OK, you want copy-and-paste, you can have it. You posted:
Ourbreaks exist in vaccinated as well as unvaccinated and partly vaccinated groups – they are inevitable. You can’t stop them, and if you think you can then you don’t understand vaccines very well. And no – I mean targeting all unvaccinated children during outbreaks – a shielding process which is already done.
There you go: an unqualified statement about the inevitability of outbreaks – “…they are inevitable. You can’t stop them…” - irrespective of vaccination level. And of course this thread is about mandating UK children’s vaccines, so principally measles, mumps and rubella.
I pointed out:
That’s just not true. You’re talking nonsense. A population with sufficient vaccination does not allow transmission. Why do you think over time endemic measles has been declared stopped by numerous countries (obviously it can return if vaccination rates drop)? How do you think smallpox infection was driven out of the world?
So I was clear that, as an example, measles can be stopped and smallpox is no more, because of vaccination rates. To which you replied:
This is false. It depends on the disease, how well the vaccine works, how long immunity lasts, and whether the pathogen can survive or spread in other ways. Interesting you bring up smallpox because it was actually a disease that didn’t require anywhere near 100% vaccination to be eliminated. It was able to be eliminated partly due to the kind of disease it was and it’s characteristics – and crucially because it was less contagious than modern pathogens today. Increase of urbanisation, population growth and international travel also contribute. This is not to say that vaccination is not the gold standard – it’s just to demonstrate that now, outbreaks are inevitable, regardless of vaccination uptake.
So you doubled down on the inevitability of outbreaks – “regardless of vaccination uptake” – and chose not to accept that, for example, measles (and rubella) transmission is preventable. That’s just wrong, as you were told.
At no point have you acknowledged that sufficiently wide vaccine uptake can prevent outbreaks of infectious disease that we immunise children against.
I see social arguments about not making vaccines compulsory for school attendance. But you didn’t stick to that. You started to imply (actually straightforwardly to say) that vaccination will not prevent outbreaks whatever we do. That’s the anti-vax bit.
I’m out now. You’re not arguing in good faith.