Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Princess Catherine Film

122 replies

letmebetheone · Today 19:08

Seen lots of trailers today for the documentary Princess Catherine has made about her recovery from cancer.
Apparently it is meant to reassure others and encourage them to connect with nature.

Is it just me that finds the whole thing a bit patronising?

It's great that she has recovered but she would have had the best medical care going and no waiting to be seen.

A lot of people have to wait for treatment and worry how they will keep food on the table whilst having treatment. Preaching to those people that they should go out and hug a tree is a bit much.

OP posts:
Piccallily · Today 20:45

letmebetheone · Today 19:08

Seen lots of trailers today for the documentary Princess Catherine has made about her recovery from cancer.
Apparently it is meant to reassure others and encourage them to connect with nature.

Is it just me that finds the whole thing a bit patronising?

It's great that she has recovered but she would have had the best medical care going and no waiting to be seen.

A lot of people have to wait for treatment and worry how they will keep food on the table whilst having treatment. Preaching to those people that they should go out and hug a tree is a bit much.

You sound patronising

Dontevenlookatme · Today 20:46

ohfook · Today 19:18

I don’t get the impression that she’s being patronising. It seems like she’s trying to be honest about how it’s impacted her so she can connect with others - however it’s just the trailer so I suppose no one will know until the show comes out.

However I do think it would be good if she could acknowledge that other people were going through the same challenges she was whilst also worrying about when their sick pay was running out, unable to afford transport to hospital appointments or trying to raise their children without support whilst battling the illness.

If we want her to acknowledge how hard it is for everyone else, are we prepared to acknowledge what it must be like to face your illness under a fierce spotlight, with people doubting your illness, your marriage and your integrity?

Indigogogoing · Today 20:46

DisforDarkChocolate · Today 20:36

Nobody owes anyone else details about their private health issues. She has chosen to share that she was diagnosed with cancer, she didn't even owe the public that. That doesn't change no matter what I think about funding a monarchy.

She’s in a very privileged position. With privilege comes responsibility. If she wants to keep her health private, she should. Instead she’s using only what suits her to make a documentary to make herself feel good.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

Superhansrantowindsor · Today 20:47

You can tell by looking at her that the cancer and its treatment has had quite a big affect on her.
If her film helps anyone then that is a good thing. People are free to not watch or switch over.
It doesn’t matter how rich you are, the thought of you leaving your children without a mother and missing them grow up must be absolutely awful. Dealing with a cancer diagnosis must be so hard - I can’t possibly imagine how hard.

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:48

Lomee · Today 20:45

There are so many strange comments on this thread. If you're of certain age like I am, you'd experience many deaths sadly and you'd very likely have loved ones who are battling diseases including cancer which sadly in my family seem to have striked a couple of my family members at the moment. Some comments are truly vile minimising their suffering. For context, my cousin who's relatively young is stage 4 at the moment, no NHS where she lives, insurance only paid out so much, and 4 boys and a husband who worries about how long they are going to have her around. She's had a truly shit life and this is the horrible non-cherry on top just when she's finally found someone who loves her. I'm sorry some people have relatives with motor neurone, autoimmune whatever. She also has the latter btw. But it's not a competition who understands death and suffering the most.

I have not minimised anyone's suffering. I simply replied to someone who said it didn't matter how a person died or how they lived the last few months of their life as dead is dead. I explained how it does matter very much using my own personal experiences to explain that.

MeghanAndTheSeals · Today 20:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Endorewitch · Today 20:48

Yes. That is after surgery to remove tumour. To stop it spreading and make sure there are no cancerous cells floating around. This is what it is called if surgery for cancer comes first.
Some people have the chemo first to shrink tumour. Then surgery.bthis is not called preventitative chemo if done first.
Some have one.vsome others.bBut sadly they have all had cancer whichever order the surgeon prefers. My daughter and her cousin were diagnosed with breast cancer the same week. My daughter had the tumour removved first followed by preventative chemo to suck up stray cancer cells. Her cousin had chemo to shrink tumour and then surgery. Different surgeons. Different hospitals. Both grade 2.
We don't know why. Think up to surgeon.

SpikeyAndTheOvenGlove · Today 20:50

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:38

No she doesn't have to share that. But if you don't want to share, then ay raising awareness is really limited in its impact.

She Is sharing. She is sharing what it’s like to have had cancer and the fact she hasn’t disclosed the cancer she had is actually helping put all cancers in the limelight and not ‘just’ the one she had. It means everyone who’s had cancer can relate to her if they want to. Not ‘just’ the x amount of people who have the particular cancer she had.

MeghanAndTheSeals · Today 20:50

Indigogogoing · Today 20:46

She’s in a very privileged position. With privilege comes responsibility. If she wants to keep her health private, she should. Instead she’s using only what suits her to make a documentary to make herself feel good.

Did you not see the pile on she got across SM when she was trying to keep it private? It was awful.

RhannionKPSS · Today 20:53

I think it is very moving , good for Catherine.

SpikeyAndTheOvenGlove · Today 20:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

SpikeyAndTheOvenGlove · Today 20:57

MeghanAndTheSeals · Today 20:50

Did you not see the pile on she got across SM when she was trying to keep it private? It was awful.

It’s obvious from this thread as it will be obvious when the film airs that she’s also making many others feel good as well.

WatchDermotGetHisTitsTweakedLive · Today 20:59

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:48

I have not minimised anyone's suffering. I simply replied to someone who said it didn't matter how a person died or how they lived the last few months of their life as dead is dead. I explained how it does matter very much using my own personal experiences to explain that.

Show me where I said it didn’t matter.

Those are your words. Not mine.

DO NOT ATTRIBUTE THAT TO ME.

I see you.

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Yes royal supporters do not like me talking about prince Andrew raping sex trafficked teenagers

CoffeeCantata · Today 21:00

I think we should watch it before rushing to judgement. A trailer can be very misleading.

KatherineParr · Today 21:02

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:48

I have not minimised anyone's suffering. I simply replied to someone who said it didn't matter how a person died or how they lived the last few months of their life as dead is dead. I explained how it does matter very much using my own personal experiences to explain that.

BeLemonMoose - you described your relative as 'not even able to blow her own nose or talk in her final months and not able to clear mucus making breathing difficult'. I saw all that and much more when my relative died of an inoperable cancerous brain tumour. Cancer was not a good death for her and those of us who watched it are traumatised. I know you don't like the Princess of Wales but please don't generalise about cancer deaths.

BeLemonMoose · Today 21:05

KatherineParr · Today 21:02

BeLemonMoose - you described your relative as 'not even able to blow her own nose or talk in her final months and not able to clear mucus making breathing difficult'. I saw all that and much more when my relative died of an inoperable cancerous brain tumour. Cancer was not a good death for her and those of us who watched it are traumatised. I know you don't like the Princess of Wales but please don't generalise about cancer deaths.

Bloody hell. I specifically said I know every cancer is different. I wish I hadn't challenged that poster who said how someone died and lived their final months didn't matter. People are just making things up now.

WatchDermotGetHisTitsTweakedLive · Today 21:06

Someone is making things up.

Unless you want to show where I said it didn’t matter.

Savvysix1984 · Today 21:06

Ilovefoodandwine · Today 20:05

I had cancer just after her. My kids are the same age. I was treated quickly, as is everyone with cancer

I’m glad you were treated quickly. But that’s really not the case for everyone. I know several people with late diagnoses that ended in quite quick deaths, despite going to the doctors for months to be told it was gallstones (pancreatic cancer) or migraines (brain cancer). If they had money they’d have got a specialist second opinion.

TellMeAnother · Today 21:07

Indigogogoing · Today 20:46

She’s in a very privileged position. With privilege comes responsibility. If she wants to keep her health private, she should. Instead she’s using only what suits her to make a documentary to make herself feel good.

"Make herself feel good?"
Wow. I repeat what I said earlier about some of the unpleasant people on this thread.
What a vile remark.

Clonakilla · Today 21:07

The Suffering Olympics are truly bizarre. Who suffers the most is not a competition, and if it were would certainly not be one any normal person would want to win.

I think people are being pretty harsh. I won't be watching, I find these documentaries usually pretty maudlin, but people are entitled to speak out about their own illness and they don't have to include a disclaimer every time they speak that they realise they're not the only person who's ever had a difficult time.

Lomee · Today 21:08

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:59

Yes royal supporters do not like me talking about prince Andrew raping sex trafficked teenagers

And you can't separate Catherine the person with the family she marries into so you choose to dehumanise her. I wouldn't marry the Royal for all the tea in China BTW.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread