Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Princess Catherine Film

122 replies

letmebetheone · Today 19:08

Seen lots of trailers today for the documentary Princess Catherine has made about her recovery from cancer.
Apparently it is meant to reassure others and encourage them to connect with nature.

Is it just me that finds the whole thing a bit patronising?

It's great that she has recovered but she would have had the best medical care going and no waiting to be seen.

A lot of people have to wait for treatment and worry how they will keep food on the table whilst having treatment. Preaching to those people that they should go out and hug a tree is a bit much.

OP posts:
SkyLark79 · Today 20:20

Disagree. Cancer does not differentiate and if it wants to get you, it will. My dad had fabulous treatment on the NHS. No long waits, timely treatment and he still died.

LifeIsTooShort247 · Today 20:20

MeghanAndTheSeals · Today 19:44

It takes a special kind of person to take digs regarding cancer and how it’s treated.

Think you would of said the same to all those who take a pop about someone feeling suicidal. But of course we all know the double standards that apply.

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:23

WatchDermotGetHisTitsTweakedLive · Today 20:16

You have no idea.

I will say that you said your mother died in a different manner.

I am sorry for your loss all the same but don’t tell me I don’t bloody know loss.

I am sorry for any loss you have had. But you did state it didn't matter how people died and in their final months as dead is dead. I was saying having seen various loved ones dying and die, it really does matter, very much.
Seeing my relative who had motor neurone disease not even able to blow her own nose or talk in her final months and not able to clear mucus making breathing difficult, was very different from my mother who although she slept a lot with cancer could tell us all she loved us and what she was thinking until her final days.

It made me very scared of motor neurone disease.

There are worse and better illnesses to die of. From my experience of being with loved monies, a fatal brain aneurysm was the kindest one.

I am sorry if you think this is morbid or strange talk. But I have been around too many deaths.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

sittingonabeach · Today 20:25

dontrunintothedark · Today 19:27

Actually we know it was preventative chemotherapy, so the cancer had all been removed during her original surgery.

Don't think you quite understand the treatment she had.

A friend of mine had breast cancer. She had the lump removed. It hadn't spread. But she still had chemo and radiotherapy. Then has been having medication for 10 years. It has had a huge impact on her. Obviously not the same impact as another friend who has terminal cancer but still a huge impact

OneZanyMintQuoter · Today 20:25

parrap · Today 20:05

With hand on heart and with some trepidation..... I think she is the wrong person to do this type of documentary. Too perfect post illness, impeccably groomed, super figure, handsome husband, wealthy beyond measure and all the rest of it.

Is she relateable in any way, apart from going through surgery and chemo? She has not been open about it really, since the first thing most normal people would want to know is what type of cancer she had. Not revealed for her own reasons which is fine, but leaves something unsaid and mysterious. If it is the leveller then just say it out loud and be open about it.

TBH if others had the same diagnosis, they would be heartened by her great recovery now. But no one knows what it is. Just a bit of a gap I think, and I know others will not agree with me. That's fine, I just feel that way about it.

Agree

MeghanAndTheSeals · Today 20:26

LifeIsTooShort247 · Today 20:20

Think you would of said the same to all those who take a pop about someone feeling suicidal. But of course we all know the double standards that apply.

Nice derail attempt - do those double standards apply to you too in relation to this thread?

WatchDermotGetHisTitsTweakedLive · Today 20:27

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:23

I am sorry for any loss you have had. But you did state it didn't matter how people died and in their final months as dead is dead. I was saying having seen various loved ones dying and die, it really does matter, very much.
Seeing my relative who had motor neurone disease not even able to blow her own nose or talk in her final months and not able to clear mucus making breathing difficult, was very different from my mother who although she slept a lot with cancer could tell us all she loved us and what she was thinking until her final days.

It made me very scared of motor neurone disease.

There are worse and better illnesses to die of. From my experience of being with loved monies, a fatal brain aneurysm was the kindest one.

I am sorry if you think this is morbid or strange talk. But I have been around too many deaths.

Once again you are reading words that aren’t there. I never said anything of the sort.

You have said previously that your mother died due to something else entirely as I was on that thread and thought how terrible it must have been for you.

I won’t engage with you as you are giving me no reason to trust what you say.

Endorewitch · Today 20:27

dontrunintothedark · Today 19:27

Actually we know it was preventative chemotherapy, so the cancer had all been removed during her original surgery.

That is what a lot of people get. Surgery first followed by chemo and radiotherapy. Others get chemo first to shrink tumour then surgery and radiotherapy. Depends on tumour and surgeon

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:29

canklesmctacotits · Today 20:14

It depends what she’s going to say, doesn’t it.

If she’s going to go on about how helpful it is to have a supporting husband and to get outside help in and to be kind to yourself by stopping work for the period of treatment + 3 months: yes, out of touch and wrong.

I don’t imagine she’ll say that. I imagine it’ll be along the lines of how shocking a diagnosis can be; how it makes you think of things you previously took for granted; how to not feel bad leaning on people who offer help whether nurses or friends or family; how terrifying it can be talking to your young children about it and how wonderful cancer support organizations are in offering guidance and tips.

Maybe hold fire before judging.

Edited

You are probably right that she will say these generalities that are fairly broad and fairly obvious.

I am glad some blogs and interviews of others with cancer raise awareness of less spoken about issues such as impact on sex life, mentally dealing with a body with parts missing such as a breast, impact on travel and holidays, impact of physical issues like a colostomy bag, etc. I learnt a lot from supporting especially friends with cancer that I didn't know beforehand. And the blogs do help people

WhitneySpears · Today 20:30

Jeez. Some of the comments.

Cancer is shit. No two ways about it. Am I supposed to feel lucky because I have stage four cancer? For some MNers, it’s not that bad.

Well done to Catherine. She’s an incredible role model and will provide huge comfort to many people.

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:31

WatchDermotGetHisTitsTweakedLive · Today 20:27

Once again you are reading words that aren’t there. I never said anything of the sort.

You have said previously that your mother died due to something else entirely as I was on that thread and thought how terrible it must have been for you.

I won’t engage with you as you are giving me no reason to trust what you say.

I had two mothers. One adoptive and one biological. Yes my other mother died in afar crash with my father.
I know you disgustingly posted this as a gotcha.
Bloody hell.

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:31

Endorewitch · Today 20:27

That is what a lot of people get. Surgery first followed by chemo and radiotherapy. Others get chemo first to shrink tumour then surgery and radiotherapy. Depends on tumour and surgeon

Catherine said she had preventative chemo.

WhitneySpears · Today 20:32

parrap · Today 20:05

With hand on heart and with some trepidation..... I think she is the wrong person to do this type of documentary. Too perfect post illness, impeccably groomed, super figure, handsome husband, wealthy beyond measure and all the rest of it.

Is she relateable in any way, apart from going through surgery and chemo? She has not been open about it really, since the first thing most normal people would want to know is what type of cancer she had. Not revealed for her own reasons which is fine, but leaves something unsaid and mysterious. If it is the leveller then just say it out loud and be open about it.

TBH if others had the same diagnosis, they would be heartened by her great recovery now. But no one knows what it is. Just a bit of a gap I think, and I know others will not agree with me. That's fine, I just feel that way about it.

What? So you have to be poor, ugly, working class to be in any way relatable? Unbelievable.

WhitneySpears · Today 20:35

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:31

Catherine said she had preventative chemo.

Do you think people just trot to the hospital and get a course of chemo ‘just in case’? Get a grip.

DisforDarkChocolate · Today 20:36

Indigogogoing · Today 20:03

She should be open about what cancer she has. I would personally find it much easier to relate if she was actually open and honest with us.

Cancer isn’t something to hide or be ashamed of. I’ve had ovarian cancer and I would tell anyone about it.

Nobody owes anyone else details about their private health issues. She has chosen to share that she was diagnosed with cancer, she didn't even owe the public that. That doesn't change no matter what I think about funding a monarchy.

StartupRepair · Today 20:36

It may be well known that cancer changes you. In my experience (breast cancer 2 years ago) people don't really see or understand that. They are happy to see you 'looking well' and assume you have moved on. Meanwhile inside you feel like a different person. I think awareness raising of this is important.

Of course Kate is rich and has all the help in the world. But she still would have felt the icy cold fear and shock we all felt. She also had to navigate trying to maintain her own privacy in a world where people were illegally trying to access her medical records and publishing hideous speculation about every aspect of her life.

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:36

WhitneySpears · Today 20:35

Do you think people just trot to the hospital and get a course of chemo ‘just in case’? Get a grip.

Who has said that?
I simply stated the facts that Catherine said.

Endorewitch · Today 20:38

OneZanyMintQuoter · Today 20:25

Agree

She had cancer. She has 3 young children. She must have been petrified she would not see them grow up. She had surgery at the Royal Marsden where countless ordinary folk get treated. She may have had a better roonmm but she had the same surgery and chemo.
She had the eyes of the world on her support fir all who have suffered. especially on bad days.
She is well groomed. Part of the job. She is not allowed to slop around with unwashed hair abd any old clothes. Even if she wanted to. Cancer doesn't care if you are rich and famous. Cancer doessn't care who you are,once it invites itself into your body. I shall watch as my daughter had BC. My daughter will also watch

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:38

DisforDarkChocolate · Today 20:36

Nobody owes anyone else details about their private health issues. She has chosen to share that she was diagnosed with cancer, she didn't even owe the public that. That doesn't change no matter what I think about funding a monarchy.

No she doesn't have to share that. But if you don't want to share, then ay raising awareness is really limited in its impact.

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:40

Endorewitch · Today 20:38

She had cancer. She has 3 young children. She must have been petrified she would not see them grow up. She had surgery at the Royal Marsden where countless ordinary folk get treated. She may have had a better roonmm but she had the same surgery and chemo.
She had the eyes of the world on her support fir all who have suffered. especially on bad days.
She is well groomed. Part of the job. She is not allowed to slop around with unwashed hair abd any old clothes. Even if she wanted to. Cancer doesn't care if you are rich and famous. Cancer doessn't care who you are,once it invites itself into your body. I shall watch as my daughter had BC. My daughter will also watch

You are guessing. I know an acquaintance had different treatment than my friend with the same cancer. The acquaintance had some chemo, but also had another medication that boosted her chance of survival that was not available on the NHS at the time.
Sometimes paying privately does mean you get different treatment.

WhitneySpears · Today 20:41

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:40

You are guessing. I know an acquaintance had different treatment than my friend with the same cancer. The acquaintance had some chemo, but also had another medication that boosted her chance of survival that was not available on the NHS at the time.
Sometimes paying privately does mean you get different treatment.

And? Are you thinking she shouldn’t have had the best treatment possible?

MN really is a race to the bottom at times.

LifeIsTooShort247 · Today 20:43

MeghanAndTheSeals · Today 20:26

Nice derail attempt - do those double standards apply to you too in relation to this thread?

It not a derail at all just unsurpising how quick you are to speak out in certain circumstances and ignore others. I do not partiicapte in draggin down women so I don't have any double standards there.

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:44

WhitneySpears · Today 20:41

And? Are you thinking she shouldn’t have had the best treatment possible?

MN really is a race to the bottom at times.

Why are you claiming things I have never said?

Catherine is in remission, her words. That is good. She obviously will have had the best treatment money can buy, also good.

But that is not everyone's experience. Money does sometimes buy different treatment

doormats5 · Today 20:44

Ilovefoodandwine · Today 20:05

I had cancer just after her. My kids are the same age. I was treated quickly, as is everyone with cancer

That’s not true, diagnosis can take a while particularly if young.

Lomee · Today 20:45

There are so many strange comments on this thread. If you're of certain age like I am, you'd experience many deaths sadly and you'd very likely have loved ones who are battling diseases including cancer which sadly in my family seem to have striked a couple of my family members at the moment. Some comments are truly vile minimising their suffering. For context, my cousin who's relatively young is stage 4 at the moment, no NHS where she lives, insurance only paid out so much, and 4 boys and a husband who worries about how long they are going to have her around. She's had a truly shit life and this is the horrible non-cherry on top just when she's finally found someone who loves her. I'm sorry some people have relatives with motor neurone, autoimmune whatever. She also has the latter btw. But it's not a competition who understands death and suffering the most.

Swipe left for the next trending thread