Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Princess Catherine Film

129 replies

letmebetheone · Today 19:08

Seen lots of trailers today for the documentary Princess Catherine has made about her recovery from cancer.
Apparently it is meant to reassure others and encourage them to connect with nature.

Is it just me that finds the whole thing a bit patronising?

It's great that she has recovered but she would have had the best medical care going and no waiting to be seen.

A lot of people have to wait for treatment and worry how they will keep food on the table whilst having treatment. Preaching to those people that they should go out and hug a tree is a bit much.

OP posts:
Meredusoleil · Today 19:14

No. I disagree. I will watch it on BBC iplayer.

Lomee · Today 19:17

No, cancer is cancer. No matter how expensive the treatment is, all sufferers experience the same grief, fear, sadness, worries. I'll be watching too.

MeghanAndTheSeals · Today 19:17

Maybe wait until it’s aired before criticising. All proceeds from syndication rights are going to the Royal Marsden, which is where Catherine was treated.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

LoudSnoringDog · Today 19:17

As someone who was diagnosed with breast cancer last year, I am keen to watch it.

I appreciate how open she is about her experience and don’t find it patronising at all.

ohfook · Today 19:18

I don’t get the impression that she’s being patronising. It seems like she’s trying to be honest about how it’s impacted her so she can connect with others - however it’s just the trailer so I suppose no one will know until the show comes out.

However I do think it would be good if she could acknowledge that other people were going through the same challenges she was whilst also worrying about when their sick pay was running out, unable to afford transport to hospital appointments or trying to raise their children without support whilst battling the illness.

Danhausenrocks · Today 19:19

I don’t think anyone should judge the way anyone reacts to such a life changing thing.

the money, lifestyle and privilege is irrelevant when you don’t know if you’ll be alive.

we don’t know what cancer she had or how serious it was. So good for her for taking the time to heal and to raise money for her hospital.

dontrunintothedark · Today 19:19

And lose their jobs.

I am irritated at the way cancer is apparently the only illness deserving of compassion or understanding.

Some people never get to come out the other bloody side of the illness that changed them.

willowstar · Today 19:20

Agree with others, cancer is quite a leveller in many ways. She was a mum to three relatively young children, I imagine we can all relate to that.

And not all services are shit. I had two cancer scares recently and was seen really quickly, both times.

JacknDiane · Today 19:20

I think she cant do right for doing wrong

MeghanAndTheSeals · Today 19:22

@Lomee - hard agree. Cancer is a bitch and can hit anyone. Took my mum in the space of 10 weeks, was devastating. Doesn’t mean I think that someone in a more fortunate position is less deserving of telling their story. I’ll be watching next Sunday.

dontrunintothedark · Today 19:22

However I do think it would be good if she could acknowledge that other people were going through the same challenges she was whilst also worrying about when their sick pay was running out, unable to afford transport to hospital appointments or trying to raise their children without support whilst battling the illness.

Exactly.

Danhausenrocks · Today 19:23

dontrunintothedark · Today 19:22

However I do think it would be good if she could acknowledge that other people were going through the same challenges she was whilst also worrying about when their sick pay was running out, unable to afford transport to hospital appointments or trying to raise their children without support whilst battling the illness.

Exactly.

That would be hugely patronising though surely?

Beautyfadesdumbisforever · Today 19:24

It’s hard to explain just how much Cancer can mess with your head. Having money may help with the practicalities but otherwise I think everybody is in the same boat. It does change you.

MeghanAndTheSeals · Today 19:26

dontrunintothedark · Today 19:22

However I do think it would be good if she could acknowledge that other people were going through the same challenges she was whilst also worrying about when their sick pay was running out, unable to afford transport to hospital appointments or trying to raise their children without support whilst battling the illness.

Exactly.

Maybe she does? It hasn’t even aired yet.

GinToBegin · Today 19:27

Anyone who thinks they might find it patronising has the option to not watch it. I probably won’t watch it, but I wouldn’t watch something like that, regardless of who is the focal point.

I suppose there’s an element of PR involved, but the RF has to change with the times, at least to some
extent. This kind of humanising content seems very much in line with the way PandPOW present nowadays, and it seems like a good strategy to me.

nyhgghfgu87gh · Today 19:27

I have cancer, I don’t find it patronising, I think cancer is pretty levelling, there might be some superficial elements that are different, I’m sure her chemo was done in a nicer room than mine, but ultimately our deepest fears will be the same. I won’t be ready to watch it now, but hopefully next year.

dontrunintothedark · Today 19:27

Danhausenrocks · Today 19:19

I don’t think anyone should judge the way anyone reacts to such a life changing thing.

the money, lifestyle and privilege is irrelevant when you don’t know if you’ll be alive.

we don’t know what cancer she had or how serious it was. So good for her for taking the time to heal and to raise money for her hospital.

Actually we know it was preventative chemotherapy, so the cancer had all been removed during her original surgery.

dontrunintothedark · Today 19:29

GinToBegin · Today 19:27

Anyone who thinks they might find it patronising has the option to not watch it. I probably won’t watch it, but I wouldn’t watch something like that, regardless of who is the focal point.

I suppose there’s an element of PR involved, but the RF has to change with the times, at least to some
extent. This kind of humanising content seems very much in line with the way PandPOW present nowadays, and it seems like a good strategy to me.

Using cancer as a PR strategy. Lovely. That's exactly what it is though.

underthehawthorntree · Today 19:30

@dontrunintothedarkI'm fairly sure there's no such thing as "preventative chemotherapy". You might have it as a belt and braces approach but it's always in response to a cancer diagnosis.

parrap · Today 19:31

I have no problem with her doing this. However I don't see such broadcasts as being of any use to anyone with cancer TBH as each person's journey is their own.

But if it helps someone, anyone out there it will be worthwhile. Just my opinion.

nyhgghfgu87gh · Today 19:32

dontrunintothedark · Today 19:27

Actually we know it was preventative chemotherapy, so the cancer had all been removed during her original surgery.

Preventative chemotherapy means she had a high reoccurrence risk, they do not do chemotherapy lightly, her situation was serious and she now has to live with the uncertainty and fear of it coming back and killing her, don’t be so dismissive.

Meredusoleil · Today 19:36

My dh had what I call "mop up" chemotherapy which is apparently the same as preventative chemotherapy. The medical term for it is adjuvant chemotherapy.

Dingdandgdoodle · Today 19:38

dontrunintothedark · Today 19:19

And lose their jobs.

I am irritated at the way cancer is apparently the only illness deserving of compassion or understanding.

Some people never get to come out the other bloody side of the illness that changed them.

This. I whole heartedly agree.

I was diagnosed with a life changing disease at the age of 16. At 45 it’s taken everything from me and I’m now housebound. There’s no documentaries about it, very little research and funding. I’m fighting for benefits, fighting to pay the bills, fighting to keep the roof over our heads.

Cancer is not the worst thing you can be diagnosed with.

limetrees32 · Today 19:39

dontrunintothedark · Today 19:27

Actually we know it was preventative chemotherapy, so the cancer had all been removed during her original surgery.

I'm.glad you've pointed this out .I was begining to think I'd missed something with the reporting going straight from.preventative chemo.to.cancer treatment ,chemo ,..

NewAgeNow · Today 19:39

dontrunintothedark · Today 19:27

Actually we know it was preventative chemotherapy, so the cancer had all been removed during her original surgery.

My dad had ‘preventative’ chemotherapy as you so nicely put it. It came back 7 years later as metastatic cancer. He died.