Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Princess Catherine Film

133 replies

letmebetheone · Today 19:08

Seen lots of trailers today for the documentary Princess Catherine has made about her recovery from cancer.
Apparently it is meant to reassure others and encourage them to connect with nature.

Is it just me that finds the whole thing a bit patronising?

It's great that she has recovered but she would have had the best medical care going and no waiting to be seen.

A lot of people have to wait for treatment and worry how they will keep food on the table whilst having treatment. Preaching to those people that they should go out and hug a tree is a bit much.

OP posts:
KatherineParr · Today 21:12

BeLemonMoose · Today 21:05

Bloody hell. I specifically said I know every cancer is different. I wish I hadn't challenged that poster who said how someone died and lived their final months didn't matter. People are just making things up now.

What have I made up? Confused

Here's the relevant extract from your post:

"Seeing my relative who had motor neurone disease not even able to blow her own nose or talk in her final months and not able to clear mucus making breathing difficult, was very different from my mother who although she slept a lot with cancer could tell us all she loved us and what she was thinking until her final days.
It made me very scared of motor neurone disease.
There are worse and better illnesses to die of."

Mulledjuice · Today 21:12

SkyLark79 · Today 20:20

Disagree. Cancer does not differentiate and if it wants to get you, it will. My dad had fabulous treatment on the NHS. No long waits, timely treatment and he still died.

I'm sorry for your loss and I'm glad you saw your dad having fabulous + timely treatment.

I'm sure you'll be aware that for many, now, NHS treatment is taking longer than it (clinically) should for operational reasons. And that thousands if not millions of people undergoing or recovering from treatment for cancer and other major conditions are not able to rest and recuperate as we'd want them to because they don't have the financial resources and infrastructure around them to allow for that. Catherine hasn't had to face those challenges, whatever cancer has thrown at her.

Clonakilla · Today 21:14

Savvysix1984 · Today 21:06

I’m glad you were treated quickly. But that’s really not the case for everyone. I know several people with late diagnoses that ended in quite quick deaths, despite going to the doctors for months to be told it was gallstones (pancreatic cancer) or migraines (brain cancer). If they had money they’d have got a specialist second opinion.

Anyone can ask for a second opinion.

The diagnosis and treatment of cancer is vastly more complex than is typically presented (including by cancer charities), and for many quite an extensive amount of time between diagnosis and treatment (or an extensive period leading up to diagnosis) does not actually affect outcomes. Optimal treatment timelines are evidence-based, not daily-mail-opinion-piece-based.

I live in a country with a dual public/private system and the advantage of private treatment being more timely is largely that it is less stressful to be able to get moving with treatment; the outcomes are certainly not better and many cancers are too complex (and therefore too expensive) for the private system to bother with. The public system treats those, and also most of the complications from treatment in the private system. I have worked in both systems and would be happy to have chemotherapy or immunotherapy in the private, but would not have major cancer surgery in the private.

Money isn't the golden bullet.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

SpikeyAndTheOvenGlove · Today 21:17

BeLemonMoose · Today 21:05

Bloody hell. I specifically said I know every cancer is different. I wish I hadn't challenged that poster who said how someone died and lived their final months didn't matter. People are just making things up now.

No. People aren’t making this up. As Ever - People are getting the better of you on this thread just as they do on other threads concerning the Royal Family. Just when are you (and others of the same mind) going to realise that you let yourselves down almost every time you post because of how hateful you are. Common decency such as not using a woman’s cancer journey to beat her with is going to beat you every time.

Strang3r · Today 21:20

I think something feels so disingenuous and unrelatable about her struggles. Nobody even knows what kind of cancer she has. Hopefully its not some sort of toxic positivity good vibes only documentary.

Lifestooshort71 · Today 21:21

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:11

How can anyone with any shred of intelligence not be aware of the mental impact? Any serious illness changes you. As does any traumatic experience.
And there have been so many articles and blogs about cancer. Even radio adverts about the impact of cancer.

I know raising more awareness can help. But I am honestly aghast at the idea that anyone with my interest in the world around them could not have an inkling at all.

I had no idea how damaging the mental impact can be years later, so, in your words, I have not 'a shred of intelligence'? This comment from you doesn't surprise me in the least.

Lifestooshort71 · Today 21:26

SpikeyAndTheOvenGlove · Today 21:17

No. People aren’t making this up. As Ever - People are getting the better of you on this thread just as they do on other threads concerning the Royal Family. Just when are you (and others of the same mind) going to realise that you let yourselves down almost every time you post because of how hateful you are. Common decency such as not using a woman’s cancer journey to beat her with is going to beat you every time.

This, 100% 👏

Applepiewithcream · Today 21:27

Ilovefoodandwine · Today 20:05

I had cancer just after her. My kids are the same age. I was treated quickly, as is everyone with cancer

Whilst most are, sadly not everyone with cancer is treated quickly and that can be catastrophic for some.

We had to battle and where outside the pathway timeframes due to administration issues. Thankfully in our case, all ended up ok. However that battling was worst than any of the diagnostics or treatment.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page