Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unvaccinated children shouldn't be allowed in mainstream childcare or school

430 replies

ApronSprings · 11/10/2026 21:42

To think children shouldn't be allowed in nurseries or schools if their parents refuse to vaccinate them..

I'm excluding children who medically can't have them for some reason, and this will be too rare to cause a problem, and they deserve the benefit of herd immunity.

But I'm growing tired of the nutcase conspiracy theorists who failed GCSE science but think they've somehow found something missed by experts.

The only argument against this is that it keeps them home with their quack parents and reduces the opportunity for them to be exposed to normal people. But I don't think we should risk other people's lives for it if their parents aren't willing to do the same.

OP posts:
Didimum · 12/10/2026 22:09

Hoodle · 12/10/2026 21:47

Ourbreaks exist in vaccinated as well as unvaccinated and partly vaccinated groups – they are inevitable. You can’t stop them, and if you think you can then you don’t understand vaccines very well.

That’s just not true. You’re talking nonsense. A population with sufficient vaccination does not allow transmission. Why do you think over time endemic measles has been declared stopped by numerous countries (obviously it can return if vaccination rates drop)? How do you think smallpox infection was driven out of the world?

And no – I mean targeting all unvaccinated children during outbreaks – a shielding process which is already done.

What does this mean? That appeals are made to the parents of unvaccinated children to get them jabbed during outbreaks? That’s not a policy, it’s not ‘shielding’, it’s an inevitable step late in the day to try to stop yet more suffering that should never have happened in the first place.

A population with sufficient vaccination does not allow transmission. Why do you think over time endemic measles has been declared stopped by numerous countries (obviously it can return if vaccination rates drop)? How do you think smallpox infection was driven out of the world?

This is false. It depends on the disease, how well the vaccine works, how long immunity lasts, and whether the pathogen can survive or spread in other ways. Interesting you bring up smallpox because it was actually a disease that didn’t require anywhere near 100% vaccination to be eliminated. It was able to be eliminated partly due to the kind of disease it was and it’s characteristics – and crucially because it was less contagious than modern pathogens today. Increase of urbanisation, population growth and international travel also contribute. This is not to say that vaccination is not the gold standard – it’s just to demonstrate that now, outbreaks are inevitable, regardless of vaccination uptake.

What does this mean? That appeals are made to the parents of unvaccinated children to get them jabbed during outbreaks? That’s not a policy, it’s not ‘shielding’, it’s an inevitable step late in the day to try to stop yet more suffering that should never have happened in the first place.

No. You misunderstand (again). My original
point on targeting was targeted exclusion of unvaccinated and otherwise susceptible children from schools during outbreaks, not appealing to vaccinate – though that can done too. In fact, it already is.

Exclusion, fines and segregation does not increase vaccination uptake or other public health aims. Education and accessibility do – that’s public policy 101.

Hoodle · 12/10/2026 22:32

Didimum · 12/10/2026 22:09

A population with sufficient vaccination does not allow transmission. Why do you think over time endemic measles has been declared stopped by numerous countries (obviously it can return if vaccination rates drop)? How do you think smallpox infection was driven out of the world?

This is false. It depends on the disease, how well the vaccine works, how long immunity lasts, and whether the pathogen can survive or spread in other ways. Interesting you bring up smallpox because it was actually a disease that didn’t require anywhere near 100% vaccination to be eliminated. It was able to be eliminated partly due to the kind of disease it was and it’s characteristics – and crucially because it was less contagious than modern pathogens today. Increase of urbanisation, population growth and international travel also contribute. This is not to say that vaccination is not the gold standard – it’s just to demonstrate that now, outbreaks are inevitable, regardless of vaccination uptake.

What does this mean? That appeals are made to the parents of unvaccinated children to get them jabbed during outbreaks? That’s not a policy, it’s not ‘shielding’, it’s an inevitable step late in the day to try to stop yet more suffering that should never have happened in the first place.

No. You misunderstand (again). My original
point on targeting was targeted exclusion of unvaccinated and otherwise susceptible children from schools during outbreaks, not appealing to vaccinate – though that can done too. In fact, it already is.

Exclusion, fines and segregation does not increase vaccination uptake or other public health aims. Education and accessibility do – that’s public policy 101.

Edited

Endemic measles and rubella can be stopped - and have been in many countries. Ending endemic mumps is more difficult but Finland managed it over 25 years ago. I’m afraid you’re circulating anti-vax rubbish.

Excluding unvaccinated children during outbreaks is no sensible answer. It’s too late by then, the harm and misery caused by avoidable childhood infectious disease will already have happened.

Jeez.

Didimum · 12/10/2026 22:56

Hoodle · 12/10/2026 22:32

Endemic measles and rubella can be stopped - and have been in many countries. Ending endemic mumps is more difficult but Finland managed it over 25 years ago. I’m afraid you’re circulating anti-vax rubbish.

Excluding unvaccinated children during outbreaks is no sensible answer. It’s too late by then, the harm and misery caused by avoidable childhood infectious disease will already have happened.

Jeez.

It’s got zero to do with ‘anti vax rubbish’ and everything to do with disagreeing with the blanket exclusion of already underprivileged children from school who are at the mercy of their parents’ choices.

Jeez indeed.

Hoodle · 12/10/2026 23:00

Didimum · 12/10/2026 22:56

It’s got zero to do with ‘anti vax rubbish’ and everything to do with disagreeing with the blanket exclusion of already underprivileged children from school who are at the mercy of their parents’ choices.

Jeez indeed.

By denying the efficacy of vaccines. Hmm.

NoProblems · 12/10/2026 23:09

The original post is a dictatorial rant without any logic in it.

If you are advocating something, you need to present a convincing argument for it.

Although you don´t state the reason for your rant, it seems you think unvaccinated children are a risk to others.

I am not making a pro or anti vaccination point, but logically why would vaccinated protected children be at risk from unvaccinated children?

If one uses a computer, apart for protecting it with a firewall and anti-virus software, one cannot dictate to the sites we visit to protect our computer from harm.

Are you going to isolate your children and yourself outside of school?

´To think sneezing and coughing and other sick people shouldn't be allowed in crowded public transport if they are infectious´.

Meadowfinch · 12/10/2026 23:59

Firefly24 · 11/10/2026 21:46

So punish children for their parents choices.. nice one.

This.

Plenty of children in the UK with stupid, lazy, nutty or ignorant parents. Having crap parents is quite bad enough, there is no reason for wider society to abandon those children to their negligence.

Get your children vaccinated, eat a healthy non-upf diet to maintain your family's immune systems and let the local health board work on persuading bad parents to accept vaccinations.

LynetteScavo · 13/10/2026 05:34

What about teens in Y9 who refuse their vaccinations? Would they be excluded from school?

Didimum · 13/10/2026 07:56

Hoodle · 12/10/2026 23:00

By denying the efficacy of vaccines. Hmm.

Nope. But feel free to copy and paste exactly where I did.

Hoodle · 13/10/2026 08:22

Didimum · 13/10/2026 07:56

Nope. But feel free to copy and paste exactly where I did.

I don’t need to copy and paste. You said that outbreaks of infectious disease aren’t halted by vaccinated populations. That’s completely untrue, and an even greater falsehood since you avoided saying that even when endemic disease isn’t stopped, vaccination slows spread.

That shows that you’re actually concerned to cast doubt on the benefits of vaccination, and to argue against measures to encourage uptake, and not really bothered about children’s access to education.

Didimum · 13/10/2026 08:48

Hoodle · 13/10/2026 08:22

I don’t need to copy and paste. You said that outbreaks of infectious disease aren’t halted by vaccinated populations. That’s completely untrue, and an even greater falsehood since you avoided saying that even when endemic disease isn’t stopped, vaccination slows spread.

That shows that you’re actually concerned to cast doubt on the benefits of vaccination, and to argue against measures to encourage uptake, and not really bothered about children’s access to education.

Nope. I said that with many modern pathogens, unlike smallpox, outbreaks are inevitable even with vaccination due to their characteristics. I did not say they did not slow the spread. A slower spread does not equal outbreaks not occurring.

What I did say is that ‘vaccination is the gold standard’. What I did say was that ‘I don’t agree with anti-vaccination rhetoric’. What I did say was that ‘fines, exclusion and segregation do not increase vaccine uptake, but that education and accessibility does’.

That’s just a handle of quotes for you. If you can’t read well enough to understand them, then don’t enter into a debate and make things up to try to prove a point that isn’t factual.

Someone can agree with vaccines, disagree with anti-vaxers, and still disagree with excluding children from school to reach that aim. It shouldn’t come as any sort of shock to you that people may have different opinions on effective incentives for vaccine uptake.

tamade · 13/10/2026 09:17

ApronSprings · 11/10/2026 21:53

The alternative is that we punish children (with their lives) for other people's parent's choices.

Presumably these other children are vaccinated though so won't be affected?

Sunbringer · 13/10/2026 09:33

While this would be ideal in an ideal world where parents would choose to home educate well if unhappy with that it’s not an ideal world and imo the children do not deserve to be deprived of an effective education because their parent has made a specific decision. I say that as someone immunecompromised. A society with large swathes of children left with likely neglect and few qualifications will swiftly become unhealthy.

ArabellaScott · 13/10/2026 10:08

Didimum · 12/10/2026 22:09

A population with sufficient vaccination does not allow transmission. Why do you think over time endemic measles has been declared stopped by numerous countries (obviously it can return if vaccination rates drop)? How do you think smallpox infection was driven out of the world?

This is false. It depends on the disease, how well the vaccine works, how long immunity lasts, and whether the pathogen can survive or spread in other ways. Interesting you bring up smallpox because it was actually a disease that didn’t require anywhere near 100% vaccination to be eliminated. It was able to be eliminated partly due to the kind of disease it was and it’s characteristics – and crucially because it was less contagious than modern pathogens today. Increase of urbanisation, population growth and international travel also contribute. This is not to say that vaccination is not the gold standard – it’s just to demonstrate that now, outbreaks are inevitable, regardless of vaccination uptake.

What does this mean? That appeals are made to the parents of unvaccinated children to get them jabbed during outbreaks? That’s not a policy, it’s not ‘shielding’, it’s an inevitable step late in the day to try to stop yet more suffering that should never have happened in the first place.

No. You misunderstand (again). My original
point on targeting was targeted exclusion of unvaccinated and otherwise susceptible children from schools during outbreaks, not appealing to vaccinate – though that can done too. In fact, it already is.

Exclusion, fines and segregation does not increase vaccination uptake or other public health aims. Education and accessibility do – that’s public policy 101.

Edited

Quite.

Hoodle · 13/10/2026 11:44

Didimum · 13/10/2026 08:48

Nope. I said that with many modern pathogens, unlike smallpox, outbreaks are inevitable even with vaccination due to their characteristics. I did not say they did not slow the spread. A slower spread does not equal outbreaks not occurring.

What I did say is that ‘vaccination is the gold standard’. What I did say was that ‘I don’t agree with anti-vaccination rhetoric’. What I did say was that ‘fines, exclusion and segregation do not increase vaccine uptake, but that education and accessibility does’.

That’s just a handle of quotes for you. If you can’t read well enough to understand them, then don’t enter into a debate and make things up to try to prove a point that isn’t factual.

Someone can agree with vaccines, disagree with anti-vaxers, and still disagree with excluding children from school to reach that aim. It shouldn’t come as any sort of shock to you that people may have different opinions on effective incentives for vaccine uptake.

It’s not my reading that’s dodgy. It’s your argument and statements.

You said - without qualification - that outbreaks of infectious disease happen in all populations, vaccinated or not. I pointed out that that’s false: measles (and I later added, rubella) can be and have been stopped as endemic diseases in numerous countries. You simply came back and argued otherwise, which is demonstrably wrong.

So either you don’t know or you don’t care. Since I told you in terms that what you said was false and misleading, it must be that you don’t care.

Vaccination is not a ‘gold standard’. It’s the standard. Everyone who can vaccinate, should. You’re also wrong that a requirement to vaccinate for nursery and school doesn’t increase take-up; it does.

I appreciate that you say you don’t like anti-vax rhetoric and that you just care about children being denied schooling. But, with respect, that’s exactly what anti-vaxxers say when the prospect of vaccination requirement comes up. And your denial of beneficial population-level effects of vaccination fits with that.

Didimum · 13/10/2026 12:05

Hoodle · 13/10/2026 11:44

It’s not my reading that’s dodgy. It’s your argument and statements.

You said - without qualification - that outbreaks of infectious disease happen in all populations, vaccinated or not. I pointed out that that’s false: measles (and I later added, rubella) can be and have been stopped as endemic diseases in numerous countries. You simply came back and argued otherwise, which is demonstrably wrong.

So either you don’t know or you don’t care. Since I told you in terms that what you said was false and misleading, it must be that you don’t care.

Vaccination is not a ‘gold standard’. It’s the standard. Everyone who can vaccinate, should. You’re also wrong that a requirement to vaccinate for nursery and school doesn’t increase take-up; it does.

I appreciate that you say you don’t like anti-vax rhetoric and that you just care about children being denied schooling. But, with respect, that’s exactly what anti-vaxxers say when the prospect of vaccination requirement comes up. And your denial of beneficial population-level effects of vaccination fits with that.

It’s not my reading that’s dodgy. It’s your argument and statements

It is, I'm afraid. I know the meaning behind my words because I wrote them and think them. Your interpretation is incorrect – do with that information what you will.

You said - without qualification - that outbreaks of infectious disease happen in all populations, vaccinated or not. I pointed out that that’s false: measles (and I later added, rubella) can be and have been stopped as endemic diseases in numerous countries.

I didn't say anything 'without qualification' – again, please copy and paste where I have. I am going to assume you can't because I have asked already and you cannot seem to. Nowhere on on this thread have I said that vaccinations do not stop diseases becoming endemic. What I did say was that outbreaks of those diseases still happen in vaccinated populations. Because they do. If you want to talk about measles, then let's go ahead – there was a duel-state measles outbreak last year in the US. Most areas had reached target vaccination levels – one area had 96.6% vaccination coverage. My point stands that outbreaks can occur in vaccinated populations – because they do, whether you want to think so or not, and that has zero to do with vaccines stopping infectious diseases from becoming endemic. That's a separate conversation, and one I did not post about or mention.

Stop making things up because you do not agree with my opinion that excluding children from school would not be an effective vaccination incentive.

Vaccination is not a ‘gold standard’. It’s the standard.

Gosh – we're moving into semantics now, are we? Clutching at straws indeed.

I appreciate that you say you don’t like anti-vax rhetoric and that you just care about children being denied schooling. But, with respect, that’s exactly what anti-vaxxers say when the prospect of vaccination requirement comes up. And your denial of beneficial population-level effects of vaccination fits with that.

Once again – that's false. And there are plenty of posters on this thread who believe in vaccination, do not believe in anti-vax rhetoric and do not agree with excluding children from school based on the decisions of their parents, and do agree that it would increase deprivation among already underprivileged children. Perhaps go bother them instead, because you just keep repeating yourself now.

fashionqueen0123 · 13/10/2026 12:38

Sunbringer · 13/10/2026 09:33

While this would be ideal in an ideal world where parents would choose to home educate well if unhappy with that it’s not an ideal world and imo the children do not deserve to be deprived of an effective education because their parent has made a specific decision. I say that as someone immunecompromised. A society with large swathes of children left with likely neglect and few qualifications will swiftly become unhealthy.

While that sounds like a potential and I’d agree at first. It seems like many other countries do it and that doesn’t happen.

twilighteaser · 13/10/2026 12:43

in Italy we have compulsory vaccination, the child can't go to nursery or school without.

OnlyOneAdda · 13/10/2026 13:38

ArabellaScott · 12/10/2026 20:38

Same here. I check evidence for each.

The HPV vaccine is wonderful. MMR, ditto. The long standing ones are well tested and have saved many lives. Amazing!

The flu vaccine, depends on the year and other factors. Covid, I took twice but not the kids. Because, as I posted upthread, the Joint Committee didnt rec it for kids.

Being aggressively pro all vaccines is just as blinkered as rejecting them all out of hand, imo. It just becomes another issue to get angry about.

Being aggressively pro all vaccines is just as blinkered as rejecting them all out of hand

Hard agree@ArabellaScott- it seems the irony is lost on OP and some others quite how ridiculous they sound declaring their absolute certainty that every single existing and future vaccine safe and the right choice as a matter of “scientific fact” without any consideration of the actual scientific facts for the individual vaccine.

walrushurricane · 13/10/2026 13:54

fashionqueen0123 · 13/10/2026 12:38

While that sounds like a potential and I’d agree at first. It seems like many other countries do it and that doesn’t happen.

Yes, they probably did it before all the anti vaxxer grifters conned people on social media though. Not sure what would happen if introduced today.

Hoodle · 13/10/2026 14:02

Didimum · 13/10/2026 12:05

It’s not my reading that’s dodgy. It’s your argument and statements

It is, I'm afraid. I know the meaning behind my words because I wrote them and think them. Your interpretation is incorrect – do with that information what you will.

You said - without qualification - that outbreaks of infectious disease happen in all populations, vaccinated or not. I pointed out that that’s false: measles (and I later added, rubella) can be and have been stopped as endemic diseases in numerous countries.

I didn't say anything 'without qualification' – again, please copy and paste where I have. I am going to assume you can't because I have asked already and you cannot seem to. Nowhere on on this thread have I said that vaccinations do not stop diseases becoming endemic. What I did say was that outbreaks of those diseases still happen in vaccinated populations. Because they do. If you want to talk about measles, then let's go ahead – there was a duel-state measles outbreak last year in the US. Most areas had reached target vaccination levels – one area had 96.6% vaccination coverage. My point stands that outbreaks can occur in vaccinated populations – because they do, whether you want to think so or not, and that has zero to do with vaccines stopping infectious diseases from becoming endemic. That's a separate conversation, and one I did not post about or mention.

Stop making things up because you do not agree with my opinion that excluding children from school would not be an effective vaccination incentive.

Vaccination is not a ‘gold standard’. It’s the standard.

Gosh – we're moving into semantics now, are we? Clutching at straws indeed.

I appreciate that you say you don’t like anti-vax rhetoric and that you just care about children being denied schooling. But, with respect, that’s exactly what anti-vaxxers say when the prospect of vaccination requirement comes up. And your denial of beneficial population-level effects of vaccination fits with that.

Once again – that's false. And there are plenty of posters on this thread who believe in vaccination, do not believe in anti-vax rhetoric and do not agree with excluding children from school based on the decisions of their parents, and do agree that it would increase deprivation among already underprivileged children. Perhaps go bother them instead, because you just keep repeating yourself now.

Edited

OK, you want copy-and-paste, you can have it. You posted:

Ourbreaks exist in vaccinated as well as unvaccinated and partly vaccinated groups – they are inevitable. You can’t stop them, and if you think you can then you don’t understand vaccines very well. And no – I mean targeting all unvaccinated children during outbreaks – a shielding process which is already done.

There you go: an unqualified statement about the inevitability of outbreaks – “…they are inevitable. You can’t stop them…” - irrespective of vaccination level. And of course this thread is about mandating UK children’s vaccines, so principally measles, mumps and rubella.

I pointed out:

That’s just not true. You’re talking nonsense. A population with sufficient vaccination does not allow transmission. Why do you think over time endemic measles has been declared stopped by numerous countries (obviously it can return if vaccination rates drop)? How do you think smallpox infection was driven out of the world?

So I was clear that, as an example, measles can be stopped and smallpox is no more, because of vaccination rates. To which you replied:

This is false. It depends on the disease, how well the vaccine works, how long immunity lasts, and whether the pathogen can survive or spread in other ways. Interesting you bring up smallpox because it was actually a disease that didn’t require anywhere near 100% vaccination to be eliminated. It was able to be eliminated partly due to the kind of disease it was and it’s characteristics – and crucially because it was less contagious than modern pathogens today. Increase of urbanisation, population growth and international travel also contribute. This is not to say that vaccination is not the gold standard – it’s just to demonstrate that now, outbreaks are inevitable, regardless of vaccination uptake.

So you doubled down on the inevitability of outbreaks – “regardless of vaccination uptake” – and chose not to accept that, for example, measles (and rubella) transmission is preventable. That’s just wrong, as you were told.

At no point have you acknowledged that sufficiently wide vaccine uptake can prevent outbreaks of infectious disease that we immunise children against.

I see social arguments about not making vaccines compulsory for school attendance. But you didn’t stick to that. You started to imply (actually straightforwardly to say) that vaccination will not prevent outbreaks whatever we do. That’s the anti-vax bit.

I’m out now. You’re not arguing in good faith.

Didimum · 13/10/2026 14:23

Hoodle · 13/10/2026 14:02

OK, you want copy-and-paste, you can have it. You posted:

Ourbreaks exist in vaccinated as well as unvaccinated and partly vaccinated groups – they are inevitable. You can’t stop them, and if you think you can then you don’t understand vaccines very well. And no – I mean targeting all unvaccinated children during outbreaks – a shielding process which is already done.

There you go: an unqualified statement about the inevitability of outbreaks – “…they are inevitable. You can’t stop them…” - irrespective of vaccination level. And of course this thread is about mandating UK children’s vaccines, so principally measles, mumps and rubella.

I pointed out:

That’s just not true. You’re talking nonsense. A population with sufficient vaccination does not allow transmission. Why do you think over time endemic measles has been declared stopped by numerous countries (obviously it can return if vaccination rates drop)? How do you think smallpox infection was driven out of the world?

So I was clear that, as an example, measles can be stopped and smallpox is no more, because of vaccination rates. To which you replied:

This is false. It depends on the disease, how well the vaccine works, how long immunity lasts, and whether the pathogen can survive or spread in other ways. Interesting you bring up smallpox because it was actually a disease that didn’t require anywhere near 100% vaccination to be eliminated. It was able to be eliminated partly due to the kind of disease it was and it’s characteristics – and crucially because it was less contagious than modern pathogens today. Increase of urbanisation, population growth and international travel also contribute. This is not to say that vaccination is not the gold standard – it’s just to demonstrate that now, outbreaks are inevitable, regardless of vaccination uptake.

So you doubled down on the inevitability of outbreaks – “regardless of vaccination uptake” – and chose not to accept that, for example, measles (and rubella) transmission is preventable. That’s just wrong, as you were told.

At no point have you acknowledged that sufficiently wide vaccine uptake can prevent outbreaks of infectious disease that we immunise children against.

I see social arguments about not making vaccines compulsory for school attendance. But you didn’t stick to that. You started to imply (actually straightforwardly to say) that vaccination will not prevent outbreaks whatever we do. That’s the anti-vax bit.

I’m out now. You’re not arguing in good faith.

Edited

You're incorrect again – you posted my paragraph about eliminating outbreaks, not eliminating a disease from becoming endemic. Please stop twisting people's words to serve your annoyance – it's not factual or representative of what was actually said.

Nowhere did I say the disease transmission wasn't preventable – I specifically stated that even areas of high vaccine coverage have seen outbreaks.

Stop making this about slowing transmission and stopping diseases from becoming endemic – that was never up for debate and I have never said that this wasn't the case.

So you doubled down on the inevitability of outbreaks – “regardless of vaccination uptake” – and chose not to accept that, for example, measles (and rubella) transmission is preventable. That’s just wrong, as you were told.

No ... once again, I wasn't discussing whether measles transmission was preventable, I said that measles outbreaks still occur in areas with high vaccine coverage ... because they literally do. You don't have to believe that – it's fact.

I see social arguments about not making vaccines compulsory for school attendance. But you didn’t stick to that. You started to imply (actually straightforwardly to say) that vaccination will not prevent outbreaks whatever we do. That’s the anti-vax bit.

I don't have to 'stick to it' when I have already said it upthread – I've said it about 5 times on this post. I'm not going to keep repeating myself for a 5th, 6th and 7th time so that you can be satisfied with a paper trail and can't be bothered to read past responses.

That infectious disease outbreaks still occur despite vaccination (because they factually do whether you like it or not), wasn't ever remotely linked to me saying that children should not be vaccinated. It was directly linked to you opposing targeted school exclusion when outbreaks occur, saying 'there shouldn't be any outbreaks' – well, yes, in la-la land there shouldn't be, but we live in the real world where many modern pathogens can and do break out – again, despite high coverage of vaccination. God, it's truly like talking to a brick wall.

I’m out now.

Thank goodness for that.

ArabellaScott · 13/10/2026 17:52

OnlyOneAdda · 13/10/2026 13:38

Being aggressively pro all vaccines is just as blinkered as rejecting them all out of hand

Hard agree@ArabellaScott- it seems the irony is lost on OP and some others quite how ridiculous they sound declaring their absolute certainty that every single existing and future vaccine safe and the right choice as a matter of “scientific fact” without any consideration of the actual scientific facts for the individual vaccine.

It just becomes another tribally motivated argument. People get classed as 'anti vax' or 'pro vax' and then have a barney.

Pointless. It does nothing to help people make informed, rational decisions.

Kate0726 · 13/10/2026 18:10

Chickadiddy · 11/10/2026 22:00

I agree.
As a teacher I became very ill with mumps as it whipped around the school due to falling vaccine rates.
I'm an adult so I suppose I have to suck it up.
But I don't see why other people's kids should have to be exposed to potentially serious viruses because of decisions made by crackpot parents.

My son & all his friends (all vaccinated) got mumps at uni.

Lemieux7 · 13/10/2026 21:12

Kate0726 · 13/10/2026 18:10

My son & all his friends (all vaccinated) got mumps at uni.

The mumps vaccine is the least effective of the MMR. That’s why. It begs the question of why isn’t there a booster for school leavers.

ApronSprings · 14/10/2026 07:05

Didimum · 12/10/2026 12:27

Disagree. Children shouldn't pay for their parents' decisions, education is a fundamental interest not a privilege to be earned, exclusion is likely disproportionate to the actual risk, and exclusion would likely deepen inequality.

The further risk is undermining trust and making vaccination harder to achieve, if people perceive exclusion as punishment.

If anything like this were to happen, it would be better to target actual outbreaks and specific risks, such as: temporarily excluding susceptible children, improving access to catch-up vaccinations, applying stronger restrictions when there is a clearly identified risk to particularly vulnerable pupils.

When children with vomiting have to be kept off school, do you consider it exclusion? Would you insist they're allowed at school, even though they would be spreading a vomiting bug?
The only difference between this and an unvaccinated child is that the parents have chosen not to vaccinate, so would be choosing not to have them at school..

OP posts: