them it doesn't mean I'm not allowed to poo it just means I have to poo somewhere that it doesn't affect others.

This is a very odd metaphor to choose.

ArabellaScott · 14/10/2026 10:04

ApronSprings · 14/10/2026 09:14

I don't think it's that nuanced of a position, as far as I'm aware children don't get the COVID jab as standard.

So, is TB going to be mandatory? Meningitis? Emergency vaccines for as yet unknown disease? Which ones will you exclude? Why do you get to make that choice and not any other person?

Up to me I'd have not had the Meningitis vax scrapped. But the decisions made aren't always the ones I'd agree with. Other things like costs and social factors come into play.

The only fair and effective method is the one we have now- only I'd advocate more info and more transparency.

Timeforachange26 · 14/10/2026 10:09

walrushurricane · 14/10/2026 09:32

I don't think they should be entitled to let their children get measles or polio tbh. They don't own them. They should be prosecuted if their child comes to harm because they are unvaccinated.

So what if the kid gets measles even if they are vaccinated. How many of you lot on here would be jumping to villify the parents as soon as its known child has measles

bullinchina · 14/10/2026 10:20

I personally am pro vaccine, but feel uncomfortable with a policy mandating that we have to do something to our bodies. It should be personal choice

Scamworried · 14/10/2026 11:37

ApronSprings · 14/10/2026 09:10

Nobody is saying it shouldn't be parents choice to make. The question is if the parents exercise their right to not give their kids basic preventative healthcare, whether this should mean that right trumps other people's right to an education free of deadly diseases. If they want their kids to have polio and measles then absolutely go for it, but they aren't entitled to put other people at risk so would have consequences to those decisions.

I have a right to have a poo, but I don't have the right to poo on someone else. If someone says I can't poo on them it doesn't mean I'm not allowed to poo it just means I have to poo somewhere that it doesn't affect others.

Ok so if a vaccine like COVID or a vaccine that wasn't proven (and you didn't want your child to have )was mandatory you would be happy that this meant you were forced to give it your child or home educate if you didn't?

Scamworried · 14/10/2026 11:42

ApronSprings · 14/10/2026 09:14

I don't think it's that nuanced of a position, as far as I'm aware children don't get the COVID jab as standard.

It's not standard YET

things can change - you are wanting parental choice scrapped but don't seem to comprehend if parental choice (free choice not blackmail or forced options) is scrapped that could result in choices you wish to make also being overturned.

You can not forsee what vaccines will or won't become mandatory or what other parent decisions may be overturned to government choice in th slippery slope takes hold. It won't always be ones you agree with.

Swipe left for the next trending thread