Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Princess Catherine Film

122 replies

letmebetheone · Today 19:08

Seen lots of trailers today for the documentary Princess Catherine has made about her recovery from cancer.
Apparently it is meant to reassure others and encourage them to connect with nature.

Is it just me that finds the whole thing a bit patronising?

It's great that she has recovered but she would have had the best medical care going and no waiting to be seen.

A lot of people have to wait for treatment and worry how they will keep food on the table whilst having treatment. Preaching to those people that they should go out and hug a tree is a bit much.

OP posts:
BeLemonMoose · Today 19:42

LoudSnoringDog · Today 19:17

As someone who was diagnosed with breast cancer last year, I am keen to watch it.

I appreciate how open she is about her experience and don’t find it patronising at all.

She isn't at all open.

nyhgghfgu87gh · Today 19:44

Dingdandgdoodle · Today 19:38

This. I whole heartedly agree.

I was diagnosed with a life changing disease at the age of 16. At 45 it’s taken everything from me and I’m now housebound. There’s no documentaries about it, very little research and funding. I’m fighting for benefits, fighting to pay the bills, fighting to keep the roof over our heads.

Cancer is not the worst thing you can be diagnosed with.

It’s not a race to the bottom. Frankly I am jealous you are 45, I don’t even know if I will make it to 40 with my diagnosis yet, cancer kills. Ill health is shit whatever the disease, but the worst thing about it is the mental aspect, and I think it’s great she is raising that aspect of it, because as has been shown by you and others on this thread it’s very easy to overlook the mental turmoil of situations such as cancer.

limetrees32 · Today 19:44

underthehawthorntree · Today 19:30

@dontrunintothedarkI'm fairly sure there's no such thing as "preventative chemotherapy". You might have it as a belt and braces approach but it's always in response to a cancer diagnosis.

It's misnamed but it's designed to lower the risk of cancer returning .

Princess Catherine Film

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

doormats5 · Today 19:44

It’s not something I would find relevant & family who have had cancer aren’t interested but some might be. I know my friend found the way Kate’s journey was presented a little patronising.

MeghanAndTheSeals · Today 19:44

It takes a special kind of person to take digs regarding cancer and how it’s treated.

doormats5 · Today 19:45

dontrunintothedark · Today 19:19

And lose their jobs.

I am irritated at the way cancer is apparently the only illness deserving of compassion or understanding.

Some people never get to come out the other bloody side of the illness that changed them.

that’s a good point

NDerbys32 · Today 19:46

My wife was, luckily, diagnosed with an early stage colon cancer that was removed within weeks and is on the 5 year post cancer monitoring pathway.

We'll be watching and can have compassion for anyone's illnesses, no matter who they are, and if she has the ability to make a difference in any way, then we're good with it.

"Damned if she does, damned if she doesn't"

We wish her and her family, carrying the weight if cancer, well

BeLemonMoose · Today 19:47

nyhgghfgu87gh · Today 19:44

It’s not a race to the bottom. Frankly I am jealous you are 45, I don’t even know if I will make it to 40 with my diagnosis yet, cancer kills. Ill health is shit whatever the disease, but the worst thing about it is the mental aspect, and I think it’s great she is raising that aspect of it, because as has been shown by you and others on this thread it’s very easy to overlook the mental turmoil of situations such as cancer.

Truthfully you would have to be blind not to have read anything about the mental turmoil involved.
Cancer sadly is not rare. Nearly everyone has either had cancer or had loved ones who had cancer.

limetrees32 · Today 19:49

MeghanAndTheSeals · Today 19:44

It takes a special kind of person to take digs regarding cancer and how it’s treated.

I've had oesophageal cancer .
My own view is that there are many chronic illnesses,say those of the autoimmune kind that wreck people's lives .
Or Alzheimer's.
I don't think cancer should be treated as though it's the worst thing in the world .

TinyDancer16 · Today 19:50

I thought the whole point of the documentary is to raise awareness that it’s not just a physical issue , so she’s effectively lobbying for people to be given more support than just the physical side of things? I’ll wait until I’ve seen it before judging.

I had cancer as a young mum. It is a leveller. I’m looking forward to the documentary as I suspect it’s going to really resonate with me. And tbh I could have had my surgery in a shithole or a palace, I didn’t care. I just wanted the cancer removed. So I can’t get excited that she’s more privileged than me, that’s just life and I’m more privileged than others.

nyhgghfgu87gh · Today 19:51

BeLemonMoose · Today 19:47

Truthfully you would have to be blind not to have read anything about the mental turmoil involved.
Cancer sadly is not rare. Nearly everyone has either had cancer or had loved ones who had cancer.

Are you fucking serious? I can tell you now I had absolutely no fucking idea what it would feel like to be given a cancer diagnosis and be faced with my mortality at the age of 38, I wouldn’t wish this on anyone, what a fucking dick head thing to say. God I hate this place.

Dingdandgdoodle · Today 19:52

nyhgghfgu87gh · Today 19:44

It’s not a race to the bottom. Frankly I am jealous you are 45, I don’t even know if I will make it to 40 with my diagnosis yet, cancer kills. Ill health is shit whatever the disease, but the worst thing about it is the mental aspect, and I think it’s great she is raising that aspect of it, because as has been shown by you and others on this thread it’s very easy to overlook the mental turmoil of situations such as cancer.

No I understand the mental trauma of cancer very well. I’ve had cancer myself as have my best friend during our childhood, both grandparents, colleagues, my neighbour, another friend, friends parents and I nursed my Dad in the final stages of his cancer last year.

nyhgghfgu87gh · Today 19:54

Dingdandgdoodle · Today 19:52

No I understand the mental trauma of cancer very well. I’ve had cancer myself as have my best friend during our childhood, both grandparents, colleagues, my neighbour, another friend, friends parents and I nursed my Dad in the final stages of his cancer last year.

Yes I am sure.

Dingdandgdoodle · Today 19:54

nyhgghfgu87gh · Today 19:54

Yes I am sure.

What?

HardShoulders · Today 19:55

MeghanAndTheSeals · Today 19:44

It takes a special kind of person to take digs regarding cancer and how it’s treated.

I think it takes a special kind of palace PR to make a cancer documentary about a royal to make them look ‘relatable’, rather than a member of a ridiculous anachronism.

Dazedandconfused28 · Today 19:56

I like that it opens up a conversation, a conversation that is difficult & painful - cancer is a very levelling experience, none of us is immune. I'll definitely watch this, as I've struggled to find ways to cope.

The wonderful thing about television - you are not obliged to watch it

SpikeyAndTheOvenGlove · Today 20:00

I’ll also be watching. I’ve had cancer.

LadyWiddiothethird · Today 20:00

Of course is isn’t patronising! She is doing it to raise awareness and raise funds for the Royal Marsden.I have many friends who have been and are being treated for cancer,they have all had excellent care from our NHS.

thehummingbirdhaslanded · Today 20:00

It’s just you. Why do you think a woman talking about her cancer journey is patronising?
bizarre. People will find fault with anything.

thehummingbirdhaslanded · Today 20:01

LadyWiddiothethird · Today 20:00

Of course is isn’t patronising! She is doing it to raise awareness and raise funds for the Royal Marsden.I have many friends who have been and are being treated for cancer,they have all had excellent care from our NHS.

Quite

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:02

nyhgghfgu87gh · Today 19:51

Are you fucking serious? I can tell you now I had absolutely no fucking idea what it would feel like to be given a cancer diagnosis and be faced with my mortality at the age of 38, I wouldn’t wish this on anyone, what a fucking dick head thing to say. God I hate this place.

Nobody really knows what anything is like until it happens to them, not really. Although plenty of people get cancer and are in remission and fairly healthy long term.
But yes I have read many people talking about the mental turmoil and impact of having cancer. Because it is so common, it is talked about a lot.

Indigogogoing · Today 20:03

She should be open about what cancer she has. I would personally find it much easier to relate if she was actually open and honest with us.

Cancer isn’t something to hide or be ashamed of. I’ve had ovarian cancer and I would tell anyone about it.

MeghanAndTheSeals · Today 20:03

limetrees32 · Today 19:49

I've had oesophageal cancer .
My own view is that there are many chronic illnesses,say those of the autoimmune kind that wreck people's lives .
Or Alzheimer's.
I don't think cancer should be treated as though it's the worst thing in the world .

I have a chronic illness and two autoimmune diseases, my life has been totally changed by these. And you’re right, lives get changed immeasurably. What I refuse to do is start minimising cancer just because my situation isn’t talked about as much.

Sorry, I don’t want that to sound snarky, the written word is often hard when you can’t hear tone etc. And I am truly sorry re your own diagnosis, I hope that you are ok.

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:03

thehummingbirdhaslanded · Today 20:00

It’s just you. Why do you think a woman talking about her cancer journey is patronising?
bizarre. People will find fault with anything.

It isn't. As long as it's her experience with no explicit attempts to generalise.

Lomee · Today 20:04

Dingdandgdoodle · Today 19:38

This. I whole heartedly agree.

I was diagnosed with a life changing disease at the age of 16. At 45 it’s taken everything from me and I’m now housebound. There’s no documentaries about it, very little research and funding. I’m fighting for benefits, fighting to pay the bills, fighting to keep the roof over our heads.

Cancer is not the worst thing you can be diagnosed with.

I'm sorry to hear your situation and wish you the best, but your last sentence I disagree and I'm sure many people who have seen loved ones dying of cancer would think it was the worst thing that happened to them. It's not an Olympic to have the worst disease or living/dying situation, everyone's experience is different.

Swipe left for the next trending thread