Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unvaccinated children shouldn't be allowed in mainstream childcare or school

430 replies

ApronSprings · 11/10/2026 21:42

To think children shouldn't be allowed in nurseries or schools if their parents refuse to vaccinate them..

I'm excluding children who medically can't have them for some reason, and this will be too rare to cause a problem, and they deserve the benefit of herd immunity.

But I'm growing tired of the nutcase conspiracy theorists who failed GCSE science but think they've somehow found something missed by experts.

The only argument against this is that it keeps them home with their quack parents and reduces the opportunity for them to be exposed to normal people. But I don't think we should risk other people's lives for it if their parents aren't willing to do the same.

OP posts:
Didimum · 12/10/2026 17:32

Hoodle · 12/10/2026 15:40

Well, I suppose one could imagine schooling where unvaccinated children have to go to specially segregated portakabins for lessons, have their breaks at different times to the rest of the school and generally be isolated.. Their teachers could be paid more to reflect the increased risk they run.

Would that be more proportionate? Would that be a less restrictive policy than having a policy of enrolment depending on vaccination or genuine exemption?

But of course that would be a complete waste of money and would end up with ‘normal’ school and ‘contagion’ school. Which would be a lot harder on the unvaccinated children, because of their idiotic parents. So I’d expect those parents to kick up a fuss, and we’d be back to the most simple and proportionate response which would be to safeguard all the other children, and the community more generally, by imposing a condition of entry requiring that all pupils have had the free, safe vaccinations on offer or are genuinely exempt.

Some of the other very good ideas you put forward for increasing vaccine uptake can be run in addition to a requirement that pupils are vaccinated or genuinely exempt. If these other initiatives get all children vaccinated, the enrolment vaccine requirement won’t matter.

The whole point of sufficiently wide vaccination is that there wouldn’t be outbreaks, so we don’t need to bother with “targeted restrictions during outbreaks”.

You’re playing straw man here. You can try to construct a wasteful policy ‘targeted’ outline and then declare it as no good. But that’s nothing like I suggested – I suggested targeting based on outbreaks and identifying susceptible children.

Once again, blanket and mandatory exclusion penalised children for their parents’ choices and is disproportionate to risk. This further harms children who already face disadvantage.

IronEverything · 12/10/2026 17:51

ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 16:25

The human carrying the cells has rights. Some cells don't have rights.

That explains a lot.

SaySomethingMan · 12/10/2026 17:56

Surely they are a tiny minority and majority of people including you, are contributing to herd immunity by vaccinating. Why let this bother you?
I know nurses and doctors who are against vaccinating their children btw. I don’t know this reasons for refusing the vaccinations but they are not all people who failed science GCSEs.

walrushurricane · 12/10/2026 18:05

SaySomethingMan · 12/10/2026 17:56

Surely they are a tiny minority and majority of people including you, are contributing to herd immunity by vaccinating. Why let this bother you?
I know nurses and doctors who are against vaccinating their children btw. I don’t know this reasons for refusing the vaccinations but they are not all people who failed science GCSEs.

Doctors aren't against vaccinating their children. Unless you are talking about the grifters on social media of course.

BrucesBarAndGrill · 12/10/2026 18:18

maybemaybenot17363 · 11/10/2026 22:47

I heard a quote once "I won't set my child on fire, to keep yours warm". I find this debate highly amusing. You don't have to worry - your children are protected by the amazing vaccines aren't they? 😍

Do people assume that parents who vaccinate are only worried about their own vaccinated children?

Awkwardisfunny · 12/10/2026 18:26

ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 14:14

You wouldn't be forced. If you wanted your child to be part of society and get those sorts of benefits of being part of a community, such as attending school, they would of course need to have mandatory vaccinations. Just as children can't come to school with sickness and diarrhea because it would make other children poorly.

Not sure why you're defending this post so aggressively. You asked a question but you're dismissing every alternative viewpoint without the slightest sign of having considered the reasoning. There is no sensible discussion here, just a dictatorship.

As it happens, I do (or used to) agree that people who refused proven vaccinations, were idiots and shouldn't be allowed to potentially harm their children and others. But in recent times, governments and people in power have proven time and time again that we cannot trust them. We have had serious ethical violations brought to our attention. So no, I won't be participating in any current vaccination schemes but if I ever got to know someone I trusted, who had the skill and knowledge to understand what serum / vaccine was in front of them, i.e. a scientist / virologist, I would let them vaccinate my child with proven vaccines.

It's selfish and narrow-minded to insist that only your viewpoint is the appropriate one. It isn't.

Awkwardisfunny · 12/10/2026 18:34

Celtic1hair · 12/10/2026 08:35

Then I assume you will have the courage of your convictions to live by the concequences of your ill informed decisions.
I do not however want to live with the avoidable risks you have decided are appropriate.

Yes, I do. Proven vaccines are fine. Brand new ones produced by unethical people in power - not a chance. And separately: no chance would I ever support forcing people to inject anything in order to participate in society. That's a slippery slope given how many crazy people are out there and the access to crazy tech like CRISPR.

Have you heard about the doctors who impregnated women with their own sperm during their IVF process? There is too much risk with forcing people to have any type of medical procedure. It shouldn't be compulsory in order to participate in society. It's short-sighted and ignorant of the bigger picture to narrow the scope to just "get vaccinated". Step back and look at the bigger picture.

Scamworried · 12/10/2026 18:52

@ApronSprings
Do you stay home when you're ill?

Your illness could be a death sentence for someone vulnerable.
If you feel so strongly about vaccines then by your own logic you wouldn't be going out to work, to the pub, shopping or to guy every time you have a minor infection or virus in case you pass this on to someone else

ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 20:02

Scamworried · 12/10/2026 18:52

@ApronSprings
Do you stay home when you're ill?

Your illness could be a death sentence for someone vulnerable.
If you feel so strongly about vaccines then by your own logic you wouldn't be going out to work, to the pub, shopping or to guy every time you have a minor infection or virus in case you pass this on to someone else

A minor infection is not the same as a disease with a low survival rate like Polio. Do you go to the hospital for a papercut? If not then you shouldn't go with a heart attack. That's your logic.

But as you asked - yes, if I was meeting with people who are immunocompromised I would not attend even with a cold, for example babies, people with serious health conditions, elderly relatives.

OP posts:
ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 20:06

Awkwardisfunny · 12/10/2026 18:26

Not sure why you're defending this post so aggressively. You asked a question but you're dismissing every alternative viewpoint without the slightest sign of having considered the reasoning. There is no sensible discussion here, just a dictatorship.

As it happens, I do (or used to) agree that people who refused proven vaccinations, were idiots and shouldn't be allowed to potentially harm their children and others. But in recent times, governments and people in power have proven time and time again that we cannot trust them. We have had serious ethical violations brought to our attention. So no, I won't be participating in any current vaccination schemes but if I ever got to know someone I trusted, who had the skill and knowledge to understand what serum / vaccine was in front of them, i.e. a scientist / virologist, I would let them vaccinate my child with proven vaccines.

It's selfish and narrow-minded to insist that only your viewpoint is the appropriate one. It isn't.

I won't consider viewpoints which are quackery.

OP posts:
BePeachNewt · 12/10/2026 20:07

Scamworried · 12/10/2026 11:45

Again - this is a slippery slope.

If unvaccinated children were banned from school then some of these will end up being children who are unvaccinated due to medical reasons.
You may think they should be and will be exempt but once we go down this route the end result will likely be unvaccinated children with genuine reasons are also caught up in the school ban

Many, many countries have vaccine mandates for school attendance. I’ve never once heard of a child who cannot be vaccinated for medical reasons being banned.

Hoodle · 12/10/2026 20:28

Didimum · 12/10/2026 17:32

You’re playing straw man here. You can try to construct a wasteful policy ‘targeted’ outline and then declare it as no good. But that’s nothing like I suggested – I suggested targeting based on outbreaks and identifying susceptible children.

Once again, blanket and mandatory exclusion penalised children for their parents’ choices and is disproportionate to risk. This further harms children who already face disadvantage.

No I’m not. I’m pointing out that a simple and easily fulfilled vaccine requirement is straightforward.

Why do you keep talking about “targeting” during outbreaks? There shouldn’t be any outbreaks. So to stop them we should make school and nursery attendance dependant on vaccination. That’s the whole point.

And “targeting” “susceptible” children? Do you mean exclude those who genuinely can’t be vaccinated and are susceptible to severe damage when the diseases appear? That seems totally wrong and upside down.

Mostly, though, you assume that it’s some big deal to have children vaccinated. It isn’t. It’s there for all and is free. There’s no “proportionality” or “least intrusive measure” to worry about. These parents should just be expected to do what millions of other parents routinely do.

ArabellaScott · 12/10/2026 20:38

Timeforachange26 · 12/10/2026 15:43

Yeah even the NHS had varying ideas on vaccines. Take BCG for example. When I was a kid the state school kids had testing and if necessary given the vaccine. Didn't seem to do anything about kids not in state schools

Then when my eldest 2 were born tthe bcg vaccine was only given to kids of Asian origin. Despite living in a part of London at the time that had really high TB rates.

12 years later When DS was born ( and ironically I was living in a very white area) he was given the jab automatically

So thinking of that my DDs didn't have the bcg vaccination. Hope that doesn't make me an antivaxer

Edited

Same here. I check evidence for each.

The HPV vaccine is wonderful. MMR, ditto. The long standing ones are well tested and have saved many lives. Amazing!

The flu vaccine, depends on the year and other factors. Covid, I took twice but not the kids. Because, as I posted upthread, the Joint Committee didnt rec it for kids.

Being aggressively pro all vaccines is just as blinkered as rejecting them all out of hand, imo. It just becomes another issue to get angry about.

Timeforachange26 · 12/10/2026 20:41

ArabellaScott · 12/10/2026 20:38

Same here. I check evidence for each.

The HPV vaccine is wonderful. MMR, ditto. The long standing ones are well tested and have saved many lives. Amazing!

The flu vaccine, depends on the year and other factors. Covid, I took twice but not the kids. Because, as I posted upthread, the Joint Committee didnt rec it for kids.

Being aggressively pro all vaccines is just as blinkered as rejecting them all out of hand, imo. It just becomes another issue to get angry about.

Agreed.

Awkwardisfunny · 12/10/2026 20:42

ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 20:06

I won't consider viewpoints which are quackery.

All of them, yeah? Okay.

ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 20:48

Awkwardisfunny · 12/10/2026 20:42

All of them, yeah? Okay.

If there are pro-disease viewpoints which aren't quackery then they haven't yet met my gaze.

OP posts:
ReplacingTheFilter · 12/10/2026 20:49

JohnofWessex · 12/10/2026 12:46

Would it be possible to vaccinate the unvaccinated on Day 1 at school and haul in the 'Home Ed/' ones whether the parents wanted it or not?

I also suggest that we need to look at should we allow some of those who support 'unscientific' medicine into the UK if they are not UK nationals?

This is a slippery slope. My child is one of the ones supported by herd immunity since he can't receive all vaccines. I wouldn't want to see this happen. I want the right to choose what I put into my body so I support that for everyone else too.

Awkwardisfunny · 12/10/2026 20:51

ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 20:48

If there are pro-disease viewpoints which aren't quackery then they haven't yet met my gaze.

"Pro-disease". Very mature. Okay, have fun on here, I'm out.

moonraker0 · 12/10/2026 20:52

I remember my sister getting mumps when she was in school and she was fully vaccinated. I think the uptake was a lot higher when she had it nearly 30 years ago as well but somehow it managed to find a way, there were a lot of children who had it around the same time and I remember my mother saying that they couldn’t understand it because they’d all been vaccinated. I know no vaccine is foolproof but it’s pointless excluding children from getting an education on the basis of vaccinations because they’ll still come into contact with each other outside of school. Unless you want them to have an identifying marker there’s absolutely no way of knowing who’s vaccinated and who’s not.

ReplacingTheFilter · 12/10/2026 20:57

walrushurricane · 12/10/2026 18:05

Doctors aren't against vaccinating their children. Unless you are talking about the grifters on social media of course.

I know one GP and two nurses who are against vaccinating. Knew them in person. I also knew, in person, midwives who are against vaccination. No idea if any of them have changed their minds. They are out there.

ReplacingTheFilter · 12/10/2026 21:00

ApronSprings · 12/10/2026 20:02

A minor infection is not the same as a disease with a low survival rate like Polio. Do you go to the hospital for a papercut? If not then you shouldn't go with a heart attack. That's your logic.

But as you asked - yes, if I was meeting with people who are immunocompromised I would not attend even with a cold, for example babies, people with serious health conditions, elderly relatives.

You don't know if you are in contact with someone who is immune compromised. Your minor infection, like a cold, could land my son in hospital. A cold is life threatening for some yet it sounds like you'd still go out and spread it. So much for concern for the immune compromised. If you're really concerned, stay off public transport, out of shops and stick to outdoor areas when you have a sniffle.

Pallisers · 12/10/2026 21:09

BrucesBarAndGrill · 12/10/2026 18:18

Do people assume that parents who vaccinate are only worried about their own vaccinated children?

I suspect they do because they've missed the word - or even the concept of "public" in public health. They only care about their own children so presume everyone else is the same. And don't realise that public health issue affect everyone - even their children. I'm old enough to have known people affected for life by diseases like german measles, polio, measles. People don't see this anymore so presume those diseases weren't that bad and/or will never affect them or their children.

I live in a state that requires vaccination for school, camp, daycares, college etc. Just the standard childhood ones not covid or flu. Don't worry anti-vaxxers there are medical exemptions and religious ones (despite anti-vax not actually being a tenet of any religion).

The way Kennedy is running health in the USA and encouraging anti-vax I'm beginning to be glad I am old enough to have been vaccinated against smallpox!

Didimum · 12/10/2026 21:23

Hoodle · 12/10/2026 20:28

No I’m not. I’m pointing out that a simple and easily fulfilled vaccine requirement is straightforward.

Why do you keep talking about “targeting” during outbreaks? There shouldn’t be any outbreaks. So to stop them we should make school and nursery attendance dependant on vaccination. That’s the whole point.

And “targeting” “susceptible” children? Do you mean exclude those who genuinely can’t be vaccinated and are susceptible to severe damage when the diseases appear? That seems totally wrong and upside down.

Mostly, though, you assume that it’s some big deal to have children vaccinated. It isn’t. It’s there for all and is free. There’s no “proportionality” or “least intrusive measure” to worry about. These parents should just be expected to do what millions of other parents routinely do.

Edited

It’s exactly a straw man to describe a poorly constructed policy, say that won’t work and then say that therefore a blanket vaccination policy is the answer.

I keep ‘going on’ about targeting, because targeted policies work better than blanket ones – in almost all scenarios.

Ourbreaks exist in vaccinated as well as unvaccinated and partly vaccinated groups – they are inevitable. You can’t stop them, and if you think you can then you don’t understand vaccines very well. And no – I mean targeting all unvaccinated children during outbreaks – a shielding process which is already done.

Nowhere did I say or insinuate it’s a ‘big deal’ to have all eligible children vaccinated – it isn’t. But it is a big deal to blanket exclude them from mainstream education. Whether or not parents should be expected to, it isn’t going to happen and it’s not the choice or fault of the child – so yes, further harm to those children does need to be proportionate to the further harm that blanket policies create.

Hoodle · 12/10/2026 21:47

Didimum · 12/10/2026 21:23

It’s exactly a straw man to describe a poorly constructed policy, say that won’t work and then say that therefore a blanket vaccination policy is the answer.

I keep ‘going on’ about targeting, because targeted policies work better than blanket ones – in almost all scenarios.

Ourbreaks exist in vaccinated as well as unvaccinated and partly vaccinated groups – they are inevitable. You can’t stop them, and if you think you can then you don’t understand vaccines very well. And no – I mean targeting all unvaccinated children during outbreaks – a shielding process which is already done.

Nowhere did I say or insinuate it’s a ‘big deal’ to have all eligible children vaccinated – it isn’t. But it is a big deal to blanket exclude them from mainstream education. Whether or not parents should be expected to, it isn’t going to happen and it’s not the choice or fault of the child – so yes, further harm to those children does need to be proportionate to the further harm that blanket policies create.

Ourbreaks exist in vaccinated as well as unvaccinated and partly vaccinated groups – they are inevitable. You can’t stop them, and if you think you can then you don’t understand vaccines very well.

That’s just not true. You’re talking nonsense. A population with sufficient vaccination does not allow transmission. Why do you think over time endemic measles has been declared stopped by numerous countries (obviously it can return if vaccination rates drop)? How do you think smallpox infection was driven out of the world?

And no – I mean targeting all unvaccinated children during outbreaks – a shielding process which is already done.

What does this mean? That appeals are made to the parents of unvaccinated children to get them jabbed during outbreaks? That’s not a policy, it’s not ‘shielding’, it’s an inevitable step late in the day to try to stop yet more suffering that should never have happened in the first place.

Urgentbiscuitrequired · 12/10/2026 21:51

You sound desperate for COVID to come back so you can have something to moan about OP.

Swipe left for the next trending thread