This is it.
What's in a Name? Women, broadcasting and the persistence of the running gag
When I listen to BBC Radio 2, I sometimes find myself thinking about the women who built British broadcasting. Not the household names or the presenters whose faces appeared on magazine covers but those we don’t always bring to mind - the producers, organisers, editors and administrators. The women who fought for authority behind the microphone as well as in front of it. And I wonder what they would make of modern radio.
Recently, I have noticed a recurring feature of one popular mid-morning programme. Producer Janine Maya Smith becomes "Janice Janine", then "Janice Janine Jolene", and eventually "Janice Janine Thingy". Traffic reporter Ellie Brennan acquires a collection of comic nicknames, among them the memorable "Harlot of the Hard Shoulder". Many listeners will shrug. It is only banter, they will say. No doubt genuine affection exists between the colleagues involved. The women concerned are accomplished professionals and perfectly capable of speaking for themselves. Yet the historian in me cannot help seeing something larger at work.
Women's history teaches us that recognition has always mattered. Across centuries, women struggled not simply for rights, opportunities and careers, but for acknowledgement as individuals. To be named correctly. To have one's work recognised. To be regarded as an authority rather than an accessory.
A name is never just a name. In the nineteenth century, married women frequently disappeared beneath their husbands' identities. Professional women fought to keep ownership of their names and reputations. Women writers battled assumptions that their work was secondary to that of male colleagues. Female academics, doctors and campaigners demanded to be known for what they contributed rather than whom they accompanied.
The story repeats across generations and broadcasting was no exception. Early women at the BBC entered an institution that often struggled to reconcile female expertise with traditional expectations of femininity. Yet figures such as Hilda Matheson insisted that broadcasting could be intellectually serious and socially transformative. Women such as Mary Somerville helped shape the BBC's educational and cultural ambitions. Their contribution was not decorative, it was substantive. They fought to ensure that women were heard as experts, organisers and decision-makers. Against that backdrop, contemporary radio's enthusiasm for turning female colleagues into comic characters feels oddly regressive. And I don’t think the issue is offence. The real issue is about representation.
Joan Bakewell belonged to a generation of female broadcasters who worked hard to establish that women could be authoritative public intellectuals. Her career was spent insisting that women's contributions should be taken seriously. That history makes contemporary habits of reducing female colleagues to comic nicknames seem strangely out of step with the battles that women like her fought half a century ago. I can almost imagine Joan asking a very dry question about it: Why is the producer's name the joke?
When a producer's name becomes a running joke, her professional identity is subtly displaced by a comic identity created for her. When a traffic reporter becomes the Harlot of the Hard Shoulder, listeners are invited to engage with a caricature rather than the professional role she performs. Individually, these moments appear trivial. Historically, however, triviality is often where larger assumptions hide.
Women's history is full of apparently insignificant acts that reveal deeper inequalities. The overlooked contribution, female speakers being dismissed, and credit for their work stolen. And, of course, the patronising nickname. None is catastrophic in isolation but collectively, they shape perceptions of who possesses authority and who exists primarily for the amusement of others.
What is striking is how unnecessary this feels. When DJ Mark Goodier covers the programme, the atmosphere remains warm and friendly. Colleagues still have a laugh with no loss of camaraderie. What does disappear is the need to turn women into recurring comic inventions. Professional identities remain intact and the humour emerges from conversation rather than caricature. That comparison suggests this is not a question of whether radio should be serious or entertaining. It is a question of where entertainment comes from.
The best broadcasters have always understood that humour grows from observation, curiosity and wit. Yet contemporary radio increasingly relies on repetition - a joke becomes a catchphrase. A catchphrase becomes a character. A character becomes a substitute for genuine comic creativity.
Perhaps that is why these nicknames jar. They feel less like progress than a faint echo of older attitudes. Not outright hostility towards women, but a lingering habit of making women the subject of the joke rather than equal participants in creating it.
The female pioneers of broadcasting had larger ambitions. They imagined a medium capable of educating, challenging and widening public horizons. They believed women could shape culture, not merely appear within it. A century later, that aspiration remains worth defending. "Janice Janine Thingy" is not a huge scandal. But it is an echo of a much older pattern of women in broadcasting being slightly reframed, slightly diminished, slightly fictionalised for entertainment.
And I suspect that is the sort of thing Annie Nightingale would have spotted immediately. Not because she was humourless, but because she spent her entire career proving that women on radio were there for what was in their heads, not because they made useful supporting characters.
After all, generations of women fought to be recognised by their own names. It seems a surprisingly modest ambition for modern broadcasting to do the same.