Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Princess Catherine Film

122 replies

letmebetheone · Today 19:08

Seen lots of trailers today for the documentary Princess Catherine has made about her recovery from cancer.
Apparently it is meant to reassure others and encourage them to connect with nature.

Is it just me that finds the whole thing a bit patronising?

It's great that she has recovered but she would have had the best medical care going and no waiting to be seen.

A lot of people have to wait for treatment and worry how they will keep food on the table whilst having treatment. Preaching to those people that they should go out and hug a tree is a bit much.

OP posts:
thehummingbirdhaslanded · Today 20:04

HardShoulders · Today 19:55

I think it takes a special kind of palace PR to make a cancer documentary about a royal to make them look ‘relatable’, rather than a member of a ridiculous anachronism.

Why so nasty and bitter? Is it because she is gorgeous rich And cares about other people? Is that what bothers you? You have to put a nasty slant on a courageous and generous act. Says more about you than anything else.

Ilovefoodandwine · Today 20:05

I had cancer just after her. My kids are the same age. I was treated quickly, as is everyone with cancer

WatchDermotGetHisTitsTweakedLive · Today 20:05

MeghanAndTheSeals · Today 19:44

It takes a special kind of person to take digs regarding cancer and how it’s treated.

I’d have gone with another word completely different from ‘person’ but apart from that, I agree with the sentiment.

Not a surprise to see some here but I am surprised they’ve chosen to go with their usual stance.

And my word would describe them perfectly.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

parrap · Today 20:05

With hand on heart and with some trepidation..... I think she is the wrong person to do this type of documentary. Too perfect post illness, impeccably groomed, super figure, handsome husband, wealthy beyond measure and all the rest of it.

Is she relateable in any way, apart from going through surgery and chemo? She has not been open about it really, since the first thing most normal people would want to know is what type of cancer she had. Not revealed for her own reasons which is fine, but leaves something unsaid and mysterious. If it is the leveller then just say it out loud and be open about it.

TBH if others had the same diagnosis, they would be heartened by her great recovery now. But no one knows what it is. Just a bit of a gap I think, and I know others will not agree with me. That's fine, I just feel that way about it.

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:06

Lomee · Today 20:04

I'm sorry to hear your situation and wish you the best, but your last sentence I disagree and I'm sure many people who have seen loved ones dying of cancer would think it was the worst thing that happened to them. It's not an Olympic to have the worst disease or living/dying situation, everyone's experience is different.

My mother and two friends died of cancer. My relative who died of motor neurone disease objectively had a worst time. It was brutal.
But I also acknowledge cancer is an umbrella term and the type of cancer someone does of does have an impact on how that death can be.

MeghanAndTheSeals · Today 20:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Lomee · Today 20:07

Dingdandgdoodle · Today 19:52

No I understand the mental trauma of cancer very well. I’ve had cancer myself as have my best friend during our childhood, both grandparents, colleagues, my neighbour, another friend, friends parents and I nursed my Dad in the final stages of his cancer last year.

It doesn't make you an expert. Everyone's experience is different.

Dingdandgdoodle · Today 20:08

Lomee · Today 20:04

I'm sorry to hear your situation and wish you the best, but your last sentence I disagree and I'm sure many people who have seen loved ones dying of cancer would think it was the worst thing that happened to them. It's not an Olympic to have the worst disease or living/dying situation, everyone's experience is different.

It’s just my own opinion. I nursed my Dad when he died of bone cancer last year and I’ve had cancer myself. You disagree and that’s fine, like you said everyone’s experience is different.

Glassfullofdreams · Today 20:08

I don't think it sounds patronising at all. A lot of people are aware of the physical side effects of a cancer diagnosis, but the long-term mental impact are another thing entirely. One of the hardest things I found about recovering from cancer was that people expected me to go back to the person I was before, they thought once I got the all clear it was over. But to me it'll never be over. The mental side effects don't end.

If she can raise an ounce of awareness on the mental side effects it can only be a good thing.

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:08

parrap · Today 20:05

With hand on heart and with some trepidation..... I think she is the wrong person to do this type of documentary. Too perfect post illness, impeccably groomed, super figure, handsome husband, wealthy beyond measure and all the rest of it.

Is she relateable in any way, apart from going through surgery and chemo? She has not been open about it really, since the first thing most normal people would want to know is what type of cancer she had. Not revealed for her own reasons which is fine, but leaves something unsaid and mysterious. If it is the leveller then just say it out loud and be open about it.

TBH if others had the same diagnosis, they would be heartened by her great recovery now. But no one knows what it is. Just a bit of a gap I think, and I know others will not agree with me. That's fine, I just feel that way about it.

Actually I agree. There have been various people who have blogged the details of the their cancer diagnosis and treatment and that does raise awareness. She doesn't have to talk about what kind of cancer she had or her treatment, but the fact she doesn't means any awareness raising claim is simply not true.

TinyDancer16 · Today 20:08

nyhgghfgu87gh · Today 19:51

Are you fucking serious? I can tell you now I had absolutely no fucking idea what it would feel like to be given a cancer diagnosis and be faced with my mortality at the age of 38, I wouldn’t wish this on anyone, what a fucking dick head thing to say. God I hate this place.

Oh I’m glad you posted this. I had typed out a long reply but then thought, what’s the point. Your response is exactly what I thought 👏

TellMeAnother · Today 20:09

God, there are some mean-spirited and frankly unpleasant people in the world.
And on this thread, of course.
FFS, what's wrong with you?

Dingdandgdoodle · Today 20:09

Lomee · Today 20:07

It doesn't make you an expert. Everyone's experience is different.

Of course it doesn’t make me an expert, I never said I was, I’ve just had very close personal experience.

MeghanAndTheSeals · Today 20:10

WatchDermotGetHisTitsTweakedLive · Today 20:05

I’d have gone with another word completely different from ‘person’ but apart from that, I agree with the sentiment.

Not a surprise to see some here but I am surprised they’ve chosen to go with their usual stance.

And my word would describe them perfectly.

I had a plethora of words I would happily have used 😂

thehummingbirdhaslanded · Today 20:11

Ilovefoodandwine · Today 20:05

I had cancer just after her. My kids are the same age. I was treated quickly, as is everyone with cancer

Same here. For me the most stressful part was the time between when the consultant told me it was ‘suspicious’ to the diagnosis of what stage it was. With very young children I was scared of not being there for them. Every body is different and it helps many for others to talk about it.

I also have a mother serious illness that is incurable. Not many people talk about that one. But so what. And as others have said it’s nota not a competition.

The fact that any money raised from the world wide distribution, will go to the Marsden, is fabulous.

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:11

Glassfullofdreams · Today 20:08

I don't think it sounds patronising at all. A lot of people are aware of the physical side effects of a cancer diagnosis, but the long-term mental impact are another thing entirely. One of the hardest things I found about recovering from cancer was that people expected me to go back to the person I was before, they thought once I got the all clear it was over. But to me it'll never be over. The mental side effects don't end.

If she can raise an ounce of awareness on the mental side effects it can only be a good thing.

How can anyone with any shred of intelligence not be aware of the mental impact? Any serious illness changes you. As does any traumatic experience.
And there have been so many articles and blogs about cancer. Even radio adverts about the impact of cancer.

I know raising more awareness can help. But I am honestly aghast at the idea that anyone with my interest in the world around them could not have an inkling at all.

WatchDermotGetHisTitsTweakedLive · Today 20:11

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:06

My mother and two friends died of cancer. My relative who died of motor neurone disease objectively had a worst time. It was brutal.
But I also acknowledge cancer is an umbrella term and the type of cancer someone does of does have an impact on how that death can be.

Last time I looked, death is death.

The road to it may be different but the end result is the same.

Go back and read @nyhgghfgu87gh ’s posts and reflect.

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:12

Ilovefoodandwine · Today 20:05

I had cancer just after her. My kids are the same age. I was treated quickly, as is everyone with cancer

My mother wasn't, and died of cancer. She was also poor.

WatchDermotGetHisTitsTweakedLive · Today 20:13

What were folk saying about the race to the bottom?

I can’t.

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:14

WatchDermotGetHisTitsTweakedLive · Today 20:11

Last time I looked, death is death.

The road to it may be different but the end result is the same.

Go back and read @nyhgghfgu87gh ’s posts and reflect.

Having seen too many loved ones die, how you die and the months leading up to it matter very much. I am kind of assuming you have little or no experience of being with loved ones in their final months and at their death to state it does not matter.

canklesmctacotits · Today 20:14

It depends what she’s going to say, doesn’t it.

If she’s going to go on about how helpful it is to have a supporting husband and to get outside help in and to be kind to yourself by stopping work for the period of treatment + 3 months: yes, out of touch and wrong.

I don’t imagine she’ll say that. I imagine it’ll be along the lines of how shocking a diagnosis can be; how it makes you think of things you previously took for granted; how to not feel bad leaning on people who offer help whether nurses or friends or family; how terrifying it can be talking to your young children about it and how wonderful cancer support organizations are in offering guidance and tips.

Maybe hold fire before judging.

cornflakeontheside · Today 20:15

Dingdandgdoodle · Today 19:38

This. I whole heartedly agree.

I was diagnosed with a life changing disease at the age of 16. At 45 it’s taken everything from me and I’m now housebound. There’s no documentaries about it, very little research and funding. I’m fighting for benefits, fighting to pay the bills, fighting to keep the roof over our heads.

Cancer is not the worst thing you can be diagnosed with.

You are lucky you got to age 45. My best friend died from cancer at age 18.

She would have been grateful to get to middle age

thehummingbirdhaslanded · Today 20:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

WatchDermotGetHisTitsTweakedLive · Today 20:16

BeLemonMoose · Today 20:14

Having seen too many loved ones die, how you die and the months leading up to it matter very much. I am kind of assuming you have little or no experience of being with loved ones in their final months and at their death to state it does not matter.

You have no idea.

I will say that you said your mother died in a different manner.

I am sorry for your loss all the same but don’t tell me I don’t bloody know loss.

Mulledjuice · Today 20:16

JacknDiane · Today 19:20

I think she cant do right for doing wrong

I haven't seen the documentary yet but judging by the messaging from her so far she has fallen far short of acknowledging that cancer patients might all have to weather similar storms but they are doing so from very different boats.

Swipe left for the next trending thread