Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unvaccinated children shouldn't be allowed in mainstream childcare or school

430 replies

ApronSprings · 11/10/2026 21:42

To think children shouldn't be allowed in nurseries or schools if their parents refuse to vaccinate them..

I'm excluding children who medically can't have them for some reason, and this will be too rare to cause a problem, and they deserve the benefit of herd immunity.

But I'm growing tired of the nutcase conspiracy theorists who failed GCSE science but think they've somehow found something missed by experts.

The only argument against this is that it keeps them home with their quack parents and reduces the opportunity for them to be exposed to normal people. But I don't think we should risk other people's lives for it if their parents aren't willing to do the same.

OP posts:
Timeforachange26 · 12/10/2026 10:48

Newname26 · 11/10/2026 21:51

I think that's punishing children.

But I do think parents should be given the actual statistics and be made to sign something to say they fully know and understand thr risks.

1 in x many children who catch measles will die
1 in x many will stuff permanent disability

Same will all of the illnesses they are refusing vaccinations for.

Same with homebirths 1 in 2 will end up with transfer to hospital.

Also make sure to tell parents that vaccination isnt 100%. I lost hearing in one of my ears due to measles. The amount of times when telling people i have had the say " well its your parents fault, thry shouldve got you vaccinated"

Which is bullshit as i was vaccinated

godmum56 · 12/10/2026 10:49

ReplacingTheFilter · 12/10/2026 10:47

Generally any live vaccines are excluded, which I think mumps is.

yes its an attenuated live vaccine.

Somethinggg · 12/10/2026 10:50

Timeforachange26 · 12/10/2026 10:48

Also make sure to tell parents that vaccination isnt 100%. I lost hearing in one of my ears due to measles. The amount of times when telling people i have had the say " well its your parents fault, thry shouldve got you vaccinated"

Which is bullshit as i was vaccinated

I can imagine that must be annoying!

Timeforachange26 · 12/10/2026 10:53

Somethinggg · 12/10/2026 10:50

I can imagine that must be annoying!

I find it very insulting actually that people rush to villify my parents. None of them seem to take into account that neither of my brothers caught it from me so their vaccinations mustve worked

Even on mumsnet ive had " well your parents shouldve vaccinated you shouldnt they" if i mention how my deafness occured. Immediately get the pitchforks out

My eldest had her MMR jabs at the right time. When she got pregnant they found she had no rubella immunity. Wonder how many people wouldve blamed me for that

She was given another mmr once tgphe baby was born. Pregnancy 2 tested again, no rubella immunity

Hoodle · 12/10/2026 10:56

A handy cut-out-and-keep guide to anti-vaxers:

  • they all know loads of catastrophically vaccine damaged kids, even though there are barely any in the country
  • they have all ‘researched’ vaccines - which means they’ve read some nutter’s blog
  • they say they’re not against vaccines, but then do all they can to tell you why vaccination is a bad idea
  • they say that gentle persuasion to vaccinate is the best idea - so they can carry on spreading their nonsense and look more reasonable and make it seem as though as there’s actually a general debate to be had about vaccination, when there patently isn’t (vigorous condemnation of anti-vaxers is definitely the best policy)

All this adds up to a group of utterly selfish freeloaders who make foolish excuses, tell falsehoods and wail whenever someone suggests that there should be consequences for their dangerous actions. And then come an outbreak they run off to get their children jabbed.

CurlewKate · 12/10/2026 10:56

PoppieCock · 11/10/2026 21:59

Well no, not all kids can be homeschooled.

I’m sure you’re aware that parents will have work commitments and some are simply not cut out to teach.

So it very much would be punishing children for their parents choices.

The parents will have to sort something out. Why risk the life of an immunocompromised child because another child’s parents are stupid.

CurlewKate · 12/10/2026 10:57

And I am happy to double down on stupid for anti vaxers. Some things are opinion-other things are facts.

OnlyOneAdda · 12/10/2026 11:06

The broad sweeping statements on this thread are wild and if the pro-vaxxers think this is topic is exclusively about “scientific fact” then they are naive or stupid.

The overwhelming evidence is that a vaccine for Measles is a sensible choice and the risk from the vaccine vs the risk of the disease is heavily weighted in favour of the vaccine.

Annual flu vaccines for children are not about the children’s health but about preventing flu in the elderly. Much more grey area. Risk of vaccine vs risk of disease much less compelling because the risk of the disease to a healthy child is very low. Is it morally right to give a medical intervention to a child to benefit others rather than the child themselves? Even though the risks are low and mild, any risk at all is potentially unnecessary for the child’s own health. There are arguments for and against this one, it’s not black and white.

COVID vaccines for children weren’t in any way about “scientific fact” . They were very new, hadn’t been widely tested, certainly not over a long period of time. By the time vaccines were rolled out, the risk to a healthy child of COVID was low; and the potential risks of the vaccine largely unknown. But anyone choosing not to vaccinate their child would be excluded from accessing certain activities and venues, travelling had to undergo repetitive testing etc. COVID vaccines, like many COVID policies were about politics not science, and many of the measures supposed to have protected have subsequently been shown to harm.

Not all vaccines are the same. Not all of them are black and white. The motivations for rolling them out are not always about pure science or health benefits and they won’t always be in the future.

BePeachNewt · 12/10/2026 11:14

ReplacingTheFilter · 12/10/2026 10:41

Actually, for my child some of the vaccines are more risky and he's not allowed them as per specialist, so no, not unreasonable.

Then, quite obviously, you are not the sort of parent being discussed on this thread so it would be best if you stop making sweeping statements that do not apply for the vast majority of children and encourage vaccine fear (undermining the herd immunity that kids like yours who cannot be vaccinated for medical reasons rely on).

BePeachNewt · 12/10/2026 11:17

ReplacingTheFilter · 12/10/2026 10:46

I hate flying. We're not meant to be shooting around the sky in metal tubes.

When I was pregnant with one of my children the doctor wanted me to take a prophylactic antibiotic after exposure to a sickness. No idea if I had it or not, no offer to test, just take the antibiotic. I informed him I was pregnant and was told that they didn't know if the antibiotic was safe in pregnancy but they thought it was. Some women had taken it not knowing they were pregnant and it seemed to have been just fine. That's much more recent. I declined because me and my baby aren't anyone's guinea pig. I wasn't prepared to take the risk and they hadn't demonstrated any good reason I should.

DES was an issue for my family, which is why it's so strong in my mind to raise.

I am actually extremely statistically literate and researched. I have had to be as each decision is critical to my child. Maybe you'd like to tell my son's specialist that he's statistically illiterate when he says my son isn't allowed any vaccinations unless he has given approval?

Edited

Again, if your child is unable to receive vaccines for medical reasons then we aren’t talking about you. This thread is about parents who could safely vaccinate their children but choose not to.

godmum56 · 12/10/2026 11:29

Timeforachange26 · 12/10/2026 10:48

Also make sure to tell parents that vaccination isnt 100%. I lost hearing in one of my ears due to measles. The amount of times when telling people i have had the say " well its your parents fault, thry shouldve got you vaccinated"

Which is bullshit as i was vaccinated

I actually had german measles as a young teen diagnosed by a GP. When i went to work in the NHS I was tested and was told I hadn't had it and needed to be vaccinated so I had the vaccination. I was tested again which was the protocol at the time, and told that I had not reacted but a second vac would fix it. had second vac, second test and still no evidence of immunity so they said they would give me one more vaccination but no retest and then give up....so yes vaccination (while I totally support it in principle) is, like everything else, not 100% reliable.

godmum56 · 12/10/2026 11:31

OnlyOneAdda · 12/10/2026 11:06

The broad sweeping statements on this thread are wild and if the pro-vaxxers think this is topic is exclusively about “scientific fact” then they are naive or stupid.

The overwhelming evidence is that a vaccine for Measles is a sensible choice and the risk from the vaccine vs the risk of the disease is heavily weighted in favour of the vaccine.

Annual flu vaccines for children are not about the children’s health but about preventing flu in the elderly. Much more grey area. Risk of vaccine vs risk of disease much less compelling because the risk of the disease to a healthy child is very low. Is it morally right to give a medical intervention to a child to benefit others rather than the child themselves? Even though the risks are low and mild, any risk at all is potentially unnecessary for the child’s own health. There are arguments for and against this one, it’s not black and white.

COVID vaccines for children weren’t in any way about “scientific fact” . They were very new, hadn’t been widely tested, certainly not over a long period of time. By the time vaccines were rolled out, the risk to a healthy child of COVID was low; and the potential risks of the vaccine largely unknown. But anyone choosing not to vaccinate their child would be excluded from accessing certain activities and venues, travelling had to undergo repetitive testing etc. COVID vaccines, like many COVID policies were about politics not science, and many of the measures supposed to have protected have subsequently been shown to harm.

Not all vaccines are the same. Not all of them are black and white. The motivations for rolling them out are not always about pure science or health benefits and they won’t always be in the future.

I think the decisions made around COVID vaccination were as was said at the Inquiry "the least bad decisions given the situation" Hindsight is, as ever, a wonderful thing.

Goldensprat · 12/10/2026 11:37

cityliving99 · 12/10/2026 04:09

Pupils at school can speak for themselves once Gillick competency kicks in.
They can be immunised without parental consent and believe me, pupils do request this.

I think ultimately that's the clincher for me. Keeping these children in contact with normal society and giving them education and choice without their parents present at least gives them the chance to advocate for themselves.

Much easier to isolate and control children if you home educate them. And no home edders, I am not saying this is a common motivation but it is true that it makes it easier. Encouraging neglectful parents towards it may well be counterproductive.

CurlewKate · 12/10/2026 11:38

People who can’t get their children vaccinated for genuine medical reasons are not anti-vaxxers.

Scamworried · 12/10/2026 11:45

BePeachNewt · 12/10/2026 11:17

Again, if your child is unable to receive vaccines for medical reasons then we aren’t talking about you. This thread is about parents who could safely vaccinate their children but choose not to.

Again - this is a slippery slope.

If unvaccinated children were banned from school then some of these will end up being children who are unvaccinated due to medical reasons.
You may think they should be and will be exempt but once we go down this route the end result will likely be unvaccinated children with genuine reasons are also caught up in the school ban

AllIwantForChrismasIsAKitchenAidStandMixer · 12/10/2026 11:47

CurlewKate · 12/10/2026 11:38

People who can’t get their children vaccinated for genuine medical reasons are not anti-vaxxers.

No one is saying they are?

Hoodle · 12/10/2026 11:50

Scamworried · 12/10/2026 11:45

Again - this is a slippery slope.

If unvaccinated children were banned from school then some of these will end up being children who are unvaccinated due to medical reasons.
You may think they should be and will be exempt but once we go down this route the end result will likely be unvaccinated children with genuine reasons are also caught up in the school ban

Why? If a doctor can provide a medical certificate with reason for no vaccination that child will be admitted.

If you mean that a parent insists their child is unable to be vaccinated without any good reason to back it up, then the child will not be admitted.

Scamworried · 12/10/2026 11:53

Hoodle · 12/10/2026 11:50

Why? If a doctor can provide a medical certificate with reason for no vaccination that child will be admitted.

If you mean that a parent insists their child is unable to be vaccinated without any good reason to back it up, then the child will not be admitted.

Have you seen schools recently?

We had a medical letter, an ed psych report and it made absolutely no difference to the school putting in place reasonable adjustments our child needed to attend school.

I can't imagine that unvaccinated would be any different

Hoodle · 12/10/2026 11:55

Scamworried · 12/10/2026 11:53

Have you seen schools recently?

We had a medical letter, an ed psych report and it made absolutely no difference to the school putting in place reasonable adjustments our child needed to attend school.

I can't imagine that unvaccinated would be any different

Obviously I don’t know the facts of your experience but it doesn’t sound like it’s got anything to do with vaccination status.

Other countries operate a must-vaccinate policy for schools perfectly well.

Didimum · 12/10/2026 11:59

While I am really against anti-vaxxers, and only agree with not vaccinating when there is a serious medical reason, I would disagree with barring them from mainstream education for this reason. It's a significant interference on the bodily and medical rights, and that's a terribly slippery slope to go down. Not worth it.

Gealach · 12/10/2026 12:10

@Timeforachange26 My son is the same - didn’t get immunity from the vaccine.

This is why vaccination only works on a population level if most of the population do it.

Anti Vax people are only a tiny part of the picture though. Many unvaccinated kids are from houses that are chaotic and can’t make an appointment.

Lemieux7 · 12/10/2026 12:11

I largely agree because now we’re seeing the proof that when people stop vaccinating, herd immunity disappears.

AllIwantForChrismasIsAKitchenAidStandMixer · 12/10/2026 12:17

Didimum · 12/10/2026 11:59

While I am really against anti-vaxxers, and only agree with not vaccinating when there is a serious medical reason, I would disagree with barring them from mainstream education for this reason. It's a significant interference on the bodily and medical rights, and that's a terribly slippery slope to go down. Not worth it.

No one is being forced to do anything though in this situation, nor are they losing any rights to bodily autonomy. They are free not to vaccinate on accepting that their access to public spaces will be limited.

It actually might help the “chaotic” category as well - I’m sure people will manage to book an appointment to vaccinate if suddenly their child can’t attend nursery and they have to go back to work

Didimum · 12/10/2026 12:27

AllIwantForChrismasIsAKitchenAidStandMixer · 12/10/2026 12:17

No one is being forced to do anything though in this situation, nor are they losing any rights to bodily autonomy. They are free not to vaccinate on accepting that their access to public spaces will be limited.

It actually might help the “chaotic” category as well - I’m sure people will manage to book an appointment to vaccinate if suddenly their child can’t attend nursery and they have to go back to work

Disagree. Children shouldn't pay for their parents' decisions, education is a fundamental interest not a privilege to be earned, exclusion is likely disproportionate to the actual risk, and exclusion would likely deepen inequality.

The further risk is undermining trust and making vaccination harder to achieve, if people perceive exclusion as punishment.

If anything like this were to happen, it would be better to target actual outbreaks and specific risks, such as: temporarily excluding susceptible children, improving access to catch-up vaccinations, applying stronger restrictions when there is a clearly identified risk to particularly vulnerable pupils.

AllIwantForChrismasIsAKitchenAidStandMixer · 12/10/2026 12:30

Didimum · 12/10/2026 12:27

Disagree. Children shouldn't pay for their parents' decisions, education is a fundamental interest not a privilege to be earned, exclusion is likely disproportionate to the actual risk, and exclusion would likely deepen inequality.

The further risk is undermining trust and making vaccination harder to achieve, if people perceive exclusion as punishment.

If anything like this were to happen, it would be better to target actual outbreaks and specific risks, such as: temporarily excluding susceptible children, improving access to catch-up vaccinations, applying stronger restrictions when there is a clearly identified risk to particularly vulnerable pupils.

You can’t have it both ways - you can’t say they shouldn’t have to pay for their parents’ decisions and then say that they shouldn’t have to be vaccinated.