Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unvaccinated children shouldn't be allowed in mainstream childcare or school

430 replies

ApronSprings · 11/10/2026 21:42

To think children shouldn't be allowed in nurseries or schools if their parents refuse to vaccinate them..

I'm excluding children who medically can't have them for some reason, and this will be too rare to cause a problem, and they deserve the benefit of herd immunity.

But I'm growing tired of the nutcase conspiracy theorists who failed GCSE science but think they've somehow found something missed by experts.

The only argument against this is that it keeps them home with their quack parents and reduces the opportunity for them to be exposed to normal people. But I don't think we should risk other people's lives for it if their parents aren't willing to do the same.

OP posts:
Didimum · 12/10/2026 12:31

AllIwantForChrismasIsAKitchenAidStandMixer · 12/10/2026 12:30

You can’t have it both ways - you can’t say they shouldn’t have to pay for their parents’ decisions and then say that they shouldn’t have to be vaccinated.

I can say exactly that!

AllIwantForChrismasIsAKitchenAidStandMixer · 12/10/2026 12:35

Didimum · 12/10/2026 12:31

I can say exactly that!

You can but that doesn’t mean it follows any kind of internal consistent logic

Didimum · 12/10/2026 12:36

AllIwantForChrismasIsAKitchenAidStandMixer · 12/10/2026 12:35

You can but that doesn’t mean it follows any kind of internal consistent logic

It does when education is a fundamental right but vaccination is a public health aim.

JohnofWessex · 12/10/2026 12:46

Would it be possible to vaccinate the unvaccinated on Day 1 at school and haul in the 'Home Ed/' ones whether the parents wanted it or not?

I also suggest that we need to look at should we allow some of those who support 'unscientific' medicine into the UK if they are not UK nationals?

attichoarder · 12/10/2026 12:55

OnlyOneAdda · 12/10/2026 11:06

The broad sweeping statements on this thread are wild and if the pro-vaxxers think this is topic is exclusively about “scientific fact” then they are naive or stupid.

The overwhelming evidence is that a vaccine for Measles is a sensible choice and the risk from the vaccine vs the risk of the disease is heavily weighted in favour of the vaccine.

Annual flu vaccines for children are not about the children’s health but about preventing flu in the elderly. Much more grey area. Risk of vaccine vs risk of disease much less compelling because the risk of the disease to a healthy child is very low. Is it morally right to give a medical intervention to a child to benefit others rather than the child themselves? Even though the risks are low and mild, any risk at all is potentially unnecessary for the child’s own health. There are arguments for and against this one, it’s not black and white.

COVID vaccines for children weren’t in any way about “scientific fact” . They were very new, hadn’t been widely tested, certainly not over a long period of time. By the time vaccines were rolled out, the risk to a healthy child of COVID was low; and the potential risks of the vaccine largely unknown. But anyone choosing not to vaccinate their child would be excluded from accessing certain activities and venues, travelling had to undergo repetitive testing etc. COVID vaccines, like many COVID policies were about politics not science, and many of the measures supposed to have protected have subsequently been shown to harm.

Not all vaccines are the same. Not all of them are black and white. The motivations for rolling them out are not always about pure science or health benefits and they won’t always be in the future.

I totally agree, the debate isn’t as simple as it is implied.

ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 13:03

BePeachNewt · 12/10/2026 00:36

Linguistic choices are telling. No human belongs to another and the fact that you use that language with regards to your children is highly revealing, no matter what you say.

The risk of vaccine injury from any approved vaccine is so minuscule as to be statistically insignificant. The risk of severe harm from contracting any of the diseases that vaccines seek to prevent is anything but statistically insignificant.

Take measles - approximately two people out of every million who receive the measles vaccine suffer serious harm or injury. By contrast, one out of every five unvaccinated people who contract measles suffer serious illness requiring hospitalisation. One in twenty develop pneumonia. One in a thousand die.

You are not making an ‘informed decision.’ You are actually just being incredibly selfish, relying on other, more responsible parents to protect your child by vaccinating their own children - hopefully in sufficient numbers to generate herd immunity and prevent the harmful pathogens your child has no protection against from circulating.

As more and more parents, like yourself, make the selfish (and statistically illiterate) decision not to vaccinate your children, there will be more and more outbreaks of measles, mumps, polio etc and children like yours will suffer serious harm on a regular basis (like the 50% of children who didn’t reach adulthood before modern medicine). I imagine your evaluation of that 2 in a million risk will look rather different at that point.

Completely agree.

This is what antivaxers can never grasp.

Vaccines are so effective that people are refusing them because they can't seem to get their heads around how preventative measures work.
The reason people had loads of kids before is because they'd all die by 30!

OP posts:
Kalanthe · 12/10/2026 13:11

I would 100% agree as a measure to protect other children. The first round of vaccines only starts working from when babies are 10 weeks old. Measles are back here in London due to antivaxers and I was so worried my baby would catch something while I was collecting my older son from preschool.

I'm against it though as children of nutjobs need to be protected too. It would start a wave of homeschooling by people who are completely unfit to teach even at a primary school level. Those children would have their lives ruined in more ways than susceptibility to infectious diseases. Also not all antivaxers are nutjobs - some are just not very bright and completely misinformed by dangerous online influencers, they think they're saving their children from dying from "vaccine injury". I think online influencers should be regulated first and banned from discussing medical issues unless they're a medical doctor

ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 13:12

MrsMorrisey · 12/10/2026 04:40

Geez calm down. Should we not give hospital cover to smokers and drinkers either?

Are you saying antivaxers are addicted to not taking preventative medicine?
I'm fairly certain it's much more difficult to give up an addiction than it is to receive the occasional sharp scratch.

OP posts:
ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 14:14

Awkwardisfunny · 12/10/2026 07:32

No chance. No one is forcing me to inject anything in to anyone.

You wouldn't be forced. If you wanted your child to be part of society and get those sorts of benefits of being part of a community, such as attending school, they would of course need to have mandatory vaccinations. Just as children can't come to school with sickness and diarrhea because it would make other children poorly.

OP posts:
ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 14:17

Kalanthe · 12/10/2026 13:11

I would 100% agree as a measure to protect other children. The first round of vaccines only starts working from when babies are 10 weeks old. Measles are back here in London due to antivaxers and I was so worried my baby would catch something while I was collecting my older son from preschool.

I'm against it though as children of nutjobs need to be protected too. It would start a wave of homeschooling by people who are completely unfit to teach even at a primary school level. Those children would have their lives ruined in more ways than susceptibility to infectious diseases. Also not all antivaxers are nutjobs - some are just not very bright and completely misinformed by dangerous online influencers, they think they're saving their children from dying from "vaccine injury". I think online influencers should be regulated first and banned from discussing medical issues unless they're a medical doctor

All the evidence suggests that countries where it's mandatory, it increases the uptake of vaccines. I don't believe it's led to a huge increase in homeschooling in Australia, Frances, Canada?

OP posts:
graygoose · 12/10/2026 14:21

So I live in a country where vaccination is mandatory for children to attend childcare and school. It’s also mandatory if you are an immigrant or expat i.e. as part of your paperwork to move to this country you have to show your child has had a specific vaccination schedule.

It’s a popular expat destination with a nice lifestyle. And I am always very amused when I see mums on Facebook forums asking for details on the vaccination schedules and where in their home countries (usually the US or UK) can they take their previously unvaccinated kids to get their shots.

Turns out a fair few anti vaxxers are very happy to throw their principles out of the window for the right incentive.

Hoodle · 12/10/2026 14:34

Didimum · 12/10/2026 12:36

It does when education is a fundamental right but vaccination is a public health aim.

Children are offered schooling as a right. All a mandatory vaccine policy would do is make the fundamental right safer to take part in for all. There’s no tension between vaccination and the provision of education. If you don’t want to meet the (entirely beneficial) requirements for the right provided by the state, do it yourself, at home.

Didimum · 12/10/2026 14:49

Hoodle · 12/10/2026 14:34

Children are offered schooling as a right. All a mandatory vaccine policy would do is make the fundamental right safer to take part in for all. There’s no tension between vaccination and the provision of education. If you don’t want to meet the (entirely beneficial) requirements for the right provided by the state, do it yourself, at home.

It's an assumption that because a requirement males a right safer to exercise that automatically makes the requirement justified. Calling a requirement beneficial doesn't settle whether it is proportionate, whether it is the least restrictive effective option or whether the burden it imposes is fair.

The key issue is that the state would not simply be regulating a parent's choice, it would be withholding mainstream education from a child who may have had no say in the choice. Saying that the family can educate at home doesn't eliminate that consequence.

Nor does the fact that vaccination reduces risk establish that every unvaccinated child poses the same level of risk in every situation. There is a difference between temporarily excluding a susceptible child during a serious outbreak and imposing a blanket exclusion on every unvaccinated child, regardless of the disease, circumstances or actual risk.

Of course, the state can legitimately restrict individual freedoms to protect others, but that is precisely why the policy needs to be justified, rather treated as self-evidently correct. We should ask whether better vaccine access, targeted restrictions during outbreaks and other less restrictive measures could achieve the same public health objective.

walrushurricane · 12/10/2026 15:18

Didimum · 12/10/2026 14:49

It's an assumption that because a requirement males a right safer to exercise that automatically makes the requirement justified. Calling a requirement beneficial doesn't settle whether it is proportionate, whether it is the least restrictive effective option or whether the burden it imposes is fair.

The key issue is that the state would not simply be regulating a parent's choice, it would be withholding mainstream education from a child who may have had no say in the choice. Saying that the family can educate at home doesn't eliminate that consequence.

Nor does the fact that vaccination reduces risk establish that every unvaccinated child poses the same level of risk in every situation. There is a difference between temporarily excluding a susceptible child during a serious outbreak and imposing a blanket exclusion on every unvaccinated child, regardless of the disease, circumstances or actual risk.

Of course, the state can legitimately restrict individual freedoms to protect others, but that is precisely why the policy needs to be justified, rather treated as self-evidently correct. We should ask whether better vaccine access, targeted restrictions during outbreaks and other less restrictive measures could achieve the same public health objective.

They could insist the parent teaches the child properly and fine them if they don't so they do get an education. Parents could also be fined if the child becomes ill because they haven't been vaccinated.

CarbootJunction · 12/10/2026 15:19

Esther Rantzen, is that you?

ArabellaScott · 12/10/2026 15:32

attichoarder · 12/10/2026 12:55

I totally agree, the debate isn’t as simple as it is implied.

Absolutely.

And if people smear people for looking for evidence based information they will undermine the entire enterprise of vaccines and sow more mistrust.

Damage has already been done by politically motivated campaigns.

Some vaccines are miraculous and life saving; others are less well evidenced and the issues are more complex.

The best approach is to treat people with respect, provide clear and evidence based in formation, and explain wider issues honestly and accurately.

ArabellaScott · 12/10/2026 15:34

BePeachNewt · 12/10/2026 09:36

Parents who choose not to vaccinate their children are either unhinged, uneducated or simply selfish. That is a fact.

The ‘aggression’ stems from the fact that because of people like you, measles is now circulating in the UK again, after over 50 years of near-zero transmission rates. That makes me incredibly angry and I won’t moderate my anger to mollify selfish idiots.

This kind of black and white thinking and aggressive othering and attempts to shame doesnt help anyone.

Hoodle · 12/10/2026 15:40

Didimum · 12/10/2026 14:49

It's an assumption that because a requirement males a right safer to exercise that automatically makes the requirement justified. Calling a requirement beneficial doesn't settle whether it is proportionate, whether it is the least restrictive effective option or whether the burden it imposes is fair.

The key issue is that the state would not simply be regulating a parent's choice, it would be withholding mainstream education from a child who may have had no say in the choice. Saying that the family can educate at home doesn't eliminate that consequence.

Nor does the fact that vaccination reduces risk establish that every unvaccinated child poses the same level of risk in every situation. There is a difference between temporarily excluding a susceptible child during a serious outbreak and imposing a blanket exclusion on every unvaccinated child, regardless of the disease, circumstances or actual risk.

Of course, the state can legitimately restrict individual freedoms to protect others, but that is precisely why the policy needs to be justified, rather treated as self-evidently correct. We should ask whether better vaccine access, targeted restrictions during outbreaks and other less restrictive measures could achieve the same public health objective.

Well, I suppose one could imagine schooling where unvaccinated children have to go to specially segregated portakabins for lessons, have their breaks at different times to the rest of the school and generally be isolated.. Their teachers could be paid more to reflect the increased risk they run.

Would that be more proportionate? Would that be a less restrictive policy than having a policy of enrolment depending on vaccination or genuine exemption?

But of course that would be a complete waste of money and would end up with ‘normal’ school and ‘contagion’ school. Which would be a lot harder on the unvaccinated children, because of their idiotic parents. So I’d expect those parents to kick up a fuss, and we’d be back to the most simple and proportionate response which would be to safeguard all the other children, and the community more generally, by imposing a condition of entry requiring that all pupils have had the free, safe vaccinations on offer or are genuinely exempt.

Some of the other very good ideas you put forward for increasing vaccine uptake can be run in addition to a requirement that pupils are vaccinated or genuinely exempt. If these other initiatives get all children vaccinated, the enrolment vaccine requirement won’t matter.

The whole point of sufficiently wide vaccination is that there wouldn’t be outbreaks, so we don’t need to bother with “targeted restrictions during outbreaks”.

Didimum · 12/10/2026 15:40

walrushurricane · 12/10/2026 15:18

They could insist the parent teaches the child properly and fine them if they don't so they do get an education. Parents could also be fined if the child becomes ill because they haven't been vaccinated.

While targeted policy will always be more defensible that blanket policy, since it’s been demonstrated that unvaccinated children are more likely to arise from deprived backgrounds and areas, I would argue a policy such as this would only deepen deprivation and underprivilege. A fine does not improve education nor improve health outcomes – accessibility to resources do.

Timeforachange26 · 12/10/2026 15:43

ArabellaScott · 12/10/2026 15:32

Absolutely.

And if people smear people for looking for evidence based information they will undermine the entire enterprise of vaccines and sow more mistrust.

Damage has already been done by politically motivated campaigns.

Some vaccines are miraculous and life saving; others are less well evidenced and the issues are more complex.

The best approach is to treat people with respect, provide clear and evidence based in formation, and explain wider issues honestly and accurately.

Yeah even the NHS had varying ideas on vaccines. Take BCG for example. When I was a kid the state school kids had testing and if necessary given the vaccine. Didn't seem to do anything about kids not in state schools

Then when my eldest 2 were born tthe bcg vaccine was only given to kids of Asian origin. Despite living in a part of London at the time that had really high TB rates.

12 years later When DS was born ( and ironically I was living in a very white area) he was given the jab automatically

So thinking of that my DDs didn't have the bcg vaccination. Hope that doesn't make me an antivaxer

TealHacks · 12/10/2026 16:05

ArabellaScott · 12/10/2026 15:34

This kind of black and white thinking and aggressive othering and attempts to shame doesnt help anyone.

And neither has decades of tip-toeing around pro-diseasers, treating them as an alternative voice to scientific fact.

ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 16:09

Tel12 · 12/10/2026 10:39

Free country. People have the right to choose as a result.

People don't have a right to put other people at risk. One person's rights don't trump everyone else's.

OP posts:
IronEverything · 12/10/2026 16:22

ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 16:09

People don't have a right to put other people at risk. One person's rights don't trump everyone else's.

Do you apply the same logic to all areas of life? If so, I assume you're anti-abortion as well as pro-vax?

ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 16:25

IronEverything · 12/10/2026 16:22

Do you apply the same logic to all areas of life? If so, I assume you're anti-abortion as well as pro-vax?

Edited

The human carrying the cells has rights. Some cells don't have rights.

OP posts:
Scarlettpixie · 12/10/2026 16:44

Curious as to where this would stop..

Why are non vaccinated adults not considered to be putting people at risk and reducing herd immunity. What about in schools or hospitals? Shouldn't teachers and hospital staff be required to be vaccinated wherever possible?

Where did you sit with the covid jab? Did you have it, did you think it should be compulsory or optional? Again what about staff in schools or hospitals - bearing in mind we were in the middle of a pandemic.

While I think anti vaxers are either conspiracy theorists or just selfishly thinking they don't want to put their child at risk by giving them the vaccine but are happy to accept the protection most kids having it offers, I don't think banning un-vaccinated children from school is the answer. You either make it compulsory or you don't and there are real risks in allowing the state to control this sort of thing in terms of what's going to be next. I do think you can draw the line though between behaviour that puts others at risk and that which only affects the individual and other countries like France and Canada have done it so I am conflicted.

I am personally a big fan of vaccines but they are not without risk and I can see why people might be reluctant if they personally know people who have had a bad reaction or even died. I am 54 and my mum didn't take me for the measles vaccine after my cousin who is a few years after was really poorly after. I did catch measles as a child and made a full recovery. I had all the other vaccines as they were offered at the time. My son has also had everything that has been offered plus the MEN B which we had to pay for when he started uni (he is now year 2). We both have flu vax every year and I have been tempted to pay for the covid vax since I am no longer offered it but it's £100 so I haven't.